The staff was a little awkward but extremely friendly! Although I did not like my ice cream, they did give very large portions which I had to add a star for.. because who doesn't love more ice cream! Maybe it was just me but that's something I can look past of course (as I am very tall and have a rbf). There was no menu in the shop which I feel would make it confusing if you were trying to order anything besides just ice cream in a cone or cup. The ice cream here wasn't just basic flavors and they're was even descriptions on each flavor so you know what it contained too. I got Mackinaw Island Fudge and it tasted like it has some freezer burn which I wasn't to fond of, and the "fudge" in it just looked, tasted, and had the properties of chocolate syrup.. it melted faster than the ice cream and it ran like crazy! My cousin, who was with me, said her ice cream wasn't like mine and was okay. Our goal is to try a new ice cream place, every time we go out for some. read more

Great ice cream! Great service! Great location. Generous portions. Took the family of 6 here. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream - Patio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mackinaw City, Michigan

There were several flavors of ice cream to choose from. They were really nice about how we ordered since kids make messes quickly and no matter how much they want a cone it it better in a cup with the cone on top to dip in the ice cream in pieces. They had a couple tables set up for eating out side which was nice. read more

Showed up at 10 p.m because their Google search showed , they closed at 11 p.m as well as their storefront sign stating they closed at 11 p.m .....I guess on this particular night they decided to close an hour early . read more

My first one star review. Horrible service. Horrible portions. Not sure if we just hit a bad night? Went to the Sweet Spot a couple nights later, SO MUCH better. read more

Staff was very rude and snippy. They judged us for looking over the flavors even though we were the only ones in the store. The ice cream portions are horrible!!! They give the smallest scoops and is not worth the money!!! read more

They wouldn't eat us pick anything but vanilla or chocolate ice cream for a shake. Really? They're all right there.

We went there while walking around Mackinaw City and were very happy we did. We tried flavors we hadn't ever had before and will definitely be back on our next trip. read more

My family has been here more times than I can count. Super yummy ice cream, reasonable prices, and very generous portions. One of the highlights of our trips to Mackinac! read more

Was disappointed in the ice cream. Staff did not know much about the products being sold. Asked what was in a few of the ice cream and staff did not know. Turned out one had peanuts in it. read more

Best Ice cream I've ever had, run don't walk to this cute little gem of a place. When in Michigan my husband and I always stop here, he's from Michigan and grew up on Mooney's ice cream. He always gets the blueberry waffle cone and I switch it up. This last time I ordered Michigan fried cherry pie. It's creamy rich vanilla ice cream with loads of huge cherries and fried pie crust pieces. Tasted just like cherry pie. Good lord it was awesome. Customer service is always great, I don't understand the bad reviews regarding customer service. The blueberry ice cream is great too, taste really fresh almost homemade. We'll be back. read more

Th scoops are huge and the ice creams have homemade fudge in them. I had the Farmhouse Turtle Sundae ice cream and it was soooooo good. I believe that was the name; it was made with butter pecan, salted caramel fudge covered pecans. Yummy!!! I wish there was one in Las Vegas!! I won't be eating ice cream anytime soon. This was the real deal!!! read more

Mickey's Ice Cream - the front of mickey's ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mackinaw City, Michigan

See all

Yes, it's really that bad. Strike 1 - Misrepresentation of the ice cream that they're selling. The sign outside says they serve Mooney's, but the ice cream they sold me came from cartons marked "Deans" - DECEPTIVE & DISHONEST! Strike 2 - All the ice cream in the freezer was partially melted. Strike 3 - Service that night was extremely poor. Each time the door opened one of the girls would just roll her eyes and sigh. Giving her my order was a total imposition on her evening. The only reason I gave this establishment my business was that I had two kids who had their hearts set on ice cream after a long hot day. Sorry, not sorry, but three strikes and you're out! read more

I came here once over the summer and the staff was a couple of friendly dudes. I got a big cone of some exceptional birthday cake ice cream. What more could you ask for? read more

Nothing fancy, but we've been to Mickey's serving Mooney's premium ice cream in Mackinac city many times over the years and they never let us down. A consistent and enjoyable stop on our family vacations to Mackinac. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream - Quaint little place with great ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mackinaw City, Michigan

See all

Solid serving size, a "single" is more than enough for one. Flavor wise, not the best quality ice cream, it really lacked bite and the flavors were pretty standard. read more

Large portions and delicious flavors. Always stop here on our annual camping trip in the city. We will see you next year!

Very good ice cream and waffle cones. Good service by very nice staff. The only thing that I was surprised by was that the ice cream isn't homemade. It's Dean's commercial ice cream but they do have some unique flavors that I haven't seen before. read more

Ice cream was decent, but workers were RUDE. I don't understand the point of treating people like that. It's not that hard to just be nice. Next time, we'll go to one of the many other establishments in a two minute radius. read more

Me, my wife and kids have come here twice now and this time the only thing good about it was the ice cream. My daughter asked for two different kinds of ice cream in a bowl, they said no, we pay and walk out and instead of helping other customers, they were sitting there counting their tip jar... And then 2+ more people walked out with 2 different kind sof ice cream.. read more

The child's cone is gigantic! Loved it, but we could not finish it. I wish I had remembered to take a picture of it!

this is the best ice cream i've ever eaten in my whole life i'm tearing up because it was so beautiful and amazing. if love could be a flavor....it would be moose tracks.also anna is perfect. read more

Mickey's Ice Cream - a hand holding an ice cream cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mackinaw City, Michigan

Ice cream with an attitude. It reminded me of the soup nazi on Seinfeld. Direct quotes from the employees, "shut the door", "what do you want" and "step aside". It was a claustrophobic building and they didn't want the door left open, maybe because of bugs. The prices were okay, but it wasn't even good ice cream. They served Dean's and mine was very soft and tasted like artificial ingredients and not real ice cream. read more

This place is so amazing I had to create an actual yelp page for it. They give you a crazy amount of ice cream for a very low price. Found this place towards the end of our trip out here. Once we found it we went ever day after. If you are looking for some ice cream this is the place that you NEED to go. read more

I just got a small cup, 1 scoop but it was still a lot of ice cream, I didn't finish it but it was really good.

If I could do less than one star, I would. The young people working here were SO INCREDIBLY rude. Yelled at us when we walked in, yelled at us about what to order, yelled at us when we were paying, and then after we had left YELLED AT US AGAIN. We had 7 people with us and all of us were yelled at by the rude women working there. Would not recommend. read more

Love this place! You get your money's worth of ice cream. The staff is always friendly when I've been in. And that's not an easy job scooping ice cream and keeping a smile on your face. read more

Was here last night, 8/8. The girls working here are RUDE. We came about 20 minutes before they closed, and the one in particular was obviously irritated about it. We read reviews about the good ice cream, which it was, but this girl completely ruined the experience. We sat on the bench outside and could hear her complain about us and the other family that had been there, and she continued on for quite awhile, to the point where we just had to leave and wish the other people walking in luck. Absolutely dumbfounded at her attitude. I get it, people coming in late can be frustrating, but you're working in a tourist town, scooping ice cream. Grow up. Owners should fire her, immediately read more

Yum! Hand dipped flavors, wide variety, waffle or cake cones, sundaes and malts also available. $11 for a family of 4- all cones. Also cans of soda pop and water for $1- that's a good deal! read more

The kids size cone was $2.25 and as big as my head. A great deal if you ask me. My gf got the single (medium) sized cone (kid, single, double) and it was so big she threw half of it in the garbage because it was so big. Literally 4 huge scoops of ice cream. Finally an ice cream place that gives you your money's worth! read more

John S - thanks for posting. We wouldn't have found this gem without yelp and your post. Awesome ice cream and a super great value!