5 stars for quality, but 3 stars for value. I got a turkey reuben, and the turmeric ginger kraut is uniquely delicious. A strong flavor, but not overpowering. It comes on fresh bread, toasted of course, and the filling to bread ratio was spot on. That said, my friend got a turkey cranberry and the ratio was wayyyy off. Like 2/3 bread, 1/3 filling. While the bread is clearly fresh and delicious, when you spend $10 on a sandwich you expect more than a baguette with minimal insides. So for me it's a yes to the rueben, but steer clear of the turkey and cranberry if you're looking for something filling. read more

Organic Sandwich - Turkey Reuben - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Loved my vegan sandwich ! Full of flavor and filling . Just wish they could offer some plant based protein. Staff is friendly; place is bright and clean read more

Excellent! This place is consistent! The staff is always very friendly. I havent tried anything I haven't liked yet! Do yourself a favor and check them out. Fresh and healthy! Value exceeds the cost! read more

The best sandwich in Boulder - get the turkey bacon jam and add Brie!! My favorite place for lunch in Boulder!

Got the turkey and Brie. There was some kind of spread but I don't think it was Brie and I couldn't actually find any slices of Brie on it. And they added horse radish; it was all I could taste. The gluten free bread was just a hamburger bun. Over all very disappointing I could've made a better sandwich at home. read more

I stopped in today for the first time. I ordered a spicy Veggie. Which is essentially a avocado, cheese, tomato and caramelized onions sandwich topped with sprouts and a mildly spicy garlic pepper relish of sorts. All served on a giant pretzel bun. It was tasty. Expensive. But tasty. I felt like it was missing something though. Some marinated tempeh or sautéd mushrooms would make this sandwich taste so much better and be worth the over a $10 it cost after tax. It's nice to have an Organic alternative to Snarfs which is definitely a Boulder favorite. I also really enjoyed the reggae music on the radio and the lovely ladies that made my food. I will be back to try some other things on the menu! read more

See all

Okay sandwiches. I think by most standards people would love this place but me not so much. They should toast the buns and put 2x the meat they use if I wanted a salad I would order one! Pretzel buns are pretty good here. I never thought I would say this but they put way to much avacado on my sandwich not enough meat so I ordered double. They have tons of kambocha there so that's pretty fun. Easy parking during the covid days read more

See all

Ordered the green salad hold the onions, all I received were the greens, no veggies pretty sad for 12.00. read more

Organic Sandwich - Salad missing veggies.... - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I don't have enough great things to say about this place. Love that their food is so fresh and organic. They make everything from scratch and it shows. the sandwiches are always impressive. I'm a huge soup person so I was so excited to see they always have fresh, homemade soups to pair with your sandwich. they also offer lots of other goodies that support other local businesses. this place is a must. The staff is always super friendly and helpful with suggestions when I just don't know which delicious sandwich I want! Love it! read more

Met a friend for lunch. She said this place has good sandwiches...but whatever, its a sandwich. Oh my gosh, so, so good! I had 1/2 turkey reuben and 1/2 beet salad. I left full, but still could have eaten more bc it was that good! read more

Straight to the point: The sandwiches are dry and flavorless. The the ingredient ratios are also always very off. Very little meat, a lot of bread. I took one to go last time and couldn't doctor it up to be more edible either. I really want to love this place, but I keep going back and trying something different and it's the same issues every single time. Rlly wish I had a picture of them. I took one the last time I was there, but the sandwich looked super bland so I deleted it. read more

I honestly don't know why these guys don't have more 5 star reviews because our experience was fabulous! I cruised in with my mom for lunch yesterday. My mom has a bit of a difficult time navigating sometimes and the young lady behind the counter was SO patient. She answered all our questions, showed us the bread choices, let us taste the soups and was generally and angel. We ordered 2 soups and shared a GF Turkey and Brie sandwich. Because she had handled the other breads she asked if I needed her to change gloves (win for me!). The cashew and beet soup was good, not my jam but my mom loved it. I had the tomato and leek soup, which was ridiculous! The honey mustard was an unexpected spice to compliment the brie on the sandwich. Turkey can sometimes be dry, especially on gf bread - not here! They use Etalia bread for those who are curious. read more

Terrible service! I ordered a roast beef sandwich with a few modifications through Uber eats and it arrived with no modifications and super-grisly roast beef. Yuck. I called the shop and explained that they had completely messed up the sandwich, and they told me they could do nothing and I would have to talk to Uber Eats. Seriously? This is the second time that they've messed up my order within the past couple of months. I lived with it the first time... read more

Very very good. Gluten free bread is amazing and very fast service! Friendly and helpful, slough it was disappointing they were out of paleo and gluten free deserts Would recommend this place to all! read more

I'd be a regular at Organic Sandwich Company if there was one near my hometown, but I was so pleased to have stumbled upon this restaurant after a hike at the Flatirons in Boulder, CO. This sandwich shop is brand new and is located in downtown Boulder. I will caution you that Apple Maps was about a quarter mile off with this location so we had a little walk from the parking garage it sent us to, but we weren't upset about having the opportunity to explore the shops along the way. I ordered a half turkey and bacon jam sandwich and a small order of chilled avocado, cuke, cilantro soup. Let me start by telling you that this soup was so cool and refreshing after being outdoors in the summer weather. I also found the turkey/bacon jam sandwich to be a great choice, but if I have the opportunity to visit again, I'd probably go for the veggie sandwich! read more

See all

Great all around. Fresh and organic, can't go wrong! The beet sandwich is my favorite.

I like the concept but not my sandwich. I only have a recommendation for them - the avocado and chickpea sandwich needs a different type of bread. The avocado made the bread extremely soggy to the point where it was inedible. It became a big ball of mush and it was like eating bread dough. Unfortunately I had to throw it away along with my $10. I might be back to try a different sandwich, and please reconsider the type of bread you use for this sandwich. Otherwise, I like the ambiance of the place and it's super clean. read more

There are vegan and gluten free options which is great but some of us found the sandwiches to be "good on paper" with fresh ingredients but the unfortunately bland in real life with not much flavor. I would recommend to somehow make the flavors bolder. read more

I like this place. I had been here in the past, but it was during a free tasting event on Pearl, so I didn't review it then. But everything I tried then had been very good. Hearing from some trusted friends that the breakfast was very good, I headed down today to have the egg slider. I liked all the ingredients, especially the nice soft and fresh brioche roll. I might have enjoyed one more ingredient on it and next time I will ask if something green could be added, but the egg, cheese and sriracha aioli was very tasty. Another place I go does arugula but I've seen places with spinach too. Either would be good, I think. And bacon is an option though this would have been my third serving of bacon in a week so I abstained. A real treat for me today was that they had just taken some oatmeal chocolate chip cookies out of the oven, so I got two to save for tonight's dinner. We just ate them and it was certainly a good choice. I will always look for some take home desserts when I am here. I like finding fresh homemade single serving desserts rather than to bake a whole recipe for the two of us at home now. We just have no resistance. I save baking for entertaining. The shop was bright and cheerful on a cold, rare gray Boulder day. I met some friendly visitors to Boulder and the staff was efficient and cheerful and the shop was very clean. I saw some other fresh sandwiches being made and the trays of fresh ingredients visible behind the counter were certainly options for the future. read more

I really enjoyed the Turkey Bacon Jam sandwich from Organic Sandwich Company. They use house-made bacon jam on the sandwich with turkey, lettuce and tomato on a pretzel loaf bun. I ordered cary out and phoned my order in so they met me at the door with my food as customers can't enter the shop during Covid-19. Their employees are masked and wear gloves, and are very nice. The weather was good so I used one of their patio tables that are set up distant from other tables. My wife ordered a vegetarian sandwich on a gluten free bun. I recommend this shop, it is worth the stop if you are in Boulder, CO. Very yummy! read more

Organic Sandwich - Socially distanced patio dining just outside of the shop. - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Restaurant normally takes Apple Pay, but it had been not working that day. Sandwich guy didn't tell me Apple Pay was broken until after I had ordered and he had made my sandwich. Wasted my time and a sandwich I had to leave behind read more

Good food. Kinda pricy. Nice staff. $38 for 2 sandwiches and a cup of soup with 2 drinks.

The best lunch place on pearl! All the food is organic, fresh and delicious. The workers are kind and helpful with anything you may need. I highly recommend if your looking to go to a easy lunch with great healthy food. read more

If you're looking for a very fresh, unique, and tasty sandwich, I highly recommend Organic Sandwich Co. I always come here when I want a quick bite that I know will be so good. Make sure to try their pickles! read more

Strolling down Pearl St today with little man, I had the good fortune to run into Marcy, the owner, who responded quite thoughtfully to my previous review, and her two boys. Although she was on her way to an appointment, she was generous with her time when I stopped her and asked if she was who I thought she was. We spoke about my previously mentioned concerns from my review as well as some other key aspects of running a business like hers. She was so sincere and open, and is clearly eager to find practical solutions to issues that arise. It was very clear by the way she spoke that she truly cares about her customers and their experiences at her restaurant, along with the quality of ingredients that go into the sandwiches. I've never had such a positive and sincere interaction with a business owner via Yelp before, and running into and speaking directly to her gave me so much more to appreciate about the Organic Sandwich Co. Their customer service in the sandwich shop is always top notch... I've never experienced anything less than friendly, pleasant workers behind the counter. I also love that they sell Bragg's ACV drinks (the ginger one is my favorite). We will be back again! read more

I ordered a caprese sandwich on a lettuce wrap. I know a lettuce wrap is probably an irritating order because they're difficult to manage, but I seriously got a piece of lettuce badly folded around one slice of prosciutto and two hunks of mozzarella... for something like $12?? Why so skimpy at that price? Don't say you can do a lettuce wrap if you can't and charge people full price. They should've loaded that sucker up with lots more prosciutto to get it to hold together, instead of one tiny strip, or simply say you don't do lettuce wraps. I would've given this 1 star but the flavor & quality of their ingredients are truly good. read more

Super pricy for nothing special. The merchants had major attitude. No indoor seating, limited outdoor seating, and really expensive when you could go to Lindsey's down the street and get a bigger sandwich of better quality for cheaper. I got the grilled Brie apple and onion sandwich and the bread became soggy from how much cheese and honey mustard was on it. Almost inedible :/ my friend's sandwich wasn't much better. Probably won't be returning. Just go to Lindsey's. read more

Organic Sandwich - Soggy with honey mustard and Brie - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Was not going to review because they made it right....but...the first half had a piece of the plastic wrap from the turkey breast packaging. The second half had a hair in it. I didn't want to believe it but my son saw it too. Ugh. read more

The service made me feel a little awkward. But aside from that the food is delicious! When I was there, the two employees acted very oddly towards me. They asked me for my order, but then started working on disentangling some cords after I stepped forward. After about five minutes, they apologized for keeping me waiting. The other employee who actually did the food preparation was speaking very lightly, as if she felt speaking louder than a whisper was inappropriate. I was pretty uncomfortable with their awkwardness. When I actually got the food, I was very pleased, however. They have a variety of jams that they put in their sandwiches, and the uniqueness is quite innovative and worthwhile. I will likely be coming again. read more

This is a must-do for locals or visitors who want to experience a locally-owned small business that cares about its craft, its customers and its community. Organic ingredients and products sourced from area farmers, bakers and beverage-makers put Organic Sandwich Company in a category of its own: fast-casual with a determined focus to provide only the purest food to customers. Last week, I had the Beetnik (roasted beets, house-made almond feta and arugula on a pretzel loaf) while dining-in at the Boulder location. This week, it was Bacon, Egg & Cheese (nitrate-free bacon, farm-fresh eggs, caramelized onions, aged cheddar on a brioche bun) to-go from the Louisville location. It's worth the price, and worth checking out if you are vested in supporting companies that do the right thing, and have a friendly staff, as well. read more

Organic Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

First off, I would like to commend this place for having delicious gluten free bread that doesn't fall apart and for having grass-fed roast beef. AND coconut oil potato chips AND gluten free desserts. I personally could not ask for more. That being said, I thought this place was incredibly overpriced. I know restaurants in Boulder are all pretty expensive, but these sandwiches are not that big (not much meat, either) and they started at $11 if I'm not mistaken. Then you have to pay about $2 for a bag of chips, so my meal was pretty pricey when all was said and done (my sandwich was $14.) My sandwich tasted so good and fresh, but I do not recommend the stone ground mustard - it tasted like chemicals to me, so I would ask to sample it maybe before ordering it. read more

Organic Sandwich - Grass-fed roast beef sandwich on gluten free bread (both sandwiches pictured are the same.) Very tasty - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I was in the neighborhood and was hungry so I decided to stop by when I saw the sign outside. The sandwich here was great! Was given a generous portion that I got to enjoy a sandwich for two meals. The vegetables in the sandwich was fresh and I liked how I got to choose from many combinations. I would love to try the vegetarian sandwiches next time I'm around. I wish there is a sandwich place like this in NYC. read more

I had the turkey and Brie sandwich and it was delicious. Turkey, Brie, sliced apples, mustard sauce, caramel used onions, and arugula in a crusty baguette. Yum! Note that the photo only shows half of the sandwich. read more

Organic Sandwich - Turkey and Brie sandwich. - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Staff was very welcoming. Got the turkey bacon jam and it was a good sandwich. Loved the pretzel roll. Would I say it's worth $10? No but I still enjoyed it read more

Organic Sandwich - Quaint sandwich shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Delicious Sandwiches!!! The Organic Sandwich Company has lots of Vegan/Vegetarian/GF options to satisfy every customer. They offered to let me taste different spreads so that I could get exactly what I wanted! As a vegetarian, I got the Spicy Veggie sandwich and it was so delicious!! read more

I was given a gift of soup and sandwich at Organic Sandwich. When I went in to pick up these items I was greeted by two very friendly and helpful women, who then prepared the best chicken vegetable soup I've ever had together with a delicious grilled prosciutto pesto sandwich. Check this place out--you'll be so glad you did!!! read more

The good: Food tasted decent and was prepared quickly. The bad: Not customer friendly, they just want to take your order and get you out. They aren't interested in answering questions. Ignored me when I asked for sandwich to be pressed. Completely forgot my sisters order who went through the full line and ordered just like anyone else. They also forgot the order for the lady two ahead of me. Somehow ran out of plates even though there were only 8 people in the store. Burnt my wife's sandwich that was pressed. I didn't think to take a picture, but it was literally black. Despite all of the above, they did not offer any apologies or any sympathy even when forgetting orders. They didn't have many customers while we were there so I don't understand why they felt like they needed to rush and couldn't be more customer oriented. read more

This is a nice place. It's nice to know everything is organic and fresh. It took a little while to wait in line to order our food but it wasn't bad. There's not really any seating so luckily it was a nice day and we ate outside. Got the turkey and brie sandwich and it was very good. It was a little expensive for the size sandwich I got but still not too bad. Not much more to say so I can't really give it an above average review read more

Rediculous---LY awesome! Just stumbled on this place. Not a vegetarian but am eating the Spicy Vegetable sandwich. Can't get enough and can't wait to return to try something else. Live in Denver but will be back next time in Boulder. read more

Boulder native, Never been in before, went to get lunch and received some of the worst service I've seen in town. Unfriendly, uncaring cold staff with bad attitudes. I was treated as though I was doing something wrong while ordering a $17 bland sandwich with stingy portions. Not to mention no place to wash hands. 2/5 read more