A nice, small quiet bar. The food is amazing. The fries are the best and the Reuben was the best…read moreI've ever had. Always service with a smile. They have a pool table as well

Food was decent. I got a cheesesteak with fries and the fries were VERY small cut. I asked for…read moreextra extra extra mayo on my cheesesteak and I feel like there was a very minimal amount.

Growing up in town back when it was dry, Gary's Bar was known as the only bar in town. I never…read moreheard anything positive or negative either way, mostly because we were all too young to go in. On a recent visit home, a friend suggested we make a night of going and boy did we have a fun time! Gary's Bar at the same time feels old and unchanged, but modern and welcoming. The only issue some might have, is they allow smoking. We didn't really care: they have a great draft beer menu of almost all local stuff from the area, plus all the national macro brands. Prices are super cheap for how fresh everything is; glassware is also clean. They have a ton of special items too, like drinks, jello shots, etc. Along the back left wall is a bunch of packaged beer for to-go service. On the night we went, there was a genuinely great local band playing. Some people danced. They have a pool table too, which saw constant action. The bartenders were also super welcoming and attentive, despite being busy. If you're a fan of neighborhood dive bars that are secret great, this is worth checking out.

I don't drink alcohol no more, but the price they charge for soda's is what a mixed drink would go…read morefor.

The king of dive bars, don't let the name fool you. All shots are $1.75 (except for the Protestant…read morewhiskey) and beer is cheep, the most expensive bottle being $2 They have pizza, which is some of the best drunk food I have ever experienced. Laid back atmosphere. Great for a drink after a bad work week. Cash only, and don't expect to get a margharita or any fancy mixed drink here.

Beers are cold and priced just right, but fair warning: you WILL smell like an ashtray when you…read moreleave.

Great local bar to grab a quick beer. Bartender is very sexy and has a way of attracting men like…read moreno other. They had an excellent keystone light special the night I went. They were practically giving them away.

We come from Delaware. Tried this place on a boos and booze tour last November and fell in love…read morewith it. When you walk in, it's is an old mine shaft. The path is lined with fragrant firewood that patrons can carry in the keep the fire going in the cold months. The bartender, Jasmine made us feel like locals. She plays great music and the drinks are well made. We have met some awesome people here including reenactment members and folks from across the country. We stop in for a few drinks whenever we come to Gettysburg. Jasmine is such a wonderful bartender. Always making jokes to help you forget any worries you may have had

Very cool and unique place. Definitely worth checking out if you're in town for a few days…read more Not a great spot if you have very bad allergies. Being that it's an old mine, it's underground and has some mildew/musty smells. Really cool history and the bartender was friendly. Sharing the details about the history of the place.

Went there for dinner on a Wednesday afternoon around 4pm. It wasn't really busy which is what we…read morewere hoping for since it was our first time there. We received service rather quickly and the ones who sat then served us were some very nice people. The food ordered came out in a great amount of time and was absolutely fabulous. I can actually say this the big bear burger captured my taste buds in a way that hasn't been seen in a good 10 or 15 years. My wife absolutely devoured her steak and the smile on her face this whole experience just made it so much more. The big serving of home cut fries, down to the big tossed salad, I really felt that my money was worth what I received. My wife has social problems and she absolutely felt so welcome and comfortable here, we have already claimed it to me our most favorite place for food in Williamsport. Thank you again for the great experience.

Heather did an amazing job to make us have a good night. Great service and great overall experience…read moreplaying bingo and winning prizes. Food was great as well. Make a reservation for bingo night!

As a swank luxurious place of enchantment, you will have your socks knocked off from the second you…read morestep into Paddock Bar. One Budweiser is only three dollars. The pool table is only fifty cents. So as long as you have tree fiddy, you are guaranteed a gay old time at ye olde bar.

The atmosphere says enough about the place as soon as you walk in. Filled everyday with the same…read morelocals, burnt out and sad environment. Not only was the bartender terrible she had an attitude, which was surprising because she chose this sad life not the customers. The place needs a health inspection and I would not recommend going here. I pity the people and the bar, but can't help but love their simply life of sitting in the same seat every night in the same dingy bar.

This place was so cool inside. I went to Gettysburg for my 21st and wasnt able to go because…read moresomeone else in my group wasnt 21. So, i went back for St. Patricks Day. The drinks were good and cheap, between the 2 of us we had around 8 drinks & the tab was $25 or $30. Which is relatively good for 2 people, in my opinion. They dont serve food which is a bummer, i also didnt play pool but alot of people were. It is a tight space, so it gets crowded and loud fairly quickly.

I have been wavering on how to write this review for some time. Mostly because I have been…read moreinfighting with whether I liked this place or not. Was I seeing this place through my own beer goggles for the night. Let's just get into it. When we showed up in the area we had asked about what nightlife was like in the area. With it being in the middle of a cold streak we were told about several places in town that would fit the bill to have a night out. We made the rounds in town and then found ourselves here for the remainder of the night. I think what drew us here was that it looked like a dive from the outside and allowed smoking. There weren't many people in here for a majority of the night, so we kind of got to observe this place with the regulars in it. That really allows to see how the locals are in an area. It was interesting to say the least. Once the drinks started flowing we started to feel a little more comfortable in here. We started talking to the bartender to find out what was good to do besides the typical tourist stuff in the area. She was wonderful with suggestions, telling us about other watering holes in the vicinity and even beyond Gettysburg. We had inquired about LGBT friendly places within a short car ride and were basically told to go to Harrisburg or a small town in Maryland. At that point, that's when things started to get a little weird. After outing ourselves, things got a little uneasy for us. We ended up meeting the owner's grandson. He was great and seconded the suggestions the bartender made. But when he introduced us to the locals at the end of the bar, we kind of wanted to not say much. It actually made us feel unwelcomed after a bit of sitting near them. Kind of like all eyes were on us. After a few more minutes of that, we paid our bill and made it out the door. So the thing is that it's a great bar, if you're a local. Or maybe even if it's crowded, so there are other people to focus on. We liked everything, the freedom to smoke, the pricing, the bartender, but the atmosphere changed at some point and flipped the script. Would we go back? Maybe if it was nicer weather wise out, that would allow more people to be in here.

All bartenders are friendly with great humor. Prices are better than most places in lancaster but…read morethe drinks are just as good. Security guy is nice, smoking bar still is awesome, charlie is a highlight of course. Patrons arent grumpy. Favorite bar of ours and we frequently drive from york just to go there!

A neighborhood dive bar. Great beer great atmosphere wish smoking was illegal in Pennsylvania but…read moreyou have to take the good with the bad. A Lancaster tradition!

Just your normal dive bar. Cash only. It is a smoking bar. Great people. They have a pool table…read more They make you feel like family here. The food is excellent! You will be surprised if you eat here. If you aren't a fan of the bar the food will sure bring you back over and over again!