Didn't try the pizza but got the breaded cauliflower, broccoli and cheese Stromboli and eggplant…read moreparm. Food was amazing, great prices and good sized portions. Will definitely be back next time we are in town.

Needed to stop and get something to eat and decided on OIP. There was a couple finishing their…read moremeals and they both recommended the spaghetti and meatballs so that's what I got. The salad that came as a side came only with tomatoes and lettuce according to my server but adding cheese, olives, onions, or peppers would be an upcharge. I'm not sure if it was $0.50 extra for each item or altogether but I got peppers, onions, and tomatoes. The blue cheese dressing was excellent which large chunks. The salad was ok but had some brownish lettuce which I left behind. In addition to the salad, all dinners come with a warmed basket of bread which was excellent. The spaghetti and meatballs were great. The sauce is slightly sweet but had an excellent flavor; the spaghetti was done slightly more than al dente and I like it. The pizza slice tasted much better than it looked. The onions were delicious, the crust delicious and crisp without being hard. The pepperoni was thin, grocery store kind which was just okay. I also got a Pepsi to go since I had a long drive ahead and was accommodated. I would eat here again. The food was good, the service good, everything was ready in a timely fashion. The cook / manager (owner?) was also very nice. I've tried other OIPs and while some are better than others, they're all pretty good.

Subs and pizza are so good ! It's small inside but you can sit outside at the picnic tables !read more

This place is overpriced, and the customer service is awful. The food is not really that good. Save…read moreyour money.

Staying up at the resort again, and ordered a large pizza over the phone. Easy peasy, and by the…read moretime I got to the dockside location, it was finishing up. Clean location, friendly folks, especially the woman that appears (my presumption) to be the manager (?). (Sanitation note - saw one of the staff sniffling and then blow her nose into tissue) She'd stepped away from the food, and immediately thereafter went to the sink to wash her hands thoroughly and then re-glove. Excellent!) Anyway, the pepperoni pizza was great! Thick with cheese and just the right amount of gooey on the crust! Very tasty. Breadsticks were less impressive, but that's okay. All good here!

great service, it's not Nyc pizza it's more detroit . cheese and sauce are great . the bread sticks…read moreare are delicious. great go to place

OIP is consistently good. They also are familiar with regular orders of locals…read more We've only had take out recently and they have a good variety of offerings. The pineapple and chicken is one of our go to's and it is always loaded with toppings. The white pizza is a nice alternative with tomato slices instead of tomato sauce. The pizza is also good the next day (or two) cold or warmed up!

2nd visit to the area & 2nd visit to this OIP - another good one! First time (a few years ago), I…read moreremember the takeaway being a great spaghetti dinner. On this visit (better documented), the stars of the show were a Stromboli & Chicken Cheesesteak (with mushrooms). Both were knocked out of the park! Typical unassuming downtown 'pizza joint' ....with great food. Service was great - typical casual dining. (I think I was even called 'hon' - it's a PA thing ;) Other diners appeared to be regulars - which would make sense for a small downtown, but have felt welcomed when here - OIP is on my list, next time I'm in town!

Wow, I haven't had a pizza this good in a long time. Passing through town. So glad we stopped in…read more Great staff. Great food. Great service and very clean.

Ordered takeout. Everything was amazing! The bread is out of this world! Definitely ordering again!read more

Best Za in all of Three Springs, Pennsylvania!! Really amazing ambience, and great people…read more Pro-tip, try the Stromboli and have yourself a time!

Literally the best pizza, Salad, Ham Sandwiches, chicken fingers and fries and etc AROUND!! Like…read moretheir food is SO GOOD!!! I would highly recommend! The people that work there are amazing and very sweet as well!

We are from out of town and were visiting family. We were looking for something to feed an army so…read moreI called in to see if Best Way could make some sheet pizzas. The young man that helped us was absolutely AMAZING and they had two sheet pizzas and three salads ready in 10 minutes! The food was hot and very tasty and the service was top notch. I highly recommend giving this place your business!

I was impressed. I called because the pizza place I usually order from was closed on Sunday. When…read moreI called to place my order for pick up I was happy to hear 10-15 minutes opposed to the normal 20-25 minutes when ordering a pizza. I got 2 large pies. One with ground beef one with just cheese. The price was competitive at $27 for the pair. They are square pizzas, and I would argue that they are between deep dish and a standard pizza. The sauce was good without being overly sweet. For my money I would have preferred a bit more toppings but it wasn't stingy. The guy behind the counter was present and very attentive, made sure all of my order was correct and what I wanted. I'm excited for the opportunity to return and dine in as they had many different slices to offer in store customers where I was feeding a crew that was doing some work in the area. I have high hopes. This was a good experience and expect everything to be as good or better on my next trip back.

Tried this place on an early evening with few customers, having heard good things. Placed an order…read morefor a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, and onions on one half but just pepperoni and mushrooms on the other half. Got instead a pizza with pepperoni, onions, and peppers everywhere, mushrooms on half, no sausage anywhere. Decided to eat it as we didn't have time to wait for another but found there was very little pepperoni or cheese and neither the sauce nor the cheese had much flavor at all. The best thing about the pizza was the crust and even that was overly salty. Cannot recommend unless you're looking for the flavors of disappointment.

I'M SO PLEASED! I called for a very large, very last minute…read moreorder for delivery. They were awesome! So quick and all the food is so good! REALLY good. We ordered. A supreme vege, a supreme meat, a pepperoni, and a cheese pizza, a ham and pepperoni Stromboli, a chicken and broccoli Stromboli, and a chicken cheese steak. Every last item was delightful! The chicken cheesesteak with mushrooms, peppers, onions and Mayo... incredible! The pepperoni ISN'T the greasy, pre processed stuff. It's a kind of spicy type and we are all in! I'm in to town for a wedding and I'm glad I chose this place!

This is one of our go to spots for quick food that fills you up. We all have our favorites... I…read morelove the focaccia sub, my son houses a Stromboli each time, and my daughter goes between a sub on their homemade bread or spaghetti and meatballs. The family that works there is the absolute best and does so much for the local community. They provide the best service there and wherever they go.

When traveling to Huntington county to visit family I make it a point to stop on by for lunch or…read moredinner before heading back to Bethesda. Service is great and the food is fantastic. If only we could get y'all to open a restaurant in the Washington DC area!

Excellent service , great Italian selections , fair prices , very good selection of drinks , pizza…read morewas very good , grilled chicken salad was outstanding , will definitely return

Visiting my daughter at PSU and wanted some Italian and pizza and found this place via yelp. Not…read morefar from campus, parking is a bit tight, be sure to only park in spots for restaurant and not surrounding place. Now, down to the food and service! Service, great. Quickly seated and our waitress was then very attentive and food also came out timely. We shared a pizza and chicken parm with egg fettuccine noodles. They definitely cook their pasta al dente, it was a nice chew vs being soft and mushy. Chicken was cooked perfectly. Pizza was tasty with some of the best crust, light and airy. Nice inside with booths, tables and fun pizza decorations.