The only word I can use to describe this ice cream is ASTONISHING!…read moreI had tried rolled ice cream before but hadn't found a place in NJ that served it, not that I moved to Montclair, I came across this place and had to try it - let me tell you, it did not disappoint!! The ice cream is $8.50 no matter what flavor you get, and it includes as many toppings as you want - which to me seems like a fantastic deal. I got the "Me Want Cookie" ice cream with fudge and pretzels ... and WOW! The way they mix the ice cream just enhances the oreo flavor but without taking away from the sweet cream they use. The place has tables and a "bar" for people to sit on, as well as some outside seating. The people who served us were really nice and got us our ice cream pretty quickly despite the place being packed. This is now my favorite ice cream place in town!

This was by far my favorite roll ice cream place because they were generous with the extras. The…read moreNutella was ample and tasted amazing thick and partially frozen with the rolls. The strawberry Nutella banana was excellent!

Loved the soft serve with rainbow sprinkles and the dirt cup sundae…read moreAnd was able to bring my puppy as well Great service and quick

First time here and the last time. Nothing compared to my fave down the shore ice cream - Cookman…read moreCreamery. I had the rocky road and sea salt caramel chunk which was caramel with chocolate chunks and it was ok, I've had better store ice cream. I'm somewhat of an ice cream snob and compare it to my fave ice cream shop I go to every summer (although they are open year round). Rocky road was the better of the 2 flavors I tried here (& my personal favorite flavor) but I had tasted 2 mini marshmallows in the 2 scoops they gave me at the bottom of the subpar caramel chunk ice cream. Service was fine, there was a short line but in the beginning of April it wasn't as bad as I could imagine it could get at other times of the year.

Really creamy gelato. Tried the espresso stracciatella and definitely would want to explore other…read moreflavors.

Favorite place in the area to get gelato. The quality is notable and the staff are helpful…read more Favorite place to stop by after dinner if I'm in Montclair.

The yogurt was delicious the add ons were fresh and plenty plenty of parking just feed meter staff…read moreis helpful

This has nothing to do with the treat and everything to do with the service…read more This past weekend my wife and I went to Lets Yo. I had received a $5 birthday promo and was excited to use it since it had been a while since our last visit. We originally planned to go earlier in the week but got busy, so we ended up going on Saturday despite the terrible weather. We picked our flavors and toppings and headed to checkout. I entered my phone number but the promo didn't show up. After checking my phone, I realized it had just expired. I asked the attendant if, since it was for my birthday, they could honor it. She went to ask the manager. The manager came over and I explained the situation. She said no, her reasoning? "If I do it for you, I have to do it for everyone." That didn't sit right with me. How many people are really coming in every day asking to honor an expired birthday promo? For a small oversight, I'd have to wait another year to use it? It made me feel like my business didn't matter. We're talking about $5, not a free treat. I work in the financial/service industry, so I pay close attention to customer experience. This interaction said a lot: the attendant likely didn't have the authority, but the manager had the opportunity to create a positive moment and chose not to. Moments like that are where you either create a loyal customer or lose one over something small. Safe to say, this wasn't handled well. I left more disappointed than anything. I don't see myself coming back in the near future.

Lot of heart and history in this tiny joint!! The service is great, and the ice cream even better…read more I need to sit down for a burger of BLT soon. I had a sundae, it was delicious. I love the ice cream here. Classic spot with a booth dedicated to the iconic Sopranos. A staple for any tourist who has seen the show, come get some ice cream here and you won't be disappointed!! I loved my ice cream from here. Always have since my sister first took me here! Ice cream is delicious, rich creamy and flavorful. Special flavors rotate. Always a classic nostalgic feel. The whipped cream comes from what looks like a soda gun!! Get the whipped cream!!

We traveled home to New Jersey to visit my elderly parents and I decided to surprise my coworkers…read morein South Carolina with Holsten's Ice Cream float mugs and coffee mugs. If you're a fan of The Sopranos, visiting Holsten's Ice Cream, Chocolate & Restaurant is a must! This iconic New Jersey landmark is where HBO filmed the unforgettable final scene of The Sopranos, making it a bucket-list destination for fans of the series. The famous booth and nostalgic atmosphere instantly transport you back to that legendary ending that still has people debating what happened to Tony Soprano. While we think we know he was whacked was Meadow the only survivor? Beyond the television history, Holsten's is a wonderful no frills old-fashioned diner with delicious food, homemade ice cream, homemade chocolate and friendly service. I ordered the cheeseburger with the onion rings. My Cheeseburger was juicy, flavorful, well seasoned and perfectly cooked medium well. The onion rings were made of thick cut sweet onions also perfectly cooked in a well seasoned light batter. A must try! The restaurant is clean, welcoming, and full of charm. Whether you're stopping by for a meal, dessert, or simply to experience a piece of television history, it's well worth the visit. Don't forget to order the onion rings and the Orange Fizz they're famous for a reason! A perfect stop for both food lovers and The Sopranos fans alike. 5/5 Location 5/5 customer service 5/5 Prices 5/5 Food Taste and Quality 5/5 Bucket list item ( actually I grew up in the area and I ate there often) .

Guerriero serves up a good Cookie Monster ice cream! Last week, I picked up a large cup for us to…read moreshare at home after dinner. Recommended!

We didn't have gelato, but my date and I had the very smallest size of ice cream. I had the Samoa…read morecookie she had something raspberry, delicious great atmosphere very friendly would highly recommend it.

I am not picky about my ice cream. I love it all. But this one is inedible. I got cookie dough and…read moreit barely had any cookie dough in it and the vanilla tasted disgusting. I threw most of it away! My son got mint chip and said there were a total of 3 chocolate chips in his. What a waste. Also there are about 8 trash cans right next to the place, so it stinks. Just awful. More like Towne Poop.

Awesome place to take your kids. Lady taught me you could order half soft serve half hard ice…read morecream. Woulda went the rest of my life choosing ! Thank you. Give it a visit if you haven't

I pass by this place quite often and on the last semi warm day we had there were a crowd of people…read morestanding outside eating the gelato. So I told myself the next time I pass by I would definitely stop to try some. This was the day. Walked in to find one family seated at a table, enjoying their gelato.And then a girl and a guy behind the counter, they were both sitting but when I came in , the girl popped up immediately to help which look , I don't mind them sitting at all , I wouldn't want to be standing the entire time either. What I didn't love was that the boy looked like he could care less that there was a customer and continued to just play on his phone. The girl was really nice. I asked her to try the cheddar cheese flavor which I thought was incredibly wild to even have as an option.And i'm still confused how you can make gelato taste like cheddar cheese , but still be a dessert, it was good! I decided on marscapone and black sesame and had a seat to enjoy my Gelato. The Mars Capone was absolutely delicious.It was creamy, it was the right consistency.On the other hand I didn't love the black sesame.It didn't have a very strong flavor and I didn't like the crunchy whole black Sesame seeds. Usually when I get black sesame somewhere , the seeds are pretty much ground up. Before I left , I took a second look at the flavors and definitely have to go back to try some more of the unique ones. I'm actually pretty shocked that they only have 3.7 stars, I enjoyed the Gelato, hope it wasn't a fluke!

It does feel a bit unwelcoming. The 3 inside tables block the walkway to the start of the line, so…read moreI had to squeeze past two families to wait my turn. There's also a printed sign proclaiming a limit of 2 samples, which is not enough; they have like 20 flavors. That said, I felt my mint chocolate chip was perfect: creamy and minty. The small size was $8 for a cup (and would've been +$1 for a waffle cone). I fully agree with other posters about how the staff is not nearly excited enough to be working in a gelato shop. Are their managers that bad?

This new spot has great fresh ice cream. The cookies were yummy too. We will be gong backread more

I definitely had high expectations coming here because of all the social media posts and…read moreadvertising. It looked like there would be tons of unique flavors to choose from, and I was especially excited to try the pistachio baklava! Unfortunately, when we visited, they only had the standard flavors available: strawberry, chocolate, vanilla, Nutella, and mint chocolate chip. There were also no cones available today. We ended up getting two scoops each. That said, they do not skimp on the ice cream...the scoops were huge and they pack the cups generously, so it's definitely worth the price. The ice cream itself was a solid 5/5! My only disappointment was that I was really looking forward to trying something different and special, especially some of the flavors I had seen advertised online.

Best café in the area hands-down!!!! Staff is very friendly…read moreand courteous. The coffee is always perfect. The owner Mike is attention to detail is meticulous. Would recommend this Café to any buddy in the area.

Came 30 min before close. Skinny vanilla was out. Some flavors were low. I decided to give this a…read moretry, and it wasn't that bad for a vegan chocolate flavor. That wasn't the problem. Service was short. The lady serving us was rude and seemed annoyed giving us samples. We felt rushed for making a decision. It didn't leave me with a good feeling walking out due to the short and poor service.