Peconic Water Sports - from my research - has the most boats to rent in the area. They have…read moremultiple locations, so you can toggle around on their website to see what's available. We were a group of seven, so our options were their tritoon or motorboat. But since we waited 'til the last minute, only the 'toon was available. But all good - we had a great time. You can rent for a half day (4 hours) or full day. We did a half day (1-5pm) with the option to extend it a few hours for extra $, which we turned down. Book and pay online; and show up early for waivers (every passenger must sign). They rec' showing up 15 min early for that, which we did, but after my beau did the test drive, we didn't hit the water until 15 min past our res, and then we returned 20 min early because we're unfamiliar with the time/distance to return... so we lost a half our on the water :/ Next time, we'll remember our noodles or ask about renting some water toys.

Rented a boat for a 4 hours. Nik and Eric were really chill. Had an amazing on the boat. It was…read morebrand new, amazing speakers and beautiful water. Had an amazing time!! Definitely going to be back soon. L

They cancelled our charter with 15 minutes notice to arrival time as we were already about to…read morearrive with a party of 15. "Mechanical issues on the charter prior." I bet. This was my plan for my 25th birthday. I had a party of 14 about to be there, and we all already paid. Beyond disappointed as this last minute cancellation has ruined my birthday and left a party of 14 in sag harbor with no backup plan since we received a final confirmation the night before. Thanks American Beauty. Not feeling beautiful.

Very nice boat ride around sag harbor with great views. David did.an excellent job telling and…read moreshowing us all the history around the area

A beautiful sail on Saturday the fourth, and the chance to experience it with a wmll tuned first…read morerate crew. At first they went in search of enough wind to sail, and we ended the cruise racing it to stay clear of impending storms.

Hands down the best thing to do on the North Fork. Erick, Hannah and Christian took 8 of us out…read moresailing for several hours on the schooner Bonnie Lynn, and it made for the most memorable, vibrant and relaxing time. Bonnie Lynn is an incredible boat, with Erick and Hannah the perfect hosts. I can't think of a better way to introduce people to, and share with them, the beauty of the North Fork. We cannot wait for next time, and neither should you.

Rob was great as always. His understanding of the tides and weather always puts you on the fish…read more He timed the day perfectly for black sea bass in the morning and fluke in the afternoon. He even provided me with a new ceviche recipe to try that evening that certainly didn't disappoint me or my family. I will absolutely be booking another trip with him soon.

This was the best charter I've ever taken. Caught the biggest doormat ever 6lbs! Captain Rob really…read morebrings your hook to the fish.

Bali Bay Boat Charters helped plan our special day. The Sea Ray was roomy (with a head if need be)…read moreand had an awesome sound system. Capt Len was comfortable on the local waters and chartered us around Shelter Island, through Greenport and even left time for a quick lunch. I welcome an opportunity to go out again soon. I would highly recommend this business for a memorable day. Enjoy!

Such a great time on a beautiful boat with an awesome captain. Capt. Len took us for a tour of the…read morewaters around the Hamptons and Sag Harbor. We saw cute inlets we never would have known existed. If you thought the Hamptons are gorgeous from land, wait until you see it from the water. Capt. Len was very professional, on time, had the coolers filled with ice and water and he was very knowledgeable about the surrounding areas. We will definitely be booking with him again once the weather warms up. We can't wait to spend a few hours lounging on the different floats he mentioned to us.

Wow. If you are looking for a way to get out on the water this summer or fall, Starlight Charters…read morehas it all. They have three boats, Luna, Starlight and Soliel. Each one has a totally different experience. I've chartered Luna and Soliel. Luna is a huge sailboat that caters to larger charters in the 30+ person range. It's a cool Caribbean vibe and very tastefully outfitted. There is even room to dance on deck or below. Lots of white bean bag chairs on deck to lounge in with friends. It's like nothing out here in the Hamptons. Have it catered and go. The other boat I chartered to Block Island is Soleil. It is a Hinckley picnic boat that has that classy Hampton appeal and is super fast with a jet drive engine. We also went to Duryea's Lobster Deck in Orient point. I mean really? Does it get any better than that? I showed up in a Hinckley, had Lobster for lunch, then went to Block Island. Bucket list checked. Thanks for such a memorable summer. Toby the owner of this charter business is awesome and knows how to make it happen with his professional fun staff. I highly recommend.

Awful experience with this guy, worst in the Hamptons…read more I've attached a screenshot with the interactions in question. The owner is as deceptive as his business practices, including fake reviews from friends , which you will find out too late should you proceed with him. In the screenshot, you can clearly see that Mr Toby Stull, owner of this business, accepted our offer on a brokerage and provided a special discount. This discount was unfortunately higher than the prices advertised - a rip off attempt. When we called him out on his skeevy practices, he then in a rage kicked our family off his boat. This is emblematic of how he runs his business. And I will note he spread bad words about my family around Sag Harbor, defaming his customers. We criticized his customer service and reminded him of our right to post about this experience which ALL consumers have.

SO MUCH FUN!!! I've…read morebeen Jetskiing before but I decided to surprise my cousins because they both have never been. Kevin was an AMAZING guide! He helped my cousins learn how to operate a Jet Ski properly and he was incredibly helpful out on the water as well. The Jet Ski's were Yamaha Waverunners and for a 30 minute rental the price is not bad at all. Overall I'd definitely recommend and I can't wait to get out on the water again with Peconic Water Sports!!!

We hired two boats for two hours, and we had a blast. The staff were former professional wake…read moreboarders, and the boats were brand new (literally a week old) specialized water sport boats that generate extra wake for better tubing, wake surfing, wake boarding, etc. The two staff members on each boat were patient, encouraging and polite. They gave great tips and instruction on how to wake board. Our group of 6 (aged 6 to adult) will be back!

I'm not sure I could have asked for a better impromptu outing. I've been coming to the North Fork…read morefor 11 years, and this was some of the most fun I've had. Feeling that I'd pickled my guests with too many wine tastings, I googled "Peconic Bay boat ride." At $180 for 4 people, this private cruise didn't disappoint. David, our captain, was funny, knowledgeable, and clearly in love with the bay. The solar powered boat was a nice, easy ride, and all the talk of oysters made me hungry. I recommend this to families and adult groups alike. And if you're from Brooklyn like us, make sure to tell him for some extra fun stories, no charge.

Charter Boat / Tours…read more Having the day off, a few of us tripped across this small tour operator in Greenport Harbor. The boat is named Glory and is a reproduction launch from days gone by. The claim to fame is that the whole thing runs on batteries and thus, is green and clean. The boat owner and operator (Andrew) was a real hoot- he took great pride in all that is Greenport, the boat, the harbor and the environment - we had a great time out there with him as we motored around Shelter Island and the bay in general. The cost is extremely reasonable - $15 for adults and if you are nice, you'll get a lollipop. The boat leaves from the rear of Prestons Marine supply. The trip is about 45 minutes and a great way to see some nature - Osprey's in particular but plenty of other birds... Parking around town.

Completely made my 2nd wedding anniversary perfect! Captain Liz and Brigitte were not only…read moreincredibly professional, they made the experience very special for us with their service. I've been sailing on several other private charters before, mostly in Miami, but this was surprisingly more relaxed. If you're looking to relax, do something that is off-the-beaten path, I highly recommend #sailing on Layla in #Greenport.

I don't think there is any review that could possibly do Layla Sailing the justice the trip…read moredeserves! There is something so magical about this boat and it's Liz! As soon as you meet her there is a joy and a love for the water that you will feel in your soul! I'm tragically afraid of the water but every time I step onto Layla the Old Man and the Sea inside me takes over. I swim every time! Every detail is taken care of and all of your needs are anticipated. It is truly a magical experience and if there is an available slot I suggest you book it now! Do not hesitate you will not regret it! Liz - thank you so much for making the day so special!