My wife and I enjoyed a great breakfast with friendly staff on hand to take care of us. We were…read morein town for an early morning swim meet at the local high school and Theo's Diner was right around the corner. Food was terffic! So much food - I couldn't finish the Pap's breakfast - it was very good & pancakes had a wonderful vanilla flavor. My wife enjoyed the grilled cheese egg sandwich.

Food is homemade. Breakfast is phenomenal and inexpensive. Homemade soups are excellent fried…read moreshrimp basket, bowl of soup and dessert. $20

Not impressed. Inside of restaurant left a lot to be desired. Only had a few slices of pizza but it…read morewas so dismally bad that I would not give it a second chance. Smelled like air freshener, seemed dirty. Servers were nice though. Not sure if they serve other foods in the morning? The place is packed at breakfast time- not sure if those are 3rd shift people getting pizza or if they different menu at that time.

I am fortunate enough to have visited this establishment when it was under previous management. I…read morehave to admit I do not really remember the taste of the food from back then, but the one thing I do remember is that the service was super duper friendly, and it still is. Of course, in all fairness my friend grew up (from birth) in Newville, and so literally everyone knows him. The food was very decent. I got the prime rib special, which came with 2 sides. I got the side salad and the fries. Their battered fries was delicious. I am a sucker for battered fries. The salad was decent and fresh with the dressing served on the side in a little plastic container. The prime rib was cooked perfectly, but unfortunately overly salty for my taste. The portions were generous, and the prices decent. The atmosphere is laid back and everyone is very friendly. It is packed on a Sunday after church and many tables get lovely sunlight through the windows.

Service was poor. The food was partially raw. Waitresses greeted us and then sat down in another…read moredining room for ten minutes before she came for our order. She spent time giggling with the other waitress and making fun of people. Very upsetting,

Stopped by on a Thursday in March of 2026. Got a beef with…read moreegg noodles in gravy. Cheese covered cauliflower. Broth Soup with chicken. Corn and onions A water with lemon. Hot Open Turkey w mashed potatoes. A sweet tea. It was all good. Staff was great!

The service is friendly and quick. Very relatable. Professional but felt like family, felt like…read morehome. Had a seated quickly. Got us our drinks quickly. Good kids cup with fun straws for the little kids. Ask the right questions. They have a wide and delicious menu with omelettes and breakfasts that is delicious. The prices are excellent. Very, very worth the price. This is a fun family atmosphere, it's like a giant country kitchen sort of dining room room. They have small booths. They have big tables. They got a nice fireplace. I have to imagine that place is like Cracker Barrel expired to be like this. Not so much but it's meaningful stuff. I loved the brisket omelette. My little split a cookies and cream on it. They loved it. They cleared their plates quick quickly. She got apple crisp waffles, a.k.a. pancakes with abs, according to my little brother, my 14-year-old says five out of five stars I would go here again. My youngest says 10 out of five stars. My sister-in-law says that her omelette was fantastic. Epic breakfast in the middle of a trip.

Great Pennsylvania cooking. Hickory Ridge always has amazing food and an extensive menu.read more

Food is awesome. Service was great. Portions were large. Had the Buffalo chicken sandwich it was…read morehuge. Wife had a pork loin sandwich again, HUGE. Also had breakfast there. If you're in the area it's a must try!

Had the best cinnamon rolls here, hands-down. Accompanied by excellent customer service.read more

Great food and service. Nice quality and selection of appetizers, main courses and drinks.read more

Excellent food, great atmosphere and service. I had the crab grilled cheese, my husband the banh…read moremi, and both were delicious.

Monday lunch Ice tea, very good…read more Cup of beef veggie soup, very good. Cobb salad. Chicken way undercooked, it was crunchy and had a snap. Egg was dyed purple, food coloring, no thanks. Well I'm leaving I need to go find some lunch.

While passing through Carlisle, PA My wife and I stopped at Mays Family Restaurant. The restaurant…read morewas quaint and clean. The staff and cook were warm and friendly. We had a special which was a seafood trio of haddock, shrimp, and scallops. Perfect portions and very tasty. The fries were fantastic and the coleslaw was to die for. We highly recommend this restaurant for the inexpensive food, atmosphere, and easy location. You won't be disappointed. Joe & Cathy Lennon Boston, MA

This place was just what we needed a hearty meal to go about our day. The country fried steak with…read moresawmill gravy was the best and I would definitely get this again.

This place is very convenient off of the turnpike. Parking is easy. Ambience is casual, clean, and…read moretidy. The desserts look fantastic. The service was friendly and our kind waitress treated us just like the many regulars there. We got our food quickly. The bill too. The fries are those kind that have like crumbles on them. Not my favorite but they were well fried. We had a burger that was a little overcooked and tasted just like one you could make at home. Also had a tuna melt. The bread was warm and toasted stout the tunela was cold. I found it odd that the tuna wasn't on the toast when it was "melted". Tasted good though. I would stop here again but probably get dessert for my meal.

Danielle was awesome. Best service I've experienced in months from anywhere!…read moreCheesesteak sandwich was awesome

Food was terrible. I ordered the pork and sauerkraut special with mashed potatoes. It was a plate…read moreof cold, unseasoned sauerkraut with 2 small pieces of chewy pork accompanied by a lump of instant mashed potatoes. It was disgusting. My husband ordered a seafood platter but received a plate of pasta with tomato sauce and garlic bread. When questioned, the waitress said "yep, that's the seafood platter". Never again!

Bravo Brother's in Newville, PA. We order from you often and can highly recommend your food and…read moreservice to include delivery service to our home. Tonight we ordered a pizza and it was our best meal with you to date. Kudos to you all for the prompt & professional delivery driver, our pizza was not only hot when we received it, it was delicious.

The chicken Caesar wrap is hot! Not only that it has wilted lettuce in it. So disappointed in the…read morequality of food here anymore.