Ordered a few sandwiches and sides to go. We got chicken salad, Italian trio, and red skin potato salad. I also got a larger bag of chips. The total was $20 which is a steal right now. This is a great option for something quick that isn't fast food. read more

A hidden stop along our route for the day. Here you'll find various fresh meats and sauces as well as local favorites. Everyone was friendly. We ordered chicken and dumplings which were very good and reminded me of a soup I had as a child. There is a seating area separate from the meat shop and it's a quiet spot to just catch your breath. read more

See all

Always enjoy going in and getting great fresh meat Lunch sandwich are some of the best around When they do the cookouts on Thursday's it's great read more

Great meats, excellent service, an old style butcher shop feel to it. Staff is friendly and helpful. We Have always very much enjoy the meats we have bought from them. read more

Always fresh, always friendly and fast. I go in there for lunch often. Look for their Grill Out Thursdays in the summer - it'd often FREE, paid by another local business in the area. read more

The sandwiches were second to none -Excellent! Great root beer -XXX root beer (wow) The staff was extremely friendly and very informative regarding the sandwiches, especially the wheat berry bread!! Thank you, Charlie read more

This business is a combo of small market, butcher shop, and deli with dine in seating. The west end of the shop is devoted to a seating area while the east end is filled with displays of local products including canned items (jellies etc.) and candies. They also have some fresh bread and baked items. The left side of the market has the meats and cheeses available to order. They had several folks working behind the counter to be able to keep up with the customers. I had already eaten before stopping in here to shop, so I passed on getting a sandwich or soup. I find it quite ingenious to offer lunch meals as a way to supplement the market when a lot of folks don't have the devices necessary to keep meats fresh in their offices if they shop at lunch. Maybe seeing the counters full of great looking options may bring them back for a purchase before dinner. Review #3628 read more

See all

Great small specialty food & meat market in Greencastle - excellent assortment of fun food n beverages esp deli and meats. Grabbed some triple dipped pumpkin spice flavored malted milk balls- yum! read more

Myers' Market - Triple dipped pumpkin spice malted milk balls- yum! - Meat Shops Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

Nice place to grab a well made sandwich. We stopped in for lunch today and the staff were very attentive and quick. The fire smoked ham was on special and it was delicious. We also had a pastrami sandwich it that was also great. We also picked up a few groceries, there is a small selection but it was quality stuff. The meats looked great but we could pick any up as we were on the road. read more

One of the best places in town. The sandwiches are great and the food quality is excellent. Staff is always supper friendly.

A small market that carries a variety of specialty and locally made items. They are also a great place to stop in for lunch. You can carry out or they have a dining area. Order at the counter, they have a check list to fill out to customize your sandwich order. I highly recommend their Fried Chicken salad sandwich, it's made with fried chicken lunch meat mixed with mayo, craisins and cashews, I recommend pairing it with their wheat berry bread. They also offer a variety of other sandwich options, sides, and drinks, be sure to check out their soup specials. On Wednesdays they offer a specialty sandwich that varies each week and during the summer months, they have a cookout on Thursdays. read more

Myers' Market - Chicken salad with red pepper gouda soup - Meat Shops Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

One of the best butcher shops I've ever been to, that also sells soup, salads, and sandwiches. They truly have it all. The best bacon in the city, and their pork steaks are magnificent! There's always great service with a smile and a place is super clean. They carry everything from homemade salsa to fresh produce. Their ground beef is the best! Every meat I have purchased from here from their bratwursts to their Ribeyes are top quality. Now I want to fire up my grill and head on over for some pork steaks and fresh veggies! read more

If I lived in Greencastle I'd be here a few times a week to buy all my meat. I was recently visiting family in Greencastle and they had to make a stop here to get meat for grilling. This is like the butcher shop my grandparents used when I was a child. Beautiful case filled with all kinds of meat. It just so happened to be a Thursday and that's the day they grill outside in the warm months. The special that day was a pork chop sandwich. Hmmm, I never heard of a pork chop sandwich so we decided to give them a try. I thought it would probably be pulled pork, but no it was a real boneless pork chop on a bun. It was probably the best pork chop I ever tasted. I believe they smoked it, it was so tender and moist we didn't even need any condiments on it. We also got bratwurst-regular and apple. We grilled them and they were also delicious!! read more

The meat is good. Best deli meat in town. It is just a shame they don't have someone in there who knows how to slice it. I like my pastrami shaved, they chip it. I like my bologna sliced for a sandwich, medium, they shave it. I would buy allot more if someone worked in deli, and knew how to slice the meat as you order it. read more

Great fresh sandwiches and unique treats from various Indiana companies. Limited seating if you're planning to eat there.

Everything about Myers' Market is wonderful--service, food quality, personalized orders, atmosphere. Greencastle is fortunate to have this business as they also donate/sponsor throughout the community. read more

Good quality meats and great service. Staff is very courteous and professional. Very helpful with any questions I have.

Love this place. Very good quality meats. Love trying all the new bratwurst flavors that they come up with. Have not had a bad one yet!!

I love this place! Great meat market and very helpful staff! When I call my order in ahead of time they always have it ready for me to pick up! read more

The Best Sandwich I have ever had! Each ingredient was Top Shelf and very Fresh. The triple xxx root beer on tap was Exceptional and I cannot stop thinking about it lol. Go and you will be Gobsmacked guaranteed! Stay thirsty my friends read more

The wife and I love to support local! So while in greensburg for another reason we checked Yelp (obviously) for a mom and pop shop in town. I love the fact that you can get a combo! That's always a plus in my book! The meat, cheese and bread were so fresh!!! My sandwich was so good it left my mouth watering for more! Not only is it a great place to grab some lunch. It's also a full butcher shop! So get your fresh meat here!! They also have some great local finds!!! All in all very impressed! Oh and the decor takes me straight back to my great grandmas house!!! Love it. read more

Wonderful lunch spot! The food was great and I also want to add that the portions were great and the cost was very affordable! My oldest son loved the root beer slushee My husband and I plan to visit soon to pick up some fresh meat for our freezer. read more

It is so good and it is right bye my house I levae on spring st and their lunch meat sand wicks are good you can get a lot of meat read more

Myers' Market - Kenzie.G - Meat Shops Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

My husband and I were in the area and decided to try this 5 star gem. I am so glad we did! Upon entering, we saw lots of local chocolates and gummies, including peanut butter malt balls, which I haven't seen in years! We ended up ordering sandwiches. You write you name, bread/meat/cheese toppings on a sheet and hand it in. Your name is called when it's ready and you have the option of making your sandwich a combo (and you can upgrade your drink to a large for $.50 more). I love that they have Broad Ripple Chip Co. chips and my husband enjoyed the XXX Root Beer, which is offered bottled and on tap. My sandwich was divine! The mustard was grainy with great flavor, the habanero pepper jack cheese was great, the veggies were so fresh, and the roast beef was the best I've ever had anywhere. The seating is quaint, with indoor and outdoor options. They didn't have honey roasted turkey on the sheet but when my husband asked, they made an exception and were so nice about it (he doesn't like smoked/roasted turkey). He was also thrilled that you can add bacon, which he said was delicious. The bathroom is also VERY clean! Upon finishing, we appreciated the free drink refills for the drive home and I ordered roast beef to eat through the week. I mentioned the hour drive so they packed my meat on ice - so nice! Definitely check out this place if you're nearby...you'll be so glad you did! read more

Happened to pop in for a sandwich. They had a giant smoker set up outside selling pulled pork and brats. Every single employee was incredibly friendly. Inside they have sandwiches. I got a roast beef which was amazing! My daughter got the pulled pork, which she ate, but didn't rave about. We are from Texas and we were just there last week where she ate a ton of it, so it's not fair to compare! The store inside is adorable. They sell their meats, coffee, sweets, jams, sauces. The decor is homey with a nice seating area outside. It's absolutely worth stopping in. Either way, I would absolutely recommend a visit if you're passing through. read more

Myers' Market - Roast beef with habanero jack on a hoagie. Yum! Lots of meat. The mustard is amaaaaazing! - Meat Shops Near Me - Greencastle, Indiana

See all

Their fried chicken salad is amazing. I'm also a big fan of their Cuban pork sandwich.

Avoid ordering from their web page. I placed an order and after a few days I hadn't received a tracking number so I emailed them twice. No response. When I called them, I got an automated phone message saying the number was not in service. I gave up and ordered what I needed from another company, and then a week later I ended up getting my original order from Myers'. Now I wasted $60 and end up with a duplicated order because of their total lack of response. read more

I'm ashamed to say I've lived in the area for over 4 years and never went in here until recently. I follow MM on Facebook and they posted about a monthly bundle deal. It was essentially a ridiculous amount of pork products for an amazing price. I did math in my head and knew I would pay at least double at Kroger or elsewhere. I decided to go for it and went to pick it up in store. The staff were very friendly. I had emailed my order and they responded very promptly then called a few days later when it was ready for pickup. The inside is much larger than I thought. Amazing products inside (local honey) and of course a vast deli counter. They also take cards so that was a plus. So far we've eaten hickory smoked bacon which was spectacular and very flavorful, boneless chops which were great, ground pork which I seasoned with Italian spices for spaghetti, and I have a pork loin on deck for tomorrow. I'm blown away by the quality for the price! Shopping local pays off! I highly recommend Myers Market. Terrific place! We are lucky to have this in Greencastle. read more

My sister has told me all about this amazing place, including their fried chicken salad sandwich. I'm from Texas & am up here visiting her. We had to go back a second time to get another sandwich cause it is SOOOO good. Fresh bread & wonderful chicken salad. The customer service was great, too!! read more

This is just a review of the lunch/dinner menu, not the butcher/deli/market offerings. Meyers' consistently makes very good sandwiches at reasonable prices. The menu for sandwiches is pretty limited and only offers cold sandwiches (except for grill-out Thursdays during the warmer months; those lunches deserve five stars!). But Even though there are few choices, the sandwiches are fresh and taste excellent. You can get a combo with chips and a drink for less than $10 and it is plenty of food for most folks. Sometimes they have soup available as well but it tends toward the salty side. I wish they didn't use styrofoam but the XXX root beer is so good that I am willing to forgive them. Add a bag of locally-made chocolate covered caramels or malted milk candies to your order... You won't regret it! read more

My favorite play to get a quick lunch near my office. Fast, good, and consistent. The team always makes you feel welcomed.

This was my first experience at Myer's Market and it didn't leave an everlasting impression. The staff were friendly but were more interested in themselves and their conversations than being helpful to a first time patron. Upon arrival here I had very high expectations as the yelp rating was on average a 4.5 stars and some random woman in the parking lot told me I wouldn't be disappointed. I wasn't completely disappointed but I don't think I'll be back either. I like concept deli + market. Tons of options for a low price. The market was pretty sweet with artisan finds! read more

Our first visit was today. Deliciously stacked up sandwiches and friendly helpful staff behind counter. Many drink choices and fresh dipped candies & chocolate treats to munch on during the rest of our errands. read more

This place is awesome! The deli is good, get a sandwich with chips and a drink or half sandwich and cup of soup and a drink for around $5. The main reason to go here though for the cuts of meat, which are fantastic! Most are from local farmers, and you can talk with these farmers to find out what antibiotics (if any) are used for the raising of the livestock. They do not add water or anything to the meats for appearance, and the meats are tender and the taste is so good! They cut the meats there in house so you can request cuts, but they have such a selection that there is really no need to. The prices are perfect too. There are Indiana products (syrup, jellies and jams, spice rubs, etc) that is available, and produce too. read more

Great for lunch. Like it when they have the grilling out days. We also purchase our meat for home, and it is always fresh. The Cuban pork is my personal favorite. My husband is a fan of the fried chicken salad. read more

Best place in Greencastle for fresh meats and a nice healthy lunch! Dont miss out in the broccoli and cheese soup if it's available and Thursday grill outs are the best during the warmer season. read more

I don't eat at the restaurant often but I purchase meats from here all the time. I. Love. This. Place! Everything is local within a 100 mile radius I believe. They have fresh fish, nearly any cut of meat you can think of frozen or fresh, the best brats money can buy and the best bacon money can buy, fresh in season veggies, honey, chocolate, breads, eggs.. I never leave here disappointed with a purchase. I have a freezer full of their meats! The staff is friendly and they are quick and attentive! The atmosphere is what you would expect for a cute market. As far as the restaurant goes, fantastic food and great service. Highly recommend! read more

I only gave 5 stars because we cant give 10. You can buy fresh meat, veggies or shop their small gift shop. Grab a sandwich or a salad and grab a seat in their dine in area. A+ read more

My friend brought different kinds of sandwiches as well as potato soup for lunch. I loved the bread they use. The chicken salad and deli meat in Sandwich were good! Looking forward to visiting the store next time! read more

Had lunch. The weather was bad so the only complaint is the soup ran out. They were making more but I really wanted the soup & 1/2 sandwich. This is a neighborhood market. The staff is friendly & food is good. read more