Headed over after the Jack Pine Lumberjack show, the ticket stubs had coupons for fudge- Win/Win!…read moreGrabbed pizza from Fox's Den pizza and enjoyed some ice cream. Marshall's staff was friendly & helpful - highly recommend the cherry cordial fudge!

Of all the MANY fudge shops in Mackinaw City (we counted 7!), Marshall's wins our vote. Not only…read moreare they actually making fudge on premises and on display, they are the most welcoming, friendly, and informative shop. The staff all went out of their way to satisfy our curiosity about their vast selection of fudge, candies, chocolates, and flavored popcorn, but they also provided us with tips and ideas of other things to do in the area. A shout-out to Brittany for her fantastic hospitality! We actually went to Marshall's twice!

I love their double chocolate expresso fudge. Friendly services. Clean shop. Live fudge making…read moreexperience.

Amazing, fast service and yummy fudge, taffy, and caramel popcorn!…read more As soon as we arrived, the staff behind the counter were so friendly and offered to help us and gave us free samples of the fudge. The fudge samples were a generous amount and so good! We decided on the double dark chocolate fudge, assortment of taffies, and caramel corn (with peanuts). We loved the experience and would recommend it to all tourists of the island!

We loved standing outside and watching them make the fudge from the window. We couldn't be inside…read morevery long because it was very hot standing in there the day we visited. The staff were okay, we felt a little rushed even though there was no line when we came in. But the fudge is amazing- literally the best I ever had. We chose the chocolate cherry to share. Your piece comes wrapped with a tiny wooden knife to cut to share. Staff told us it lasts weeks out of the fridge.

My children are now hooked on fudge. Delicious! Turtle was very good and all the fudge lasts…read moreawhile.

$33 for 3 pieces of fudge. $15 brittle boxes…read more The store in town sells Moomers Traverse City cherry ice cream (that waa deeeeelishus).

They don't say too much when you come into the store- I guess to let you browse but it was a little…read moreawkward. No prices are posted anywhere - she said 'it has to be weighed' - how about just a sign with the normal lb price somewhere besides the scale? So sharing here- $25.95/lb for just a single slice purchase. This is a gift for our family reunion so will weigh in on taste later. They do have specials - I've posted the current ones, but you have to buy quite a bit more and we just don't have room for anything else at the moment. Smells amazing in here tho.

Not authentic Mackinac Island fudge, fudge had a salty, processed taste. Truly disappointed.read more

This place caught my attention because you have to walk through it to use the restroom if you are…read moreover in Nonna Lisa's or the winery. Nice selection of salt water taffy, candy, caramel corn and ice cream. They even have an arcade. Where they got marked down was that I found the caramel corn that they make in St. Ignace 200 miles away at half the price. I know there is a mark up for the tourist in Mackinaw City but c'mon. I didn't buy any fudge because Joann's has that market cornered. Street parking. Organized and clean. Lackadaisical staff. If you go be ready to pay up.

One of the nicer fudge and candy shops in Mackinaw City…read more If one thing is for certain, it's that Mackinaw City is teeming with fudge shops. You look one direction, there's a fudge shop, whip your head around, there's another.. and another and another and so on. You get the point. Between the city and the island, I've lost count of how many there are. In fact, it seems like a few companies have sealed the deal on fudge by owning multiple shops under slightly different names all over town (and the island, plus a few downstate storefront locations) offering similar products, prices and promotions. Way to monopolize! It's a bit confusing, to be honest. Combine that with the fact that several of the traditional gift shops and restaurants have even gotten into the habit of offering fudge, and well, the choices are rather dizzying. With that said, not all fudge shops are created equal. Some have better quality fudge, taffy, truffles, ice cream, etc, while some have better salesmanship and service or a more competitive price. It all depends on what you want. We stopped into Mackinaw Fudge on vacation this summer. They had the single best fudge promotion going at the time- "buy two, get two slices free" of any flavor(s) for $16, which translates to merely $4 per slice. Nowhere else in town did we find a fudge deal as good as that one. So, what about quality? Well, I haven't really ever had anything that could be described as bad fudge from any of the shops around Mackinaw before, so the quality is pretty even among all of the competition (of which there is a lot), with a few variations. Overall, I liked the selection of fudge here, which was massive and the dark chocolate, mint chocolate and maple fudge were all rich and creamy and tasted legitimately sublime. For me, the dark chocolate varieties are where it's at. There's no telling how much of it I could eat, so reigning in my "inner fudgie" is a must. The taffy selection was pretty extensive as well and the deal on that was also great. I like homemade taffy (the good stuff, not the crappy carnival goo), so I thought theirs won out on the taffy taste challenge. It had great flavor and wasn't too stiff or sticky. Of all the taffy I sampled, theirs was one of the best when it came to consistency and flavor. Their saltwater taffy promotion was $6.99 per pound, not at all a bad price. As for service, it was hospitable and the guy that waited on us pointed out the various fudge promotions and operating hours of other fudge shops around town, showing us that he wasn't just trying to make a sale. There was no hard sale involved and he was generous with the samples. I think he doled out between 5-6 samples to us before we decided on what we really wanted. I didn't get to see anyone making fudge here (they do it in the back and not in front of customers), so that was a bummer and this particular shop stopped scooping ice cream awhile ago. I asked why and it was explained to us that they eliminated the ice cream counter to make way for more product. That, too, was a bummer, but I understood why they made the change. I was little disappointed because I remember getting fabulous ice cream here before, but I found a worthy alternative ice cream spot shortly thereafter. The fudge promotion remained the best in town, so we took advantage of it. It was the best deal of the day.

I have a soft spot for fudges so this is a biased review. I guess it's hard to make bad fudges but…read moreit's the perfect amount of sweetness & flavour. There are so many to choose from! It's a cute shop & service is great. Everyone's friendly around here which is an added bonus :)

Stopped in for a chocolate fix. Got the chocolate peanut butter cups, turtles and smores bar. All…read morewere great and hit the spot. Really cute gifts -and ice cream. Such a cute shop!!

I just received 3 flavors of fudge in the mail-choc pecan, choc pb, & rocky road. They're good, but…read moreless buttery, creamy, & rich as I've had from there over the past 6 yrs or so. They seem to taste sweeter than before & smooth, but the texture seems a bit different. I'm a very picky fudge connoisseur, & the fudge is still good, but this is the 1st time I haven't felt it was great.

******** and a few more stars. My daughter bought me some salted carmel…read more chocolates......deeelisousss. Love them, wish I had more! Never heard of Sugar Daddy's, no I can't forget them

greatest candy store everrrr!!!!!! staff is so nice and the ice cream is to die for ughhh!!!! i'm…read morewatering just thinking about it!!!!!