A little diner out in the middle of nowhere... there a number of words that describe the…read moreexperience: FANTASTIC, EXCELLENT, GREAT... First time visit and had breakfast... Everything was cooked to perfection... eggs, French Toast, coffee... Everything was exceptionally delicious... We HIGHLY RECOMMEND a visit to the Newville Diner for a great meal and enjoyable experience...

So far everything we have ordered has been good compared to some of the restaurants in…read moreShippensburg. We drive from Ship. Only thing's I personally didn't care for is there FF, don't care for coated fries, and Cole slaw tasted like all mayo.

Not impressed. Inside of restaurant left a lot to be desired. Only had a few slices of pizza but it…read morewas so dismally bad that I would not give it a second chance. Smelled like air freshener, seemed dirty. Servers were nice though. Not sure if they serve other foods in the morning? The place is packed at breakfast time- not sure if those are 3rd shift people getting pizza or if they different menu at that time.

I am fortunate enough to have visited this establishment when it was under previous management. I…read morehave to admit I do not really remember the taste of the food from back then, but the one thing I do remember is that the service was super duper friendly, and it still is. Of course, in all fairness my friend grew up (from birth) in Newville, and so literally everyone knows him. The food was very decent. I got the prime rib special, which came with 2 sides. I got the side salad and the fries. Their battered fries was delicious. I am a sucker for battered fries. The salad was decent and fresh with the dressing served on the side in a little plastic container. The prime rib was cooked perfectly, but unfortunately overly salty for my taste. The portions were generous, and the prices decent. The atmosphere is laid back and everyone is very friendly. It is packed on a Sunday after church and many tables get lovely sunlight through the windows.

Service was poor. The food was partially raw. Waitresses greeted us and then sat down in another…read moredining room for ten minutes before she came for our order. She spent time giggling with the other waitress and making fun of people. Very upsetting,

Stopped by on a Thursday in March of 2026. Got a beef with…read moreegg noodles in gravy. Cheese covered cauliflower. Broth Soup with chicken. Corn and onions A water with lemon. Hot Open Turkey w mashed potatoes. A sweet tea. It was all good. Staff was great!

We held a reception following a funeral at Park Lawns. The food was delicious with a great…read morepresentation. Amy and her staff were helpful and friendly. It was a perfect place for our family to enjoy a time of celebration and remembrance.

Had the 3 meat sampler. I selected 2 portions of half rack ribs and the meatloaf…read more The ribs were good as was the Mac n cheese and hash brown casserole. The meatloaf was fair, but I'm not a big fan of chopped meat in any form due to the grease and all the negatives of meat in general, especially chopped meat and chicken. The server was a young woman who initially indicated her displeasure at my asking questions about the slight difference between the online and in restaurant menu (no senior citizen choices in the online version for example and a couple of other differences) she told me they don't like to advertise the senior menu (wow!). I guess that says something about senior citizen business but I'm unsure if it's good or negative. Another surprise came when I asked what the difference was in the number of ribs or weight between 1/4 rack and half rack choices. She to me 1/4 was 2 or 3 ribs and half rack was 2 or 3 as well. I tried to clarify in my head if it was literally by the bone or by weight. She became defensive and I could tell she wasn't happy with my question, drilling for a precise answer not a guess. But again rather than make her more perplexed or more unappreciative of my question I just chalked it up to today's generation and lower schooling on precision than my generation. That changed the relationship for the better and all was fine after. She was attentive to my requests and did a great job bringing everything correctly and the other things like wash n dry type towelettes for the rib eating. The place is located in a busy area. Has a nice, comfortable inside and is clean with plenty of room between tables/booths. It's a comfortable climate with the local country music station playing overhead the tables and booths. After realizing my server and I were from vastly different generations, things went better. I'll be back and I received recommend this establishment.

Food is awesome. Service was great. Portions were large. Had the Buffalo chicken sandwich it was…read morehuge. Wife had a pork loin sandwich again, HUGE. Also had breakfast there. If you're in the area it's a must try!

First time visitor because I was looking for chicken and waffles and found them recommended in the…read morebook of faces. I wanted to eat this for my birthday don't judge me. I was sad to hear they only serve chicken and waffles at breakfast. WHYYY??!!! Please add this to lunch and dinner. Our waitress was on point. Super friendly and refilled the sweet tea before it got halfway. I ordered the famous fried chicken and was pretty happy with the food. The baked potato was fine, it was just on the smaller size (4inches long it was literally the length of my size 6 lady finger). Mac and cheese was good, It did have some black spots but I chalk it up to coming in a 730pm. The roll was bland would not recommend. My fiance ordered the BBQ sandwich and onion rings. He is particular and was also very happy with his food. The other thing I would say is consider changing the hours. Closing at 8pm is insane, at least 4 tables arrived at 745pm! I say this because I know the competition is Martinsburg Family and that is open 24/7 I would reconsider the hours. I'm certain since the food was good you could justify a 10pm closure time but I'm just giving an opinion. I'd still go back.

Phenomenal cuisine; so eclectic it's hard to label beyond "A Unicorn of a Restaurant for Polyglot…read moreFoodies". Server Carter was also phenomenal. I felt that the décor left something to be desired. Felt more dark and grungy than bright and rustic. Food was the star; we'll be back.

Absolutely great service and food! From the moment we walked in the door, we were welcomed warmly…read moreand seated immediately. The Marry Me chicken soup was tasty and filling, and the Crab Rangoon with sweet chili sauce was delicious. Additionally, the mussels had a scrumptious sauce and the crabby chicken was tasty as well. This was our first visit and we definitely will be back!

Monday lunch Ice tea, very good…read more Cup of beef veggie soup, very good. Cobb salad. Chicken way undercooked, it was crunchy and had a snap. Egg was dyed purple, food coloring, no thanks. Well I'm leaving I need to go find some lunch.

While passing through Carlisle, PA My wife and I stopped at Mays Family Restaurant. The restaurant…read morewas quaint and clean. The staff and cook were warm and friendly. We had a special which was a seafood trio of haddock, shrimp, and scallops. Perfect portions and very tasty. The fries were fantastic and the coleslaw was to die for. We highly recommend this restaurant for the inexpensive food, atmosphere, and easy location. You won't be disappointed. Joe & Cathy Lennon Boston, MA

This place was just what we needed a hearty meal to go about our day. The country fried steak with…read moresawmill gravy was the best and I would definitely get this again.

This place is very convenient off of the turnpike. Parking is easy. Ambience is casual, clean, and…read moretidy. The desserts look fantastic. The service was friendly and our kind waitress treated us just like the many regulars there. We got our food quickly. The bill too. The fries are those kind that have like crumbles on them. Not my favorite but they were well fried. We had a burger that was a little overcooked and tasted just like one you could make at home. Also had a tuna melt. The bread was warm and toasted stout the tunela was cold. I found it odd that the tuna wasn't on the toast when it was "melted". Tasted good though. I would stop here again but probably get dessert for my meal.

THE BEST DINER IN Southcentral PA!! The entire staff is…read morefriendly and efficient, and the food is great. Highly recommend it to anyone getting g off I-81 or visiting Gettysburg. Ask for Kadi as your waitress!!

Sister and I were traveling, wanted something close to I81. I was skeptical based on the 3.5…read morestars...but we stopped, took a chance. The table we were seated at was dirty, place wasn't busy, strike 1. Waitress arrived, took our drink orders, and disappeared into the great beyond. When she finally showed up again, hands full of dirty dishes, I quickly said "we're ready to order when you have a minute". I got a look of disgust from her and she replied snappily, "I'll be back in a minute, my hands are full", the welcoming vibe pouring from her pores. I looked at my sister and rolled my eyes, and said something about the 3.5 stars are already giving them credit, as the cleanliness and attitude are not deserving of even that. She must have heard me because when she came back to the table, her sticky sweetness was flowing from her gums. Aside from that, the food was really good. I got a western omelet with wheat toast and home fries, though it was more like hash browns. My sister got 2 eggs over medium, home fries and white toast. The wheat toast was very light in color, I had to check to confirm it was wheat. If you're looking for A good breakfast, I can recommend this place. If you're looking for friendly service, and a spotless table, this isn't for you. Another bonus...you can pay ur bill on your mobile so no need to wait for the waitress to take the payment. Eat, pay, leave! Nice!

Bravo Brother's in Newville, PA. We order from you often and can highly recommend your food and…read moreservice to include delivery service to our home. Tonight we ordered a pizza and it was our best meal with you to date. Kudos to you all for the prompt & professional delivery driver, our pizza was not only hot when we received it, it was delicious.

The chicken Caesar wrap is hot! Not only that it has wilted lettuce in it. So disappointed in the…read morequality of food here anymore.