Our friends got together in the back gaming room, normally used for gaming but we used it for a…read moreHalloween party with gaming.

I entered 20 minutes after opening on November 7, I was hoping to have a conversation about their…read moreOne Piece collection. The store clerk ignored most of my questions, and continued doing whatever it was he was doing. It got to the point where he just wasn't even answering me. I understand if you have other tasks that need done, but I felt unwanted and pushed to leave. As a first time customer, I will not be going back and I will tell my friends to never go there.

I am in the board game hobby and am very impressed that all board games are 25% all the time. Their…read moreselection is good but stock is limited, however, they are willing to order games in, still honoring their standing discount. It's a great place to get board games for a good price.

I hate to leave a bad review, as I once loved going to this shop. However, in recent months they…read morehave just become another greedy card shop that marks up their Pokemon product by almost 50%. Went in the other day to buy an ETB for Destined Rivals. Should be $60 for an ETB, they're asking $90. They will whine about "bad distribution", yet when I first started going there they told me they have great relationships with the distributors. They're laughing all the way to the bank around the Pokemon hype. Easier to just go to another shop like Empire Game Center and get Pokemon product for actual retail price. Do better!

Great people, great place, great service. Always something going on from trading card games to role…read moreplaying to miniature games.

Low selection of pokemon cards and location was hard to find! Definitely a disappointmentread more

I've been going here for years, and every single time I go it's an amazing experience. Everyone who…read moreworks here is so helpful and kind, always ready to help you find whatever you need or answer any questions you may have. I genuinely love this store so much. Thank you, Off The Wagon, for being the location for so many hang outs, and for fueling my questionable financial decisions of buying yet another plushie.

Went in for a specific item and was told they had none and had been out for hours. I spoke to two…read morefriends, one of which had purchased one an hour before I went in and was told there were six left, and another who bought one an hour after I left. So, whether I was lied to or the employee was too lazy to check stock, it was not worth the trip.

Great location for Warhammer gear from models to game resources. There is an enormous wall of…read moreMagic cards that has a huge selection. The employees seem very knowledgeable and helpful. For me the real draw was the board game section (which is in a separate section of the building). The prices here were surprisingly affordable and again, the employees seemed very well informed.

Selection never fails to impress. Prices are fair and sales are great. Everyone there is great to…read morework with and always maintain positivity despite all the nonsense they get to deal with every day. I'm terrible with names, but Ben, Jack, Ashley, & Aaron are always a pleasure. A lot of other shops in the area are closing down so options are limited but to be honest, I would be going here anyway. Five stars!

I found what I needed there and it was a good experience. I will def go back again. I had a hard…read moretime finding the hours but I found them on Facebook. I just needed to know where to look.

AKRON - A really nice comics and gaming store. Not a particularly deep selection of new books…read moreoutside the Big Two, but a lotta dollar bins.

Trip Review : Carol and John's Comic Shop. Carol and John's Comic Book Shop…read more I don't think anyone would argue that this shop is a prime example of everyone's favorite friendly-neighborhood comic shop. John and crew make this shop accessible to all ages. They have their layout dialed in, their social media dialed in, their special events dialed in and exciting and their books and pricing dialed in so all collectors can enjoy. New books weekly with some cool Facebook intros. A stellar shop cat, Winston, who actually runs things. ( it's a his shop and he actually let's us all enjoy it.) Their back issues are on sale, they have some neat manga titles and families will like the kid's area. They have supplies and probably the largest dual wall of Graphic Novels in Northeast Ohio. I don't think a review can capture the lighting in a bottle that is Carol and John's. Follow them on Facebook and see them May 4th for the largest Free comic day in N.E. Ohio.

Anytime I go to a new city, I try to find the best comic store in the area and this was clearly it!…read moreThe customer service was amazing. The back issue selection was top tier. I found 3 key issues I've been wanting for a great price! Easily one of the best comic book stores I've been to. I love it here!

Went first time with my son because he wanted to learn how to play Magic (which until he started…read morebugging me a week ago I'd never heard of) and I saw they were having some Magic event. Store was clean, well lit, and organized, easy to get to location. Lots of players, male and female of different ages were playing Magic, Pokemon and Dungeons and Dragons. Clerk was very helpful, not condescending and seemed knowledgeable about Magic. Spent a good 20 minutes with us answering all our questions. Steered us toward a duel deck to start out and it seemed about the same as best price we found online +shipping. Would recommend.

Worst shop I have ever encountered. Staff that doesn't know what they're doing. The prices are…read moreinsane. Trade offers are horrible. This is a shop for stupid people. Regardless what you're looking for there are better deals pretty much everywhere else.

Off the Wagon is a super fun local toy store. My boyfriend and I stopped in on a whim to wander…read morewhile on foot in Downtown Chagrin Falls, and were blown away by the warmness of this store. We don't have any kids in our lives we were shopping for, yet still were entranced with how much fun we had! You can find nearly anything in this beautifully curated store. We found ourselves spending a lot of time browsing the adult-friendly puzzles and proclaiming that we wanted to complete 100 different ones. You could easily find a beautiful gift in here for a child or adult alike and I felt inspired for future Christmas gifts. Other standout areas included the kitschy toys meant to make you giggle, and the large selection of fun stuffed animals. I am still actively thinking about the absolutely adorable dog in a space suit and regretting not buying it for myself. The store is very well-organized and the staff are excited to chat with you. Truly a gem of Downtown Chagrin Falls!

This toy store is so much fun!! There is something for every age group- for real- they have items…read morefor babies, young children, teens and even adults! We loved the section with adult socks, mugs, soaps, games, plushies and more! They were very punny and would make great gifts for coworkers or friends! I also absolutely loved their collection of plush toys. There were typical stuffed animals, mythical creatures, food, viruses and they ranged in prices and sizes. Most were items I haven't seen in other stores and there was even a really cute and high end Axolotl weighted toy that caught my eye! They also had puzzles, board games, dice, marbles, pop culture/ fandom merchandise (like Grogu, Star Wars, and Studio Ghibli items) and they had some fun candies and drinks too! If you're looking for gifts this is a great spot to check out!

Do not go here, do not support them and most importantly do not sign up for events in advance with…read morethem. This store is a scam. I recently signed up to play a set championship at the store. Before the start time the event was completed. The store wasn't even open at the start time. A local showed up and said that this store has done similar things before. The worst part is, the store charged the registration fee upfront, and had 12 players sign up. So they made well over $1000 between the entry fees they gained and the prizes that they will sell. The store claims that they are closed on Saturdays and Sundays. That is fine but why have a set championship scheduled on a day when they know they are closed? The guidelines for set champs are that they are to be held on Saturdays or Sundays. This store should not be able to hold events, and should be reported to the BBB for falsely advertising and taking payment for an event that they had no intention of holding.

Went to go check it out since i couldn't find pokemon cards anywhere else by me. While they did…read morehave pokemon cards it was obvious why after asking about their pricing. Compared to the market values that tcgplayer and pricecharting were giving all of their pokemon cards and sealed etbs were almost double the current market value. Seeing someone else post a similar experience 2 years ago is upsetting to see they are still trying to make people overpay. Will not be going back.