Grilled to order double cheeseburger and house fries were fantastic. Everything about classic smash burger and fries, patty shack delivered!! Staff were nice and quick to get an order in, didn't have to wait long at all after ordering either! Inside was complete with several arcade games and pull tabs. Also neatly displayed menu options for burger additions and side choices! Great spot! read more

See all

Sometimes, you just need a good burger! We spent the morning trying to figure out what we wanted for lunch and ultimately landed on Patty Shack. It reminded me of any regular little American joint, like a Sammie's or a Chicago Red Hots. Lots of burgers and sandwiches to choose from, but we were starving and chose the first thing we saw. I got the Maddie Melt, which I DIDNT EVEN KNOW there wasn't a patty in it until I was almost done with it. The flavors were so spot on, I really believed there wasn't a burger in it the whole time! It came with extra veggies, grilled onions, and mushrooms and was really good and is a good veg option if you don't eat meat. My bf got the pastrami burger which was just as good. Both came with fries and the patty sauce, which tasted like a mayo ketchup mix. Price was super reasonable and we left full and happy. Free parking. They also had a food truck in the front, so you can probably rent it for a party or find it in the wild! They had arcade games and crane games so I can see someone having a good time there. Would def come back!! read more

Patty Shack - Pastrami Cheeseburger with Fries Cheeseburger with Fries Maddie Melt Veggie with Fries - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I was in the area and looking for a late night dinner with Patty Shack being the closest bookmark that was open. I stopped in and ordered a double cheeseburger with fries to go. The burger was meh. Even though it looked like it had a lot of cheese on it, I thought the cheese was pretty flavorless. A disappointment for sure. The fries, however, were great. They were crunchy, battered, and had good flavor. They were easily better than the burger. If I stop back, I'd get those again with something else as the main item. read more

See all

This place is a hidden gem, and well worth the find. What doesn't seem like much from the inside, this place has got it all in flavor. This is the perfect burger joint. All of their burgers have the tastiest flavor. You can pack it with all different types of toppings, including unique sauces. They also have extremely awesome brunch sandwiches. The service is pretty decent, if it's super busy with Uber eats orders, plan to wait a little bit. I wouldn't say it's overly staffed, but it's enough to create pure deliciousness. The inside is fairly simple decor, but sometimes those are the best places. If you're looking for a super tasty burger in Bayview, this is your go-to. read more

The burger was amazing !! Very flavorful and juicy. The man working the register was very nice and made the environment very welcoming. He even offered me something to drink even though I did not order anything to drink. He attended to all his customers that were dining in. I will be back! read more

Patty Shack - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Customer Service 5/5 - I was greeted right away and my order was handled quickly. Food 4.5/5 - The pastrami burger was delicious with tender pastrami and nicely seasoned beef patties. The fries were hot, crispy and nicely salted but could have used a little additional seasoning. Value 4.5/5 - It was a pretty decent volume of food for the price and I was full after eating. Ambiance 5/5 - The building itself is tucked in a little alley with off the street parking. Inside there is plenty of space, seating, and even a couple old school pinball machines. read more

First time here. Ordered the single Bacon Cheeseburger and added raw onions and pickles. Tge burger patties are a 1/4 lb and the burgers include a side of "natural cut" (skin on, frozen) fries. You have a lot of options to add to your burger for free. My burger was cooked to well done. I wasn't asked how I want it cooked, so II assume all cooked well done. My burger wasn't juicy (partly because it was cooked well done), but it was good. There was a slight char flavor from the flat-top (I did not see grill marks on patty), and I could taste a little seasoning, even with the cheese and bacon. Fries were crisp and nicely seasoned. There were a couple of pinball machines, a racing video game, claw game to get candy, and a pull tabs machine. read more

See all

I stopped here for new restaurant of the week to check them out because smash burger places are getting popular. The guy working the counter was super friendly with all the customers. The place is clean and nice looking. I ordered the single bacon cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, pickles and raw onions that comes with frys for $13 ish. My food came quickly and I was off. The bacon cheeseburger looked good except for the bun which looked like a Chia pet. The frys were really good and cooked to order hot, seasoned well with a crispy shell and soft center. The bacon cheeseburger was pretty good with the fresh toppings. The hand formed beef patty had a nice fresh beef flavor I thought but not seasoned like the frys were ?. Overall it's a decent burger and frys place that I didn't see any shakes on the menu and I bet if they had good shakes on the menu they would be a great spot for a burger and a shake. read more

See all

One of the guys I've been stopping here since they opened and needed to bump up the stars. Great burgers. Great breakfast sandwiches. Best fries. I've stopped in to order and have done online. Food is up fast or on time. Staff is always friendly and the place is super clean. What a great addition to the area. read more

See all

Highlights 1) Great Burgers 2) Fast 3) Online Ordering Available We did Patty Shack take out recently and it was so great! We were able to very quickly order online and our food was estimated to be ready in about 20 minutes. Our food was ready when we arrived (right on time!). The burgers were great! I was able to order mine with a lettuce wrap instead of a bun which was awesome. Fries were good too. This is an awesome take out option! read more

Patty Shack - Burger sub lettuce wrap instead of bun - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Patty Shack has delicious burgers and a friendly atmosphere. I can rave about their juicy patties, especially the double bacon cheeseburger, which was packed with flavor and topped with crispy bacon. I added grilled onions and mushrooms, along with tomatoes and lettuce. The fries were crispy, salty and served hot. I absolutely loved my take out meal. Patty Shack is a great spot to satisfy your burger cravings. I'll definitely be back! read more

Patty Shack - Double Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Food was very good nice lil gem I would definitely recommend this place if u like burgers they have a unique menu that will shock your taste buds service was okay read more

The energy was great, service was perfect. I got a double cheeseburger and fries. It was on 10! go here for a tasty burger. i will be back with friends! Very clean; seems family owned. read more

I stopped in to check out there food The burgers were amazing the lady was making them by hand fresh the fries were so good not soggy or greasy like some places it is a great place to eat service was great the place was clean you have to check this place out read more

Delicious burgers, fries, and friendly staff! Quick service and made fresh to order!

Very dependable burger. Can't go wrong here. Food is always fresh, super tasty. Beats five guys easy

SERVICE: I came here on a rainy day after finishing a practice exam. I thought I should indulge myself with something a little unhealthy. I think I waited about 20 minutes for my burger. With this long wait, I was expecting my burger to be warmer than what it was. FOOD: Despite being lukewarm, the burger itself was very good. I got the double cheeseburger. The patties are well worth the money. I would say for a burger place that this is a little more on the expensive side. Double cheeseburger with fries and soda cost me $17.50 . AMBIANCE: Given the prolonged wait time, I now understand why the restaurant has a bunch of arcade games. I would highly recommend that if you come here, you should bring some quarters to pass the time. You will be in for a wait. read more

See all

This is a build your own burger. I had a single patty cheese burger without a bun. It was on a lettuce leaves. The burger was cooked perfect. The French fries are awesome. Golden brown and nice size. My husband had a burger with fried onions. Nice place. Clean and great location. You order at the counter and if you stay it is brought to your table. The counter worker was friendly and explained how the ordering worked. Nice and would go back. Definitely order with a bun! read more

My husband stopped in and picked up lunch for he and I. We each created our own burgers and I have no regrets!! I had bacon, mushrooms and an over easy egg. DELICIOUS. The fries were crispy and full of flavor. The home made ranch was . Can't wait to have a burger from there again!!! read more

Descent burger, bun a bit too think, not a fan of the taste/texture of the bun. Last time I got the breakfast burger and fries. Burger was 3.5/5 fries were 3/5 warm but not hot, and I picked up right when they came up, so they weren't hot out of the fryer fresh, but ok. Meh ok food. Could be great if they had a better bun and fries were served piping hot. read more

Went to Patty Shack today. Solid burger and great service. You order at the counter and there is a clean seating area for dine in. Nice addition to the Bayview area. read more

See all

I moved to Bay View very recently and fell in love! Today, that love grew bigger and stronger after I filled my belly at Patty Shack. Do I start with the burger? Probably should, considering. A single with fresh onion, fried onion, BBQ sauce, and bacon was all it took for me to know I won't need to find another burger joint. Since I prefer my beef cooked close to well-done, a smashburger is heaven-sent, and the Shack's was an exemplar. The bacon (perfection in quality, crispness, and quantity), double punch of onions, and piquant BBQ sauce were the chef's kiss on that perfect patty. I'll be thinking about that satisfying sandwich for days! The same can be said for the fries. Lordy, lordy, lordy, they were simply outstanding! Crispy crispy crispy, hot hot hot, I didn't leave behind so much as a grain of salt (which was applied with an experienced hand). I got to have a little chat with the (an?) owner, a really nice man who obviously cares about his restaurant and its patrons. If I have any complaint it's with the bun, which I found just a little insubstantial, but that's pretty darned insignificant in the scheme of the whole meal. I'm pleased I found Patty Shack, and I'll be back again. And again. And... read more

I am glad this place just opened up this location because they were delicious. This little burger joint is clean and has enough space to eat your burger there or take it to go. We ate too fast to be able to take photos. The burgers were delicious and reasonably priced and the pastrami on top of the burger added so much flavor. A lot of toppings were included as well. The french fries were very crunchy so worth getting as well (most of their burgers come with fries). The service was quick and friendly and made for an overall fun lunch experience. I really hope you give this place a try and they stay in this spot because they really are a good burger place. read more

We stopped in on a whim on a Saturday about 5:30 PM, and both had cheeseburgers with fries, and cokes. We ate there, the dining area was very clean - we were the only diners there. Food took about 10 minutes to arrive and was delicious! This filled us up as much as Culver's double deluxe burgers. The fries, in particular, are worth recommending as they are seasoned and super-crispy. We'll be back! read more

Staff was friendly, the bun and burger tasted fresh, triple patties are a thing, the onion rings were very good. Seriously how much more do you want in a burger joint? ‍ read more

Patty Shack - I even stuffed some onion rings in the burger - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Made a delivery order through their app .. received wrong items. called, lady who answered the phone was nice and recommended trying to request a refund through the app. I checked the app it didn't have an option to report issues. I called back, and they got an owner on the phone who said they couldn't do anything day of to make it right. It's shocking to see a place unable to fix or refund their mistakes. hopefully they realize they need to have managers on the clock while open at some point. If you're willing to risk having to do a chargeback eat/order here, otherwise I'd stay away. read more

The single bacon cheeseburger was crispy around the edges of the burgerthe bacon was bacon crumbled on the burger I was expecting a strip of bacon the fry sauce the bag was so light I thought they forgot the burger and just gave me sauce I will try them again but I would appreciate my burger to look just like the picture on their website I will get a double or triple the single patty is super thin I feel cheated they burger alone was $9.00 I did get tomatoes pickles lettuce and onion but really was not a 9 dollars burger will c what happens on my next visit read more

Such a good burger joint. Classic old school spot with an amazing burger. Up there on my list of burger spots for sure.

A dry burger rates three stars but when when you place a delivery order and part of your order is missing the restaurant should strive to make it right. They refused to respond to the text thread and when we called they said that we should come pick it up! No apologies no refund just a request to pick it up on a delivery order. There are many options available so choose a place that doesn't despise their customer. read more

If you're looking for a local burger joint that's open late at night and delicious then I'd recommend Patty Shack. I'd recommend getting all the toppings with your burger. The spot is located right off KK in Bayview. They are open late at night if you're craving something after grabbing a drink. Service was great. read more

Finally made it here, got some burgers , fries and onion rings to bring home for the family, so delicious! Great flavor for the food, service at pickup was efficient and friendly! Download the app for rewards, recommend! read more

Patty Shack - Bacon cheeseburger, fries, Small Onion Rings - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

One of the best burgers we had. I ordered the bacon cheeseburger. All of the toppings are at your request and even the premium toppings are free too. All burgers come with a healthy small fry. The menu is not extensive but worth what they do have. The service was top notch. Took care of us, answered our questions, checked on us. They were cleaning the walls when we were walking in, the place is very clean. I would definitely give this place a try. read more

FOOD: Absolutely fantastic fries. They were both potato-y and crispy at the same time. Perfect amount of seasoning. A+ on the fries. I would come back just for the fries alone. As for the burger, soft bun with the best topping to party ratio you can imagine. Also came with a sauce that was kind of ketchupy/mayoish and great. A- on the burger, as it could have used some (more?) seasoning on the patties (but that's more of a personal preference type thing). SERVICE: super, super nice staff and very attentive. We actually had to wait "10 minutes" (it was like 4) for them to redo the patties on the burger because the first ones weren't up to their standards. A++ on the service! Great value buy at this place. Both my wife and I would highly recommend. read more

We stopped here for a delicious burger. We have never been here before. The burger was juicy and cooked to perfection. The service was really good as well. We will definitely be returning. read more

Small shop in a place that has struggled to keep a tenant, but I was pleasantly surprised how good the burger was. I got a single cheeseburger with lettuce, mayo and grilled onions. It was delicious. Came with fries that were crispy too. I hope this place does well, I'd try it again. read more

Patty Shack - a view of the inside of a restaurant - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Excellent burger! Very fresh. I little overpriced but that's Bay View for you! Simple clean dining room. Very friendly owner and service. I highly recommend Party Shack! read more

Food was delicious. Staff were friendly and professional. We enjoyed the arcade games while waiting for our to go orders.

The BEST breakfast sandwich in the world! Got the breakfast daddy with the patty cake. YUM. I am definitely going back. I was baffled by the taste i experienced, absolutely glorious. read more

Went in for takeout, they had the meal ready in about 10 minutes. I had the bacon cheeseburger- AMAZING! Came with a side of fries, also wonderful. The onion rings? Those were the best part. Super crispy and not flimsy at all! Service was great - worker was so nice and made small talk. It was super quiet in there and I can't imagine why as I had such a good experience! read more

Patty Shack - Small Onion Rings Patty Melt with Bacon Small Fry - Burgers Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

The burgers were good. Beer bartered fry's were average at best. Rude people and service is slow. Not the best crowd coming in and out.