Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Peachey's Amish Store

    4.8 (9 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 4:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    Peachey's Amish Store Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Peachey's Amish Store

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Slyn T.
    1
    63
    12

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 years ago

    Great place to get the basic stuff!! Got a great jar of apple butter and several baking extras... also great for butter and spices

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Peachey's Amish Store

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Wolf's Fine Chocolates

    Wolf's Fine Chocolates

    4.5(19 reviews)
    34.5 mi
    $$$$

    I remember stopping in to Wolf's Fine Chocolates during one of my Tenderness Tour events that took…read moreme through Attica. This is the home base for Wolf's, though they do also have a location in nearby West Lafayette. Wolf's has been in business for over a half century, though they've mostly lived in the shadow of other familiar Indiana chocolatiers. They use a handmade process in their Attica factory. Located in an easy to miss building near the National Guard Armory on U.S. 41 (which is known as Council Street in Attica), Wolf's also offers shopping online and they have some of their chocolates available at A Taste of Indiana here in Indianapolis. I'm sitting here having devoured a Fine Milk Chocolate Crisp (think Nestle Crunch but a zillion times better). Four servings? Who are they kidding. I ate the whole thing without regrets. Wolf's offers box chocolates, specialty size chocolates, caramel corn, candy bars, chews, pan-crafted chocolates, holiday chocolates (especially Valentine's Day and Christmas season), fudge, baskets, and more. The candy bars typically come it right about $3 - I personally think this is an amazing price for quality chocolate locally made. Custom boxes vary in size from 8-pieces to 48-pieces and you can create your own. Prices are fair - in fact, I'd say quite good. The people are friendly even during the holiday rush. The tradition is as rich as the chocolate and I'm just delighted that I can find them here in Indy not too far from my northeast side home. While some of the bigger names charge MUCH more, Wolf's simply makes wonderful chocolate at a fair price. I'm a big fan and highly recommend.

    The service when you walk in is fantastic and the chocolates are delicious. We were passing through…read morewhen we stumbled upon this gem and we are so happy we did! We got an assortment but it was 90% gone by the time I remembered to snap a photo. We will be back

    Photos
    Wolf's Fine Chocolates - Raspberry Truffles

    Raspberry Truffles

    Wolf's Fine Chocolates - Milk chocolate Santa with white chocolate and milk chocolate star suckers and a box of assorted chocolate.

    Milk chocolate Santa with white chocolate and milk chocolate star suckers and a box of assorted chocolate.

    Wolf's Fine Chocolates - Cooking Carmel

    See all

    Cooking Carmel

    Candy Kitchen - Exterior

    Candy Kitchen

    5.0(3 reviews)
    63.7 mi
    $

    One of the most unusual B & B's you'll ever stay at. A complete Soda Fountain from the 30's has…read morebeen completely restored. The whole place is filled with memorabilia from when the store operated. Brenda and Wayne are the most gracious Hostess and Host you'll ever meet. Wayne has stories that never ended about the history of the fountain and the town.

    Greenup is a small town in the heart of agricultural Illinois, and near where many of my wife's…read morerelatives lived, where her parents grew up. We've visited the area a few times since moving to central Illinois a few years ago, and we always make a point of having a meal at the Candy Kitchen. This place continues the Illinois (at least) tradition of locally owned establishments that specialized in making and serving ice cream and candy. Although I can't figure out why I haven't tried their candy, I have tried their ice cream and their (less sweet) food. On our latest trip, with a pile of relatives, we all stopped at this place, that my in-laws used to call "The Greek's". Since the time my in-laws were growing up, decades ago, the place has changed hands (at least once), but you can tell that the current owners care about quality and service. When we arrived, the place was hopping, but with only one server in evidence we were concerned about how long we'd be there. Within a few minutes, though, there were servers everywhere. Seems that when it was seen how busy the place was, everyone was called in to help. On this latest trip, I had a really good patty melt. My wife had a (huge) pork tenderloin sandwich. We all shared around pretty much all of the various fried stuff, including mushrooms, onion rings, and green beans (!!!). My wife swears by the black walnut ice cream, but I prefer some of their other flavors. They're all made there, and all a lot better than you'll find at the typical ice cream shop or supermarket carton. I'm sure we'll be back to the area and I'm sure we'll be back to Candy Kitchen. If I'm a good boy, maybe I'll get to have some candy next time!

    Photos
    Candy Kitchen - Ceiling

    Ceiling

    Candy Kitchen - Interior

    Interior

    Candy Kitchen - Burger

    See all

    Burger

    The Fudge Kettle - Gifts

    The Fudge Kettle

    4.6(17 reviews)
    43.6 mi

    When I was younger, this shopping strip at the corner of Dan Jones Road and U.S. 36 was one of the…read morevery few strips around this area. Yes, that means I'm old. However, I was feeling a bit nostalgic during this past weekend's trip to Putnam County and decided to stop and really check this retail strip out. I spied The Fudge kettle and knew I had to stop. The Fudge Kettle was started in 2020 - what a time to start a new business, eh? Despite the challenges, it thrived in a different location before locating to this spot in 2023. This is a former Jack's Donuts and it reportedly offered The Fudge Kettle about twice the size of its previous spot along with a variety of other perks. In case the name isn't obvious, The Fudge Kettle specializes in candy, fudge, local crafts, and a variety of other products. Despite being an older strip center, accessibility is pretty strong here with ample parking and curb cuts. The double-sided glass doors are pretty manageable. I found the interior to be nicely designed. I'm a fan of fudge and definitely had to try the fudge while here. Absolutely a delight. You can also get chocolates, freeze-dried candies, and some national brands like Pez, Necco Wafers, Buns, Boston Baked Beans, Rock Candy, Candy Cigarettes (Yes, I'm old enough to also remember when candy cigarettes were considered cool), and more. Local crafts include candles, keychains, t-shirts, wreaths and more. I'm a huge candle fan and I definitely prefer supporting local. So, this is a great find. I will note that new owners took over - I believe in 2023. It seems like there's some shifting going on and the website indicates that new products are coming soon. However, I liked what I saw here and the employee I dealt with was friendly and helpful. I found the prices to be fair, the quality to be amazing, and this just feels like a really welcoming spot. This shopping strip is a little more off the road than most. You really have to look to see The Fudge Kettle, however, it's definitely worth looking for and making a quick stop. Will I return? Absolutely.

    The lady who was working the counter today older lady must hate her job very very rude. I have…read morespent a lot of money at this store I will shop elsewhere

    Photos
    The Fudge Kettle - Variety of Candies

    Variety of Candies

    The Fudge Kettle - Travel Mugs

    Travel Mugs

    The Fudge Kettle - Shirts, gifts

    See all

    Shirts, gifts

    Hoosier Cupboard Candy and Snacks - Ice cream

    Hoosier Cupboard Candy and Snacks

    4.8(42 reviews)
    64.8 mi
    $

    What a hidden gem! All kinds of old Timey candy and some great ice cream. The people that own the…read moreshopper is nice it can be and they run it seven days a week. If you like sweets, you definitely need to check this

    This place will satisfy your craving for sweets. They have ice cream, sorbet, soda floats, sundaes,…read moremalts, chocolate-covered nuts and chocolate-covered pretzels, old-fashioned candy, taffy, fudge, gummies, licorice gum, root beer, sodas and a whole lots of other sugary treats. It's a candy and snack joint! You will definitely find something for everyone here. Hoosier Cupboard is located in downtown Franklin, in a cute little house that also looks like a train depot. Across the way is some sort of train thing, so I'm sensing a theme. My children got an ice cream cone (Blue Moon) and a scoop of chocolate ice cream in a cup. They have kids' sizes, which is appreciated. I am not an ice cream person, so I got two hand-dipped peanut butter cups, one for each hand: one milk chocolate, and the other dark chocolate. Both were delicious! We ate our treats at a table on the outdoor patio. There is lots of outdoor seating, and zero indoor seating. So, your options are to sit outside or get your goodies to go. The people who work here are polite and patient, which is also appreciated. You know how it goes when you visit a sweets shop with kids -- they can't make up their mind about what they want. But the people behind the counter were very kind and waited with the utmost patience while my children made their decision about which ice cream flavor to choose.

    Photos
    Hoosier Cupboard Candy and Snacks - Sizes

    Sizes

    Hoosier Cupboard Candy and Snacks - Hoosier Cupboard

    Hoosier Cupboard

    Hoosier Cupboard Candy and Snacks - Candy shop

    See all

    Candy shop

    McCord Candies - The Swedish Mix is to die for!

    McCord Candies

    3.6(82 reviews)
    46.5 mi
    $

    **MY EXPERIENCE**…read more Stepping into McCourt's Candies feels like a nostalgic journey to simpler times. The atmosphere is rich with history, reminiscent of a bygone era, where each corner tells a story. The store is a treasure trove of exquisite chocolates and candies from around the globe, offering something for every palate. You can practically taste the charm of a bygone era as you explore the selection. The soda fountain bar adds an extra layer to the experience, with sundaes and drinks crafted to perfection. It's a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in a classic treat. Locals and tourists alike have found a beloved haven here, cementing McCourt's as a cornerstone of Lafayette's Main Street. This isn't just a store; it's a vibrant piece of history. Whether you're a local or passing through, McCourt's offers an unforgettable experience that captures the essence of both nostalgia and modernity. I will be back! **HISTORY & CONTEXT** McCourt's Candies has been a staple in Lafayette, Indiana, since its inception. Established in the early 20th century, it has become a symbol of the town's rich heritage. Over the decades, McCourt's has evolved while maintaining its core identity--a place where generations have gathered to savor unique sweets and beverages. The store's continuous presence on Main Street underscores its significance as an anchor for the community. The establishment reflects the spirit of innovation and tradition, offering a blend of classic charm and modern convenience. Its commitment to quality and variety ensures that visitors experience not just a treat, but a piece of history. McCourt's Candies stands as a testament to the enduring allure of its offerings and its place in the heart of Lafayette. I will be back!

    Overall a cute spot for locally made candy (mostly) and Other little things…read more A bit pricy for somethings, but not terrible. Came in for their annual candy Cane making class, where you see how they make their Candy cane's, then you are given a small piece of the candy to make your own "creation", which is neat.

    Photos
    McCord Candies - Vintage items

    Vintage items

    McCord Candies - Lovely chocolates

    Lovely chocolates

    McCord Candies - Iconic corner

    See all

    Iconic corner

    Peachey's Amish Store - herbsandspices - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...