Went online and ordered two pizzas from this Papa John's location for pickup. Literally, we drove from about 3 miles away (about 10 minutes with traffic) to the location to pick them up. Walked in the store and the lady greeted me with a big smile and asked what my name was and said my pizzas were ready. They had just taken them out of the oven and boxed them up....they were piping hot. The pizzas were very generously topped with the ingredients I had selected and for the money they were pretty much perfect. Highly recommend this location. Sending a big Thank You to the employees of this location!! Keep up the excellent work!! Service: 10+ Food: 10+ read more

Went to Papa John's many times over the last few years. Sign outside said, "large one topping pizza $7.99 before 5 P.M. It was about 3:30 P.M. I ordered one large pepperoni, (thin crust) and one large cheese,(thin crust). The order taker said $45.00 And change. I said why so much. He said because I ordered thin crust. The owner has always given me the carry out deal, whatever it is even if I ordered thin crust. The owner wasn't in just the tall dude with the long hair. Unbelievable really. Good pizza but not priced as advertised. read more

What garbage pizza! Just paid almost $100 for 2 large pizzas and a brownie order delivered and there was no pepperoni and few others on the meat lovers and very few toppings on the vegetarian...both drowning in cheese! I'm afraid to try the brownie after the garbage pizza... read more

The service was awful. I tried to call in an order the girl on the phone was rude and not helpful at all. I was trying to order three pizzas. Two that were on special and one special order. The girl charged me 75 dollars. The guy who was at the counter was shocked how much she charged us for a small pizza. It ended up being over 39 dollars for the small crappy pizza. He couldn't change the total. I was so anxious by the whole ordeal we just paid and left. I will never go back. read more

This is bomb. I am happy and feel great. I recommend fasting all day so you can really enjoy the meal. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Buffalo chicken 10 piece and Philly Cheesesteak Papadia - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

I love the food but why aren't there any prices listed? Makes it really difficult to order having to ask the person at the register the prices of many items. read more

fantastic food every time! The pizza as well as the sides, including the garlic breadsticks are really good and the people are always polite and helpful! read more

Great friendly people work here..also top customer service!! Support this pizza location before they close it due to low demand. Great pizza crust and taste even better with that yummie garlic sauce!! read more

See all

During the midst of the coronavirus outbreak, we ordered a pizza for delivery. After the driver had left, I noticed that the sticker had been peeled back and to my surprise a piece of the pizza was missing. My wife called the store and they said that they would send a new one. I then called the store to request that the 25% tip I had left be refunded; I'm not going to overreact but I feel like this behavior doesn't deserve a tip. In a condescending and flippant manner, the manager refused and said that I could not be correct and that I'd have to take it up with corporate. He also said that any Yelp reviews I left would be removed. Order with caution. Better hope that the sticker that ensures an uncontaminated product is intact, because if not, they won't believe you. Nothing like ignoring a clear and obvious health violation in the midst of a declared pandemic. I'm not sure what the manager thought my scam was; I can't see what I have to gain by calling this out. Something is wrong with operations at this location. Bummer too because I like the pizza. If the manager would have handled this in a responsible way, I would have understood and continued to get their pizza. But after this, I cannot, and I recommend others look elsewhere. Update: My wife drove the pizza into the store to show them, and they actually told her that the pizza had the right number of slices and there was nothing wrong with it. They said this was how its supposed to look. Doesn't look right to me. Be the judge. Oh, and the replacement pizza never arrived. With no refund. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

First time getting pizza from a 'Papa John's '. Got 2 specifically LG pizzas and paid Xtra for stuffed crust. The cheese in the crust was hard and not melted at all. There was hardly any toppings on the pizzas. I've gotten frozen pizzas that have had more toppings. Was very expensive for what you got, the whole family was extremely disappointed and I will never order Papa John's again. read more

The young woman working Easter Afternoon was so helpful and kind with me getting my order.

Our driver accidentally gave us the wrong order. Within minutes, we had a replacement order and a sweet upgrade as well. We love our Papa John's, and even more now for so quickly fixing a mistake. They rock!!! read more

Very disappointed. Staff not wearing masks, breathing over pizzas. Not once did I see anyone wash their hands or use hand sanitizer. I'm a nurse that is working with Covid patients. This is reckless and beyond comprehension that you would put so many people at risk by not being sanitary and preventing the spread of an illness that is killing so many people. Your questions asked of staff prior to working are ridiculous too. Many infected with Covid-19 do not have symptoms at all and people who make low wages are more likely to lie and use Tylenol or other medications to hide symptoms to avoid losing their income. I expected better of you Papa John's. Won't be returning unless your loose and very unhygienic practices end. read more

A big shout out to Papa John's! I found one of their 'Easter eggs' (a branded beach ball) didn't Easter Weekend which won me a free large one topping pizza! We got the Italian Sausage, which was very flavorful. I'm generally not a red sauce fan (I much prefer white) so all I can really say is their red sauce was tomato-y and thankfully not excessive. Good coverage of cheese but the absolute best part was the hand tossed crust. Fluffy and consistently cooked- no hard or chewy spots. You could pick up a slice with one hand if necessary and eat it like you should be able to eat a pizza.... It doesn't droop, the toppings don't slide off and it's not dripping with grease. Thank you for this fun giveaway and I'll definitely be back! read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Italian sausage hand tossed pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Just not impressed at all. Dough is a lot of air and filling, and for a large pizza with such a large (No, massive) area of crust it really takes away from the whole "large pizza" kind of thing. When it is hard to find the two ingredients you ordered on a slice of pizza you are eating you know you are eating at the wrong place. Skimping (actually more than skimping - saving money by not giving what you ordered) was what killed the last Papa Johns in Bellingham many years ago. History is repeating itself. I have ordered from many Papa Johns in more than 10 states and it usually doesn't go like this, but for some reason in Bellingham they think it is okay to save a little money and give the customers much less. If it keeps doing business like this it will end up the same way the last Papa Johns did - out of business fast! From my experience I would definitely recommend going somewhere else for your pizza needs in Bellingham. Dominoes is a much better deal for what you get, Papa Murphys is far, FAR better if you are okay cooking your own pizza. In fact, anywhere you go would be better - so disappointed that Papa Johns is okay with this kind of pizza service in our town. I don't think it will last long, and I think that is a shame for people that like decent pizza, even if it is a franchise. I have had Papa Johns in many other cities and it can be good, but this is really not very good in Bellingham. read more

I know what you're thinking- this is a chain restaurant and they are all the same. People at pizza places are grouchy and mean. Wrong. This is a great Papa John's! I order pizza here sometimes for carry out but they also do delivery within a certain delivery area. The carryout is nice because they have a 'carry out card' here that can actually allow you earn a free pizza! I always get a great pizza that's exactly what I ordered. My guilty pleasure is the garlic dipping sauce they have here. It's literally heavenly and they never forget to include it it the box! The people who work here are really kind as well. When I come to this Papa John's I'm always greeted by a couple people on staff, even if it's busy. It's really refreshing to get pizza at a chain store and have good food and great service! read more

One of the best chain restaurant pizzas I've had! As a picky eater, that's saying a lot. The dough is soft and crust is too. I usually don't like crust but with the garlic dipping sauce they give you, it's amazing! Definitely better than domino's and pizza hut. I also got the cinnamon pull apart bread drizzled with icing - amazing! Staff are very friendly too. Highly recommend! read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Not flattering lol but you get the point. Small pepperoni & sausage pizza. Comes with pepperocini and garlic dipping sauce - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

We tried this Papa john's for the first time on May 12 we received our pizza with no Peperoni for a all meat pizza with no sausage we actually got what look's like double sausage and no Peperoni. , the store did apologize when we called them and offered another free pizza. That is nice , but why do we as consumers have to constantly call to make our orders correct. the more we up the minimum wage the worst the customer service. (General observation not just to Papa Johns). read more

Sign says the close at 10pm. Walked in store at 9:45pm and they said they close "in store" at 9:30 pm and they only "deliver" i just want some pizza dude and your logic sucks. read more

Went to order a pizza @ 9:43 pm and the person says were in the process of closing and I asked if I could still have a pizza and was told no. Called back the next day only to be slammed on hold 3x. Waited on hold 5plus minutes. Finally I said STOP! The man was rude and told me he didnt like my additude and proceeds to tell me he doesnt feel safe with me coming in to get a pizza. He told me to go ahead and report him to corporate cause he was management. I was not threatening or swearing i just simply wanted service and he by far was much more rude than I. If I could give less than one star I would. Who knows if the pizzas any good read more

Papa John's has finally arrived! On opening day the staff was very friendly and fast! If you ever need a good fingerlickin' pizza pie stop by Papa's House and don't forget a sodie pop to wash it all down. #papabless read more

They deliver to Sudden Valley now!!! It's nice to have other pizza options outside of Tino's! However, you can not order online yet for SV which is no big deal as the customer service I received tonight was on point! They were happy to help me with my order as it was confusing getting the online deals done over the phone! The food was on time and hot! My family and I were very pleased with the entire order and will definitely be ordering from them again! read more

The best pizza in Bellingham! Gets my order right every time. Thin crust, light sauce, light cheese, olives, peperoni, mushrooms, roasted garlic, baked well done. read more

I just moved to Bellingham, have been relying on pizzas to eat on the run a lot of nights. These guys are just a legit shop. Always friendly, pizza is always ready before I get there, never gotten my order wrong. Highly recommend if you're looking for a decent pizza made fast. read more

Swung by the new Lakeway Papa Johns with OPEN sign. Yet, I was informed the lobby closed at 9:30pm. Pizza girl said I can call for delivery... its available until 10pm. So I cant order at the counter, have to call in the order, then try and beat the delivery guy home? Makes NO sense. *add on delivery charge read more

I live in Everson, a good 20-30+ minutes away from this shop so when my fiance forgot our breadsticks and soda when he picked up our order I figured no biggie, was our bad and just accepted we missed out on that part of our mail. Well apparently these amazing folks disagreed because a lovely young man just delivered our breadsticks and soda to our door. I mean we live WAY beyond the delivery zone and I just cant believe how thoughtful and amazing these employees are. Just great. Seriously, also the food is great read more

A lot of money was wasted. Lets first start with the most important aspect of this review, the food; upon arrival (delivery) the food was luke warm. The dessert (cinnamon dessert blobs) were pretty dank. The pizzas (spinach/alfredo/chicken/bacon concoction) smelled terribly of bad/spoiled ingredients. First bite, we all agreed it was likely the sauce, but could have been anything in the toppings. Terrible. The second pizza was a large chicken/bacon/ranch w/ olive and mushrooms. The olives smelled and tasted past expiration. The cheese was extra stinky beyond the usual parma cheese expression and the pizza could not be eaten. The only thing good about the selections were the crust, which was fresh and decidedly the best consistancy/flavor of crust in Bellingham. Otherwise, completely inedible. Delivery for this order was on time/better than expected. But the food waste was not worth the convenience. read more