Sayle's is my new seafood obsession. Mostly because I love having an easy access to a fish…read moresandwich. There's a place to park, I can walk in, order a fried fish sandwich, look at some lobsters in a tank for ten minutes (the best part) and be out the door with a hot n ready fried fish sandwich in my hands. On my last visit, the woman at the counter was so happy. I was already happy because I was getting a fried fish sandwich. And then I was feeding off of her energy, and I was just having such a great moment in Sayle's Seafood! Now, I could sit in and eat here and bask in their fishy glory since there are tables, but I have yet to do so. I also love the view of the harbor from the front porch and that it's tucked down that little street and the vibe is so island that it contributes to the over-romanticism of Nantucket that happens in my mind but that's okay. The fish sandwich was really good. The time before that, I ordered the clam strips side, which was a lot smaller than I believed it was going to be. They were small individual pieces and fried well-done, while I do prefer a softer crunch. Next time, I will order the clam strip platter which comes with accoutrements. I also had their clam chowder, which I also thought was pretty good. I will be back for more seafood, and I hope that it is soon!

We had the 1.5-pound lobster dinner, which came with clam chowder, red potatoes, corn on the cob,…read moreand a side of butter for dipping. We sat on the deck, and the staff was so sweet--they literally took the lobster straight from the tank to the back to steam it. They even cracked it for us! It was incredibly fresh and absolutely delicious. Such a great price for the quality and freshness!

Holy yum. Breakfast bagels were amazing. The bagel itself was dense in a good way. Perfectly crisp…read moreand chewy. Not too hard. I got Asiago cheese bagel (sausage egg and cheese). The white cheese they used (idk which) was so yummy and added perfect flavor to the bagel sandwich. Most days I'd probably only be able to eat half but I was so hungry today so the full sandwich was good. They serve Starbucks and that was perfectly made as well (I got hot white mocha). There was an awkward situation where one staff member tried to hand us our bagel order then the other staff said it's not ready and they proceeded to go back and forth, confusing us as to whether or not we were okay to take the bag. Turns out it was the correct order, but only half of it. One staff member just wanted to put the second half of the order in the same bag and the other didn't understand that - causing confusion for us as well. But good service for us regardless just a little awkward. Cute store and good breakfast options. Would go back!

A must visit food establishment when you are in Nantucket…read more Whether or not you are cooking your own meals, or need prepped foods, NANTUCKET MEAT & FISH MARKET is a must visit. The raw meats & seafood section has a well-curated selection of meats, seafood and cuts. The shelves are stocked with items that will go well with the meat and seafood selections cooked in the manner you'll likely choose. Party items like wine, champagne, charcuterie board elements are available too. Their DELI is a great place to get your LOSTER ROLLS or even CRAB SANDWICHES. They make and serve coffee as well. They have a sizable parking lot which is overflowing with impatient vacationers in certain times of the day. All workers are efficient.

Came here after a day at Cisco Beach and WOW was I blown away by their lobster roll!…read more Located on Hummock Pond rd. We came on bikes. Very close to Cisco Brewery and on the way to or from the beach. This is a must-stop. We got two lobster rolls (which come with chips and a pickle) and to drink a sun tea! I was BLOWN away by these lobster rolls. I'm a bit of a lobster roll enthusiast. This was the best cold lobster I've had outside of Maine. They have a slight twist in the classic. Hardy amount of lobster, perfectly cooked, and lightly dressed and topped with chive. I think they drizzle them in a lemon butter too. The bun was outstanding, buttered and then salted, the extra salt is a nice touch. Drooling writing this review and remembering how good they were. They were that good! We also got "Hannah's homemade sun tea", sweet and refreshing. They also have ceviche, guac, and other things on the menu that looked great and I can't wait to try. Staff was friendly and welcoming. They have outside seating with umbrellas for shade. The parking lot gets packed though so come on a bike if you can. A+ 167 Raw, can't wait to come back.

The Food Truck is great, the food is expertly prepared strangely. Beautifully fried oysters that…read morewere smothered in Hot Honey Garlic Sauce rendering them wet. The Poke Bowl, is just Ahi Tuna, without veg or rice...just Tortilla chips? That food is delicious but seemly made for Californians or people from Fairfax Virginia.

Our go to source for protein from the sea! We stop by when we need ingredients to assemble our poke…read morebowls. Add this place to your shopping list!

We have used nantucket seafoods for many years to supply steamed, cracked and packed lobsters for…read morebeach parties. Last night was one of those occasions and NS, once again, did a fantastic job. The (18) lobsters were tightly packed in a Styrofoam box (easy to transport) and lined with aluminum foil. They kept warm for hours. Opening the box on the beach and revealing those red beauties was a moment to remember. Our beach party friends all asked who supplied the lobsters so I thought I'd write a review on Yelp.

Wonderful, friendly staff! Best fresh fish. We order cooked lobster to take out. Always perfectly…read morecooked and expertly cracked. And the sell fresh eggs from a local farm!! A++++++

We are regular seafood cookers. Bought a 5.5 pound bag of mussels from Gliddens and stored them…read moreshortly in our fridge before going to cook them up. When we opened and went through the mussels, over half the bag had long gone bad and the shells were open. Disappointing to say the least. Will not be returning.

I kind have been telling everyone about Straight Wharf Fish. A new player on the block/wharf - it's…read morecasual, but still upscale, with a covered dining area on the water and a modern, cozy inside. No reservations and early season, we had no problem snagging a table for 2. However, a friend recently shared they were told a 45 minute wait the other day. Prices and portions are reasonable to that of the Brotherhood and the Trap, and well executed. The fish tacos were delicious and my son's burger was basic but delicious. Heads up, while no kids menu, they did say they had a secret one - I'm imagining coming from so many families popping in. The burger as was $18 and a double patty with no toppings and homemade chips. The chowder was also really good with I believe some pork in there. It's been a minute, so I'm a little rusty. Service was great and kind. I didn't order any cocktails, but they did look small for the price - they may be bottled? I could be lying there. I saw a many a fried seafood and fries platter go by and they looked so good and fresh and crispy, in the best way possible. Overall, five star addition! I'm sure the lines have begun, but it's worthy of a wait, especially over at the Gazebo, so perfectly convenient. Ps: they also have a retail portion but I did not pay much attention to that side.

Excellent tasting food, service & atmosphere on the island using a hy-line ferry from c cod. We had…read morea clam chowder prob the most loaded with clams & other seafood in a long time. Then we had the swordfish griddled with fries & cole slaw & tartar sauce delicious w other generous portion, also an halibut tacos all in all I rate 4.5 stars

This review is specific to the Caribbean takeout menu, not the normal menu for Nantucket Lobster…read moreTrap. While wondering around town, we went down a side road behind the Nantucket Lobster Trap and a wonderful aroma of curry reached us. The takeout window has a special menu off to the right side of Caribbean curries and other dishes. We came back that night and were rewarded with some of the best food we had on the island. The chicken was so tender it fill off the bone, sauces were rich and flavorful without being too spicy. We tried Festival, which is a bread that is a little sweet, and found it good for dipping in the sauces. Everything was excellent. Give it a try, it is like a hidden secret on Nantucket.

Another incredible, highly prized by the locals, seafood / lobster shack on Nantucket. In town,…read moreeasy walk - parking is, well, Nantucket town parking. Classic old school looks. Nautical decor, stained tables, pictures of local lobstermen and boats. My only complaint: I am 6'6" and the tables / benches do not move at all... so it's a bit uncomfortable if you are tall or big. Open year round, limited hours and days off-season, including the Take Out Window. Damn good lobster. Steamers to die for. Coleslaw is nice and cold just like the Cisco draught beer. Prices are very fair and reasonable. Been there three times in '25, a great go-to when on ACK. Highest recommendation! 10DEC2025

I mean, on Nantucket, Bartlett's Farm is an icon. It's a farm, it's a nursery with the most…read morewonderful flowers and bushes, it's a high end grocery store, it's a deli, it's a bakery, it has merch, and so on. Now... everything is going to cost you a pretty penny, but that's Nantucket life for you. In June, you can pick your own strawberries. They offer up breakfast sandwiches, lunch options, they even have daily dinner specials like roast turkey one night and a tri-tip another. Some items are great, somethings are ok and somethings are eh? For a one stop shop though, this place is it. A few things: I don't love the donuts, Bake Shop is way better. The lobster salad is delicious. The sammies? They're fine, Something Natural or Henry's are better options, but they suffice. The cookies are incredible. Their dips, their salads - all so good. The produce? I spend all my money on their tomatoes. Anything they grow, you should buy, anything they don't grow is way overpriced. If you have kids, they have a nice little play structure right by the picnic tables (about 6-8 picnic tables) which is fun for my 3 year old, but also my 7 year old. With that, Bartlett's is a Nantucket legend and we must all bow down to Queen B.

What a great find on Nantucket. A good bike ride to the farm market but well worth it. There are…read moresome great finds here, from breakfast sandwiches, to fresh pastries like the chocolate donuts and blueberry muffins. Then there are pies and cookies too. And some great fruits and vegetables.Oh yea, there is local honey, some cool hats and shirts, great soaps and candles, and just about anything else you might need. A great find.

We encountered Yoho and its lovely folks at Cisco Brewers on a Friday, when we went for drinks and…read morelive music. A dozen oysters were $33 and well shucked with just a few shell fragments and LOTS of liquor left in the shell. Oysters (described as "Nantucket Blondes") were meaty, very briny as east coast oysters often are, substantial. They reminded me a lot of Wellfleets. Lemon wedges and horseradish + vinegar sauce were on offer as garnishes. Yoho has SO much good stuff on the menu, including a gorgeous ceviche, that I must come back to try. Reasonable prices for Nantucket. We're going to seek this place out.