My wife and I were hankering to try some New York style pizza, so we checked out NY Pizza & Pasta at Campus Corner. It was off hours, in between lunch and dinner, so it wasn't crowded, and the manager/cashier on duty was very friendly and telling us about the history of the store, and helping us with the order. We loved the lunch special: either 2 pieces of pizza with a drink, or a big slice of pizza with a house salad and a drink, for a very moderate price. The pizza was fantastic, and we loved the freshly made dressings for our salads. We definitely plan to be back! read more

The pizza is the best New York pizza you will ever find in Oklahoma. It is the best pizza I've ever had. The service is always delightful. There are always kind and wanting to help the desserts are solid. read more

The pizza here is just like it's from NY. The slices are the right size and it reminds me of eating pizza back home. This is REAL NY PIZZA right here. FUHGETTABOUTIT! read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pizza by da slice! - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

My main problem was the delivery service. Pizza was pretty good but cold when delivered 50 minutes after promised. They use a third party delivery company that doesn't have reliable staff. I got a discount because of the delay but would definitely not order delivery again. read more

Food is incredible. I read that the garlic knots were dry and doughy. That was NOT my experience. Garlic knots were great! My fiancé and I got the 18' pizza and it was HUGE. Loved it. Hot honey goes really well with chicken bacon ranch pizza. Service was great. Guy that served me was very chill and nice. Watched the OKC Thunder game on the 8 or so TV's in the bar area. Great atmosphere. read more

classic ny style in all the right ways . a rare staple of campus corner for many moons . read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Pizza is always good but that's all we ever get. They get your order prepared in a timely manner and do a good job keeping everything clean. read more

First and foremost I had an out of body experience here at New York Pizza in Norman Oklahoma! I have traveled many states and have never been as impressed as I was tonight. If I had to give it a star rating I would give it 6 out of 5 stars. If you have not visited here you are genuinely missing out. #goat read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Garbage. This is not New York Pizza. This is Costco pizza. Even those two dummies that run around Costco yelling boom wouldn't give this pizza a boom. If you are 19 and drunk and this place was open at 2 am, it would soak up the alcohol. The reviews of this place are nonsense. They show the ignorance of the people writing them. There is nothing here that resembles anything in New York. Look at the crust. That is not a New York crust. It's too thick. The sauce is a bad food service canned sauce. This is not even a good college town pizzeria. Think Ian's in Madison WI or original Cottage Inn in Ann Arbor or even Daniel's at Rutgers. read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

As good as pizza as you will find in Norman, friendly staff, order was fast , restaurant was clean, wish I had more thumbs

When I first came here, love the food here! Great garlic knots, pizza in general is phenomenally delicious, service is decent and the ambiance is chill, with a bar with tasty drinks. read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - This is a small custom made pizza with pepperonis, extra morze cheese and jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Pizza is pretty decent for a chain restaurant. Never ordered a whole pie, only tried it by the slice. Had a calzone this past Saturday and there was a ton of ricotta cheese but not much sausage. Felt like they really skimped on it. Crust had a nice amount of buttery garlic. read more

The setting is straightforward. Late night pizza, drunk college children, immature register worker, rude kitchen staff. If you're expecting anything more, move along. The pizza tasted like the boxed, frozen variety from a big box grocer. We were really hungry and figured out how to stomach just enough. The rating would have been three stars, but they lose another star for the disappointing and entitled attitude projected by staffers, beginning with two back counter kitchen employees and ending with the register person. Unfortunately, remarkably disappointing all around. read more

Went to New York Pizza and Pasta on Campus Corner in Norman, Ok after the spring game "Boomer"!!. The place has a cool NY feel to it with old brick walls and a nice bar area. On game days, you can hear the crowd from inside. I got two traditional cheese slices "one bite everyone knows the rules"....Service was great, food was ready in about 5 minutes. I would consider this a NY style football pizza... Pizza had a great undercareage, little NY flop but had a great crisp, cheese was solid and fresh, sauce was tangy and fresh...see that burn bubbble, just like i like it...Gave the pizza an 8.1, great Pizza, not just for the for the OKC metro area but for anywhere. read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

7.5 / 10. Pizza is hit and miss, some is good some is bad depending on what you order. Service is ok. It was game day so the ambiance was great I'm not sure what it's like in a Tuesday at 3, probably boring read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Please do not support this business if you care about people with disabilities, as this business will blatantly and unapologetically discriminate against them. On 10/7/2025 around 1 pm, I came into this establishment with my study group and my service dog to get lunch. The man behind the counter, who I later learned is the manager, told me that 'they don't allow dogs in here'. I informed him that my dog is a service dog, and he is not legally allowed to ask me to leave. He then, illegally, demanded to see her paperwork. As there is no requirement for service dogs in the United States to be certified by any organization, I informed him that there is no such thing as legitimate service dog paperwork in the US. He then went quiet for a moment, but after I ordered, he told me that I would need to eat outside. I informed him that it is illegal to make me eat outside just because I have a service dog, and he responded with 'we will take that chance'. Additionally, there was no outside seating at this establishment, so he was just using alternative wording to kick me out. My service dog was very well behaved the entire time we were in this establishment and was not causing any kind of disturbance. As the man I spoke to in the restaurant did not identify himself as a manager, My parent called to speak with a manager the next day, and spoke to a man called Shawn, who I believe is the same person. Over the phone, he was belligerent and combative, claiming it was his right 'as an American' to deny anyone service for any reason. This is not true in cases of discrimination. After this, he told my parent to speak to his lawyer. When information on how to contact his lawyer was requested, such as the lawyer's name or phone number, the manager simply hung up the phone. read more

The number one place I know of for great New York thin, foldable slices or whole pies. Salads and pasta dishes are also available. There are a lot of tables for dining. A fixture on campus corner since my college days, the owners are actually from New York. They do it right! Still have to try Pronto NY in OK City. To be fair to negative reviewers, we usually order a fresh whole pie, which can make all the difference! read more

Closest thing you're gonna get to a slice of NY pizza in Oklahoma. My favorite All authentic Italian food and you can get a NY Dog too.. Family dining and dive bar feels, altogether a great atmosphere. Drinks are cheap and the beer selection is pretty big also. read more

See all

Very convenient that they're open late on the weekends. Pizza was affordable by the slice. Did not however enjoyed the ingredients and flavor read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

The pizza is definitely NY style. Nice and chewy. Decent pepperoni on it. But you don't go here for the ambiance. It's a pizza joint with good REAL pizza. read more

Ordered a pizza on line! Large pepperoni! A nice 18 inch za but it did not taste New York Style! The crust was way to thick! Honestly- Not horrible but not great! NOTE: I paid for this online. They make you use the Slice App. I paid ~ 23 bucks. When my son in law got there to pick it up...he was told he did not pay for it! He knew I did and said so. They told him he did not. He called me over and I had to show them my online receipt. They refunded what he paid (we think)! NOTE: make sure they don't charge you twice! It was barely worth 23 bucks but a major rip off for 46! My son in law will make sure they refund his card! But I wonder how often a place could do this with unsuspecting people who never know nor check! The lady told us they have a new system. However son in law also told me the last time he ordered 6 months ago or so they did the same thing. NOTE: CHECK YOUR COST CAREFULLY IF YOU ORDER ON-LINE! You do not want to be charged DOUBLE! read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Food is mediocre at best,, that is when there not "out of it", wjich seems to be often. Plus the owner's an a%%!

Good pasta and beverages make this essential for Campus Corner social events. Spaghetti withe meatballs works just about any day.

We love going here feel like we are back at our 2nd home NYC! Big slices of pizza and Cannolis are awesome!! read more

I Like the Pizza very well, as well as the employees. Very efficient at their work. Definitely a nice place to visit after going to the bars or going for low price food. Very good food the provide read more

We ordered delivery from New York Pizza over the weekend...an 18-inch pepperoni pizza and spinach artichoke dip. If you're in the mood for some New York-style pizza, this is the place for you! The pie was enormous and perfectly topped; generous amounts of cheese and pepperoni were perfectly spaced and extended close to the edge on thin but not floppy crust. The spin dip was maybe the best I've ever had - super rich and creamy in a big tub with what seemed like an entire loaf of sliced and expertly toasted bread. We had more than enough food for four and couldn't have enjoyed it more! read more

New York Pizza & Pasta - 18" cheese pizza with pepperoni, spinach artichoke dip - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

On gameday, it's always NY Pizza. Love the alcoholic red slushies! Crowds are always here though if there's something going on. It's not exactly Norman's best kept secret. It's been around for decades. Still, whenever I go out of town, I'm always craving NY pizza when I come back! read more

Great service and friendly faces. Good food and low key place to watch game. Trevor is the best.

Fair pizza. Had small sausage and mushroom pizza deep dish. Really was purely marginal at best. Sewer smell existed near where I ordered and paid. Always hate that. Not a fan. - The Plain Truth. read more

Worse Italian for we have ever had. Garlic knots were raw, calzone was raw and very few pieces of pepperoni, spaghetti had about three teaspoons of sauce paid for mushroom and got three slivers, meatballs were cold in the middle and there was only two, sauce was scarce. Don't waste your money on this. A 2.00 frozen dinner would have been better. read more

Went to New York Pizza for the first time in Norman with my wife and child, and when I was asking my 9 year old what they wanted the owner rudely said "hurry up bitch I don't have all day". I was grossly appalled by the comment and after asking for the owner the same man returned with his middle finger raised pointed directly at my child. I will never come back to this establishment and I highly suggest anyone that cares about customer service ever go there. Would give 0 out of 5 stars if I could. read more

This is my go to pizza spot in Norman. I never gotten anything here that wasn't excellent.

Not worth the price and frustration. Either the store is always out of something, like bread, or the employees just don't want to make the food. They charge High prices for their product but delivery marginal quality at best. They constantly change the time frame for the food where 20 minutes turns into 45 which turns into an hour and a half. The "customer service" from them and the app they force you to use is horrendous. Once they have your money, they're done and they obviously don't care about repeat business. read more

Keep an eye out if you order online! Multiple times we have been asked to pay again in store. They'll refund if you catch it, but insist it's not paid for. Also, you can hardly call this NY style pizza. Mediocre at best. Crust is too thick. Toppings are sloppy. Overall meh read more

TERRIBLE PHONE SERVICE... when I went to call NYP to inquire about their karaoke night they proceeded to lie about the day that it was held, and the time that they closed. I am greatly disappointed and hope that those don't make the same mistake that I made. Pizza is good though. read more

This is a place my friends and i attend after all our nights out. We love it. During a recent late night visit, the owner (who no one knew was the owner) began to bang on the women's bathroom door and try to get in while it was in use. We told him to stop and that girls were in there as he angrily went for the men's restroom next. With us being upset with his attitude, he told none of his workers to serve us which they obliged. The owner was more worried about proving a point than understanding the uncomfortable environment he created. A shame. read more

I'm writing this review based on my past few experiences. Usually it is a great place to hang out. The past few times I've gone in, the staff has been cliquish, short, and off-putting. I've asked for a beer, and the first time they treated me like an asshole for asking. They stated the bar was closed. I went today 2.5 hours before they close. Guess what? Bar is closed. I asked them if none of them had a liquor license. ITS CLOSED was the response. I asked again if none of them had their liquor license, and this time I got a proper answer of no. I'm not sure if it's the new management, or staff that doesn't want to sell product, but when I go out of my way to sit down and have a cold beer, then am met with rudeness, it makes me not want to go back. The place was empty, except for three 19 year olds (I can only assume) who were already boxing up pizza to take home. I'll change my rating when this gets rectified, but for now, it's looking like NYP has gotten pretty lousy as a place to hang out and spend your money. read more

Great food, great service, great sports and music. great bartender service from Bree. Will be returning

Dishonest workers. I recently dropped my wallet after a night out and the next day had narrowed it down to here. I called and asked if they had my wallet two times before having to go in and ask to which again, I was told they did not have a wallet. It literally took ringing the Tile I have in my walleye for them to magically find it in the back room in their "lost and found." Lied 3 times to me about my wallet and had to be proven wrong. Obviously I didn't get the money that was in my wallet because "whoever turned it in must have taken it." Additionally, any attempt to speak with a manager was met with the message that i would have to have the manager call me back, which never happens. read more

Awesome pizza, pasta and wings. Large group so we ordered a wide selection of items. Everything was wonderful, including the service. Will definitely be going back soon. Limoncello cheesecake is amazing. You will want to save room for it!!! read more