What a fun place, terrific food and people. Fun art on the walls. Ordered 2 different focaccia pizzas to go: caramelized onion & walnut, chili garlic mushroom; and the absolutely delish goat mountain salad. Would most definitely recommend this unique pizza place. read more

Fans traveling for the Taylor Swift concert in BC filled our downtown streets last night, so we went hunting from restaurant to restaurant, looking for a place without a long wait. Lo! We saw some people exiting Goat Mountain and were able to snag their empty seats at the bar. Lucky us! And not only for the seats. We've never been here before, and we had a great time. We ordered the Goat Mountain Salad--huge! A bargain! Varied! Delicious! And I, who has never met a beet that I didn't dislike, was delighted that ingredients were grouped individually so I could avoid those. Wonderful salad! And--for a mere buck--you can order a dressing on the side for anything you want. The buttermilk was delicious. I ordered a slice of the Apple & Bacon pie; my guy, Potato & Bacon. Upon their arrival, our notions of pizza were shattered. These were big slices of cake! (Website says Roman-style--we've been to Rome, but these exquisite things were very different.) Totally yummy. As was the warm chocolate chip cookie--divine. (Funny story: I didn't have my readers on. I thought the price was $25. "That's quite a cookie!" I thought, imagining one as large as a pizza--which, incidentally, would have been more expensive than their full pizzas! I looked over the Happy Hour menu, planning a future return. The cookie on the HH menu was only $2. A savings, I excitedly told our bartenders, Miyuki and Montana, of $23!!! No, they told me: 50 cents. I hadn't been able to see the dot.) And speaking of our barkeeps, I am so glad we sat up at the bar. They were wholly delightful and friendly. We very much enjoyed chatting with them. We felt like we had just moved and this was our new "neighborhood bar." And their recommendations for food and drink were spot on. The Smoke in Mirrors was fantastical! Great place! read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - The talented, wonderful and friendly barkeeps: Montana + Miyuki - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Had a bad experience today, a very nice Friday afternoon. Poor service started at the register where the employee had a hard time focusing, and a hard time understanding that I just wanted a single slice of pizza, then actually placing the order. 30 minutes later, still no pizza and was told repeatedly "just five more minutes". I finally gave up and just left, even though I had already paid. It just wasn't worth it for a single slice of pizza and I had other, less crappy things to do. read more

This is the coolest little spot. The interior is very homey and modern at the same time and the food is incredible. Just based off the menu it felt like I couldn't go wrong with what I ordered. The staff was kind and considerate. I highly recommend stopping in if you have the chance read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

Love the pizza. Love that you can order by the slice, so you can sample multiple flavors. Crust reminds me of focaccia.

Awful service. The new hostess? Manager? Busser? Not clear what her role was, but her customer service was awful. Insisted that there was a "wait list" despite there being no one waiting and no posted notice of this change to the status quo that's been in place for years (see picture). Sat people she seemed to know ahead of us when we'd been waiting over 45 minutes. I fully understand restaurant work can be stressful, but there's no excuse for treating customers as we were treated. We loved playing trivia here and it was a really fun tradition for our neighborhood, but will be taking business elsewhere if this is the new standard of service. Truly disappointing that one bad apple can ruin the bunch for everyone. read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Policy posted on the door. - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Absolutely delicious pizza and salad, great service. I definitely recommend it, and plan to go again.

I was expecting to like this place, but not quite this much! We stopped in for a couple slices of pizza, very reasonably priced and so so delicious! We tried the mushroom pizza and a Greek-style with hummus and sun dried tomatoes. Both were so good. My favorite discovery were these tiny tinis, small martinis for when a full 'tini is too much!! Can't wait to come back already. read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is amazing and the service is great. Very pleased to discover Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar.

Never having tried this style of pizza we took a chance and it paid off. The crust was thick but much lighter than I thought it would be. The topping flavors worked well together. Service was friendly. read more

The food, atmosphere, and service was great! We had the potato bacon pizza and a salad and it was amazing! read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Potato bacon and hummus sun-dried tomato with goat cheese pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Negatives almost outweigh the positives. I found the atmosphere is dark, woodsy, industrial, and almost movie-esque which is very awesome. However, I am honestly in shock that a little square slice of pepperoni and sausage pizza can run you $6, $4.50 if it's just cheese. That doesn't include any side or drink. For most, those two little yummy slices- won't fill you up and will end up running you the price of a full pizza elsewhere. Here a full size pizza, which is about the size of your standard printer paper will run you about $20 or so. If you want to build your own pizza this is not the restaurant for you. There are, in my opinion unique, fun, delicious, but limited options for the pizzas. If you are willing to pay around $50 before a tip for two people to each get two small slices of pizza, a drink, and an appealing atmosphere, then this is the place for you. If you want to have a full stomach and don't want to or can't drop hours worth of pay on food for the night this is not the spot for you. On the topic of atmosphere... It was pretty cold out today and it was not warm enough inside the restaurant. I had to keep my puffer-coat on and my feet were still cold in my boots after being inside for hours. If you're paying a premium for such a smaller portion of yummy pizza, the restaurant should certainly be comfortable temperature to where the customers feel comfortable taking their coat off to eat. The staff themselves weren't overly social or bubbly, just chill people who seemed cool and provided good service. No complaints whatsoever about the staff and their service. Thank you staff!! The in house made orange soda I also found expensive, but is good, very fizzy, but a fun and refreshing change from typical soda. That was $5 and not sure if there were refills on that. Came in a tall skinny glass served beautifully with a slice of lime garnish. I was a fan of the music being played inside, it was tasteful, matched the atmosphere, family friendly, and being played at a perfect volume. Conclusion? Sometimes it's worth paying the extra money even though you can get many many pizzas from dominos with the same amount of money that was spent here because 1. You may be on a date night or celebrating a special occasion 2. The pizza flavors are unique and tasty 3. Other than the fact that it was cold, the atmosphere was cool and fun I'd love to see: slightly lower prices or at least sides offered with them Live music, I would totally come and would feel like you're getting your moneys worth if live music was offered nightly on weekends, they definitely have the space in the front and I think it's a missed opportunity. That would totally add to their cool vibe going on! read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Fantastic Negroni, wonderful gochujang carrots with candied walnuts And goat cheese, rad pizza by the slice (maybe it's on focaccia bread?) read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Negroni on tap - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Great food, this was my first experience with Romanian pizza it was great we tried several slices I think our favorite was the bacon and goat cheese slice. read more

Excellent potato and bacon pizza! Great service great vibe nice stop on the Saturday night bar hopping route! Warm atmosphere plenty of seats and drink options. read more

I could not be happier about Goat Mountain's return! I was so sad when they closed. The tastes are just as perfect as they once were. It's located where Bar 542 was. I highly recommend trying it out if you've never experienced it. read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - a view of the bar - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

This spot is so delicious and totally underrated. The portions are great and every pizza I have had has been excellent. Stop by if you can!

Awesome slices with interesting toppings. Great slice and beer deal. Cool vibe and nice service

Great pizza, great craft cocktails and beers on tap, and amazing service. Miss this spot immensely. Was so sad when they closed. Good news is they're back and right beside their old spot. Feels very much the same, although they do not do pizza per weight anymore, instead offering half and full pizzas. Strongly recommend this pizza to anyone. Nice airy yet crispy crust. Only place that offers this kind of craft pizza. Kudos to the waiting staff also, very attentive and responsive. read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - New location and a different play on the pizza, but the same otherwise. - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

Their plain cheese pizza was fantastic. It was all about the crust. We will definitely be back to try other kinds.

I'm Italian, and am not a big pizza fan ( sorry famiglia). That being said, this pizza is amazing, the crust, the flavors and toppings are creative and delish. We also had an amazing salad with berries and quinoa that was in my dreams last night....soooooo good!!!! read more

Chris & Chris are great loved the potato & bacon pizza. The aperol spritz was also amazing. Can't wait to come back & try more of the menu. read more

Goat Mountain Restaurant & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Had an awesome experience at Goat Mountain. Amazing food and even better service from Will!! ----Love from folks from New York!

The pizzas are very different and unique. You will definitely not be disappointed. We had the roasted mushroom and onion pizza . Although not a great fan of oyster mushrooms, this tasted really good !! The service was great! And the staff were very friendly:) read more

Wonderful and unique pizza choices and delicious sides! Also really good cocktail:beer/wine list. Service is so great. Very friendly and very efficient. Best of all, the prices are so good! Highly recommend!!! read more

I was visiting from Seattle and craved pizza, so I came to Goat Mountain. This place is perfect, with a beautiful interior, amazing drinks and pizza, and the service was incredible! I recommend this place 100%, it's nice and somewhat affordable! read more

So great to have Goat Mountain Pizza back. The food is incredible, the service has been so great. Cool spot too. Great beer selection. If you haven't tried, I would definitely suggest it. read more

was in town visiting western washington university and was on yelp looking for a good italian place to eat. the place we originally were going to go to was to long of a wait and thank god!! we walked right in and found a place to eat there was many open tables and right away we were greeted by some very friendly staff!! the food came out very quick and was to die for!! tasted amazing, spelled amazing and was amazing!! wish there was more options on the menu but being able to order a full pizza or just a slice was super nice. me and my dad ordered a full pepperoni and sausage and it was the perfect amount!! can not recommend this place enough!! we will be back if we come to visit again!! read more