New York By The Slice

I saw a pizza special on tv for dominoes pizza looked like a great deal 2 large pizzas for 4.99. I…read moredecided to travel to Dominoes pizza in Hartsville SC to grab the special. We get inside the place was quiet and there were two employees in the building. Looking around it was a clean establishment and the soda refrigerator was well stocked. They had a menu above the counter and menu on the counter. Young gentleman approached the counter and asked if he could help us we explained about the special that was advertised but he said it probably was online only. He said if we wanted to order online to that dominoes he would wait and gladly fix our order . Well we couldn't find the special online so settled for the managers special they had listed on the wall for 13.99 large 3 toppings. We ended up ordering Italian sausage, ham and beef on a thin crust pizza. We ordered and he said it would be ready in about 15 minutes. Staff was helpful and friendly asked if we needed anything else let him know. Our wait wasn't long at all. We got the pizza hot out of the oven. The only thing it was cut in squares and being from New York I'm used to having it like pie slices. But I forgot to tell him so. When I got to the car I just had to taste a piece. The pizza was really good and the thin crust was so crispy. The meat was fresh and not too salty I was satisfied. I would recommend this place and return again if I am in the area.

ordered a pizza at 6:30 said it would be delivered by 7:10 or 7:30 and turned into over 3 hours-…read morestill no pizza or even money back due to they don't answer the phone. definitely will be calling in the AM and corporate! If it would let me I would give 0 stars!

Front counter with menu above

Square Pizza slice

See all

Front of menu

Sophia's Pizzeria

3.7(63 reviews)

1.5 mi

The service and my Stromboli was delicious! The salad bar had everything to make a great salad.read more

They had a fire and decided not to open back up. So they are closed for good. Sorry about that.read more

Meat Stromboli

Large marinated chicken over Greek salad.

See all

Large Meat Lovers Stromboli

Wild Heart Brewing Company

4.4(73 reviews)

1.6 mi

Visited on a Friday evening and had a great time. There was live music which made the inside a…read morelittle loud, but we sat on the patio. Service was great and our server was friendly. The beers were great and we tried a variety of them. I got the chicken nuggets and couldn't believe how many came with it as an app. I got the sauce on the size since it was a bit spicy but the Gorgonzola was a nice touch! Everyone enjoyed their food and it was a great night!

I met a friend for a lunch date and the atmosphere was very inviting. I tried a flight and was…read moresatisfied.

Veggie burger with side salad.

See all

Papa Johns Pizza

2.1(7 reviews)

1.7 mi

Ordered online, found some specials, opted for text updates. Pizza was hot and ready when promised…read more Yummy too!

*Update: Manager did refund me. Also said she was brought in to help turn things around. She was…read morekind and pleasant on the phone. Hoping things have gotten better at this store now. Original Review: Walked in to order pizza. Was told it would be 15-20 mins... 35 mins later still no pizza. Can't get manager on the phone, have called 3 times now. Very poorly ran and managed... over priced pizza and apathetic services. Will be calling dominoes from now on.

Tomato and black olives on thin crust.

See all

Big Daddy's Pizza & Wings

4.2(5 reviews)

2.0 mi

I wanted to get some pizza for my kids, found this place online and had good reviews. When I…read morearrived a lady that work there was outside the door and started asking questions for no reasons and was guarding the entrance. It wasn't until she saw the car I was driving that she finally answered how much a large cheese pizza was. Really disappointed with this place, I ended up going to the mcdonald's across the street.

Ordered the garenden veggies pizza combo. Small (medium by other pizza places) pizza, 3 wings…read morew/choice of sauce and a can of soda. All for $9.99. Nice chewy pizza crust, not too thick or thin. Plenty of crisp veggies. Could have done with a little extra cheese, just my preference, and a zesty red sauce. I received 4 wings instead of 3 as they were smaller than usual. I chose the sweet chili sauce. Wings were nice and crispy even after the addition of the sauce. Came with 2 pots of ranch for dipping. Excellent value for money especially when you think many places charge $3 for the can of soda alone. Everything was fresh and hot, except the soda which was ice cold.

I stole a can of tomato sauce out of the pantry and put sauce on my dry pizza. It was better but not as good as it could have been.

Small (10") veggie pizza

See all

Pizza. yummy!

Pizza Hut

2.9(14 reviews)

1.9 mi

Food was hot and ready. I asked for my wings hard and being that I thought they weren't hard enough…read morethe young lady didn't have a problem re-dropping them for me. Exceptional service. Great job keep up the great work.

pizza was good with lots of toppings. We ordered half supreme and half veggie with extra onions…read more They did NOT skimp on the onions- loved it! Place appeared clean and service was good. BUT, there was NO SALAD BAR. The only salad listed was a SIDE salad and it was listed as an APPETIZER! There were no prices listed on the menu. There was hardly any sauce on the pizza and we were charged a dollar for a cup of maranara sauce - a small cup. I asked the sweet waitress for an extra cup and she brought one for no charge. There was no unsweetened tea and the pepsi machine was broken so no other drinks except sweet tea and water. so we ordered water. We wanted thin crust but the waitress did not offer an alternative. We got hand-tossed. It was pretty good. All-in- all not a real bad experience- there was NO MUSIC! Thank God! But the lack of sauce on the pizza , no soft drinks that were sugar free and caffeine free, no salad, the charge for marinara sauce made the experience lacking. And i did find a small hair in one slice of pizza. The main good points were lots of toppings on the pizza, the cleanliness of the restaurant, and the sweet waitress , and a nice quiet atmosphere.

See all

Little Caesar's Pizza

2.0(6 reviews)

2.0 mi

The delivery was good, The toppings on the pizza were correct, but the crust was soggy and when I…read morecalled and informed them all she would say was okay thanks

Whatever you do, don't go to the Little Caesar's in Hartsville. A male employee locked the doors at…read more9:30pm tonight, 6/22, when the hours were posted it would be open until 10. He opened them back up because so many people knocked on the door and told about 50 people, including myself, that our orders we had paid for online would not be prepared because his staff had left. I neglected to at least check out the online reviews which are almost ALL NEGATIVE since I was running a late errand and spontaneously decided to order some wings. DO NOT GO!!!!

See all

Zapata's Mexican Grill

3.7(29 reviews)

2.0 mi

My cousin and I recently moved here, and this was the very first restaurant we tried. Within the…read morepast two weeks, we've already been back around five or six times, which honestly says everything. First and foremost, the staff here is incredibly friendly and welcoming. Their menu is HUGE, with so many different options, and they were very patient helping us navigate through it and figure out what we were craving. They genuinely helped guide us toward different sections of the menu based on what sounded good to us. The portions are amazing for the price. Everything is very affordable, especially considering how much food you get. My cousin ordered fajitas, I ordered carne guisada, and we've continued trying different dishes every time we go because the menu is so extensive. One thing that really stood out to me was how attentive they are. One time, I ordered a dish with ground beef that I personally didn't finish because where I'm from, we prepare that style of meat differently. When they noticed, they kindly asked if I didn't like it. I explained honestly that it just wasn't what I was used to, and they were extremely understanding and apologetic, even though it simply came down to different regional cooking styles. I appreciated that they cared enough to ask. The next time I went, I ordered burritos covered in lettuce, sour cream, and sauce. They actually remembered that I hadn't loved the ground beef before and suggested I try a different meat instead. They gave me one chicken and one beef burrito with the meat they recommended, and I absolutely LOVED it. It was so good that I literally came back the next day and ordered the same burritos again, this time both with the beef they had suggested. Another small thing that meant a lot to me: I gifted them a Mexican peso bill and asked if they'd actually put it up somewhere in the restaurant. They said yes, and they really did! This has become one of those places that feels comforting and familiar very quickly. I've already recommended it at my job site and invited friends to eat here with me. Everyone who has gone has been thrilled with the experience ranging from the staff, the cleanliness, the flavor, the huge portions, and the affordable prices. You can tell the people here genuinely care about their customers, and that's what keeps bringing us back.

great customer service and great food will come by again. the drinks were delicious and the steak…read morewas nice and juic. Really enjoyed the meal!!!!!

Dog friendly patios win our hearts!

Steak fajitas plater. The sides came out after this picture was taken - shells, lettuce, sour cream, & beans.

See all

Shrimp & Chicken Enchiladas. It came with salad & beans as sides. A nice meal! Nachos & salsa in the background.

Spiro's Wingz & Ale

3.2(25 reviews)

1.4 mi

Take out order:- Good variety of food options. Portions…read moreare on the larger side and give value for prices charged. We opted for the lunch tenders plate. Came with 3 decent sized hand breaded tenders, choice of 1 side, we went with hand cut fries and a dipping sauce. Unfortunately they gave us basic ranch when we asked for the pineapple habenaro which was disappointing. The other plate was the Spy dog box. 2 hotdogs with chilli and onion rings. The dogs were loaded with chilli and a fork was definitely needed. We had requested cheese on the dogs but this was missing. The onion rings were phenomenal. Light crispy batter cooked to a golden brown and not a bit greasy. All in all, we enjoyed our food. It more than filled us up. A shame the sauce and toppings were missing. For the 2 plates and a Pepsi it came to just under 20$.

This place is Awesome,, I Loved everything I had ,, that's a 100 + for me and my wife ,, that's…read moregonna be our New spot for now on !!! Great place to eat !!! Great Job Guys !!!

Wings and Chili Cheese Fries!

Spy dogs and onion rings

See all

Wings and Chili Cheese Fries!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Patricia K.

0

9

0

7 years ago

I stopped in for lunch today and was the only customer. The waitress was pleasant and very attentive. The food was average. When I was getting ready to leave, the absence of customers became obvious. The owner is a lunatic who should not be near sharp objects, like knives. He was screaming and cussing at his employees, making Marine drill sergeants look like nannies. When I went to the cash register, the waitresses asked if everything was OK. I informed that it was except for the owner. He then approached me and began cussing me out. I told the waitresses to get another job because this guy did not respect them or the customers and it wouldn't get better. They were obviously embarrassed and continued to apologize while the lunatic continued cussing at the top of his lungs. read more

Kaylee E.

0

2

0

7 years ago

Read their Facebook reviews before going here. I have eaten here for years, as I grew up in this town...unfortunately the owner has become a very very outspoken RUDE guy. Not a good place & I would not recommend read more

Carol R.

2

8

0

11 years ago

Italian. Awesome. Will definitely come back. Much better than the other pizza restaurants in town.

Crystal M.

78

5

0

9 years ago

Husband and I love to dine here. The food is delicious and staff is friendly We Love coming here read more

Kathryn M.

0

2

1

12 years ago

Food is always hot fresh and always so good! Best pizza in town by far! Friendly staff

New York By The Slice - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Restaurants near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Things to Do near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Desserts near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Coffee near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Breakfast near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Dinner near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Burgers near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Shopping near New York By The Slice

BEST of Hartsville, South Carolina Movie Theatre near New York By The Slice

Best of Hartsville

Things to do in Hartsville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed New York By The Slice also viewed

Rebel Pie

4.5

(120 reviews)

This place is Amazing! From the moment you walk in the…read morestaff is friendly, the restaurant is clean, the appetizers are delicious, and it just continues to get better! I definitely recommend this place, it was well worth the hour I drove to try it! And the prices are great too!

Stopped by here during a weekend trip and man were we glad, the service was top notch, and the…read moreambiance really set the expectation for how good the food was about to be. When you hear something like 's'mores pizza' you have to try it but you know 'it's probably going to be a miss' but man, 9.5/10. Really loved the pie of the month as well

Mamma Mia

4.4

(21 reviews)

Mamma Mia's has been our favorite pizza spot for the past several years. Our favorite is the cheese…read morepizza. The crust is perfect- not too thick and not too thin. It has just the right amount of crispiness. Delicious! The staff is always very friendly and personable. We look forward to Friday's- our pizza night!

This is now my go-to for pizza! The calzones are excellent as well. (We have only sampled those 2…read moreitems on the menu.) No dine-in option but we live nearby so that's not a problem. The food has been consistently excellent. Everything tastes fresh and like someone actually cares about the food they are serving. I have never really liked pizza crust and usually just eat the toppings. But I will scarf a whole slice of this pizza and actually enjoy the crust. Just the dough alone is that good! Service at the drive-thru is prompt and friendly. Can't recommend them enough!

Stefano's

4.3

(184 reviews)

Great service.Young man kidding around with my young grandson…read more Food is always delicious! Cannot wait to see the remodel~

Never disappoints! I have NEVER had anything that wasn't delicious and always have to take food…read morehome as portions are ample!

Cibo by Stefano's

3.8

(84 reviews)

Best pizza!! The crispiest crust. The best Philly…read moreCheesesteak sandwich. Really good chicken Parmesan.

We visited Cibo by Stefanos today for a casual family dinner -- our first time there. My wife, our…read moretoddler daughter, and I were hoping for a chill family spot, and the restaurant did have a "hole in the wall" vibe that felt casual enough. Unfortunately, the food and service didn't live up to expectations. I ordered a calzone, my daughter had spaghetti with Alfredo sauce, and my wife had shrimp scampi. The only positive was portion size. Everything else fell flat: my wife's meal came out cold and bland, the shrimp was tough, and the sauce tasted canned. The bread was stale and cold, and my calzone felt more like a Hot Pocket than a freshly made dish. Service was slow and unenthusiastic, like the staff didn't want to be there. Considering the prices, the experience was not worth it at all. I would not return or recommend this place -- I would give it 0 stars if I could.

Big Daddy's Pizza & Wings

4.2

(5 reviews)

I wanted to get some pizza for my kids, found this place online and had good reviews. When I…read morearrived a lady that work there was outside the door and started asking questions for no reasons and was guarding the entrance. It wasn't until she saw the car I was driving that she finally answered how much a large cheese pizza was. Really disappointed with this place, I ended up going to the mcdonald's across the street.

Ordered the garenden veggies pizza combo. Small (medium by other pizza places) pizza, 3 wings…read morew/choice of sauce and a can of soda. All for $9.99. Nice chewy pizza crust, not too thick or thin. Plenty of crisp veggies. Could have done with a little extra cheese, just my preference, and a zesty red sauce. I received 4 wings instead of 3 as they were smaller than usual. I chose the sweet chili sauce. Wings were nice and crispy even after the addition of the sauce. Came with 2 pots of ranch for dipping. Excellent value for money especially when you think many places charge $3 for the can of soda alone. Everything was fresh and hot, except the soda which was ice cold.

Da Massimo Ristorante Italiano

4.6

(78 reviews)

This is THE BEST Italian restaurant I've ever been to in South Carolina! It is a tiny little…read morerestaurant that is a "hole in the wall" and the food was DIVINE!!! The staff were all very nice and friendly. The chef came from the kitchen to make sure everything was to our liking and I told him that it was the BEST Italian food in South Carolina...at least any of the ones that I've been to!!!

Da Massimo restaurant is wonderful. Delicious and authentic Italian meals and the service is…read moreexcellent.

Doughlicious

3.0

(1 review)

For the area it was around considering that. The aesthetic of the pizza shop itself it's appealing…read morebut more time needs to be focused on the quality of the food. Which is mediocre, either with effort or little to some. The quality is comparable to skating ring pizza, but the service was consistent. They offered a variety of different arcade games to be able to play during the wait considering this is the only pizza shop the submits itself as a pizza place in that part of SC, it gets a - 3.6 - TLDR: Digiornos pizza at home on the PlayStation would be just as good if not better, but for social reasons and family memories would recommend a place to eat at.

Michael D’s

5.0

(6 reviews)

Any of their barbecue sandwiches are great. Ribs are good in fact, overall, probably the best…read morebarbecue I've ever eaten

Best barbecue ever! They even have an inside place to sit with a classic home bar feel.read more

Marcella’s Italian Restaurant

5.0

(2 reviews)

I have eaten at Marcella's several times with friends or family and each time it has been a great…read moreexperience! Today went with family for lunch and my lasagne was the BEST! My, daughter is gluten free and she was extra thrilled with the many options. The staff is always so kind and friendly which is a huge bonus! The ambience is comfortable with touch of upscale for a great price point.

Excellent pizza, got the pesto style pizza. The pizza dough had very good flavor, service is fast…read moreand polite.

Bigs Meats & More

4.4

(37 reviews)