I placed a catering order for our a school club dinner for 100 people. We ordered fettuccine and spaghetti and garlic knots. IT WAS A HUGE HIT!!! Guests approached me asking who catered the dinner and everyone was well fed and we had plenty of leftovers. The catering order was ready when I arrived and I received the best service from the owner and staff. They made this dinner a huge hit and a night to remember. read more

Didn't feel like making dinner one night and this pizza location was nearby and close enough to go pick up pizza from. We got the large deluxe pizza that includes pepperoni, sausage, and vegetables. Overall flavor was really good. The crust is definitely a little thinner, but I wish it would have been a little bit more cooked so that it actually held up to the ingredients on it. I found that all of the pieces at the very end of the pizza kept falling off because the crust just became soggy. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Queen's Deluxe Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

Pizza was fresh hot and delicious. We had the meat lovers and it was full of tasty toppings. The dough was crispy and cooked perfectly. The service was great. Love the decor as an NY sports fan. read more

Ny style pizza right here in winter garden. My go to pizza place for a good sausage or meatlovers slice. Perfectly salty and they never skimp on the toppings. The slices are huge! Almost like 2 slices in one from other shops. They also have fried oreos which is the only reason id ever go to the fair so needless to say the dessert junkies in me is very happy. The menu has a lot to offer, pastas, chicken, you name it, and im never disappointed with them. Staff is courteous and very nice. The vibe is very new york and has ny street signs inside and different staple NY energy and so much seating. I have had some pretty mediocre pizza since being in Orlando and this is not one of them. as a new yorker I definitely would recommend this place. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

Came here late one evening to meet up with a friend. We got the Coney Island fries, without the jalapeño and..... not good. The cheese used was just sitting on top and honestly looked like sliced mozzarella just tossed on top of the stack of fries. There's killer bee pizza we ordered though was fantastic. We got the 14" and had 3 slices left over between the 2 of us. Packing it to was no issue. Our server was very nice, and the restaurant itself was very cozy and clean. We'll probably be back to try some other pizzas, but never again on the Coney Island fries. read more

This place was absolutely amazing from the minute. I walked in the waitress, was accommodating, super sweep and gave me great recommendations. She was also telling me about the massive Stromboli challenge, which I would love to watch somebody try. Pizza was outstanding as a matter of fact, they thought that two slices were a little smaller than normal so they gave me a free third slice Which clearly the size of these things I didn't need but didn't want to upset them so of course I ate all three. Highly recommend anytime you're in the area. I will certainly go next time. I'm in that area as well. read more

This place has changed things up a bit! The window work was redone~sends you fun vibes even before you walk in! Front dining room holds booths and tables, back dining room, same. They could accommodate larger parties here. I love that they let me sub an ingredient on the Queens pie when I didn't want green peppers. Thin crust, requested well done. Perfect! Just so happens I was here on a night when their wine distributor offered samples of their wine menu! Definitely switching from my usual IPA to a glass of Cab! Love the changes!!!....passing through dining room on my way out, the pastas looked amazingly. Changing it up next time! read more

See all

Great experience every time!!! I always forget how big the slices are and my eyes are always bigger than my stomach!! Such great service as well so friendly read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

See all

Pizza is always good. Service is terrible, they are unpleasant on the phone and don't acknowledge you when you walk in to pick up your food. Tried the soup for the first time, but $6 for a super tiny cup of soup is insane. Garlic knots and fried ravioli are decent. Stick to the pizza though, they've been consistent with that read more

Last week we had the most amazing night throwing a surprise party for my 12 year old son! The staff and owner went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfectly memorable. To top it off they made an incredible Zepoli "cake" tower! Can't say enough great things about this restaurant! read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Zepoli cake - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

Good food, fast and friendly service, like the atmosphere. Prices are reasonable, especially at lunch and their Tuesday specials. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Lunch menu, January 2026 - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

RUDEST SERVICE EVER!!! NEVER EAT HERE! This is the worst service i have ever gotten in my 40 years on this earth. This fat short lady was so rude to me and my friends, throwng the straws on the table and no graditude. The most i could tip was 0.01 read more

The past year NYPD has added great new menu items. Please try their happy hour menu with great prices! Service is always excellent and NY ambiance feels like back at home. read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza in Winter Garden if not all of Orlando and Florida!!!! PJ delivered our order promptly with a smile and it was still hot. He also reminded me to mention that we live in SBW for the discount. read more

We tried the NYPD Pizzeria today, complete with NY themed painted windows and wall coverings. Furniture was nice, AC definitely works. Staff was friendly, attentive and fast. The food was good, but the prices were definitely on the expensive side. I am sorry, the value is just not there. Will not be going back. read more

See all

This place looms under the radar for great pizza. It's good quality, consistent, and always cooked right. It's ready when they say it will be and it's what we ordered. Any mistake is quickly addressed with professional responses, but that's only happened once for us. I really don't know why we bother other places, for quality and price it's perfect. read more

The pizza was so good and the waitress was very sweet to my toddler The Hawaiian pizza was delicious and it's a kid friendly environment read more

Always looking for a non-chain restaurant and this one fit the bill. Being close to the turnpike on our travel to Miami didn't hurt either. Service was fast and Sonja was awesome being able to handle the whole restaurant by herself. You walk in and feel like you are in NYC with all of the decor. Trust me, have the arancini and cheesy garlic bread. Loved each bite. If you order slices come hungry. Each slice is about a quarter of a large pizza. You could also split a 2 slice lunch special with someone else. And you can't go wrong with the zeppoles. We threw caution to the wind and let Sonja choose the flavor. Can't go wrong with cinnamon sugar. Come hungry!! read more

We enjoyed. After getting so many not good pizzas in greater Orlando, this was certainly a step up.

Great speedy delivery service even on a rainy Sunday! Thank you. Enjoyed the cheese pizza - my go to.

Great food, any even more impressive service. Visiting my daughter in Florida with one of our pups in tow on a stormy night. Called to see if they could accommodate us with covered outside seating. So friendly and welcoming, waitress asked permission to bring the pup a water bowl, then proceed to serve us an outstanding Greek salad and beautiful and delicious Calzone. Thank you, NYPD Pizzeria, for such a nice meal. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Outside covered seating - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

See all

Hey guys! john here, me and my friends were eating here and the food took way to long to come out! another thing is the staff was jst overall rude and uncooperative, a fat short lady was throwing straws at me and my friends! which i find absurd i would not recommend this NYPD Pizzeria at all! read more

Great pizza and friendly service! One of the few places whose pizza crust is the star of the show.

Karaoke was fun and the chicken parm was delicious as was the friendly staff.. The pizza was also really delicious... I hope to be back again the NYC vibe is also cool.. read more

NYPD Pizza is a pizza place here in the orlando, Florida area. At one point, it had multiple locations, but now, I believe it is only down to this one. Curiosity just had me look at their website and I find that there is still multiple locations. The one that I remember here on the east side of Orlando has long since closed. In defense of the pizzeria, it was a very bad location that they chose. NYPD Pizza offers at best, middle of the road food. Mediocre pizza, the staff was friendly. I grew up in new jersey, where there is great pizza pretty much on every corner. With that being said, my expectations are high. Even if you're living in Florida for over twenty years, where I sadly discovered that great pizza is not available on every corner, I still seek out great pizza and am sadly more disappointed than celebrating a great find. It is not that NYPD Pizza is terrible, it is just not great either. As I said, middle of the road. read more

Best pizzeria I've ever ate at and I've at a lot of pizzerias. Something about the atmosphere when you walk into nypd the servers are great the owners one of the nicest owners I've had a chance to meet overall I rate nypd a 10/10 and highly reccomend if your ever in winter garden Florida read more

I have only been here once a few years ago but decided to give it a shot again through Uber Eats. Ordered the Patrolman Pepperoni Calzone and Bone-in Wings. The calzone was mediocre. I can't really say anything bad about it but can't really say anything good about it either. I didn't love the flavor of the pepperoni itself and the sauce that was on the side was pretty basic. It was fairly large which made it a decent value for the price. I was more bothered that the wings were wrong. The order was for bone-in wings but instead I was given breaded boneless wings. Definitely wasn't what I wanted, which were basically over breaded chicken nuggets. I tend to order hot Buffalo wings but the hot sauce here was quite hot. I imagine the soaked thick breading had more sauce which probably made it seem hotter. All in all, there's much better pizza places in the area. I wasn't impressed the first time which is why I hadn't gone back, but this delivery I think was enough for me to realize that I should just keep to the other places in the area. read more

Pizza had no flavor and was cold. Server couldn't care less. Suggest you go somewhere else.

the food wasnt the best and the service was worse me and my friends werent treated well

I have enjoyed NYPD Pizza a couple of times over the holiday season. Both times it was for pick up orders with multiple pies. The pies were freshly made and taste great. The chicken ranch and bbq chicken was a crowd favorite but I especially liked the Buffalo chicken pizza. It had moist chicken, wing sauce, mozzarella cheese and a light drizzle of blue cheese dressing. It was mild and very tasty. Ordering was easy and the restaurant was clean. read more

See all

This review hurts me to write as this used to be the only pizza place we ordered from. NYPD Pizzeria was my go-to order when I wanted tasty and authentic NY Style pizzas, calzones, and strombolis. My last 2 out of 3 orders using Door Dash from NYPD Pizza have been terrible. Two times, the Swat Team Stromboli has been undercooked. Literally raw dough on the inside of the stromboli. As for the calzones, the cheese was barely melted on the inside. In addition, I ordered everyone desserts. New York Cannoli - Soggy and inedible Oreo Zeppoles - Super oily and tasted like old stale frying oil Brooklyn Stuffed Zeppoles - Same as above All of the desserts were inedible. The first time, I gave them a pass as I can understand errors can occur. This time I felt compelled to write a review to hopefully allow them to address their issues. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Raw pizza dough on inside of stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

See all

I was shopping in the area I decided to order a small cheese pizza to go from NYPD Pizzeria in winter garden. First I would like to say the crust was absolutely amazing I mean it was just like I was back in Manhattan From there it went downhill. I know the picture May reflect otherwise but there was an extreme lack of sauce and cheese on this pizza I mean I seriously felt like all I was eating was the crust I was so excited to try their pizza from the pictures on yelp but in true life it did not reflect the same. Was very disappointed . They have locations in Tampa and our office used to order from them every once in awhile and the pizza was absolutely amazing and had plenty of sauce and an abundance of cheese not sure what happened here. I would seriously eat here again just for the crust but I guess maybe next time ask for extra cheese and extra sauce . read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Small cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

NYPD Pizzeria is usually our go to spot when we want a good pie... we called at 8:45 and placed our order, they informed us that they'd be closing soon, but we could still order... so we went ahead and did so. We wanted half double pepperoni, half Hawaiian because my husband doesn't like ham or pineapple and I don't like pepperoni .... I guess they just threw everything together and called it a night. Next time just say we can't order if you're not going to make the pizza the way it was ordered. We had to leave the house again and get McDonald's read more

NYPD Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

I'd really like to give them more stars. Ordered delivery last week and it was no issue. The girl on the phone was so super friendly and so was the driver. I'm a new address and it took a minute to find me. Pizza was amazing and we were really looking forward to our second visit. Until I just called to place an order. A different girl on phone who was super rude and told me that I was not coming up in the system. Then asked for my address and gave me the "Unfortunately you are 6.2 miles away and we deliver in a 5 mile radius". I said well you just delivered to me last week. So we tried my cell number to see if I came up that way. Got the same spiel repeated to me as if I were wasting her time. Then she tells someone else that I was the second person today who said that to her as if I were making this up. I hung up. The food was so good we thought we had found our new favorite pizza place. After this snotty girls attitude, we will not return. Too bad because it was tasty and authentic. read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida

I was passing through the Stoneybrook area and was craving a slice of pizza. I recalled NYPD Pizza was close by and decided to grab a slice to go. I was very disappointed when opening the box. The slice was full of oil. Not a big deal. I just used a napkin to clean it up a bit. I was hoping to eat the slice while continuing my drive. Slice was as soggy as a wet towel. Completely collapsed when trying to pick up. Could not lift or fold like NY style pizza. Again, no big deal and stopped to eat. Unfortunately, tasted like day old pizza. It was very chewy. I have been here in the past and pizza was better. I noticed the slice was not pulled from the window display and pulled from the back. Not sure if the older pizza is kept in the back. Decided not to eat the whole slice. Tasted like 7-11 pizza. Not sure what changed but pizza is not the same as before. read more

Have driven by here a 100 times and a friend said they really enjoyed their pizza so we finally decided to support their business. Warm friendly environment and They did not disappoint with service, atmosphere, appetizers, or Pizza....we will be back and recommend you give them a try and support the local eateries. read more

See all

My daughter was looking for pasta and my wife and I were looking for a greek salad and a calzone. I am not usually one for take out, but right now it is great to see restaurants doing it good. I got home and realized that we were missing our garlic knots. We were not going to call because I did not want to drive back out there. After eating the calzone we realized we were missing the mushrooms on it. I messaged the restaurant just to let them know to watch their orders as they are adjusting to the volume of take out. The owner was very wonderful in rectifying and seemed appreciative of the information. Started with the greek salad. It has a good mix of feta, olives, lettuce, onions, and peppers. The calzone was filled with items with a good mix of flavors. The crust has a garlic butter topping that complements it perfectly. The sauce was a little on the sweet side. We finished with zeppolis which was a great way to end the meal. They are better fresh, but considering the time they sit it is still good. read more

Had a little misunderstanding with how a special went, the manager reached out personally to make it right. I appreciate that very much!

Food is decent. I order from here more than other places because it's convenient to places where I gather with friends and eat Pizza. Are there better places? Sure but I have not been disappointed by them. read more

LITERALLY the best pizza in town! Anytime we want pizza, we drive the 25 minutes. Yes, it's that good. The Large is massive! Perfect hand tossed crust. Lots of toppings with great variety of options. Do yourself and try them out! They have dine in for those looking for a family pizza night out. Order online - save 5%. Download and order from their app to save $3. (Order the zeppoles - cinnamon version... heaven on earth!) read more

NYPD Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Winter Garden, Florida