Delighted to find a local bean to bar chocolate shop on our trip to Nantucket. The owner was…read moreincredibly welcoming and informative about their chocolate as well as offering us a sample of plain dark or milk chocolate. We took home a bar of milk chocolate with strawberries, dark chocolate with cacao nibs and dark chocolate togarashi. Really enjoyed the dark chocolate bars but the milk chocolate with strawberries was kind of soft and almost crumbly. Maybe it was the moisture from the strawberries which were pretty gummy? Great chocolate shop but on the pricey side with a full size 75g bar being $24.

After reading the Nantucket Today, "2024 Best of" issue last year, we've been customers of…read moreNantucket Faraway Chocolate! Simply put, it is custom - gourmet chocolate made by hand from 'bean to bar' by Andre and his wife, Erica. Very high quality, purity, and deliciousness. The ingredients are exceptionally fresh and searched for, world-wide. The combinations of 50% or 70% cocoa and the addition of cranberries, ginger, orange peel, marshmallow, etc. make the bars quite a unique, adult treat. Toffee, bark, and cocoa - all are also exceptional. Prices very reasonable. Service is just the best. Wednesday, during tourist season (May to Labor Day) they run a class on how to make chocolate. We vacation on ACK, usually do two or three overnight trips, and about six day trips. One thing is certain: when we get off at Straight Wharf, we walk over to Old South Wharf and buy up a bunch of stuff. They also ship to the mainland, which is nice so we don't have to carry it around the island. No negatives whatsoever. A must visit chocolatier. 10DEC2025

I came to try Millie's Market ice cream after having a meal from Millie's restaurant…read more This little store has a lot of goods inside. They do sell alcohol, but only before 8 pm. The main focus is the dessert here. My wife and I wanted something that was popular and the worker recommended Moose Tracks. It is a vanilla based ice cream with miniature peanut butter chocolate cups and fudge. By far one of the best ice cream flavors I've had. I am usually not a fan of peanut butter and chocolate like Reese's cups, but the pieces inside this ice cream were delightful. The store sells some merchandise including clothing, accessories, some fruits, half-dozen egg cartons. Very impressed with Madeket portion of Nantucket.

This spot used to be a real bodega years ago. While it has a few real food necessities - milk, some…read morefruit, eggs - more than half the store is souvenirs. About 1/4 of the store is alcohol. There's some of the best ice cream on the island. This spot is handy in a pinch, especially given its location. Eat at Millies too while you're at it!

Was a 5 star but it has been closed this season due to, sadly, the poor health of the local…read moremanager. Ownership seems to have abandoned this island must-visit.

Um, I think the stores in Edgartown and Vineyard Haven are closed!!!! The Edgartown one is pretty…read moreempty. Too bad

Amazing people! Amazing customer service great incredible fudge. Highly recommend! Went to find a…read moregeocache and was met with the nicest lady I've ever met in my whole entire life. Tried the fudge, mind was blown. (Key lime pie)

We come here whenever we're in MV, a nice local business with great chocolate. They have a variety…read moreof items like chocolate covered oreos, pretzels, non parels, bark, fudge, and more! The woman who owns it makes it herself. Cute shop.

Best quality ice cream and best bang for your buck on the island! They scoop big portions, and it…read moreis a lot less busy than the other shops in town. There is so much patio seating, string lights for dark, and friendly staff. Don't skip the toasted coconut ice cream!!! If I could buy a whole tub, I would! All flavors I tried were full of flavor and goodies. Highly recommend!

Three Way Scoops in Nantucket is such a fun little spot for a sweet treat. Great ice cream, plenty…read moreof flavor options, and super friendly staff. Perfect place to stop after the beach or an evening walk around town.

I am so sad like literally sad. My parents went up to the vineyard for the weekend to check out our…read morehouses and brought me back what was supposed to be a lovely present a reminder of my misspent youth but instead of the beautiful light pink spotted with Cape cod cranberry fudge of normal size that I was expecting I got a hot pink tiny sugary blob of disgustingness. The fudge was always the length and width of the box and the depth was about half the box so that they could fit two pieces of fudge in their perfectly now it's maybe a third of what it was. Not only that my mother bought me Cape cod cranberry but there are no fucking cranberries. Cape cod cranberry was a beautiful light pink spotted with delicious Cape cod cranberries now it is a hot pink nightmare of sugary garbage. It's so sad that murdick's fudge has become garbage like many other things on the vineyard. Welcome to the fucking Hamptons... Or maybe like seaside Heights judging by The taste and texture of this disgusting fudge

Alright idk where these good reviews are coming from. We stopped in here because the line for Mad…read moreMartha's was out the door. Walked over to Murdick's and saw that it was completely empty- should've taken that as a hint. We got two ice creams- the Moose tracks and peppermint. I swear that's the exact same moose tracks that they have at Aldi. It legit tastes exactly the same down to the quality of the PB cups. AND it was horribly freezer burn. Almost to the point of it being inedible. I ate what ice cream was on the top of the cup and was just scraping at ice chunks after that. Peppermint was also freezer burn but not as bad. Overall just a disappointing experience. I haven't had ice cream that bad in a while.

Oh Murdick's.... some of the best fudge I have ever tasted…read more Get some while waiting in line for the ferry so you have a little of MV to bring home! :)

The smell inside this little fudge shop is worth the visit alone. Murdick's Fudge has shops all…read moreover the island, and it's a definite favorite with the tourists. You can buy 1/2 or full slices of fudge in different flavors, including: Cape Cod Cranberry, Rocky Road, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Penuche (maple syrup with walnuts), Chocolate Walnut, Vanilla, and more. Boxes can be purchased with 3 or 5 slices, and you can ship anywhere across the country. They also sell cashew and peanut brittle, popcorn (caramel, butter, and cheddar) & taffy at the Oak Bluffs location, and chocolates (turtles, etc.) at the Edgartown location. The fudge is not the best I've ever had, but it's pretty good & a nice treat if you're sick of all the ice cream (although, really, how can you be? I get both).

Nantucket Cupcakes is as good as it gets. I have never even considered myself much of a cupcake…read morefan in the past but I don't think I have tasted anything much better than these cupcakes. The only negative is there is not a shop downtown - The good news is they will deliver cupcakes to you anywhere on the island. Any trip to Nantucket is not complete without bringing some of these cupcakes back with you. I would recommend the Jetties Lemon and Nantucket Red Velvet flavors. Nantucket island already has a reputation for offering some of the best gourmet food in the world. Nantucket Cupcakes have taken it to the next level.