After seeing the great reviews I knew I had to try Nonno's when I was in the area! I finally got a couple pizzas today and I can say that the reviews are justified! I'm not a pizza expert by any means and it took me a while to figure out what really set Nonno's apart from your conventional chain pizza. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce is good, but I think what hooked me is the crust. The crust has enough crispness to it to hold a slice's shape and has a delicious chew to it! I'll have to go out of my way more often to get Nonno's pizza and I'll have to try their calzones and veal sandwiches!! read more

Very disappointed. Wings were cold and hard even though were just out of oven.Garlic bread was gross.like a slice of cheese thrown on a stale bun and microwaved.First and last.Giorgios 100 times better and more friendly read more

Nice veal sandwich & decent pizza. Staff was great! Just passing through town & decided to check them out. Was pleasantly surprised. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

See all

We love trying local businesses whenever we are in a new area. When we came in, we noticed a lot of regulars and I can see why people keep coming back for their pizza. The dough was thick and crispy with just the right amount of oilyness. A good amount of toppings and cheese. Texturally I would say this was nearly perfect. However, I thought it was lacking a little flavour. Also I'm not sure if it was because there was too much sauce or if it was because it was piping hot, but some of the cheese and toppings kept sliding off but it was easy to just put it back on.   Overall, if you are looking for a nice freshly baked pizza, definitely give this place a try! read more

See all

We grabbed a large deluxe pizza from this place and found it to be pretty good! Staff were nice, pizza was quick, and made fresh! it was about $20 for the pizza and an additional $1.50 per pizza. It wasn't bad for the price but I didn't have the chance to try the pizza until it was cold and so don't have a good grasp on the flavor. It seemed not bad but wasn't extraordinary or stand out in particular. So overall, I give it a 4/5. read more

See all

located stouffville is this no frill pizza joint. You can purchase their pizza in slices or as a whole pizza and price are very fair! We tried their pepperoni slice and meat lover slice and they definitely do not cheap out on their cheese and toppings!!! the dough is also super crispy and tasty. The only issue i had was the sauce was a bit salty but still was so delicious! The asian lady at the counter was also super friendly and helpful! not many seating but there are a couple of tables for people who want to eat their pizza hot and fresh! definitely will be returning! read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

At the time I write this the reviews are 4.5 stars. Either the folks in Canada have a very low bar for pizza or this is the best the area has to offer. We start by ordering a cheese pizza and ask them to add Ricotta as a topping. The Asian women at the register says "We don't have Ricotta" We look up at the menu and they sell Calzones. Ingredients of calzones: Ricotta, Mozzarella and dough. Ok they don't have ricotta. #rolls eyes# The plain cheese pizza arrives. There is so much sauce under the cheese that the entirety of the cheese on a slice just slides off onto the plate. If this is 4.5 star pizza in Canada then its time to move south. read more

Have been coming to crupis my whole life & know the owner well! I would say I would recommend it to anyone but if you don't already know of them you have been missing out. Best pizza in the city by far. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza is the best Pizza in Ballantrae, on Highway 48, north of Whitchurch-Stouffville! I ordered their veal on a bun. Toppings were extra. I also had their cheese* pizza which was good. Their Calzones look good baked fresh with cheese and tomato sauce, toppings extra. Be sure to pick up a few Brio bottles to go with the pizza. Closed on Mondays. Local delivery available minimum $18. With a minimum 24 hours notice, they do catering for events and school events. Lasagna tray is $90 for a large size. Large size Pasta Tray is $60. read more

See all

Perfect tasty pizza! Fresh salad! I ordered two party size pizzas and Caesar salad for my guests! Everyone liked the food , special pizzas were super tasty ! read more

Veal sandwich is a must!! Pizza is amazing as well. :) Super nice servers/cooks. Quiet a quint little area, only down fall is the parking lot is not big enough. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza used to be in Markham before the moved up to North Stouffiville. So being the only decent non chain pizza joint in the area, I totally understand the high rating as a local neighbourhood place. No frills, good ingredients, friendly service. Dropping by here after servicing my car for lunch one afternoon. A lot of truckers popped in for take out or eat in. Parking for sure can be a challenge in this small parking lot so a lot of people just park in roadside or wherever space without blocking others. My Deluxe Pizza Slice is A-OK. It is usually hard to rate a pizza if it is not fresh from the oven. But at least Nonno Crupi's has a high turnover so it was still good. Worth supporting local small business if you are in the area. read more

See all

Amazing staff , great service , delicious food . This location is only take out , with very reasonable price . I recommend everyone to try it , you won't be disappointed. read more

Do yourself a favor do not go to this place the door is very heavy sauce was on cooked toppings were not fresh attitude from the owner and the list goes on there is a better place on Highway 48 if you go north on the left hand side read more

Excellent veal on a bun. Only error was on my part I should have added hot peppers on mine. Next time.

Nonno Crupi knows how to make a hot grease wheel, and it's a blessing for the surrounding area. No need to flock to the pizza chains in the area, because this place is making sure Stouffville isn't stuck with Pizza Pizza bullshit. Crispy pizza crust, with a tangy sauce and fresh toppings are only missing the necessary Caesar salad on the side. Make sure you don't miss their wings, and I promise you won't be letdown by the veal. read more

About a month ago, I fell upon this amazing gem of a place. Traffic stopped on the 404 and my maps directed me to go across a road I wasn't familiar with to Hwy 48. Thank goodness for that detour because I fell upon Nonno Crupi's Pizza and decided to stop. I learned from a young child, travelling with my parents who taught me that if you don't know where to eat, assess by checking out parking lots and go where it's busy. That's what I did. Today I was on my way home from Toronto and decided to take this route just so I could stop here. My husband wants to to go this way all the time now lol! I usually have a cooler with freezer packs and or ice so this works out because I want to eat with my husband, not on the road. I ask for the veal cold and the buns separate as my drive from Nonno's to my home is about 1.5 hours away. I put it in the oven, covered with foil at 375-400 for 20ish minutes. The veal is the best I've had, and way better than California Sandwiches. California Sandwiches are good but tough in recent years but Nonno Crupi's veal is tender and just so amazingly perfect!! Next time I'm buying the veal and my husband wants me to pick up a calzone. read more

Came here on a recommendation from a friend and glad we grabbed dinner here to go. I was feeling like having pizza so we swung by half an hour before close and they did not have veggie but they did have almost all the slices available. I grabbed the deluxe slice, my friend got a cheese slice and an order of wedges. The deluxe slice was really good and the pizza dough is flavorful which is always important to me. I have to say the slice was huge and good portion. Deluxe was 5.75. The wedges took 15 minutes to bake and was a bit disappointing because it was not crispy at all, very soft. I wouldn't order it again but I'll be back next time to order the veal! Lots of options here and even getting a full pie looked to be worth it as well read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Deluxe PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

I got to admit that it wasn't the pizza that drew me to this tiny establishment in the middle of nowhere just off the side of the road. Rather, it was their large sign for veal on a bun and my ever increasing hunger. Thankfully, all the patrons before me ordered pizza so I changed my mind and got a slice of pizza instead. Good thing because it was absolutely delicious!! Throughout the meal, there was a steady stream of hungry people ordering their own perfect slice so you know you've made a good life decision. The pizza itself is pretty perfect. The crust was thin, crisp, and solid enough to carry all the fresh toppings and tangy sauce. Heated up to order, it comes piping hot and the cheese melted all over. You can even get your piece 'well done' if you like it on the crispier side. A great meal to satisfy any hunger pangs or a snack during a long trip up north. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - The delicious pizza.... I think this was the deluxe? - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

After hearing about this little establishment for years I had to try it. To date, I have eaten several items on this menu. So here we go... 1) The calzone is amazing. Old school. Just delish. Make sure you are hungry because this is quite large. The basic is cheese. You can add all kinds of options to this i.e.): pepperoni, mushrooms, and bacon plus many more.... 2) The Veal sandwich. You must try this. You can add mushrooms, onions, and peppers etc..... YUM. 3) Chicken wings are a very nice little added nibbly. 4) The pizza slices. Drive up to this location at noon. Sit, watch and learn. 5) Potato wedges. Very basic with a dipping sauce. Meh... When you see all kinds of roads department staff and construction workers and truck drivers going here. You know it is good and very reasonably priced. I recommend the super pizza. Check out the menu. It offers all kinds of catering options. * I have not checked out the restroom. That is something I normally do. I will keep you posted. In general the place is clean. You should go!! read more

This place nailed it. One of the better veal sandwiches I've had. Firstly the bread they use is fantastic. Perfectly soft and toasted. And did I say it was huge! Veal - very generous portion of meat. I see a lot of places that cheap out on the meat. Not this place. Well breaded, deliciously seasoned and generous. Great tasting sauce that's not too acidic. Overall a great tasting sandwich. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Veal sandwich with cheese and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

Best pizza joint around . Very tasty and always fresh. The calzones are to die for , huge and so cheesy. The chicken wings are delicious, especially the honey garlic. Very nice people that run it, they work hard and always make you feel welcome. Incredible pizza with that homemade taste! Our favourite read more

First time here and it did not disappoint. The owner was super nice and the pizza is amazing. Definitely worth paying the extra few bucks. Thin and crispy thin crust, lots of fresh toppings and not greasy. It was totally worth the drive up there. 100% recommend this pizza joint. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

See all

Best Mom and Pop Shop that caters to your taste variations to the "T". I've been eating the pies and sandwiches from them since the opening, Never had a bad thing come out of their kitchen. Sorry for having the Greek Church have to go, but it was a fair trade-off. Thick or thin pizzas are custom made to your preferred taste and degree of spices. Sauteed onions and peppers available for the veal sandwich as well. read more

Woah.... The food was life changing. Never in my life have such an amazing meal. The panzerotti was beyond my my expectations, and the sauces were the cherry on top. read more

it's 7:30 as im typing this, I tried calling before 7 and only ever got user busy, so i decided to drive over to find they closed early, normally I wouldn't care but it's a weekend, and they're closed Mondays anyway, just shows laziness and a poor management decision that makes me wonder what other laziness and poor decisions are going on read more

I really like Crupi's pizza! I've had it several times and I'm always happy with it. Thin slice Italian style pizza. Great toppings. Reasonably priced. There isn't much parking out front but I've parked in the plaza on the side to pickup my pizza! Definitely better than any pizza chains! read more

This is an excellent place to eat, the service was great and friendly, and the pizza was really good and pretty well priced, they also have a selection of other things like chicken wings which are also really good and pretty well priced as well. Can't go wrong with eating here. read more

Nonno Crupi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitchurch-Stouffville, Ontario

Stumbled upon this place in 2020 and it was amazing. Have driven 30 mins (from home) because it was so good! Tastes so authentic.

Some great pie. Veal sangwidge is pretty dang'd good too ! It's in the middle of nowhere on 48 just south of Aurora Rd ... check it out

Great pizza made in the traditional fashion. Their hours are a little strange so make sure they are open if you're just dropping by to get something. read more

Delicious pizza. It's a bit out of the way for me but well worth the drive. Crust is fluffy and decent amount of toppings; reasonable price.

Best pizza around. All made fresh. Very friendly service. Calzones and Veal sandwiches are huge and delicious. Never go away hungry after eating a veal sandwich. read more

Delicious and affordable pizza all year round. Ingredients are fresh. May just get a pie tonight!

This is a local pizza joint for me and it took me a while to check it out but I was pleasantly surprised. They are a little pricey but they were willing to make any combination we suggested and managed to nail it. They are a little difficult to get a hold of on the phone at times so not always convenient. I will be back regularly as long as they keep answering the phone... read more

Luv this place. A local favourite. Pizza is fresh and veal sandwich are awesome. Pizza slice is well priced and my fave! read more

This establishment should be embarrassed for the way they treat their customers. Rude/Arrogant. They should also stop giving their customers extra food in return for positive reviews. The food should speak for itself. read more

Been going to crupis since I was a kid. Lived right down the street. Have known everyone working here for years. Very hard workers and make only the best pizza and food ever. Give this place 5 star any day. read more

One of the best pizza places in all of the city. Wish they had more locations their pizza is amazing and so is their panzerotti. The most delicious around. Hard to find pizza places that are authentic and have top notch quality. Always go there when I'm in the area. More then 5 stars in my opinion. read more

I used to go to Crupis pizza in Markham back in the day before it closed down. I was so excited to try this pizza out when I heard there was still a Crupis pizza around, wow was the pizza ever good, great quality toppings with a delicious pizza sauce, Yum! read more