First time customer at Pizza Supreme. I "really" wanted to like this place, due to proximity to my…read morehome, and the fact they offer "take-and-bake" pizzas. Love picking up pizza this way and simply cooking it on my schedule hours later. Ordered hand tossed 14 inch with traditional pizza sauce. Toppings were cheese and Italian sausage. Presentation was excellent. Couldn't wait to enjoy it later. First criticism would be the sausage, however. What cold be better than fresh Italian sausage on a pizza? This sausage (on the other hand) was pre-cooked, obviously provided by a food service company... very similar to what any consumer can purchase from grocery stores. Disappointing. Now the crust. I opted for "hand tossed" style crust. The crust "looked" freshly made, but after cooking it, suspect it too was not homemade dough at the restaurant, but rather, received, likely frozen from a vendor. Baked at 425ºF (per instructions) for around 15 mins. Crust edges were lightly browned, as was bottom crust. Top cheese had acquired some color as well, so it was done. The crust lofted when baked like "hand-tossed" crusts are supposed to, however, I did not smell the characteristic scent of "yeast" when baking. When sampling the pizza, could not detect any flavors of yeast in the crust, even when it had cooled a bit, further increasing suspicions this is not homemade dough on site. Crust tasted quite like some of the frozen varieties of "rising crust" pizzas do that you can find in your grocery freezer section. If it is homemade dough on site... I must apologize for being incorrect, but it certainly did not taste as such to this reviewer. Now the sauce. The traditional red sauce provided was only "okay" as well. Would describe it as very thick. Like it's 80% tomato paste, 20% sauce with very little spice. "Lacking" in flavor is what I would say. So: a crust not unlike frozen rising-crust, lackluster manufactured Italian sausage, and lackluster sauce. Nothing tasted "bad" but nothing stood-out as exceptional either. Goal here is not to upset the apple cart of this restaurant. There are plenty of 5 star reviews so they seem to have a solid fan base. Coming from a pizza lover who makes their own often from scratch, however... Pizza Supreme did not inspire. UPDATE: June 2, 2026. Just noticed the last two review after mine that glorify the place are interesting as they are the only review either reviewer has done on Yelp. Makes one wonder if they are even real. Just sayin'

Best Pizza, honestly. Just moved to the area, and looking for our new go-to's. Pizza Supreme hits…read morethe mark. We ordered 3 different personal pizzas and a personal pizza fries to try multiple. Not a single bad slice to be had.

Best pizza ever! It's always delicious and tastes great. The staff is amazing and so friendly. We…read moreget pizza here monthly! Love supporting small!!

I like this place quite a bit. We've gotten them a few times. The Carnivoro pizza is pretty good,…read morealthough I'm not sure I would order it again given all the other options that they had. It almost seemed like too much meat, but that's literally what you're ordering with the Carnivoro so I can't complain. The Chicken Alfredo pizza was good. The garlic cheese bread is also fantastic! I want to come back and try some of their other specialties, we've had some of them before, but I can't recall which ones I did and didn't like. I also haven't had a chance to try their wings yet so curious to do that. Heads up, though, these guys are very expensive. If you're looking for something cheaper, you want look elsewhere. But if you want some higher end, New York style pizza, these guys do it pretty dang good!

Where the pizza slices are bigger than your head and the whole pie is bigger than your stomach.read more

A clean though I found somewhat cramped space with a not displeasing, straightforward utilitarian…read moredesign. I thought the atmosphere was redolent of great Italian aromas. Serves very good pizza, tasty sandwiches with spicy chips and flavorful, generous pasta with a slice of garlic toast.. I had a large bowl of spicy chicken fettuccine with a slice of garlic toast hanging off to one side. I found the dish to be full of flavor (and to be fair probably calories as well). I devoured the toast but took home enough leftover chicken and pasta to make a nice meal for later consumption. If dining in one orders at the counter, is issued a number stand and grabs a table or booth. Orders when ready (relatively quickly) were promptly brought out by cheerful servers. Fountain drinks, silverware, plates and paper napkins can be found at a separate stations along the wall opposite the order counter (in the midst of the dine-in portion). Ate here with my son who works nearby (shout out to Wilkes Auto) and two old friends from my college days. All left with satisfied looks on their collective faces. Based upon the number of people milling around awaiting their respective orders as well as the steady stream of customers in and out of the main entrance (on a weekday evening no less) Joey Nova's appears to do a brisk take out business.

This spot is located inside the Rosedale mall at Potluck. They are a New Haven style pizza spot…read moreserving up Za's & more. I saw they had a pickle pizza available & I had to go try it! I had been once prior and enjoyed it then as well. Mall parking is easy. You can park right in front of the potluck if needed! I came for the Big Dilly made w/ white sauce, mozzarella & parma blend, garlic & dill pickles. I really liked it. Is it my favorite pickle pizza I have had? No - but it is a top five for me. Their pizza is actually top five overall. The crust & cheese blend hit.

The previous times I've been here, the margarita pizzas were good. This time, it came out really…read moreburnt. When I pointed it out, the guy said that's how it's supposed to be and told me to look at the pizza on their tv. Also, I saw a mouse run out from under the counter and run back under... That's my last time getting pizza from there.

By far my favorite pizza spot in Minnesota--and one of my favorite pizza places in general. They…read moreserve authentic Neapolitan pizza at an extremely affordable price, and it truly stands out. The owner grew up in Milan and was inspired to bring true Neapolitan-style pizza to Minnesota. Having lived in Italy myself, I genuinely believe Punch Pizza can hold its own against many Italian pizza spots. The pizza is incredibly light, flavorful, and made with exceptionally high-quality ingredients. The mozzarella di bufala is even flown in from Italy weekly, which really shows in the taste. On top of that, the portions are very generous. If you're ordering, don't skip the Punch Salad--it's a must. The service strikes a perfect balance between casual and sit-down dining. You order and pay at the front, then you're seated and served, which keeps things efficient while still feeling relaxed. Honestly, I love everything about this place.

I stopped in for a to-go pizza and was able to place an order and have it ready in 10 minutes. The…read moreMargherita Extra was so good, with Mozzarella di bufala, Mt. Vesuvio tomato, and basil. Sometimes the simplest pizza is the best pizza and this is case in point. I will definitely be back to get it again!

I've been coming to punch since I was a kid, it's that good! The pizza here is the best I have ever…read morehad (including abroad). The salads are very good as well. Service is generally pretty quick, and order ahead options are available. The staff is friendly. Highly highly recommend if in the area!

It was a wonderful weekend to enjoy their outdoor patio space for a date night. The parking space…read moreis ample even with shared area with other businesses. As soon as we walked in, we were warmly greeted and menus were easy to browse without feeling pressured to pick right away. The service was quick and the staff was helpful. The food is consistent and freshly made. It's a great location for Neapolitan pizza rain or shine with plenty of seating both inside and out!

Pretty good, I'd come back if someone asked me, though I'm not going to rush. It's small, almost…read moreentirely counter seating, there are booths but good luck scoring one. That did kinda detract from the experience. This feels like it's somebody's little dream or hobby project. They make the pizzas with love and care, expect it'll be about 20 minutes, more if they're busy. That isn't long but it feels long when you're hungry! On the other hand, they're perfect little pies, a good meal for a hungry person or strong snack for two. They are also DELICIOUS. I loved their mushroom white pie in particular, very strong herb and garlic notes atop the umami and crispy crust. The wine is fancy for a dive bar atmosphere, and that was super fun. The bottle prices are much better than the glass/ tap, if you want more than one glass you may as well buy the bottle and take leftovers home. The price is steep, nearly $70 for two pies and a bottle of wine, but that's what staff and rent cost in this district. That puts them in a weird space -- they're not family friendly bc no space, they're too expensive to be a weekly thing, but they're not fancy enough to be a splurge. Enjoy while you can, I'm worried this place may not last.

The real chicago pizza - tavern style. Super crisp thin crust, cooked crispy with even a few…read moreburnt spots, it is really good Not bad choices of wine and beer, this place is kind of a locals hangout and fun if very casual pizza place. You want a casual date place? This works to and don't be afraid of bringing kids in either with house made soft-serve sue to please. It's a nice yet super casual place with good pizza.

First time here. I ordered Medium meat lovers for college kid and my husband. My husband wanted…read morelarge, which is only XL and 24" pizza. The guy asked how many will eat it and I said 2. He says to order medium. I also ordered 10" single spicy pineapple for myself. Now, I'm comparing to Red Savoy and it is similar but crust is thicker. The green dipping sauce was similar to a tomallito salsa. The size that came with the 10" pizza was super tiny. I hate forced tips at checkout when paying with a card. Call me cheap, but I tipped 5% for just putting pizza in 2 boxes. This place had all kinds of weird stuff for sale. Trail mix in bags, ice cream, rugs, bottles of 2 liter orange pop. It was OK, but not Red Savoy great. I wish they had specials. I might return if/when shopping at Outlet Mall but no need to make a special trip. Review 1 in 2026.

Stopped by here randomly because we were starving! Ordered an XL pizza and OMG this is literally…read moreTHE BIGGEST pizza I've ever seen! And so delicious! Heavy on the sauce and toppings, thin crust, and fresh! Made very quickly also. We also got the cheese bread and the fries for our babies and they were also delicious! Super impressed and will definitely be back!