Here for the buffet and it is whack!!!! My friend also said the beer is flat!! Very disappointed in the buffet experience here at atwater mountain mikes. I been here for over 20 minutes and it's still the same Pizza as when I walked in being served. They have not brought nothing fresh out and the pizza that's been sitting for almost a half hour is cold. read more

See all

Had pizza delivered last night. It was the best pizza we have ever had from here. They put lots of toppings and cheese. It was delivered faster than the time frame they gave us. Delivery person was polite and personable. I would order from here again. read more

I ordered the large Mt. Everest, chicken wings and cheese bread. Food was delicious. I was impressed the pepperoni on the pizza wasn't burnt and curled up, that is very important to my family. The service was quick and friendly. The girl that assisted me made sure I had my correct order and was very attentive. The price of the pizza was a bit high hopefully they will adjust the pricing. Much better than Merced location. read more

Don't order a pizza for delivery. Fucking idiots can't read or take down instructions. Went to wrong house, called wrong number. Fucking whiny ass babies who want 15$ an hour and can't even make a fucking pizza or deliver it to the right address or call the right fucking number. Fuck these idiots. read more

I like this spot rather then the one in Merced. Doesn't look as dark and cold.... Pizza is great.... Kids like to play the games and they usually win on the claw.... Haha we will be back read more

Pizza was tasty, hot and crispy. Ordered 6 specialty pizzas and all were delicious. Cheap and awesome! Good beer tap selection for having only some to choose from. I'm not from the area, but I'd go again. Gave it a 3 because I didn't taste their ranch which matters a lot when eating pizza. read more

Mountain Mike's in Atwater serves good pizza. I bought a bunch of 'buy one, get one free' coupons at the beginning of the year, and we use them for work all the time. Only one time has the pizza arrived a little cold, but that's not bad for as many times as we've ordered. Their lunch buffet at the store is okay too (3.75 stars for that). read more

Frequently when I get home from work late, Mountain Mike's is the solution for a quick and delicious dinner for the children who always love pizza. The order is always accurate at this location, and they're always ready in 25 minutes or less. Friendliness is never lacking in the service, and even delivery is quick and free of kinks. The salad bar is always fresh, but sometimes not well-stocked. The only really significant negative I would have to mention is that the chicken wings are not prepared in house, and they taste like the frozen seasoned chicken wings that can be bought in the freezer aisle of the grocery store. They used to be much better than that. There is always a significant sporting event playing on the nice large screen TVs, which make the 25 (or less) minute wait very tolerable. read more

Poor customer service. I had placed an order online for pick up. Called and asked how long it would take to be done. I was told 35-40 min. Came 45 min later to pick up my pizzas and when I came I was told that 1 of the pizza I ordered they forgot to put the sausage. So therefore I have to wait another 10 min for them to remake the pizza. What is the point of ordering online if they can't even read the order correctly. In fact I think they gave my pizza away to someone else that had place an order that they messed up. I am not happy with this pizza parlor. I would recommend it if u want efficiency. read more

decent pizza - not awful but not terribly impressive. kinda tastes like round table and this may be lose point for some, but i do like how they slice their pizza into smaller pieces so nibblers like me can handle slices without making my hands super greasy. plus, the pride of saying "i finished off 8 slices of pizza" (even if they're three-bite slices) makes me happy. read more

The pizza is tasty, the crispy pepperonis on top are the best! They do cut the pizzas into a million skinny pieces, but overall, it's good pizza at a cheap price. read more

We ordered a large Everest for take out and was very unsatisfied with it's taste. The pizza was unbelieveably bland all four family members felt the same. I've never eaten a pizza with no flavor before and I am at a lost for words. I do want to be fair and say the one star was earned as the store was clean and customer service was good. read more

This is our go to place when it comes to pizza. We've always had get service and delicious pizza with the exception of last night. Placed our order and customer service has always been great my issue is when my food arrived my order was wrong and the pizza was unusually greasier. Gave the pizza a bad taste. It'll be awhile before I order from them again. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Large McKinley - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

Had some fundraiser coupons that we had left at home. Understandable that they would not honor the deal without the coupons. Picked up the pizza at the time and returned within a couple of hours bringing the coupons to get some money refunded. They said they would have to call manager to see if this could be done. Of course it could but they refused to do. POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE!!! Looking back should have left the pizza there. This truely happened. Can you believe it? read more

I have ordered here at the Atwater restaurant for 5 years now with no problems until last night. I had my son order our normal pizzas after he asked about their specials. I heard him say a large 3 topping because it is currently $18.99. After he was done ordering, he said the total was around $28. I questioned it and told him to write it down next time because that was too low that what we normally get charged but they ended up sending a mini pizza with 3 topping instead of the large.I called to say no one said mini and I heard my son place the order and the girl said large 3 topping for 18.99 and that's what my son ordered.The manager didn't even offer to send another pizza and have us pay the difference. I was very annoyed by her demeanor and then she said she would charge us another delivery fee. Obviously the girl answering the phone made an error. 5 years and we never had an issue before. Very disappointed with the lack of customer service skills. read more

Buffet was great, fresh pizza, variety and decent salad bar. My daughter loves this place we come every other week!

We called in a pick-up order. Had we not, we would not have purchased the pizza. The eating area looks old & worn. It is not inviting. While we were paying, I observed a male employee throw something that looked like a piece of pizza topping at the female employee preparing the pizzas. Kids will be kids, but managers are supposed to make sure his kind of stuff doesn't happen. This was our first experience with Mountain Mike's. We liked the pizza just fine, but if there's a next, it will be at a different location. read more

Ordered pizza over the phone early to avoid the dinner hour rush. Was told 35 minutes. I arrived 37 minutes giving them a few minutes leeway. Was told it was ready yet it would be just a couple of minutes. How about another 47 minutes. They hadn't even started the pizza. Had they been honest I would have cancelled the order & left upset but not fuming. They kept ignoring my asking when will it be ready until I got loud. Then they offered me a dessert pizza free. Oh heck now it would have been another hour. All in all worst customer service ever at the Rush River Location in Sacramento. Pizza was not worth the wait! read more

How disappointing this place was. I ordered pizza for my grandkids and daughter over the phone paid for it ahead a time and went out to do some shopping. They came to the house to deliver and wasted everyone time by saying they couldn't leave it because I wasn't present! What a shame not even a courtesy call to me so I could come back and prove it was my order. The manager was the rudest woman ever. But at least I know now NEVER to order from them! Maybe better management or training for your managers would help and courtesy to your customers. read more

Customer service is really good Cindy the cashier is nice and very polite store is really clean and pizza was delicious thanks mountain mikes coming back soon read more

There pizza sucks And customer service sucks I told them I wanted more pepperoni and they didn't even put a lot and now to mention the delivery driver did not give me back my change! read more

Idiots and buffoons running Atwater location! Phoned in order at 5:03pm for extra large pizza. Came to pick it up at 5:30. Was told it would be ready in 3 to 4 minutes. Half hour later I asked what happened and was told a mistake was made and the new pizza would be ready in 5 minutes. Finally left with pizza an hour and 15 minutes later. Was so angry I asked who the manager was so I can go in later in the next week to calmly tell him how poorly his staff is trained and that he and his corporate bosses are a joke. Wow! Have not had these kind of issues with the Modesto location I usually frequent. Avoid this place like the plague!!! read more

Very dissatisfied with their service. My grandparents ordered a pizza for pick up a large combination, she asked them to cut the pizza into smaller slices. ( my grandparents are 78 and 88) they showed her the pizza but she was paying more attention to the smaller slices not even noticing they gave her the wrong pizza. So she called and asked for the supervisor and she told my grandma it was he own problem since she accepted the pizza and next time to ask for the supervisor when ordering a pizza. This isn't the first time they have missed up on her pizza I'm very upset how they treated my grandparents you would think they have have a little more respect for the elderly. Especially that they are veterans. They lost a great customer. read more

Not that impressed. Pizza is just okay. Very expensive. Not a lot of sauce. Salad bar a little sluggish. I would suggest you bump up the pies. read more

I come here a lot and the quality of the pizza is consistantly excellent and very affordable. They use a lot of toppings for the combo I always order. The staff and management are very friendly and professional. The weekday and Tuesday night all-you-can-eat special is a great value. read more

Pretty good customer service! But the quality of their dough has dropped drastically.. you can see the perforations in the bottom of the product and you can tell its mass produced not handmade anymore kind of disappointing read more

Pizza is mediocre at best. Very greasy. Service is absolutely terrible. I called in an order for delivery and was put on hold for almost 10 minutes (phone times it)and finally hung up and called back abs they answered can you hold I said no and they put me right on hold anyway. I called back and asked to speak to a manager and the girl was absolutely rude and after being put on hold three more times for at least 5 minutes each time and people who weren't even the manager kept getting on phone and when I would say are you the manager they would say no ill get them but didn't. Once I finally got to the manager he said oh well don't know what to tell you we are busy. I run a very busy, pretty big business and if my employees or managers acted the way they did I would fire then immediately. This guy didn't even care. I will no longer be using mountain miles for my business meetings or for when I buy all of my employees pizza for lunch or when I get pizza for my youth sports teams. I am also asking all of my family and friends and anyone else who has any guts and standards to boycott them. It is time we start demanding good service with the prices we pay. These aren't 5 dollar little cesar pizzas. One star only cause I can't pick zero read more