We stopped in for dinner last night. Beer is always good, and my daughter enjoyed her margarita, even though she wasn't sure if it had any alcohol in it. We started with the new crispy Brussels and cauliflower. It was pretty good, even though it could've been hotter, and there were a lot more Brussels than cauliflower. After a few bites, my daughter, who is allergic to peanuts, started feeling tingling around her lips. The waitress checked and confirmed the dish didn't have any peanuts in it, so we're not sure what that was. We each then had a salad...two Caesar's and one garden, before our entrees. We thought the dressing would be mixed in, but it came on the side. Oh well. Not in the mood for my regular Sicilian pepperoni rolls, I decided to try the new chicken rustica, which comes with red-skin potatoes. The dish came out, but there weren't any potatoes. The waitress said she thought I was substituting the side salad for the potatoes, even though I never suggested that. She apologized and said they'd come right up. She then came back a few minutes later saying it'd be five to seven minutes. Ok, fine. I started on the chicken. The first piece was pretty good, while the second piece, which was kind of burned on the bottom, wasn't as great. I've finished the first of two breasts, but no potatoes yet. I try to stall but then eventually start on the second breast. I lost track of time, but maybe 15 minutes later, the potatoes show up. The small plate has five slices...2.5 potatoes. Why didn't they give me the extra half? It's fine though because other than a little cheese on top, they didn't have much seasoning or flavor, so I gave two halves to my daughter to put with her other leftovers. Both my wife and daughter had the Farmers Daughter pizza, which they typically do. My daughter added chicken and onions to hers. They both like the pizza a lot. Service was good overall, other than the great potato caper of 2026, or this rating would've been much lower. read more

See all

Read comment. Don't send out sub par food and treat your customers with kindness and compassion. When a customer is clearly in the right, showing the manager/s the food that is not prepared properly, then don't treat them like they are your employee, just do better. I know it's just a cookie but it's the principle. Money is meant to be spent on what is asked and expected. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - ordered a large cookie--burned & raw. No manager. been here 20 min after the cookie come out & the bartender has not been attentive. - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

First thing I see when arriving is a server putting on deodorant behind the bar. Didn't wash hands after either. That was not okay! I went at around 3:30 there was only a few people there yet they took forever to get to us. The food also was dry and slightly over cooked. I also ordered thick pan and it was not as thick as it used to be. I used to come a lot as a child and would love to see the quality improve. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - The classic pizza - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

See all

I've been to a few Old Chicagos in the past few years, decent restaurant, good food, decent beer selection. The happy hour menu is great but if you miss it this restaurant can be pricey. I had the grilled chicken, apple, walnut salad. It was a healthier option, not much on the menu is. I ordered to go so I can't comment on the service. read more

See all

You would think that on St. Patrick's day a place that has Guiness all over their restaurant would serve Guinness. WRONG! They were out of Guinness because the keg "wasn't working." On St Patrick's day! False advertising if you ask me. Please see the attached picture. Way to go old Chicago! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

I still dont understand why this place doesnt have a higher rating. Their food is good. Especially when i tend to order, later at night. There are scant options in this town past 9pm and Old C's never does me wrong! read more

My party of 3 and one man at the bar were the only patrons in the restaurant. We ordered at 12:09pm. Our food came at 12:47pm. There were 4 people in the restaurant and it took nearly 40 minutes to bring entrees to a party of three. Clearly Old Chicago's new slogan is "We don't care and it shows". read more

Great food - excellent customer service! We needed to cater pizza for a large group of around 20 people. The pizzas were hot and tasty.

I had eaten here before, several years ago, and remembered how much I loved it. I made a point to order it again on this trip. I was so looking forward to amazing pizza. Man did it look and smell awesome but as soon as I touched it, I knew it was a fail. The crust was soft. When I picked up my pizza it immediately folded down and toppings started rolling off the limp pizza crust. Sadly it wasn't cooked. A thick crust pizza should be crispy and crunchy. I'm a huge pizza lover, and I only ate one piece. That tells you how much the quality has gone downhill from the last time I was there. Sadly, I won't be ordering on any future visits. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - CRAFT YOUR OWN PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

See all

I hate I didn't take a picture of the Italian nachos I just tried to eat. Take my word, it is a HARD NO!! Terrible I wouldn't even say it's worth the one star read more

Best Old Chicago in No Co (now that Loveland is shut down) and I hope they continue to keep their doors open. Location sucks, especially now that there's an empty RL next door, but it's still my family's go to restaurant in Greeley. read more

There's a reason why this chain is closing all locations. The bartender was more concerned with serving his drunk regular pals than being timely with orderly customers. Won't go back again. Ever. read more

The restaurant is not known as a sports bar, although they do their best to accommodate sports views on their limited licenses. However, when live commentary is not offered, there should be alternative media accessibility! The establishment offers play to listen music. It was available tonight, until the off duty manager turned down the volume so paid for music couldn't be heard! Still, no live action sound for The World Series! People live stream at their table for both sports and music! My tip goes to my play, not THEIR pay! read more

There was a STAPLE in my pizza!! Under the cheese. Waited on the phone for 20 minutes and returned to say "do you want a refund or something?" Wasn't good anyway, wings were tough. read more

Great management Adam helped me get my correct order providing a good resolution! Thank you !

I was contacted my management and they made it right. Impressed with the quick response and outcome. We will give the restaurant another try. Thank you read more

The pizza was fabulous. I recommend the thick crust. It doesn't disappoint. The beer cold and refreshing. We sat in the bar area. The best part of the visit was our waitress/bartender. Adrienne Chacon was friendly, efficient and attentive. We'll be back for another visit. read more

A 3 star review is perfect for this place. The pizza was typical of any pizza Hut in America. That's exactly what it reminded me of. The nice thing about this place was the bar atmosphere. Thursday night football was on and I would have rather been sitting at the bar drinking a beer and watching football than eating their pizza. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Hut pan pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

Was a quick walk from several hotels in the area. Staff was friendly and helpful. Loved the menu options and selected a salad. If I wasn't going to the beach soon i would have tried much more. Nice bar area and lots of TVs. read more

This review is for covid time deliveries. OC is mostly incapable of order specifications. "Naked wings" arrive slathered in sauce. Cheese is on a hamburger. Food quality is hit or miss as well. Sometimes it's hot and delicious. Other times, like tonight, the wings are gooey, pizza is undercooked and soggy and the big cookie can only be described as rancid. If there is an issue and you call them, you may be told they're no longer taking pickup or delivery orders because they're too busy. Even if they screw up food for a kid. I know businesses are struggling right now, but restaurants should still be able to serve edible food. read more

Clean your bathrooms already...came back after 5 years to meet friends. Avoided the food cause you know..it smells like raw sewage. Needed to use the restroom-lol, they still have an old, old, old freshener hanging on the first stall that has no freshener attached to it, nobody has discarded it after all these years. The door had old emesis splatter all over. Disgusting. Someone is going to catch hepatitis, if not already happened. What happened to you Old C Greeley?? read more

I ordered takeout for dinner tonight and it was very disappointing I ordered a 8 slice buffalo chicken pizza and I was very doughy and raw when I opened the box at home. The other complaint was when I showed up to pick up my pizza it took around ten minutes before an employee came to the front to ask about my pick up order. Overall was very disappointing for a restaurant I usually really enjoy. read more

So not only do I love the food here (and drinks). The service is awesome! When I was making a homemade dinner for my fiancé, I I called and Elena (sorry if the spelling is wrong) was on top of it! I just needed their ranch dressing (my fiancés favorite). She told me come by and get it!!! These people are awesome as well as the food! Thank you! read more

Good pizza and bar. Almost didn't go based on recent Yelp reviews but tried it out when I was stating across the street on business. Got a table quickly. Staff was pleasant. Good atmosphere with lots of TVs all tuned in to various sports. Got a decent side salad as appetizer (nothing special) and a calzone. The calzone was huge. Server told me afterwards you can get them split into two--one to eat and one for later. When I go back, that will probably be the plan. read more

We had an excellent lunch here today. Bartender was taking care of a lot of tables but she kept the waters full. Food was a little slow to come out but we enjoyed every bit of it. Pepperoni rolls were excellent! Boneless wings were good. Bbq had a great flavor, mango was tasty Pizza was absolutely wonderful. Loved the Chicago classic. Garlic was so yummy. Meat was good too. Summer shandy beer was perfect for the hot day. Will come back when in the area again. read more

Old Chicago was right across from our hotel so we decided to give it a try, it became our hangout for the couple of days we were in Greeley! We received great food, better drinks and amazing service! Barb and Johnathan are super fun human beings! We couldn't decide what to eat so we ordered a bunch of different things, the fried pickles are good, the rib wing ms were great, but that artichoke cheese bread yum!!!! When we go back to Greeley we will definitely go back to Old Chicago!! Thanks y'all for the hospitality and good food!! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

Great beer and pizza!! We had the Double Deckeroni thick crust delicious. We had wings and mozzarella sticks. The wings bone in (of course) traditional and bbq 8-10 now the sticks they were perfect Crispy cheesy and not one bit of cheese leaked out of the breading never have I ever had non leakers haha 10-10 read more

I'm gluten free and ordered the cauliflower crust. Late night and tired, when it arrived i ate it and it was so good i couldn't believe it was cauliflower crust. The next day i looked at the website and realized they by mistake gave me regular crust. I called them and they were so kind and attentive. The manager emailed me with an apology and sent me 2 pizzas that evening. Cauliflower crust this time. I will definitely be ordering this anytime i'm in Greeley. Good people, good pizza. read more

Chris saved the day!! Two days ago I used Uber Eats to order food. A delivery driver who may have pretended to be deaf, according to the girls at the font desk, picked up my food but never delivered it. After the Uber app said my food was delivered, and I still did not have my order, I called and talked to a manager, Chris. Chris was so kind and helpful. Although this was not the restaurants fault, Chris was so kind to remake my order for me. Thank you Chris! Tracey C read more

The pizza was just okay. The entertainment at the bar was a fun experience. I would go to hang out at the bar and watch sports with friends before I go back for the pizza. The pizza wasn't bad at all, it just wasn't memorable. read more

We went last night for the first time in years (bad experience last visit). It was wonderful. Staff very friendly and wanted to help in any way they could. We ordered bread bites which were good, not excellent but good. Then ordered pepperoni pizza for grandson and a specialty pizza for us. All items were really good. Then decided since pizza was so good we would order boneless wings to try. They were so good and all glad we tried those also. Will definitely be back for sit down pizza, beer, and wings. read more

I'll give them one star for effort. I try to imagine a hostess saying what old Chicago's said to anyone with any other disability. Yes, for the uninformed, celiac disease is a disability, recognized under the ADA, so to tell me at the door I should't eat there because, frankly, we can't be bothered....first strike. Second strike was bringing our order to the table prepared incorrectly. The third strike was some...women...who was not wearing a name tag and never once bothered to identify herself explaining to us ENDLESSLY why our redone order also being incorrect was OUR FAULT...because we should have used these exact words when ordering...apparently, asking for a pizza with extra sauce isn't CLEAR at old Chicago. We should have ordered 4x extra and asked for extra on the side....all I can say is wow. By the way...hi, I'm "....", the manager. Give it a try. read more

Got delivery from them and it was completely burnt and black. I don't even know how it got this bad. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Chicken TWISTED TENDERS - Pizza Near Me - GREELEY, Colorado

I'll agree with other reviewers that the service was on the slow side. That being said, the food was fine and our waitress was personable and friendly. I got the sense she had too many tables and the kitchen is just plain slow. We were there during the big annual volleyball tournament so the place was packed and had large parties. Ordered pepperoni bites as an app. I'd pass on those in the future - think deep dish pizza edge crust rolled up with some pepperoni. Just bland and boring. My caesar salad and app of edamame were good except lighten upon the flavoring on the edamame. Daughter had build your own mac and cheese that looked delicious and she said was quite tasty. Other daughter and hubby had sandwiches - chicken with fries which they thought were fine. read more

We are from Lubbock Tx a long way away from home. DJ is awesome! The food was great and wonderful customer service. If you come eat here ask to be seated in DJ's section. read more

Once again completely blowing off your carry out customers .... Put in order late ... said it would be 15 mins. 25 mins later still no food. Only excuse.... "We have to take care of our inside customers first". Gee thanks. and after all that the order was missing items and poorly made... there are plenty of other options for Pizza, Mac N Cheese, and Burgers in this town, I think I'll take my unappreciated business, elsewhere read more

Good service. We ordered a few appetizers to share and they came out quickly. The artichoke dip and pepperoni rolls were delicious.

The food was okay. I had the wings and there was barely any sauce and they were overcooked. The service wasn't great, as I sat for over 5 minutes before anyone came over. Then it was, "I want to get your order before they put in that big table." Just wasn't the best for the amount of money they charge. Usually Old Chicago is a better experience...maybe it was just an off night. read more

First time trying this restaurant, our server Camden was very good although he was busy with several tables, he made sure that we had everything we needed and our drinks were never empty. We order the nachos, boneless wings as appetizers and they were great. We both ordered calzone, I was quite surprised on the size, when they came out as they were large and they tasted good. We did have mixed drinks but they do have quite a variety of beer, will be back to try a few. read more

Love the Italian nachos! Old Chicago is still - and always has been - a great place to hang out in a casual environment, drink good beer, and have yummy food, served quickly, hot and tasty, by friendly staff. I've eaten at their restaurants all over the Colorado Front Range, and never left disappointed. I wish I could join their beer tour, but I think by the time I'd earn a mug, I'd have lost my liver. read more