My first time at Moby Dick's Oyster Bar & Grill was an overall great experience. It is a classic bar and restaurant setup with main bar seating and tables all around. It isn't huge inside but they use the space so wisely. The kitchen is open to the bar so you can see and hear all the amazing things happening back there which really adds to the local neighborhood vibe. The bartenders there are very sweet and attentive, they help bring the whole experience there to 5 stars. I came on a Wednesday for the $17.99 lobster roll special and it was easily one of the best I've ever had. It is a quarter pound of lobster and you get actual lumps of claw and meat rather than the shredded stuff some other places serve. The butter it's sautéed in is seasoned delicately to accentuate the fresh lobster instead of covering up the taste. The portion was surprisingly large and it comes on a fresh bun that is lightly buttered and toasted. It even comes with a little cup of extra butter which I totally slathered on because I love butter! Every bite was so fresh and soft. The roll comes with fries and I did the optional $5 upcharge for the lobster bisque. That was also the best I've ever had because I've never seen bisque with such large chunks of lobster in it. It was just crazy good. Everything was well worth the price and I'd honestly come back even on days when it's not a special. They have something going on every night like the $9.99 burger and fries on Mondays, so that will definitely be my next reason to visit. I will be back for sure! read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - 4 oz Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

Money Dick's was one of the best meals of our vacation week! They have a few tables outside, high tops, or you can sit at the bar like we did. I hope Courtney is your bartender because she is fantastic. She was showing the ropes to the very nice Mellisa, and they both took great care of us. We started with a lobster roll and decided that it was so good. We wanted another because I didn't wanna share. We enjoyed some vodka sodas, which is our usual beverage of choice. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Happy Hour Menu - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

I cannot come here without getting the tuna tartar. It's fresher than most sushi restaurants. The quality is unmatched especially for the price point. The lobster roll is UNREAL. The brioche toasted roll, hand picked lobster meat and the seasoned fries are too hard to pass on especially for $18 on Wednesdays. Last but not least. The crème brûlée house made cheesecake is money. Crispy and creamy in all the right places... I cannot wait to indulge again. The hospitality and service is incredible. The staff is pleasant and attentive. The craft drinks are well executed by Courtney, Riley and Gianna! It's a place where you feel at home! read more

See all

Honestly the food was not impressive. I ordered the bread crumb covered baked shrimp which were served poached in liquid, no breadcrumbs or baking to be found. My guy ordered the lobster bisque which came in a coffee mug without much lobster and the fried shrimp which had such a greasy breading it had to be removed. BUT.... They comped my dinner AND gave us a gift card. So coodos to the manager who stood up and did the right thing! I will definitely come back and give them a second chance. I love my Wiggles and my Rake! So I will be fair and return because they stepped up to the plate and treated me right! So please give them a shot. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

This is a small bar with a few dining tables both indoors and outside. We came on a Friday and the bar was full of happy patrons. Our very attentive waitress came and took our orders. We heard the lobster rolls were highly recommended and tried them. They arrived warm and tasty with butter and fries on the side. Scrumptious! My fish sandwich was huge but somehow I cleared my plate. This is such a cute and friendly place. The owner greeted us on the way in and on the way out. We will be back. read more

See all

Okay ...saw the reviews here and had to come for the oysters and crab dip. Got an Uber from our hotel and guess what? They were out of oysters, crab dip and shrimp cocktail! The bartender said they had a busy weekend - it was Tuesday? Well, we decided on the lobster roll and it did not disappoint. So full of lobster and the bun was perfect. The bartender wasn't very friendly. We had to ask several times for drinks and there were only four other people in the place. Luckily, Sam took over the bar and was terrific. The restroom was clean and when I walked by the kitchen, it looked like they were having a party. We will be back and hopefully they will have oysters! read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

Hands down the best Lobster Bisque I've ever had. Such a cute location, amazing bartender, and bisque, lobster rolls, and shrimp cocktail that was out of this world! This place is a gem!! read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Lobster roll and bisque - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

Moby Dick's Oyster Bar is a hidden gem -- small in size but absolutely spot-on in service, vibe, and cocktails. The staff couldn't have been friendlier or more attentive, and the atmosphere strikes that perfect mix of laid-back and lively. The French Martini (with vodka, naturally) was flawless -- smooth, balanced, and beautifully presented. Add in a fun jukebox and cozy bar energy, and it's the kind of place you don't want to leave. Can't recommend it highly enough! read more

We came back here a few days later. The meatball and lobster sliders are just as amazing as everything else we tried! And the clam chowder was flavorful, hot, and delicious! Really friendly bar patrons- had a great time since everyone was amazingly friendly, too! Thanks everyone!!! read more

See all

What a fun place to be. Food is delish. Customer service is top notch. My fiancé and I have been here numerous times and we love it!!! It's a bit small but very clean and designed beautifully. read more

Stopped by for dinner last Saturday and the food was amazing!! And so was our waitress! My date and I tried the spicy calamari to start, fried to perfection and not too spicy, delicious. I had a grand margarita and it was just right. Next we tried the special...lobster Rangoon dip so good I can't stop thinking about it! The chef was so kind and brought it out to us and was the most humble, kudos to you!! I ordered the lobster Mac & cheese and my date had the fish sandwich & fries. We loved & enjoyed every bite and we'll be back soon. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Lobster Rangoon Dip - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

Cute hole in the wall and the food tastes amazing but I was sick for 48 hours after eating oysters and crabmeat and avocado dip. Sorry but I'm a nurse and it had to be the food! read more

What a find! When I travel for business, I always head to Yelp to find a place to eat. This was my first time in the New Haven area so I was searching for seafood. Moby Dick's is a cozy little place with a great vibe. Courtney the bartender was very welcoming and steered me straight to the lobster roll (Wednesday night special) and I was craving clam chowder because it was chilly. Both meal items were fabulous. A generous amount of exceptional lobster and perfectly toasted roll with just the right amount of butter. I'm definitely coming back next time I'm in town and I want to try the raw oysters. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Regular Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

I recently visited Moby Dick's Oyster Bar and was deeply disappointed by the service and treatment received. It's unacceptable that as the only black customers, we were not provided service, which felt both discriminatory and unjust. This experience highlighted significant issues with their approach to inclusivity and respect for all patrons. Therefore, I cannot recommend this establishment to anyone. I highly encourage everyone to spend the money at other inclusive establishments in West Haven. There are many restaurants that value and treat all customers with dignity--choose one that upholds these principles. read more

We had an excellent experience at Moby Dick's this Wednesday evening. First time here and we were welcomed by Courtney. Looks like a neighborhood bar with a few locals already there. Happy hour until 6. Food was fresh and plentiful. The pasta is from Durantes's in West Haven and they prepared it perfectly. read more

See all

Service was superb! We had the clams on half shell, Lump crab meat, and the most Amazing oysters Rockefeller read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

I went here today to try their new menu and everything was so fresh and so delicious !! The owner and staff were so friendly too!! If you love seafood I highly recommend trying this spot out!!! The oysters and lobsters are fantastic!! read more

See all

Our new favorite place! Don't miss the lobster roll and lobster bisque with more lobster than anywhere I've been to. Also try the sauteed shrimp! It will become your favorite as well! read more

Had the place to ourselves on a snowy week day. They had happy hour specials on drinks. $2 draft beer and $5 vodka and soda. My husband and I had the lobster bisque, mussels (ask them to warm the bread) and the lobster roll. The food was great. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

See all

The Best Lobster Roll in 20 years . The Oysters/ Clams on point . My only regret I did not order the Shrimp . My new go to. The Bartender Was professional and very welcoming on her game . A fantastic Find . read more

Great spot - lobster roll on Wednesday is the way to go with the Bisque - bartender (Courtney) was great - thank you - will be back !!!

I have yet to receive the refund for the soup I didn't get and the gift card I was promised for the bad experience.... So unfortunately, as of right now, I cannot change my review... read more

Moby Dick's Oyster Bar & Grill is located in an unassuming small storefront on Campbell Avenue in West Haven. They serve a creative variety of flatbreads, signature cocktails and charcuterie boards. We had had a late lunch so we only ordered drinks but the food we saw looked awesome. I am definitely looking forward to trying the unique combinations of flatbreads. One group of customers had ordered a tower of shells with oysters, clams, shrimp and crab meat which made for an impressive presentation. Another table was having clam chowder and a lobster bisque. Both people commented they were pleased with having lots of clams and lobster in their choices. read more

We had lunch at Moby Dick's yesterday during a visit to New Haven. The bar staff was incredibly friendly. The crab dip happy was very tasty and the lobster roll was awesome. We also tried the lobster bisque, which was outstanding. We will definitely stop here again on our next visit. read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Lobster roll...really tasty! - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

Sure, West Haven is on the ocean, but I don't really think of it as a seafood spot for whatever reason. I was proven wrong when I found this little spot downtown. It took $1 raw oysters to pull me in (they don't do this all the time, so follow them on whatever the kids are using these days), and like the fish on the menu, I was hooked. The place is a little small, but getting a seat is worth it. The drinks are strong and expertly made, the kitchen is fast, and seafood is fresh and served with many homemade sauces. We only had the raw oysters this time, but in perusing the cooked and raw items, I couldn't find anything I disliked. Fresh seafood, well prepared, at fair prices? I can't wait to come back. read more

I feel as though I am doing a disservice to this establishment by only rating it 5/5 stars since they absolutely exceeded my expectations. From the food, to the service, ambiance, and owner Moby Dick checked the box of elite on every level. Ask yourself, have you ever sat at an eatery with a date, awaiting your food and upon the first bite you both under your breath say oh f***? If not I implore you stop by this spot for a bite. My girlfriend and I ordered the crab dip and lobster bisque(in 85 degree weather lol). The crab dip was phenomenal, packing plenty of meat, loads of flavor, and toasted baguettes slices topped with cheese!!! The lobster bisque mirrored the crap dip, consisting of again a lot of meat and loads of flavor. The gentlemen next to us indulged in the raw bar(if that's your thing) and would stop raving about how fresh and huge the oysters were. I honestly can't wait to go back with more room to eat so that I can try other items. Josie, our bartender, while in training, was pleasant and engaging. The chefs were also quick, cleanly, and personable. Lastly, the owner, Nick..I cannot rave enough about him and his style of ownership. He's attentive, a conversationalist, and an all around great owner. He made sure that not only his customers were taken care of but also all of his staff who seemed to adore him. With this place checking all of the boxes that they did I am surprised they are such a hidden gem. I will be back next week for dinner and will be sure to review again once I get a hold of a piece of the lobster grilled cheese, lobster/bacon flatbread, and the steak frites!!!! read more

See all

Very small restaurant with 4-5 tables total and about eight bar seats. Very slow service and the food is mediocre at best. Came in Easter Sunday and experience was miserable. Ordered oysters Rockefeller (they had a piece of bacon on top of them lol) and the fried dumplings. Dumplings were ok. Oysters were awful. That took about 25 minutes to get. Our lunch took another 45 minutes. For three fried fish sandwiches that looked like they came frozen from Cisco. Fries were basic frozen garbage as well. I can't believe it took almost two hours to eat some fried dumplings and a fried fish sandwich lol. Also took about 15 minutes to get our check. I would never eat here again. read more

This place was really good! Great food! The owners came out to welcome guest, the hospitality was amazing. Drinks were great too. read more

See all

Really like Moby Dicks. Went for lunch once on a lazy afternoon, then went back for dinner a few weeks later. Cocktails and lobster entrees are fabulous. It's a small space so hit or miss on getting a table unless you call ahea read more

Moby Dick’s Oyster Bar & Grill - Owner plus customers - Seafood Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

We went on a Friday night and the the place was not very busy. The bar was loud and crowded, but no one was at the tables. We got a beer and placed our order. It took about an hour for us to get our food. Someone apologized to us, but there wasn't a lot of food going out to people, just drinks, so I'm unsure where the delay came from. The food was not great, but expensive. I got the drunken clams linguine. The clams were chewy, there was barely any sauce, and there were no tomatoes to be found. My partner's burger was fine, but he ordered a side of garlic mozzarella flatbread which came out with no mozzarella. After bringing it to our server's attention we did get one that actually had mozzarella. We got the bill and were surprised at how expensive such subpar food was. Great for a drink, not a great place for a meal. read more

I reviewed Moby Dicks when they first opened and I was very excited about the new restaurant to the downtown area, as I had stated I loved the awesome New England Nautical Style decor, the staff was great, and seafood was fresh. A few months later, they're doing awesome! I went back recently and got to try their amazing Clams Casino Pizza & Lobster Mac & Cheese. We capped off the night with an espresso marini that was fantastic. You never have to wait for food or drinks. The staff is very attentive. read more

See all

I'm a pescatarian and have traveled worldwide for 24 years. This dish was one of the best red snappers I've ever tasted. The stew on top was just right! It was a chilly and rainy day in May, and the tomato and cannelloni bean stew topping was on point. Courtney, the manager/bartender, made an excellent Manhattan. My husband had the lobster and bacon flatbread and he enjoyed it. read more

See all

My husband and I ordered take out on a Saturday night as we knew they would be busy at their convenient location on Campbell Ave in West Haven. Meatball sliders (ordered with no cheese for dietary reasons) were FANTASTIC! We are excited to come back for Meatball Mondays! My husband enjoyed his bacon flatbread. The cheesecake was amazing and he wanted more! We can't wait to see an updated menu on your Facebook page and website! Thank you for being so accommodating and being a new West Haven favorite! read more

Moby Dick's is amazing! The owners and staff are so welcoming, the cocktails are spot-on, and the food is next level-- fresh oysters, creative seafood dishes, and seriously... the lobster roll will blow you away. A quality spot and cozy neighborhood bar, I can't recommend it enough. read more

What a great spot. Oyster Rockefeller Colossal Shrimp Cocktail Tuna Sashimi Crab Cakes Lobster Bisque Coors Lights Spicy Tequila Bloody Maria Oyster Shooters Owner Nick was engaging, friendly and we had some laughs Bartender Courtney was dialed in and has a great smile Was looking to get out of Branford for happy hour We got stuck in traffic on Q bridge for 25 min but that only made arriving at Moby Dicks that much better and really having a great experience The kitchen does a great job of cranking out the food Awesome Friday Night in West Haven Giddy Up Looking read more

Don't be fooled by what you see on instagram, like we were. I checked the site via their link and the advertising is deceiving. Not worth the drive. It's a small dive bar, food is meh, and the 1st drink my hubby had came with a complimentary small fruit fly, only to return it for something else with a larger black fly. Do better or trying so hard to get people through the doors. read more

Went to New Haven for a business trip and stayed for a few extra days to relax. Stopped by Moby Dick's Oyster Bar for oysters and lobster rolls. They have amazing FRESH seafood and excellent service! If you're in the New Haven area you need to stop by. Truly exceptional hospitality and food offerings. read more

The location is amazing right by the water. Plenty of parking for all the places in the area. The seafood is all super fresh and the portions are plentifull. I had the oysters and a lobster roll and both were delicious. The drinks and bar staff are great as well. Great beer list and great pours on the drinks. Definitely a place to go for some great food and drinks. read more

Great discovery of an historic pub-like experience. Situated solidly in the West Haven community. Friendly management and service, bar side is authentic, appointments inside the small establishment call attention to its history. And the food was extraordinary. Lobster Mac, oysters and creative burgers and sides included. Added it to my favorites. read more

See all

I have so much good to say about this place. Patrick the bartender took impecable care of me. I walked in at 11:30 PM after 6+ hours of traveling and said all I want was some food andDespite that the kitchen was closed the chef Who is off shift offered to make me food anyways. He cooked me the most delicious lobster roll that was dance in my chair delicious! We ended up Vibing over 90s music and playing songs from my childhood. I felt like these were friends and people that have known me for years.The people who run this establishment care deeply! I highly suggest you go experience their delicious food and their warm hospitality. read more