The food was really good and the the time from order to pick up was spot on. The staff was very friendly and polite.

Was a good place for a long time, now has let things go and it's run like a slumlord. Hour late on delivery, food looked like hot trash, so it went right there, the trash. When asked for a refund, they wanted the food back. I give them a year unless they clean things up. read more

New York Flying Pizza - Trash - Pizza Near Me - Bridgewater, Virginia

See all

This place is pathetic. Below average food, and utterly atrocious, actually hostile, service. We ate there twice in person because our son is obsessed with boneless wings, and they offer them. Both times, different waiters insisted on taking our order without writing it down. Naturally, both times, the food was wrong. The second time, we even said before ordering that last time the order was taken without writing it down, it was wrong. The waiter brushed it off and insisted on not writing it down. Then when we called them out on the fact that it was wrong, again, not happy since we had taken steps to ask them to ensure it wouldn't be wrong by writing it down, the manager (I presume) came over and chastised us for being hostile. While we weren't happy or pleasant, hostile was a laughable exaggeration. The only thing I can say is they did take the specific meal off the ticket that was wrong, which they did not do the first time, but that time we had not made an issue beyond a simple report that it wasn't what was ordered, which should have been more than enough to comp it. At that point, my wife and I had decided we would never eat there again, even though our son still wanted to. Then they even upped their game of incompetence and aggression. Our son placed a delivery order--first time he ordered since the incident described above--to his campus residence hall. The next thing he gets is a cryptic text saying the food was left at the garage. Confused, he asked us about it, and I told him he would have to call the driver and find out what happened because there is no garage at his campus residence hall. Apparently after not being able to communicate with the driver effectively due to language barriers, my wife called the restaurant to explain the problem. The restaurant repeatedly insisted the food had been delivered, despite the glaringly obvious explanation that they delivered it to the wrong address. While asking them to re-prepare the meal and deliver it to the correct address, they hung up mid-sentence. Charitably, my wife assumed it was a disconnect and called back. This time, they became aggressive, insisting that because the food was delivered to some unknown party the situation was "out of their hands". There would be no new order. There would be no refund. And once again, they hung up mid-sentence, this time leaving no doubt. This place needs to clean house, fire everyone who's currently there and has been corrupted with foolish policies, like refusing to write down orders, and then responding with acrimony when the inevitable complaints come in from their incompetence. Or maybe the fish rots from the head, and the owners set the tone, in which case there is no hope of correcting their complete failure at managing a business founded in customer service. Now we will refuse to allow our son to eat there, and this time given he's been left at nearly 8pm with nothing to eat, he's probably just fine with that. read more

Casual Italian restaurant. Pasta entrees served with ample size side salad. Found the service and food taste to be average. I'd prefer the pizza here. Located on Main Street, easy parking in front lot. read more

I placed an order online, after 20 minutes there was no ETA so I called the store. I was told they didn't receive my order so I placed a second order. While I was upstairs BOTH orders were delivered by a single delivery man. I called the store and was informed that my first order had been received but was in the kitchen so they missed it. I requested a refund for one of the orders and was told no refund because I received both orders. I explained it was an oversight/error on their part which caused the second order to be placed. They would not fix this. When two pizzas cost over 60 dollars that's a mistake that should be fixed.. UPDATE slice, refunded the first order. I am thankful for that however the restaurant took no responsibility in their mistake read more

Wonderful service and very kind staff. They handled our large party so well and the food came out so quickly. We were on a long drive so it was nice to stop somewhere and get good food fast. All the pizzas were great, especially the chicken bacon ranch one and the meat lovers. The ranch on the side was great too. read more

So we live right down the street from this place and it was great until it was sold to the new owners. We have ordered here a few times as well as sat down. Unfortunately when we have ordered out the order has never been right or on time . We have had to walk back to pick up items that was missing,burnt,etc... While dining in, in the summer we have not been pleased with the AC not set at a comfortable temperature and was sweating while trying to enjoy our meal. We experienced flys flying around and landing on our food as well as having to swat them away. The owner's daughter I'm assuming has her kids in causing an unpleasant environment. They run around and/or leave their IPads playing at a high volume so you can't have a conversation with the party at your own table. I believe a place of business this is very unprofessional and disrespectful. I wouldn't recommend going here and I believe after tonight we will not be doing business here anymore. read more

Order around $ 50 of items added 20% as tip. Never got my food. They went to a house that nobody was home. And left it. In fairness I had not updated my phone number. And used the address saved in the app, like I had done several times before. However with an order that size you would think they would bring it back to store. When I called in a very rude girl bandit told me tough " we left it at the address on the order". I- Asked were she said whatever was on ticket, no help, no offer to get it nothing. Well they got me, however we order out often, an will never order from them again. Probably have spent a few hundred dollars at there place this year. But no more read more

place was miserably hot. they were outside smoking pot instead of offering refills sandwich had tomato that was mush won't return gave 2 stars cause sandwich after removing the mush was ok read more

The building has one wall mount heater. It is so cold inside that the wait staff wears winter coats. When a waitress was asked to do something about the heat, her response was to just do take out. She was extremely rude. I suggest that you go somewhere else in Bridgewater. read more

Masks are not being worn by cooks or server. When asked why, they said because masks are hot and there's no penalty, so why should they? Not cool! read more

Pizza was good, nice thin crust and plenty of toppings. Salad was awesome, although I'm not a fan of canned or jarred mushrooms in a salad. Would definitely get again. No issues with service or delivery. read more

Ordered at 7:11pm at 7:47pm still waiting for the order. Highly recommended for those who love to wait extended periods of time for food.

Really good pizza and really good service. Add in their nice selection of beers and you have a winner

If you're looking for good or even decent Pizza, let alone New York Style Pizza, this is NOT the place. The only expectations you should have of this place is to "expect to be very disappointed." Pizza, pizza dough/crust was bland, tasted like cardboard. In fact, I think the pizza box it was in gave it more flavor than was originally in it. Caprese Salad, SMH, is NOT suppose to have Iceberg Lettuce or carrots in it, nor onions, nor peppers. It was a a disaster of a house salad with peppers and Chunks of mozzarella in it. The Tiramisu... SMH. #1 it was FROZEN! - enough said... Was more of a Coffee Flavored Ice cream cake. And they finished killing it off, finally taking it out of its misery, by adding whip cream to it. Definitely not the place to go eat at if you're already having a bad day... read more

Placed an order on Slice to be picked up at 4:00. Received notification in app that order was ready and arrived a few minutes after 4:00 to pick it up. They had not even started my Strombolis, so I ended up waiting 15-20 minutes. Slice always sends you a notification after pickup wanting to know if your order was ready on time. I told them that it wasn't and they contacted the restaurant and tried to get a refund of the $12 tip I had already paid in the Slice app. The restaurant refused stating that they were sorry, but they were busy. This is absolutely not true. We have ordered from here before on Slice and apparently they don't don't like you using Slice. My husband went in to pick up a previous order and when he said it was an online order from Slice their demeanor changed and they started complaining in Spanish about Slice orders. I will not order from here again and will make sure my coworkers, who frequently order from here for lunch, are also aware. read more

What did I order? 1x NY Pizza Party Pack which consisted of the following: 2 Neapolitan pizzas, 1 Grandma thin crust pizza, and 1 Sicilian Pizza. When did I order? Apr 2015 Cost of order? 1x NY Pizza Party Pack for $89.95 each Discount (code: GIMMEPIZZA15): $-13.49 USD Subtotal : $76.46 USD Shipping : $24.99 USD Total : $101.45 USD Review- I didn't realize I ordered 4 Cheese Pizzas (my fault). I should have read what the details of the Party Pack. At first we thought the cheese tasted sort of unique and was a nice change from the typical cheese pizza but once we got to the 2nd cheese pizza the uniqueness was nothing to write home about. The crust was pretty good but other than the crust I just didn't think it was that great and I tossed 2 of the 4 pizzas in the trash. I actually started getting sick every time I would have a slice on the 2nd pizza. In my opinion I wasted 100 dollars on cheese pizzas and I would not order from here again. I would not recommend the "cheese only pizzas". Maybe the other menu items are better. read more

Rude staff, waitress made it sound like it was a huge deal to add thousand island dressing to a sandwich. Then kept questioning what we wanted on our subs. Brought a slice of pizza 15 minutes before our subs. Then never brought our to go sub. She was clueless and rude and had a attitude problem. Service sucks! read more

Horrible service from the owner ! Almost 2 hour wait for a burnt , cold pizza ! Well never go back

Solid pizzeria. Much better than most that I've tried in Virginia. I'm from Long Island and can be pretty picky. Solid marinara sauce for pasta and pizza and pretty good pizza. My one complaint? STOP PUTTING WHIPPED CREAM ON THE CANNOLIS! Agh they are great plain and don't need the whipped cream or the Hershey's syrup - that just ruins them. read more

Their pizza is very delicious but unfortunately I won't be eating there again. After eating, I waited in the line to pay for my food. While waiting, I saw a long-haired Spanish guy picking his nose and then made a pizza without gloves. So picking his nose is what disgusted me the most and I think all restaurants should wear gloves. My only hope is he didn't make the pizza I ate! read more

My extended family lives in Bridgewater, so whenever I come to visit, this is their "go-to" place for pizza. Maybe I'm a bit biased because I've lived in larger cities where you can throw a stick and hit three pizza joints, but I know I've had better pies in other small towns. They run a few special combinations that include sodas, breadsticks and other things, but I'm never certain that they're a good deal. The pizza itself is unremarkable, with a thinner crust that's slightly reminiscent of cardboard, and a sweet tomato sauce that tastes a little off to me. It's not the worst pie I've ever had, but it's not going to blow your socks off, either. If this is honestly the best pizza place in the Bridgewater area, as my family believes, then I am deeply sorry, and I weep for you, B-water residents. read more

Oh man... The breadsticks??? Awesome, and the pizza is great too. But you gotta try the breadsticks.

Always make it a point to come here when visiting Harrisonburg. Pizza and Stromboli are very good. The Sicilian Special was quite good?

Unfortunately, the eggplant and baked ziti isn't any better than their pizza. Is Campbell an Italian name? I wonder because the sauce is reminiscent of canned tomato soup. Maybe, I'm being a little harsh. Sorry Campbell's. It was literally orange and totally tasteless. I ordered the eggplant rollentini. The filling was "okay". The spaghetti side was swimming in water. When I sent it back to be drained, they added more orange sauce. Tossing ziti with ricotti and orange sauce and melting cheese on top does not make baked ziti in my mind. You know how sometimes great service will make things a little better. The service wasn't making anything any better. Take our order...check. Deliver our food...check. Refill our drinks, ask about our order, ask if we want anything else...no checks. You pay your check is at the counter on your way out. I feel bad for Bridgewater residents if this is the only Italian restaurant in town. I would recommend driving a few miles and checking out Harrisonburg. read more

Love Flyin Pizza. Kinda bummed they aren't open on the weekends anymore. The Calamari here is some of the best I've ever had! Give it a try if your in good ole Bridgewater! read more

Great restaurant really. Wonderful food. Great quality. Great service. Location is just a little hidden. Worth the find though!

The pasta is decent. The pizza crust is good (for Virginia). Even the meats and seafood are fairly good quality and are prepared well. What completely runis everything is the sauce. The same "red" sauce is used for pizzas, pasta dishes, subs, etc) orange and tastes like it was dumped straight from a can and simmered for hours...with a dirty dishrag as the only added ingredient. The only reason I gave it 2 starts is: the fried calamari is delicious and cooked perfectly (nothing gourmet but excellent for a pizza shop), their salads (nothing special but that with the calamari is a great take-out meal), and the quality of some of their pastas (just hhld the sauce!) read more

I think they offer a great Italian variety for decent prices. The pizza is great and the atmosphere is laid back. The only complaint is the time the food takes to get out is inconsistent. read more

Wonderful authentic italian cuisine! Great place to go with the family or grab a beer with some friends and watch a game. I enjoy everything from their wonderful Double Stuffed Crust Pizza to the Steak and Cheese Sub to the incredible Rigatoni in Vodka Sauce. This place will leave you full and wanting to come back for more! read more

I ordered 2 pizzas dec 17, the email said 3 day delivery. I called the 22nd when I found out it wasn't delivered. The guy said bc of the holidays maybe it would go out after the new year. No email to say bc Xmas and new year fell on Wednesday there could be a delay. The guy said he would call me the next day to tell me for sure when they would deliver. No call. Forget the Facebook advertisement that says delivery for the holidays. I'll be lucky if my pizza I paid $127 as a Xmas present mid December gets to its destination by January. read more

My wife and I recently moved to Bridgewater from NC, but we're originally from the northern suburbs of Philadelphia. We haven't found a decent cheese steak until we tried the ones at NY Flying Pizza. They're quite good and very close to the "real thing." Their wait staff has been very good to us, even allowing us to customize our cheese steaks like we get them in PA. On a busy night expect a little wait as the cashier on your way out, since the wait staff doesn't take your payment. We've eaten there twice and will go there again. read more

Not impressed - ordered pizza by the slice and it was like it had been setting out for quite a while. In my opinion, their claim of "best pizza in town" is not true. Go 1/2 mile down Main Street to Francesco's. read more

I have had pizza from coast to coast and the pizza i had last night was the worst i have had in my life. Crust was burn't so bad that you could only eat the top and then that was very poor, no sause to speak of.Any body that thinks this pizza is good doesn't know good pizza. will never go there again. read more

I have been going to the pizza place on a regular basis. We have froze the last 3 times there. Decided to speak with the owner and make him aware ---- but as you looked around, everyone was sitting with their coats on even the waitresses had jackets on. The owner said the temperature is set on 75. I told him to go sit where I was sitting and when the heat turned it blew cold air. Then I heard a waitress complain to him and he did not seem to care. After reading some of the reviews here I am finding that he has not resolved any of his issues or he does not read his reviews. So sad, food was good not great just like the idea of a small place that you like to visit and could enjoy yourselves. Wishing this place the best, maybe the students will keep him in business, not too many places to go in the area. read more