If there's one thing to get from here, get their mint frosted brownie. It's divine and let me tell you why. It's chocolately but not in an overwhelming way, fudgey but also slightly cakey, making it an irresistible texture. The frosting is light, airy and minty but not to the point of tasting like an overpowering breath mint. Bonus point is this place is located on Lake Mohawk, which is stunning and transports you to what feels like a little Swiss town. The interior of the bakery is cozy and has an almost Hallmark movie ambience. The staff is friendly. They have 1-2 outdoor tables and I think serve coffees too. read more

See all

Cute place and their Easter selection had me going overboard. It's a smaller place but there are so many goodies inside. Their cookies are a work of art. I took two little kids with me and the staff were very patient with us! read more

Went for the first time after seeing tik tok videos of Pattycakes and how it seems like it would be a welcoming environment. The worker inside wasn't the nicest and seemed like she didn't want any customer to go into the store that day. The coffee itself was 7 dollars, which isn't bad when comparing to other coffee shops. The service itself could have used some work. read more

I happened to be walking around Sparta and noticed the adorable Pattycakes Bake Shop. I walked in and was in awe of the tantalizing desserts that all looked completely adorable. There were small cakes topped with cannolis, cupcakes topped with whoppie pies, and more. I had never seen anything so playful! Despite the allure of the creative treats, I opted for a basic Chocolate Chip Cookie, which was still quite large and tantalizing. When I got home, I could not wait to try a piece of the treat, but, sadly, I found it just mediocre. The soft and chewy cookie lacked flavor. Yes, it was packed with chocolate chips, but they seemed to be made of milk or semi-sweet chocolate, as they provided little impact. In addition, the cookie could have used some salt. It essentially resembled a larger Chewy Chips-Ahoy and was not super exciting. Though my cookie was a bit of a letdown, I would give Pattycakes another shot, in order to try some of the other, more adventurous pastries. read more

Pattycakes Bake Shop - Chocolate Chip Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

I ordered the cake for my sister's bridal shower from Patty Cakes. Throughout the whole process, the staff was communicative and responsive. They listened to my ideas and made sure the final product matched what I'd requested to a T. The cake was simply gorgeous and, just as important for any cake or pastry, delicious. The guests all loved it, and it was quite a hit. I also ordered a dozen cupcakes on the side, just in case the cake wasn't enough. Big thanks to PattyCakes for making my sister's big day special and memorable! read more

See all

Went on Saturday to pick up two of the small grab n go cakes available. They had a wide variety of flavors and the employees working were super sweet and took the time to explain each flavor. The little cakes are so cute and comfortably yielded 6 slices. I thought the cakes were a little pricey at $42 but that's essentially $7/slice for the best cake I've ever bought, which is a spectacular deal. The cakes were enjoyed by all - hope to return soon for more goodies! I also grabbed a pistachio latte and it was delish! read more

One word to describe this lovely bakery: Amazing. I was recommended to try them out, and let me just say it was worth the visit. Not only is the location in a wonderful area but the scenery around it is beautiful, it gave me Hallmark movie vibes. They have Outdoor seating for those lovely warm weathered days, the moment you walk in you are warmly greeted and let's talk about how aesthetically pleasing it is. Lovely displays of all the sweets. It was bright and welcoming. I bought an assortment of desserts ranging from their yummy cannoli cake, a few of their themed cupcakes (cinco de Mayo with the a mini taco on top), lava cakes and of course those lovely cookies that are displayed once you enter. The flavors and quality are 10 out 10. If you are a local or just visiting the area and need a place to grab something for your sweet tooth look no further, I will certainly be back. read more

Checked this place out and while it's tiny & cute... it's way overpriced for the quality! On top of that they listed an item for $4 and then charged $8 and then gave an attitude about THEIR false advertised sign. Didn't apologize or adjust the price and seemed annoyed that we pointed out the mistake. Would not recommend or return. read more

When im in lake mohawk, I always grab a cup of coffee and something sweet from patty cakes! They have many desserts to choose from and they also make some fantastic cakes and cupcakes for any special occasion. Staff is always friendly and accommodating which makes the experience that much better. read more

Pattycakes Bake Shop - a display of cakes and pastries - Desserts Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

See all

We had cupcakes and a smash cake for our grandson's 1st birthday. They were delicious and beautiful. The pumpkin pie cupcakes were a big hit. They were decorated with a little piece of pie on the frosting. Would order again . read more

good service. lady was ok she coulee smile a little cookies 5.50 that a lot of money I was going to buy a cake but was to much nice ambiance it was ok my not be back you need a big money for dessert read more

I recently bought two cakes and specialty cookies needed for an event. Due to the short notice they were able to accommodate my cookie order but I had to choose cakes they had available. The cookies were beautiful and exactly as I requested and the cakes amazingly delicious. Some of the best cakes I've ever had. The staff tried their best to accommodate my needs and were very professional and courteous. I highly recommend Patty Cakes. read more

Unique, delicious, and fabulous! The imagination and creativity is so fun! The varieties of cupcakes, cookies, treats and unique gifts make this shop stand out ! read more

We ordered a birthday cake for our daughters 14th last month. We ordered on the Tuesday prior to Saturday pick up. I knew it could be last minute, but was assured that it would be fine as long as items were available. We ordered a chocolate layer cake with fruit filling. And a design that was recommended by Patty. It was a beautiful cake. But the actual cake was brick like, had no flavor and the fruit filling was a thin layer of jam. It was so dry and inedible that we kept the half of the cake we hadn't cut to give to the bakery to show them. We called the Sunday morning after and expressed our total dissatisfaction and we're assured we would get a call within the week. Well it's now a week and no call or follow up. Completely dissatisfied. I cannot recommend at all. read more

Bakery is great. Coffee not so much. Ordered a large latte and it was warm... also looks like they use a Nespresso machine?

Everything I've had from Pattycakes has been delicious. From the muffins to the cookies to the parfaits - I loved everything - you can't go wrong no matter what you choose. read more

I love this bakery! I haven't ordered a cake (yet) but their in shop menu of treats is so cute and delicious! I love the attention to detail, especially with the cookies. The staff is just as sweet as the desserts too! read more

Pattycakes Bake Shop - Thanksgiving mini cookies! So sweet, perfect mini size - Desserts Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

I called and emailed multiple times. Finally got a response that they were booked for my date. A prompter response would be more professional and helpful to customers who are trying to plan an event. disappointing! read more

Every time I walk into pattycakes bake shop, they greet me like I am one of the family. I was I initially impressed with the organic beauty of her work, and then I was extremely surprised to find out that patty makes cakes and treats that taste as good as they look. It seems everybody is getting their custom cakes from Pattycakes and now I know why. I can't imagine going anywhere else. Thanks for doing what you do so well. Rev. Rob read more

We received a gift box of pretzels, cake pops and cookies as a gift. Everything was delicious! They delivered and it was such a nice surprise. I can't recommend this business enough! read more

Pattycakes Bake Shop - Gift box after my kids started sampling. It was beautifully packaged when it was delivered. - Desserts Near Me - Sparta, New Jersey

We love PattyCakes!! Patty first created a dessert table for our engagement party. Her desserts are so good that we asked PattyCakes to make our favors for our wedding. When covid19 hit, we had to make other plans. Patty was so accommodating and understanding of our situation. She talked with us through the whole process making sure everything was absolutely perfect! In the end, she made beautiful favors with a variety of desserts. She also made us a 6in cakes that was absolutely delicious!! We love working with PattyCakes that we are also having her make our favors for our big ceremony/reception next year. Thank you so much for everything Patty! read more

I have used PattyCakes a few times and they never disappoint. Attention to detail and always the best service and professionalism. Cakes and cookies are delicious. I highly recommend them! read more

If you are looking for drop dead gorgeous cakes backed with amazing and dedicated service, you are sure to find it at Pattycakes. When our cruise wedding got cancelled 22 days before the big day we were left back at square one with 30% less in our total budget. When didn't even know where to start to pick of the pieces and Patty came to our rescue with her donation of a wedding cake. And when I saw our wedding cake I don't just mean wedding cake I mean beautiful, elegant, decadent, rich, creamy and everything you could imagine wanting in a cake, It was even better than the one we had originally chosen. I can't believe the lucky we had when Patty reached out to us. Her dedication to helping us keep our special day as magical as we had hoped speaks volumes to her genuine personality and work ethic. Thanks Patty so much for all that you did and continue to do! read more

See all

Ordered cookies for my daughter's baptism and they were perfect! They were beautifully decorated and packaged, and tasted delicious. Very friendly and accommodating too! read more

From the moment we met, we knew we would get our cakes with Pattycakes. We planned from San Diego, so it was difficult to plan a wedding, but this was so easy and delicious! Our cake was beautiful and we can't wait to share photos. The Suisse buttercream was clean and tasty. We're not big fondant fans, but we love the smooth look. Our cake was beyond smooth, and tall at 5 tiers! She coordinated with our florist to decorate the cake and the placement was to perfection. Now I love cake, and always make it a point to eat cake at a wedding, but I know many people who don't. Those people came up to me and raved about it! The different flavors included carrot cake, cannoli, raspberry vanilla, and a red velvet. I wish I could eat it all the time. Thank you so much for the most beautiful and tasty wedding cake! read more

Beautiful baby shower cake at an affordable price. Thank you everything was perfect from communication to delivery. You were able to create what I found online beautifully. Highly recommended. read more