As a novice oyster shucker, Zoe said don't use a knife. You will hurt yourself. She suggested that…read moreI buy an $8 oyster knife, which is actually blunt. On the first oyster, the knife slipped and I jabbed by palm. Thank god I bought the oyster knife or the regular knife would be sticking out the back of my hand. Here is the lesson: $8 oyster knife -or- $1000 ER visit. You decide. BTW, I liked the raspberries the best.

I was so happy to find a fresh fish market like this one. I love the way everything's laid out…read morebeautifully, it's clean the merchandise is very well displayed. Everything I bought was absolutely fresh and delicious. I wanted some of everything in the store I can't wait to go back. It's more than just fresh fish it was an experience in such a good way. York really needed a market like this. Also, take time to browse. Try something new! I had the dry scallops and they were divine. Prices are what I expected. The service was a bit slow but, they answered my questions thoughtfully. I'm sure they will meet your expectations. I can't wait to go back.

Not bad at all. Mind you, I'm comparing these crabs from my hometown local crab restaurant, in…read moreMaryland. I ordered a dozen male mediums, for $75 - somewhat heavy, could have been steamed a little better. I love a crab, where there is little effort in the picking and the claw meat, slides out. We miss our Maryland seasoning, but The Classy Crab's spice concoction was very similar tasting. My husband and I are anxious to see what a large and jumbo look like. We will be back, to try those. This is strictly take-out, only. You either order by phone or from their store's window. The owners were very friendly.

Great folks. They always address me by name and always make sure I leave with fat crabs and butta…read more best crabs in Lancaster

Good place to buy canning tomatoes. Other produce is rather expensive but good qualityread more

Witness the owner in the restroom taking a piss then proceeds to walk right outside of the bathroom…read morewithout washing his hands or anything walks over to stand and gets to work he then told me he washes his hands at the stand and meanwhile he's touching surfaces between the bathroom and the stand able to spread covid-19 but in his eyes he's keeping everyone safe. Disgusting.

I love their fish sandwiches and Make sure to stop by here every single time I come to York. I'm…read moreamazed that nobody has reviewed this restaurant yet, it's got great food great prices and very friendly service. Their Maryland Clam chowder is to die for!

Got crabs here twice now gave them the benefit of the doubt. I thought I'd give them a second try…read moreshould have known better. The crabs were supposed to be mediums They look like smalls and meatless will not be returning to purchase crabs there again. If they had zero stars I'd give zero stars.

Too expensive and they dig crabs out of the mud during hibernation. I also think they break one…read moreclaw off each crab with 2 pincers and they sell them (the claws) separately. This is all conjecture.

Got an order of crab's through Scrubby's Saturday crab deal with Captain Bob's. Crabs were steamed…read morereally well, no light crabs and the seasoning was plentiful. The seasoning is a bit more on the spicy side, but it still hit the spot and the price was really affordable. Would definitely recommend their crabs.

We pre-ordered a bushel of their largest crabs end of May. Cost *choke* was $300…read more There were a few larger crabs on top with the little ones hiding below. Many of the crabs were empty and many were dry. Taste was not good. Not pleased at all. I'm not sure if we just ordered too early in the season but we'll be hauling our crabs in from MD from now on.

Food was very fresh! I was very happy. drove under an hour away to do some thrifting, and this hit…read morethe spot. Also stop for the bonus flower, and market!

I had two crab cake baskets at your crab shop. ($48.00) What a big disappointment, Taste like cheap…read morecrab meat out of the can from China, very bad fish small. Not something from a good crab shop. I'm in my 70s and I know what a good crab cake tastes like. These were a cheap knock off. I and all my friends will not be back. Not like Hank's anymore. The End!

If you are looking for the best hardshell crabs look no further than here.. It is the best place to…read morebe..

Got to go for Dad's Day...They were Fabulous!!! Great People!!! The crabs were priced Reasonably,…read morebut the size and seasoning we're Fabulous!!! Will not go anywhere else in the future!!!! Even though there are 5 places closer!!! Outstanding job !!!!!

Crabs tasted great. Clam strips were not fresh, they were prepackaged. The macaroni salad tasted…read morelike nail polish so we didn't eat more than a bite. Ordered half a dozen large. They said it would cost around $33 when I called them before arriving. When I went to pay, the bill was almost $70 because they gave me jumbo sized crabs. Thus, the crabs cost $49 instead. I paid it but wasn't happy. Kind of feel taken advantage of.

While driving through good old York Pa I stumbled upon this place. It's kind of unique because the…read moreright side sells fresh and fried to order seafood and the left side is a sports bar. Always being in the mood for some kind of good fried seafood sandwich I decided to give it a try. It was your typical no thrills place and I checked out the variety of fish, crab cakes and salads they had to offer. After speaking with the girl there and letting her know I was in the mood for soft shell crabs she smiled and brought out a fresh bunch of them that just came in this morning. I picked the 2 biggest and she made me a delicious old school soft shell crab sandwich on toast with tartar. Next time I come I will probably try some fried fish. The only thing negative I can say is the salads didn't look very fresh but I didn't eat them so can't comment on taste. The service was great. I will return to this place for sure. Great lunch or dinner spot for something casual.

The crabs are normally the best. I got a dozen extra large close to closing yesterday and then…read moreseemed dried out n stale. No the normal but I will try to decide if they will continue to be my place to go or not

This place certainly isn't at a location where you expect to find crabs, but they do offer quite…read morethe selection. We had our bikes on the rail trail and stopped by afterwards for some food. Our waitress was friendly and helpful. The crabs were decent and cooked perfectly. The full rack of ribs was fantastic. Make sure you BYOB.