Cancel

Open app

Search

Papa Johns Pizza

2.8 (11 reviews)
Closed 11:00 am - 11:55 pm

Order Papa Johns Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

Business Info

PAPA JOHNS PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Papa Johns Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Maggie W.

Today was the Grand Opening of Papa John's Pizza in Stouffville. Never tried Papa John's before, so I didn't have an expectation. Ordered online 2 mediums with 2 toppings (Their promo on the website), $20 total. But apparently at the store there was a flyer with more deals. Opening Special Large 4 Toppings $11.99 Promo Code: ST4T Dunno how long the special will be on for. And not sure if you have to order online to get the deal. But this deal wasn't on the website. Pizza came with a smal tub of garlic sauce and a hot pepper. Probably their signature? First impression was it was sloppy..lifting a slice, it kind of drooped over. There was quite a bit of sauce at the bottom and the toppings weren't distributed evenly enough. Taste was not bad, their garlic sauce is really tasty, pepper for me wasn't hot at all(I can take a lot of heat :P). Their dough is chewy which I kind of like! Crust wasn't dry at all. Would give them some time to settle in and we'll try more items :)

Outside

See all

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Stouffville location very good. Pizza is delicious and the staff very friendly and professional.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ken M.
0
29
0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,385 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Saints Island Pies - Lamanny

Saints Island Pies

4.0(8 reviews)
2.1 km

Renamed and rebranded to Saints on Main, which is open for breakfast as well, but will only mention…read moremy takeout pizza experience from there. Filipino-inspired pizzas were delicious! Crust had a great crispy texture and toppings for the 2 pizza options we got were tasty. The pizzas are small considering the cost (you could get a larger one elsewhere for the same fee), but it works so since their pizzas are pretty hearty. Ordering was easy - online through one of the food delivery apps. Was ready for pick-up at the indicated time. Would get their pizza again.

The food was AMAZING. We got Lamanny and classic longanisa. The pizzas are Detroit style pan…read morepizzas. Thin and crispy, not burnt and it was very juicy and full flavour!! Tried both, I def recommend getting these two. The egg was a nice touch on the longanisa! Service was spectacular. The staff was attentive and very friendly. They really achieved the "gathering place" vibe here. I also loved the interior. Look how airy and light it is. It carries a summer vibe all year long. This is a very well loved gem in Stouffville and I def recommend getting here before 5pm to secure a table for dinner. They close reso/the kitchen between 4-5 to get ready for dinner service. You can sit inside but the kitchen would be closed. You could still order café things! Def gotta come back. This is a very lovely place.

Photos
Saints Island Pies - Interior. Bright and airy!

Interior. Bright and airy!

Saints Island Pies
Saints Island Pies - Calamansi juice and iced cortado

See all

Calamansi juice and iced cortado

Domino's Pizza - The box.

Domino's Pizza

3.7(3 reviews)
0.2 km

Very prompt. Very pleasant. Very clean…read more I love this place. There is sit-in available with at least three to four tables. You are greeted with a friendly smile as soon as you're at the counter. You can even see them make the pizza right there. The place is very pleasant and kept spotless. There is a television set available so you don't get bored. The only thing is that parking can be an issue on busy evenings such as Fridays or Saturdays due to the fact that the lot is shared with other businesses such as the steak restaurant to the left and the fried chicken place to the right. The pizzas are not too oily which is wonderful. Nicely presented and nicely sliced. I ordered 'carry out' from theiwebsite which seemed A LOT easier to use compared to the competition. I will certainly go back for seconds or thirds! A-1 service for great-tasting pizzas! Update: Back again for a second time with a coupon I had received in the mail. They checked my coupon and told me to hold onto it for the next time I would be back. They had a better offer for me which saved me $3.00. Awesome! And the pizza still tasted great!

Wow! Just wow! The pizza was cold, it was also 13" when the large pizza's are suppose to be 14"…read more The pizza was thin crust when I ordered regular crust! Even though the store was 15mins Away from my home, the driver took extra 24 mins to arrive. Poor service, poor quality on the pizza . I would not order from this place. Companies cannot use COVID as an excuse for the shitty service they provide anymore!

Photos
Domino's Pizza - Large two-topping with ground beef and green peppers.

Large two-topping with ground beef and green peppers.

Domino's Pizza - Large two-topping with ham and pineapple.

See all

Large two-topping with ham and pineapple.

East Side Mario's - Mario's 3 Course Feast! Mario's Mangia Sampler - no way this meal should be priced at $29.99.

East Side Mario's

2.8(21 reviews)
0.7 km

This East Side Mario's Stouffville restaurant is a fabulous place to kick back and watch one of the…read moreFIFA World Cup games. Even if you're not a soccer fan, there's plenty of offers on tap for busy families including: * All-You-Can-Eat Pasta Mondays Special * Kids Eat Free Tuesdays * Buy One, Take One Home Free Wednesdays * Thursday Amore for Two Special for $50 * All-You-Can-Drink Violet Iced Tea Lemonade or Italian Soda for $3.99. We enjoy coming here for their comfy seating, cute decor, and family friendly atmosphere. They really did a fabulous job with making the atmosphere playful and fun. Instead of my usual order of Mario's Chicken Parmigiana, I opted for a pasta dish which I didn't regret at all. It was served along with the All-You-Can-Eat Soup, Salad, and Garlic Bread. My family agrees that this location is the best in terms of food quality, delicious taste, and friendliness of all the staff working here. We were lucky enough to have many servers tending to our table, along with other tables. Although it was a very busy night, the staff's teamwork was phenomenal. Stouffville East Side Mario's is an excellent place for a family dinner!

This was my first visit back to an East Side Mario in over 10 years. I was hoping it would have…read morebeen than what I remembered because I really wanted to give the brand another try. We started off with the garlic bread. I was a bit confused by the the fact that for 4 people, they only brought 2 small garlic breads, which by the way is "All You Can Eat" when purchasing entrees. Next we ordered the spinach dip. It was pretty good, not heavy in any way, the flavors were there for a decent spinach dip. The best part was the pull away bread for dipping which was served warm. When purchasing entrees there is a choice of three "All You Can Eat" items to choose from / soup, salad and garlic breadsticks, but you can only get 2 orders at a time. I opted for Caesar salad, but they were out of romaine lettuce at 5:30 pm on a Saturday evening. I decided on the garden salad. Not really impressed by this or the way the salad was served. The tomatoes did not appear to be fresh and the iceberg lettuce was cut into very large pieces and placed in a bowl that was clearly too small. On to the mains. Hubby ordered the build your own pasta with Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken added - he wasn't overly happy as he felt that the taste of Alfredo sauce was just not there. Kids ordered off the kids menu - can't mess that up, but the pasta was dry and lacking in Alfredo sauce leaving it dry - so yess, they messed up. I decided to go for the Mario's 3 Course Feast! Mario's Mangia Sampler - this was a really big disappointment - the chicken parm was cold and hard. The lasagna was flat on the plate. I pointed to the plate and asked the person that brought out the food if what I was pouting at was the lasagna. Her response was a yeah dripping with sarcasm. The Fettuccine Alfredo was very dry and hardly had any sauce. Our server came to our table to ask how everything was and I pointed out the 2 pasta dishes and cold chicken parm on my plate. She quickly took both pastas leaving me with the chicken parm " so I had something to eat" is what she explained. Saying that no, that the lasagna should not look that way and would have that and the fettuccine alfredo redone. I sat there eating cold chicken parm while I waited. By the time the 2 pasta dishes were brought back out, I had pretty much lost any anticipation or desire over the meal. The lasagna was all cheese and sauce and barely any noodles. Not sure I will go back, but happy to have at least given it another try after so many years and realizing that it was not going to change for the better. At least I tried!

Photos
East Side Mario's
East Side Mario's
East Side Mario's - Mario's 3 Course Feast!  Mario's Mangia Sampler

See all

Mario's 3 Course Feast! Mario's Mangia Sampler

Regino's Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage, and corn pizza slice. It's a large.

Regino's Pizza

3.8(37 reviews)
8.1 km
$

Regino's Pizza is literally my favourite childhood pizza joint! Ever since my family discovered…read morethis place, this was the place to go when ordering for birthdays or just wanting some pizza for dinner. You're not getting those typical franchise pizzas, this just feels like those home style dishes you want! I recently ordered off Door Dash and for Reginos and I decided to order the 3 topping large pizza with Red Onions, Hot Peppers and Feta Cheese which is my go to! If you ever just want some good pizza, I totally recommend checking this place out! 9/10 recommend!

We ordered from this Regino's for some late night grub on a sat night…read more We got an XL, 3 topping, thin crust pizza. Pepperoni and sausage for the entire pizza and then half mushroom, half eggplant. My first time trying eggplant on a pizza and I liked it! The toppings were well cooked and this shop actually puts enough cheese on the pizza unlike some other chains which skimp on the cheese. It was a change-up from our usual late night Dominos or Papa Johns but a welcome addition to the roster! Crowd sentiment seemed favourable as well. Located in a dingy strip mall just east of markham road and 16th ave (on 16th). The entrance to the shop is actually inside the food court which is accessible via the parking lot out back.

Photos
Regino's Pizza - Food court. It has four stalls.

Food court. It has four stalls.

Regino's Pizza - Pizza slice. It's a large pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers pizza.

Pizza slice. It's a large pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers pizza.

Regino's Pizza - Storefront

See all

Storefront

Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...