I went in on Sunday night to have a meal with my Husband, and Old friend. One whom frequently goes to the island because of the staff and food. As far as it being my first time, I couldn't recommend it more! Our server Lola was well knowledgeable of the menu and had some great recommendations! She was very attentive and seemed like she did care abut our time spent.She was very personable ! I got the Blacked Fish Dinner and My husband got the Surfer Dude burger! Both were amazing and very filling. Somehow I was convinced to get a slice of the key lime pie and by golly you have to get an peice everytime you go! Overall it was an amazing night, after the meal was finished we sat and talked for hours. During the whole evening Lola was consistently checking on us and keeping drinks full. However when I was looking around I found it very disappointing that they were using AI generated images to promote their menu and theme nights. It's a shame to see small businesses not caring about the environment or their staff. I then took a glance at their Facebook and it's almost COMPLETELY AI! As far as I can tell as well it is all things that they sell. I can't say for sure although . I personally just don't understand why they think it could look good. CANVA IS FREE YOU ARE DRIVING AWAY BUSINESS! Anyways overall I would absolutely recommend the Island Grill. Amazing people and Amazing food!I read more

Island Grill was a pleasant surprise we stumbled into on a drive through Ft. Collins. What a find!!! Great variety of beach food (like yummy Fish Tacos) in a cabana bamboo style setting that makes you feel like you're in Malibu or Maui. Menu is full of fresh salads, great burgers and tons of amazing finger-foods. The basket of beer-battered Onion Rings was SPECTACULARLY delicious as an appetizer. I had the Fish & Chips, which was a HUGE plate-full and really delicious! My wife had the Turkey, Bacon, Swiss & Avocado on a Ciabatta Roll -- WOW, terrific! And, service was OUTSTANDINGLY FRIENDLY and very efficient! Like I said, we found Island Grill by accident this time, but we'll definitely be back many times in the future! It will be a must-stop in Ft. Collins! read more

See all

Fun island theme bar. The menu is all over the place. The service was great and friendly but a little slow considering the place was not very busy on an early Saturday. The deep fryer oil needs to be changed. The wings, mushrooms and fish tacos all had the burnt taste. read more

It's a nice little restaurant. Very much the island vibes. I sat at the bar. I had the fish and cajun seasoned chips. It came with their homemade tartar sauce. I'm not much of a tartar sauce kind of guy, I asked if they had cocktail sauce instead. The bar tenter Hannah or Heather said they didn't have any but that she would make some for me. That was a plus in my book. The fries nor the batter fish were greasy. Four pieces of fish all 1"x1-1/4"x6". It was great service all around. I would definitely come back again. read more

Went because of high reviews and the most random menu I've seen in a bit... tacos, burgers, stir fry and Mexican? It started OK, staff didn't notice we walked in but seated us when we walked up to them chatting at the bar. The server recommended a milkshake, which was prepared kind of like a virgin daiquiri. Didn't taste bad, but was definitely not a shake. Waiter offered to remake it promptly and without being asked, but it was still more slush than shake. Our orders (half an order of fish and chips, and a burger) took a weirdly long time. I ordered medium rare and got well done. Waiter never came back to check on us after food, I eventually had to walk over to the staff still chatting at the bar, told him enough time had passed that I'd pay for it but wanted him to know it was wrong. He offered a discount, which ultimately turned out to be a paltry 10%. He then finally returned to our table and said the chef had been cooking since 6am (!). It was 9:30pm at the time. The burger did have good flavor, so at least it wasn't inedible like the milkshake. We again had to go to the chatty staff at the bar to ask for our bill after a solid half hour and didn't get an itemized one until our second ask. That's when I found out I'd been charged for the "milkshakes" and the hilarious burger "discount". It was late, the staff were young and we did tip them more than they clearly deserved, but we won't be returning. Waste of time, money and calories. The live band was great. read more

Great place. Funky decor. Great menu. Lots of room. Great place to watch games. Owner came over and introduced himself and chatted for a bit. read more

Every time I ordered (the same brand) of beer the price changed. One time the bartender charged me for a double whiskey. Funny business going on. read more

I love the Island Grill they have amazing food but I would especially tell you about their wings perfectly just so thank you to our server, Brittany read more

Great food but the wait staff and bartender, amazing and friendly I would recommend you stop in for a bite and great atmosphere

Fun vibe and would try again and trivia / music would be fun! Little overpriced for what the burger was. 6.5/10 Minimal guac and pico. Kids liked the Island theme and wave fries. Nice servers and food didn't take long. Water topped off and checked in. Will give it a try again. Merry Christmas to the Island Bar team! read more

See all

Great neighborhood bar, It's always such a great vibe when you get to sit at the bar and chat with any of the wonderful bartenders! Always my go to when I want a quick bite to eat or a grab a drink and sit for a while. Love the buffalo wings too! read more

Siria was the kindest and sweetest waitstaff. I loved my Mule and the painkiller was delish!

'great burgers and chicken tacos. not where I'd go for a good glass of wine but fun atmosphere and a great variety of music. not many places have live music now in our area. I especially love Wednesday night jazz night. wish they had more jazz on other nights. read more

I ordered two drinks at the bar, carried them myself to our table. I rounded up a 20% tip on the grand total (including the restaurant's 2.7% "credit card surcharge). The total was $18. When I got my credit card statement I see that they gave themselves another dollar. I realize a dollar isn't much. It's the ethics of it (on top of the surcharge). read more

At the IG on a Saturday night. Staff outnumbers the customers. And the band??? Well crap. They had to get a pass from the nursing home to come play. And...They suck !!! IG, you want customers to come and stay?? Get at decent band!!! Be advised, this bad review is for whoever booked this band!! Food is great and the staff is great. read more

Island Grill - The wild and crazy at its best???? - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

ordered an appetizer, beer, and entree. Everything was hot which was nice but very bland. no amount of hot sauce, ketchup or tartar sauce could save my meal. finally added salt and it helped just enough. Honestly very frustrating because the battered looked seasoned but had no flavor. Server was lovely and kind. Food came out in a timely manner. Decor and setup has much to be desired. the Entrance area is crowded. and the seating arrangement is very confusing- it was not clear if i was supposed seat myself or not. read more

It's been quite a few years since I've eaten here. Recently, while using YELP! to find Mexican restaurants nearby, it popped up as a suggestion. Not only that, but there was a "pay $30 for $50" voucher offer. and also. a 10% off if we spent over $25! The food was good. My friend had the steak fajitas, and i had the Cobb Salad with fish. He had to take part of his home! There were drink specials, a lively crowd, and good choices of beers on tap. Also, plenty of TV screens to catch the various football games from any seat in the house. We left satisfied and full. We'll be back! read more

See all

Love this place. The specials each week, plenty of room to eat, great prices. Fish tacos are my favorite but here are many other items I enjoy. read more

Love going here for food and a drink and a love watching football game here. The servers are always super nice. And the ambience is just perfect for a little local bar and restaurant. read more

Went to the Island Grill to listen to music. Was accosted by a very aggressive drunk who was looking for a fight. I'm 73 years old! his buddy was similarly making trouble. Staff said those 2 are there all the time, behaving like that. Management won't do anything about it. This is very dangerous. I'll never go back to that place read more

Awful, awful food! The fish tacos consisted of one tiny piece of fish with a bunch of tasteless cabbage in a stale soft corn tortilla. The rice was room temperature and hard, like it had been sitting out all day. The black beans were in the same bowl as the rice and were also room temperature. First - and last time there! read more

Ordered a burger to go - when it showed up I felt like someone punk'd me. Charred piece of meat (I ordered it medium) on a grocery store bun with an actual rotten piece of lettuce and missing half the fixins. Inedible. I get that food doesn't always travel well, but c'mon guys. Do better. I can go to Burger King and get something on par or better than the crap I got today. read more

Island Grill - Surfer dude burger - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Such a cute area in Fort Collins! We were surprised at how easy it was to get in on a Saturday but the patio was packed. There seemed to be only two people working but they were on top of it! We had the fish tacos and the fish and chips - both were great! Will definitely be back! read more

We visited Island Grill on a late Sunday afternoon. We got seated right and and were offered a menus and drink orders. Waitress was very attentive and professional. There were 5 TV screens on with different Tokyo Olympic events on. We ordered the battered mushroom appetizer. It was served fast and was so rich. We ordered the house Margaritas. I watches the bar keep make them fresh. So refreshing on the hot day. The menu offers sandwiches, burgers, and a huge variety of tacos. We both ordered the Island Thai Stir Fry. Very good mix of spices, noodles, vegetables, and shrimp and chicken. I recommend this restaurant and will return. read more

See all

This place is horrible. We were the only table in there on a Sunday evening and the service was trash. I had to go to the bar and get my beer we ordered we waited forever to place our order. No one would be responsive. Place is bad news. read more

So meh. We used to love going to the Island Grill when it was in Loveland and had tried this location about 8 years ago and I remember it being fine. But we were a bit disappointed this time. We ordered chips with queso, salsa and guac and the chips were so undercooked, they were still Tortillas. We asked for new chips and the second batch was better but not great. Sauces were all good. My husband got fish tacos and a teriyaki bowl. We like to order an extra entree just to try new things. His bowl was pretty good. The fish tacos were all right, Def not the best in town. That's laughable. Have you been to La Luz? Lol. The fish was VERY fishy. Mango salsa was good and the sauce it's served with is yummy. Couldn't tell a difference between his blackened and my jerked fish I got with my fish fajitas. The fish was so boring and sad. They give you a ton of sides with the fajitas and plenty of Tortillas which is nice when most restaurants skimp. Our Mexican rice was undercooked so think crunchy. Our waitress was in training and did a great job except she didn't refill our water till it had been empty a long time. Also no apology or compensation for the nasty tortilla chips. Won't be going back. read more

On a Friday night, January 19 at 5:45 we went to Island Grill early to get dinner and listen to the band that started at 7 PM. We arrived to empty seats in the bar and we were promptly told by the waitress that they were all saved for the band. What kind of business is this? Saved for the band??? I guess they're not looking for new followers! read more

Better food, update the bar area. Light your bathroom on fire and just start over. It's stuck in 1995

Cool place, they definitely need more sauces for their wings.But it's a fun place to come to after work. Always good deals, and I get pretty boozy after I leave so yeah kudos. read more

Second time here. Seem to have good prices and good food. Mostly locals. Fish tacos are their specialty. No complaints here. Live bands on the weekend. read more

Island Grill - Classic local's bar and grill! - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This restaurant needs the Bar Rescue guy. It's called Island Grill and they don't even have a Mai tai on their menu. In definite need of an identity. We took one look at the filthy floors after waiting to see if they made Mai tais and we chose not to stay and eat as planned. Trash and dirty floors in the front of the house - I can only imagine what the kitchen looks like. read more

Great burgers! I got the tasty wave hamburger and it was delicious! Especially when you get their fries! If you are going there anytime soon get the tasty wave, it is a standard hamburger with onion pickle tomato ketchup bacon and guacamole read more

"Cheers", in FTC. Local bar with good drink prices (Beam is their well whiskey) and great food. Seriously, the food is better than "bar food" (Kills Red Robin). The burgers are amazing, and nothing beats a Tasty Wave! If you are looking for a great lunch spot- this is your place. Drinks after work? YES! Nobody wants to watch your game at your house? They may be able to help you out. Brunch used to be cool. I do not know if they are continuing that in COVID times, but if you have an opportunity to indulge in that event DO IT. Long story short, you don't survive 20 years in a college town by doin' folks dirty, this place is legit. read more

The restaurant was nice and clean. The waitress was nice but it was her first day. The drinks were also great. However, the fish was uncooked in the middle. I asked to speak w/ someone regarding the issue but no one came. The waitress then came out and said they will issue a credit. I again asked is someone coming to look at the dinners but she said no. The management,in my opinion does not care about their customers. No one came to apologize and we at least deserved that. read more

Island Grill - Uncooked fish on all you can eat catfish night - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Our company finally was able to have an in-person holiday party since Covid shut things down in 2020. Worked with Ken Kuk (owner) to create a customizable buffet dinner for our 70+ employees who attended on December 7th for a Holiday Luau. While making plans with Ken, I asked him about his thoughts on entertainment. He recommended a one-man-band in Steve Johnson who kept a good vibe going throughout the night. Ken was also so very accommodating and closed the entire restaurant/bar for our gathering. Ken's staff the night of the festivities were amazing. What a great group of people he has making his business a success. And the food you ask!? AHMAZING!! Thank you for everything Ken!! read more

Great service and great food. Great daily specials and karaoke also. I'll come again when we're travel to Colorado again. read more

Island Grill - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The all you can eat fish was okay, not great. My plate had a large chip in it that was touching my food, and chips are hotspots as bacteria breeding grounds. This would have lost them points on a health inspection. Server was also just alright. read more

Island Grill - Chip in plate (bacteria hotspot) - American Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Nope. Service huge fail (hostess & server(s)). Food huge fail. Price fail. Atmosphere fail (way too loud). It wasn't good at all. We certainly won't be back. read more

Such a beautiful restaurant. I was sad that the food was so sooooo bad. It was horrible. The onion rings were drenched in grease. Sent those back. I got the blackened fish tacos. The fish was dried out, the salsa was soggy. My tortilla fell apart and the rice was like an uncle Ben's rice that you heat up in the package and it was cold and the black beans were cold as well. I didn't want to send that back and be that person so I just pretended I was full. My ice water was the only thing good. The bartender waitress was fabulous. The cook is sabotaging the whole restaurant. Find a new cook. I saw him back there touching his face, head and mask with his rubber gloves. His food was awful. read more

I sooooo wanted to like Island Grill but it was not meant to be. The first time I went there the service was horrible beyond belief! We got seated right away and given glasses of water to drink but no one came to take our order and we waited a very long time. Not only that a bunch of the wait staff was standing around joking with each other or busy serving the few people that were there. We left. I decided to give them another chance and the service was much better but I was not impressed with the salsa and chips on a spice level, much too plain. the tacos I wanted to like but that did not happen either. I don't know what else to say other than don't go there if you want an authentic Mexican food fix. read more