The food was delicious. Best New England clam chowder we've had in a long time. Creamy but not too thick - full of clams and potatoes in every bite. We also got the Codfather sandwich - lite panko crusted piece of cod, melted in your mouth. The calamari was large pieces, which means chewy to me, but this was tender and flavorful. Light batter that wasn't greasy. Can't wait to go back and try other items - and get more of that chowdah! The woman who greets you and takes your order was super nice and on top of everything. She made sure the food was good and cleared our dishes quickly. Very pleasant - a 5 star employee. read more

See all

My first time with the new owners and everything went well I like whole belly clams and finding them can be difficult and they are pricey. This is one place that has them, fried to perfection and offers them in their Combination for a small upcharge. I got an order, which was a generous pile of scallops, shrimp, belly clams and filet. I got a separate order of fried calamari with cocktail sauce; another fave. The eat in area is cute and comfortable and the two men, owners, I believe were friendly. I ate about half of my order and took the rest home. Yum! read more

It's a little hole in the wall and to be honest I almost drove by it. Friendly service. Crab cakes was all crab and really good. The bang bang shrimp was the hit of the meal. Everything was clearly very fresh. read more

I ordered the Supreme combo and 4oz lobster roll, seafood wasn't seasoned and the fries were undercooked and not crispy at all. Portion size was terrible and I couldn't find the fish. I wish I opened my order at the restaurant because It was unacceptable for the price. I didn't even receive one piece of fish. The lobster roll was decent. read more

I follow a couple on IG they went to eat the famous lobster roll at Clam Castle and that was our plan. We arrived at Clam Castle and as I was about to get out of the truck my cousin text me the viral lobster roll at Supreme Seafood. I told my fiancé I want to go to Supreme Seafood. He said it's only down the street. We arrived and I was very excited. As we walked in we were greeted by the owner and the two young ladies at the counter they were very welcoming and iit was very clean inside. It's a very small establishment with a eclectic vibe and it was quite cozy. Our starters were clam chowder and I had the shrimp corn chowder. It was very flavorful and they didn't skimp on the shrimp. My fiancé ordered a full order of the clam strips with coleslaw and I ordered the $55.00 lobster roll with steak fries and coleslaw. They do have a $40.00 lobster roll which 4 Oz and $80.00 which is 16 Oz of lobster meat. The clam strips were fried perfectly and there is nothing better then tasting that fresh clam they were perfect. My lobster roll had 8 oz of sweet, succulent meaty lobster over flowing in perfectly toasted buttery roll. I had very huge pieces and there were some trying to escape the roll but I won that fight that lobster roll was banging. The new owner informed me that the original owners were there for 35 years. The new owner had been there for 4 years. I told him where I was initially going and he said they had a family that ordered their 2 foot lobster roll that cost a working $230.00. He showed us the lobster roll he prepared and what was left after the family of three which included two adults and a newborn baby. I will definitely return to try the 2 foot lobster roll. If your in North Branford, CT please stop and enjoy all the delicious seafood at Supreme Seafood. To all my Yelper let's continue to eat our way through the world.#Foodie4life. read more

See all

I got dinner with my daughter and granddaughters who love seafood. We had the fried combo platter and they had the softshell crab and the shrimp corn chowder. Everything was delicious and we got a fried shrimp platter to go with.. The food was fresh and delicious . The staff is great the service is pretty quick . It's on the small side but they also have picnic tables outside . They do a big take out as well . It was pretty steady the whole time we were there . We only got the half platter next time for a few bucks more we will get the full size one . If you love seafood and don't want to drive to the shore this is your best bet . Enjoy Thanks Chris M read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - The fried seafood platter yum - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

I believe this is my first time visiting here since Vinnie retired. In any case, I stopped in today for lunch and ordered the Sole Selection fried fish sandwich. Reading the menu description, the sandwich appeared to come with steak fries. Technically it did, but rather than a small side of fries, three steak fries were inside the sandwich. Odd, when I asked the waiter while ordering for malt vinegar for the fries, he did not tell me this. Although the sandwich was hot and freshly made to order, the three fries were cold and didn't seem fresh at all. Though I've been here several times, this time I noticed there appears to be no restroom - unless it's behind the "Employees Only" door. read more

Being a summer baby, I hate to see this season end. Having a delicious lobster roll made it a little easier to say goodbye to the warm weather. The weather didn't cooperate, but the fact that the shanty is set up at Owenego was a major plus. The view of the ocean, overcast with cloudy skies and cold breezes was still delightful. read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Owenego's view from the Shanty - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

See all

Supreme yet simple fare here. Fried seafood, Sandwiches and chowders all delicious. Not the most extensive menu but that's ok, had the basic scallops, sole, and clams. No frills yet friendly service. read more

This is awesome little quaint place for delicious seafood... The food proportions are more than satisfying and the taste is extraordinary tasteful. I RECOMMEND ANYONE WHO WANTS DELICIOUS SEAFOOD AND FULL PORTIONS to get to Supreme Seafood Restaurant. The Service and atmosphere were A+. They also have a nice section if you would like to eat outside. read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - The supreme seafood platter with steak fries... - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

Excellent food and service! The restaurant is small, but very neat and clean. I recommend going at an off peak dining time as there aren't many tables (although there is outside seating when it's nice out). My husband had the lobster roll and onion rings which he said were delicious! The roll was steaming hot when it arrived at the table. I ordered the shrimp and corn chowder that was very tasty. I also couldn't make up my mind between fried shrimp and fried clams, so our waitress suggested a combination dish. It was excellent! So very crunchy and tasty! I ordered the full platter which I ended up taking a large portion home with me. We look forward to going back to SS again in the near future! read more

See all

After new management, seems to be very inconsistent with expensive orders... Still taste good but as to value for dollar.. ITS A CRAP SHOOT... read more

Great seafood in a cool space. Can't wait to come back when the patio is open. Great service and just what I needed for lunch!

Still very nice help but the fish does not taste the same. Not sure if the batter changed but I was so disappointed after going here for over 20 years. read more

Wow! What a great find! It's a small restaurant with friendly service. There is an outdoor eating area for those nice warm New England days. Today it was a cool day and the place was full. No wonder, the food is amazing! We started with the New England clam chowder which was spot on, creamy loaded with clams and goodness! Meals were a whole order of fried clams with a side of onion rings, and the Supreme Casserole which was loaded with scallops, shrimp and lobster claws. The sauce was savory and delicious, served with rice pilaf and Brussels sprouts. The clams were fresh and large, not skimpy or overdone, fried just right. The breading was flavorful. The onion rings were ok. Would come here again for sure! read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Fried Full Order Clam Strips and Onion Rings - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

See all

Perfection on a plate. Jim C is the certified Duke of Supreme Seafood. We walked in & Jim immediately took charge. Introducing my Dad & I to the owners and making it known much food would be ordered and he was in charge! It was a blast. Jim was the absolute most kind & gracious host. We started our meal with Onion Rings & Fried Calamari which we all shared. Real onions lightly fried & Crispy Calamari. Delicious. I just wish there was tentacles. Then we ordered the chowders. My first time having Rhode Island style Clam chowder. I tasted my Dads and took a quart to go home. But I had the shrimp corn chowder which was amazing. Then my Dad & I finished up with large meaty fried Softshell Crab Sandwiches which I had mines with French Fries and cheese sauce on the side. Jim C had the luscious looking Lobster Roll. Every last dish was perfectly cooked & seasoned. A1 in my book. Thanks for making great seafood! Visited on 6-24-2023 read more

See all

Food was absolutely amazing. Best Lobster Roll I've ever had. I'm from TX so I may not qualify as an expert, but I've had a few and by far this was the best one. read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - 8 Oz lobster Roll and the half order of the Supreme Combo w/Bellies, Half - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

Enjoyed every bite of my scallop platter. The scallops were perfectly cooked, sweet and tender. Our server was super friendly and seemed to be running the entire restaurant by herself - successfully. read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Scallops, Full - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

Hi went to one of my favorite places this weekend. I found out Vinny and Ralph retired in November of 2023. I was sad to hear they moved on in life. I support retirement 100%. I was hoping the food did not change. I ordered a combination platter (well done). I like a "crunch" on my fried seafood. Needless to say it was % the same. Thank God. The service was AWESOME. The music was very nice as well. The TV has been removed. This is a very good thing the TV is gone. Folks should interact with your party. I feel that socializing/conversation at the table is lost art. Between TV and cell phones when we dine out we forget we came to eat with humans. LOL Well my advice to the new owners is keep serving us good food, great service and providing a nice atmosphere and you will have longevity in your business. Happy New Year and New Beginnings 2024. See you soon. read more

See all

Fellow yelper Jim C recommended this place and the food was just as he said, delicious. I started off with the Rhode Island clam chowder and it was so good that I had to get a couple of quarts to go. the soft shell crab was huge a cooked perfectly. the calamari was crispy on the outside and melt in your mouth tender.JimC had the lobster roll that was huge and filled with lobster meat. the place is small but the people that own the place and our waitress made you feel right at home. read more

See all

The fried food needs more seasoning but the batter was golden. It's very small inside, I thought it was bigger. The cashier wasn't very friendly. The supreme seafood dish was cooked really well and my left overs tasted better the next day once I added seafood seasoning. My standards are higher than most because I come from a family of excellent cooks. The onion rings were thicker than I like. I prefer them a little thinner with more flavor. read more

See all

i try the fish sandwish yesteday and was not nothing compare our near from before the smount of fish inside was was very vey little for the $15 dollars sandwish that not include the fries they realy nned to step up big time read more

From the service to the 1 pound lobster roll, they are awesome! Well worth the journey to get here and try! read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Hot Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

We for take o from here last night and we were surprised how big and fresh the food was. My husband got a lobster roll. We are addicted. It's definitely the place to go for seafood. I had the supreme casserole. I ate half and have enough leftovers for lunch tomorrow. read more

If you're looking for a place where the food is spectacular this is the place to go... Dinners on the back of the menu will amaze you The chef Oki and Louis are out to please you and you won't be disappointed for sure read more

Great food! Made with love, it's obvious. Fish and chips, baked filet, shrimp dishes, it was all great.

This REVIEW is WELL-OVERDUE!!! I am a sucker for a classic Mom and Pop brick and mortar establishment! This is probably my 6th/7th time going to Supreme Seafood and I can honestly say that I have never been disappointed! Not only is the seafood fresh, plentiful, served hot and no skipping on any condiments, but the service is equally as a great! I don't know the owners name, but he is awesome! I most enjoy, that he walks around when he can of course and check in on his guests. We need that more in dining-out experiences. It creates a warm and inviting guest atmosphere and shows that the owner(s) truly cares. The restaurant does have about 6 to 7 tables that you can sit down and dine in. I really love to take my family in the summertime where you can sit outside in the adjacent parking lot on picnic tables, rip your bag open, crack open a beer (that you have to bring of course) and enjoy! You will drive away with a Huge smile on your face, Promise! read more

See all

One visit to Supreme Seafood and they very much have our hearts! Not only was all of the food delicious, but their portion sizes are impressive! We still can't get over the size of their "smallest" lobster roll - I can tell you they didn't skimp out and it had nice chunks of claw meat! Another one of my favorites was the calamari supreme, which is made with their homemade marinara sauce and was truly addicting. Every week they do a special with a fresh catch called "Off the Hook". It was mahi mahi when we went, and it was fantastic! So many options for land lovers too. Great wings, and the chicken parm sandwich was a showstopper with that big slab of fried mozz! A great casual spot with friendly staff. We'll definitely be coming back when we're in the area! read more

See all

Amazing experience from start to finish. The food was fresh and full of flavor -- Service was fast and friendly, and the place was clean and welcoming. Portions are generous and prices are fair. This is now our go-to spot. Highly recommend! read more

Food is great, especially the lobster rolls. While there are some outdoor tables, this is a strip mall on a busy road so there is not much in the way of ambiance. If the weather is not cooperative and you plan to eat in the restaurant, be warned. It is not much bigger than a Subway sandwich shop and the dining area is bare bones. I have had their food at NEBCO in Branford and it was awesome and the atmosphere was much better. SO food is a 5 and atmosphere in North Branford is a 3. read more

The best seafood combo in CT. This restaurant is worth the travel. The food is always fresh and delicious. This is our first time ordering to go and the amount is still a hefty amount. Will be back again soon!! read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Supreme Seafood Combo to go with French Fries! - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

See all

The fried scallops, shrimp, and fish in the combo platter were good. However, the whole belly clams were dry and rubbery. The 8 oz lobster roll with mayo had only claw meats, was plentiful and tasted ok. Clam chowder also had lots of clams in it.. Service was good. read more

The best seafood and lobster rolls in CT. Service is friendly and casual. Large portions and great quality! Always order the specials read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

Wow- really great. We were on our way to Stowe's Seafood and thought we'd look up a seafood restaurant that was closer to where we were shopping. We were not disappointed. I'll be disappointed if they don't make their own clam chowder because it was great. My ultimate favorite clam chowder is at Cape Pier in Kennebunkport and this rivals theirs. We shared the seafood platter - lots of fried goodies. The batter was light and the seafood morsels were cooked to perfection. We shall return! read more

Stopped in for lunch and what a delightful and delicious surprise ! This little gem flies under the radar but if you're in the area, stop in .. you won't regret it The service was quick and friendly.. read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Fried combo platter w fries (scallops, shrimp, calamari, haddock, clam strips) Yum - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

Supreme was a really cute little spot to satisfy a seafood craving. We visited 3/2/25 and tried the Fried Shrimp, Fish Tacos, Onion Rings and French Fries. There was little to no grease in the baskets and the food was delightfully crisp and tasty! While the fries were cut larger than I care for, the onion rings were massive. I ate until my tummy hurt. The staff was friendly and attentive and the cost was really affordable. I would definitely go back in the summer to enjoy again. read more

The fish is definitely supreme! Lunch on a Thursday with my lady and we had the place to ourselves, clean and tity. We got the large combo fish platter which we shared but definitely could have fed 3-4. Coleslaw was a little plain tasting and not sure if there is a restroom in the place. Otherwise very good food and we would eat there again no questions asked! read more

See all

Not what it used to be. Ordered the fried clams (my favorite) but portion was smaller than before, clam chowder was just so-so and they no longer had Dr. Pepper. Waitress told me they we now a Coke customer. Will not be going back. You guys have lost a good customer. Should have kept the old folks. read more

If you want some of the Best Fried Seafood in Connecticut this is the Place to have it. Every single time I've been here the Food & Service did not Dissapoint. Fresh Seafood, Fried in Fresh Clean Oil Every Time. Would Highly Recommend this Restaurant to all Seafood Lovers read more

Supreme Seafood Restaurant - Fried Sea Scallops, Fried Clam Strips & Fried Shrimp Yum! - Seafood Near Me - North Branford, Connecticut

The lady taking our order did a very good job she was very busy and was able to handle it by her self. The cook that was putting the food in the window was very rude and very unprofessional the way he was talking to the lady taking our order he kept telling her to tell them to wait you need to run the food soon as she finished with our order she did run the food. We sat out side to eat and as she is taking orders, running food to people inside and out side also cleaning tables all by her self there was someone from the kitchen out back smoking and talking on the phone. Maybe they should help her out ! They had time to hang out side. The lady that worked on Saturday July 26th at 3:33 should get a raise and be thanked for her hard work. read more