Pecan Penny's

3.9 (361 reviews)

ModerateBarbeque, Cocktail Bars, American

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Pecan Penny's Photos

Pecan Penny's - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - Corn bread, collard greens, chicken wings and brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - Brisket, wings, corn bread, greens - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

+508

Business Info

Health Information

View Health Score

Pecan Penny's menu photos

See all

PECAN PENNY'S ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

64 Photos

Outside

58 Photos

Hipster

Casual

Trendy

Moderate noise

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pecan Penny's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Meika G N.

Hidden gem downtown they don't get the recognition they deserve! Service was great and friendly the restaurant is so nice love the patio and they are dog friendly ! Food variety is so good

Laura F.

Son was home and wanted to go downtown for dinner. We intially started out around the corner at Little Palace but we wanted BBQ and remembered Penny's was close by. So glad we did! I have been here many times but never at night. At night, the patio is amazing. Twinkle lights. Comfortable tables that seat at least six. They have fun music playing at just the right level. They also have patio games: jumbo jenga and two sets of corn hole to play. Plus, the patio is very dog friendly. I was completely in my element and was having so much fun there. Food, as usual, is amazing. Its consistently this way. I recommend the Penny salad if you like beets. Mmmm They use cornbread for croutons and you can add protein for a reasonable up charge. Get dressing on side if you don't like it poured onto your greens heavily. The guys ordered burgers. Fries were delicious and plentiful. When the burgers came out they both said "oh, these look small" but as they ate them they realized they were filling and a perfect size. They each said they would order them again. They didnt leave hungry at all. Our server, Echo, was so nice. There wasn't anything she could have done better. So glad we came. We will be back. Highly recommend.

Left: Pork It, Collard Greens, Cheesy Grits Middle: Half Poutine Fries, Chi-Town Dog Right: Chicago Beef, Potato Salad

Demetrius B.

When I picked up my takeout order, my first thought was, "this would be a fun place to have a few drinks." They had cheap beer, shot and cocktail specials reminiscent of a campus bar, and the patio/open windows have Sunday Funday written all over it. But those good vibes didn't follow the food home. Everything tasted fine, but that's about as far as I will go. The main portions were sizable, but the sides were on the small side. I would give the food another chance but definitely onsite with a beverage in hand.

Sampler Platter: 3 meats (pulled pork, chicken, and brisket), greens, baked beans, and Texas toast.

Niccole A.

It was our first time visiting Pecan Penny's. We had heard good things + figured we'd give it a try. If I can be honest, the parking is terrible because of their location. I would not go on any other day but Sunday, which is the day we went. The atmosphere was good but they kept the front door wide open, which allowed too many flies in the dining area. I don't particularly care for eating with a bunch of flies all around me competing for my food. Our waiter was THE BEST!! He was friendly, patient, kind, + funny. We tried the "DOWNTOWN SAMPLER" which consists of ¼ Beef Brisket, ¼ Pulled Pork, ¼ Chicken, Texas toast + 2 sides. The greens were the best + seasoned great! The baked beans were good; creamy with a little spicy kick, I personally prefer sweet + creamy. We also got to try a free sample of their Mac + Cheese. Very bland + not baked. I was disappointed cause I'm a big Mac + Cheese girl. I could tell If they would have added some additional types of cheese + baked it, it would have been really good. Now onto the MEATS!!! This is where I found out that I am not a fan of their smoked barbecue at all. All their meat is made with a dry-rub and a "signature spice" + cooked slow over pecan and oak wood. It was something about the signature spice + the way they cook it, that I did NOT enjoy. Everyone's taste buds are different. They had four signature wet sauces on the table that you could add to your meat for flavor. I personally did not like any of them and I'm not sure why. Desserts!!! Our absolute FAVORITE was The Funnel Cake Fries!!! They were piping hot, fresh, + so sweet + good! We couldn't get enough of those! Overall, I would definitely visit Pecan Penny's again, but I would have to switch it up + try their signature hot dogs, a burger, a waffle fry, pretzel sticks, and definitely the The Funnel Cake Straws again. Go ahead and + give them a try + tell 'em Nicci sent ya!

Andrew H.

Great BBQ but stingy portions. I got: wings, collard greens, and brisket. All were very good! While they do serve up brisket (a Texas BBQ staple), the pecan-based name and the collard greens side tells me this place skews "Southern BBQ" which...is my favorite kind of BBQ. This place also has a lovely indoor/outdoor ambiance, complete with firepit. Decent selection of beers on tap too, usually a big weak-point of BBQ joints.

Heithem E.

Came in for a quick meal before a show. Good bbq place with nice beers and cocktails. I had smoked wings with dry rub and a brisket Philly. The wings were medium smoky and not overdone (they can get mushy if they're over-smoked). The brisket Philly was very good - the brisket was smoky and extremely tender! They have a fun feature - a pickle soaked in Koolaid - the flavor changes weekly (?). I had a pickle soaked in cherry koolaid - it was like a gherkin but not as sweet or spicy. Service was excellent - one server was managing the dining room and the bar that evening and was able to come around frequently . It was pretty quiet that night I was there.

Ang H.

Great find with a nice outdoor space that's family friendly. The brisket was the best I've had, perfectly smoked! The onion rings were delicious too, the batter was kind of buttery. Highly recommend!

John C.

An industrial, modern BBQ restaurant and bar in downtown Columbus. A bit of off street parking and on street parking. Indoor bar and mostly bar height table seating, outside seating as well. There was at least one child with her family dining. And one dog outside on patio with its family. I had the brisket Philly sandwich which was fresh and very good! A side of uninspired potato salad. They have Coke products, a plus for me. The bar was making Sunday special Mimosas and other drinks that looked good. Service was prompt, efficient, and pleasantly attentive. I tried here on a recommendation and would have no reservations about coming again. But, I doubt it will become a regular for this older fellow.

Cristina P.

Pecan Penny's is a good place to just chill with friends, It's very casual as if you are hanging out at a bbq in the park . There are outdoor games and you can bring in board games to play if you like. Servers are friendly. This time l stopped in for Burger and Beer week- the featured burger was Brisket Chili Burger it had brisket patty with chili and cheese- the burger was a bit of a disappointment - the chili left bun mushy and l had to add lots of bbq to get the flavor. I would definitely come back to Pecan Penny's as l typically like the food and burgers- - but l should have just went with one the normal burgers (which l know is cooked exactly the way l like). This special gave me more of a patty melt taste than the beef burger taste.

Julia G.

The food here was fine! The fries were good, especially with the different barbecue sauces. The Kramer was a solid burger, the smoked chicken sandwhich was just ok. Didn't give us pickles despite the menu saying it comes with fries and a pickle. Service was borderline not acceptable. Only a few tables at the restaurant and waited 25 minutes before i went inside and had to ask for the check because nobody was coming back to give it to us.

Waffle fries because I already crushed the pork sandwich

Jason H.

Service was excellent. Ordered to go food and had a couple of beers. Ordered a mashed potato bowl with pulled pork, baked beans, and queso. Instead, I got a Mac and cheese bowl with croutons, brisket, cole slaw, and I don't know what else is in here. Not even close guys.

J J.

Whenever I'm in the Columbus area, I always find my way here. Always a solid choice. The brisket is definitely the star here they are always consistent with the flavor and cook! This is one spot I don't have to hope. I'm going to get some good brisket it's always legit. You definitely want to save room for deserts they got that down, too. The banana pudding is my thing! Staff is always super cool. I even got pointed in the right direction of a liquor store with a good selection of bourbon. Parking is minimal, but with being downtown, I'm glad they have some parking on premises. Definitely would recommend at least one trip there. The vibe is cool. Every time I've been in the music playlist always hit!

Joey H.

To the lonely man who was recently divorced, who keeps coming in for the barbecue, but maybe for human connection too: The ginger waitress in the yoga pants, the one who smiles a lot, talks with you, laughs with you, and kinda flirts with you while you give her your business card -- you know, the one who is working hard to raise the energy? She makes fun of you when you leave. After you provide her such a large tip on your check, she laughs about how men are so simple to get interested in her until she sometimes reveals to them the fact that she's pregnant and has a boyfriend. Her friends laugh with her as she diminishes you behind your back for being divorced, lonely, and frequently returning. You, sir, have probably had an incredible career. You made it further in marriage than many do. Some of us single men have reasons why we shouldn't take that leap into marriage yet. And now that you are alone after working throughout your life to leap for commitment and happiness -- from one man to another, I believe you still deserve happiness. And even though the barbecue at Pecan Penny's is amazing, you're not going to find happiness with a woman who makes fun of you after you seek her attention, tip her noticeably well, and step out. You did nothing wrong here to deserve being made fun of by her and her friends in front of other customers, but since we're being real -- you're not going to find what you're looking for at this bar. I highly recommend travel. You talked about Spain today. Try Latin America or South America. There are warm places that will naturally and authentically support your energy, where a woman has real empathy and a real heart for you. Find the authentic kindness. It exists. There is so much beauty out there, and you'll find a woman who values how you work and who you are as a man despite past flaws. Pecan Penny's bar is not the place where you're going to find that kind of woman. If it was, there would be a line around the corner for the amazing barbecue and authentic friendship. You're being used and diminished. This bar is not a good place to be alone. 3/12 Update: My friend went to Pecan Penny's. He sat down to eat and invited me over. I told him I wasn't ready to go back. He mentioned this review to the bartender, and the bartender told him to go to The Walrus (kicked him out). 3/19 Update: Heather, manager of Pecan Penny's texted me and told me this review is crazy. She said she is going to request Google to review it (photo attached). I don't know why Google would remove this review, when it is honest. Realizing I'll never be going back to this restaurant now, I think about how I supported Pecan Penny's for years (thousands of dollars of purchases during the pandemic when we ran Hidden Drive-In events in Downtown Columbus). I don't regret those times of support. I just notice how much has changed in the culture of this restaurant and maybe that is a reflection of downtown, or Columbus, or the country -- but I try not to let myself go that far. Kindness to others must continue on, or what's the point of cooking for them, serving them, having them as customers and inviting them to choose your restaurant to consume, rest, and relax in?

Dining area cabinets and hope my silverware didn't come from here.

See all

Jim S.

5 years ago

Excellent food! Any of the meets are done perfectly with great flavor. Their sides are less flavorful however still edible. Eating at the restaurant is much preferred rather than delivery. When in person you can get a taste of their desserts! They don't allow delivery of desserts. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nathaniel R.

5 years ago

I love BBQ, and Pecan Pennys has the best wings & ribs in Columbus, hands down! I have spent an irresponsible amount of money at PPs, and have zero complaints about the food! Always quick, hot & delicious! Unfortunately, I have to give 3-star because of customer service (would be a 2-star if not for the great food). Now, this does not apply to all the staff, as I have had great service from certain staff members, but unfortunately the poor service out-weighs the good. Certain staff are snobby, condescending & rude - really for no reason as I am very easy-going, easy to please & not quick to complain. I find the restaurant to rarely to be short-staffed, and the staff doesn't seem to be regularly overwhelmed, giving no justification for poor customer service. I regularly attempt to call in for pick-up in the evenings on my way home from work and often get put on hold, and my call is never taken, and I'm forced to eat elsewhere. Likewise, I call in and the line is busy for several minutes. My latest experience, I called-in with about 20 min until I arrive; I was placed on hold, after 5 min I hung up to call back; for the remaining 15 min drive to PPs, the phone was busy as no one had hung up the phone from my initial call. Once I arrived, I informed a staff member (who has worked here for a while) of my wait, and that this had happen multiple times before. He offered no apology or genuine interest in my complaint, and simply proceeded to take my order - of which I was happy to give & wait for for 10 min to get my food. Wish I could leave a better review because the food is so good - however, when staff are not interested in feedback from loyal customers, and show no signs of bettering themselves it will effect your online presence, and future business. I will order from PPs again, probably for many years to come, but would sure like to see some improvements with the staff in the service area. 5-STARS & A HUGE SHOUT-OUT TO CHEFS & KITCHEN STAFF! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Iris T.

112

7 years ago

I got a brisket sandwich, mac and cheese, and banana pudding. The sandwich was great. The brisket was pretty tender. The bbq sauces were good too. The mac and cheese was ok...nothing over the top. The banana pudding was horrible. I've never had worse banana pudding. It tasted like hospital pudding. read more

Pecan Penny's - Banana Pudding - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Logan I.

8 years ago

My wife and I recently visited Pecan Penny's for a couple drinks and sampled some of the food as well. We sat at the bar and ordered the smoked nuts and pickled avocado to accompany our beers. We didn't come with a huge appetite but after an hour of watching everyone else eat we decided to order some meat. The brisket was well executed (tender and juicy but not overcooked) and a great vessel to sample the amazing sauces that come with the BBQ. Next, we tried a quarter chicken which was some of the best smoked chicken I have ever tasted and could easily pass without sauce. If you must, try the white sauce on the chicken. I'm really looking forward to coming back with a bigger appetite and sampling some more of the BBQ. There are several other BBQ restaurants in Columbus but I see myself coming here the most as it has a great vibe, really good food and a full service bar. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Lindsay J.

145

8 years ago

SMALL PORTIONS & OVERPRICED I was really excited about this place, but my experiences were extremely disappointing. Firstly, I popped in opening weekend. I ordered wings, a slab of ribs, large order of pork and three large sides (mac 'n cheese, greens and hush puppies). My total was $67.50. The portion sizes were so incredibly small--it's laughable. For instance, the $7 large side of hush puppies included ONLY FIVE HUSH PUPPIES. And the large pork was a scoop--at best. The pics are self explanatory and display just how small the portion sizes are. BBQ is a type of food one expects to get hefty portion sizes, especially when one is paying $20+ per plate. I gave the place a second chance last night. I felt maybe the single meals (which are non existent--everything is a la carte) would fare better. Turns out that's a joke as well. The cashier advised the "downtown sampler" would serve two . Even considering my low expectations, it was even more laughable than the first experience. We paid $23.66 for what you see pictured. Overall, the food itself is good--not great; I have impeccable taste in BBQ, because I grew up in BBQ-rich city. The meat was tender...I'd say the pork was the best of the 4 meats I've tried. The sides were mediocre...baked beans were the best of the 5 side I've tried. The sauce selection (they have six) is incredible! The orders come with free Texas toast that should be free, because it's nothing to write home about. I didn't bother with cocktails or dessert, so I can't speak on that. The service was okay--I ordered takeout the first time and dined in the second. Uhhhh, what else? The atmosphere of the patio is really dope, so if you're looking for a lite bite when you're out on a Friday night--this is a perfect place, because that's all you're going to get. read more

Pecan Penny's - Good wings! - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - These are $7 large sides! Salty greens, I make better Mac on an off day, 5 hush puppies for $7. - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - Great sauces! - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - $23.66 #howsway - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - How the scoop of pork constitute as a large portion, I don't know. - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Business owner information

Carla D.

Lindsay,…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Greg W.

Elite 18

174

218

237

8 years ago

The brisket, the brisket, GET THE BRISKET! I can't stress it enough; the brisket is incredible! Now, with that out of the way, I'll assume you're reading the rest of this while gnawing a mouthful of brisket (get the fatty cut if given the option). It's a little similar to how City BBQ is run, in that you walk in to the front counter and order, then pick out a table. Pricing is pretty reasonable too. One side that I didn't see on the menu is the smoked pecans. Get them! They are damned good, and you get a lot of them. If there's 2 or 3 of you, consider the Downtown Sampler. All of the meats are good, and you get to grab a couple of their delicious sides too. When it comes to sides, I've tried them all except the cucumber salad and the coleslaw. The collard greens are good, and I don't typically like collard greens. There are jalapenos in the hush puppies, but they aren't spicy; just a bit tangy. The only downside is the parking situation. Don't try to park in one of the surrounding lots; none of them belong to the restaurant! You need to find a spot on the street nearby, so you don't get towed. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mallory B.

4 years ago

The BBQ bowl and Pork It sandwich were wonderful. Friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Athina W.

Elite 21

214

6 years ago

Came here for brunch a few times. Great service, love the bottomless mimosas they offer. For $20 it's definitely a great deal! I wish the brunch food was a little better, but the smoked chicken wings are amazing! read more

Business owner information

Krista S.

Thank you do mich Athina, we would move to hear what we can do to…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Gee M.

5 years ago

I wanted to really like this place, but I didn't. BBQ is bland, fatty and over priced. Brisket was nasty. Wow, missing Austin TX read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bob D.

Elite 19

153

208

7 years ago

Big fan of the wings - great smoked flavor and very crisp. Enjoyed the various sauces available. The waffle fries were a big hit unexpectedly. Chips and guacamole fresh and good. Only knock was that lunch service a little slow. Will be back for sure. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

John C.

5 years ago

Half a ear of corn for $4.00 dollars REALLY!! Didn't even have butter on it. I also got rib tips and I might as well been chewing gum. read more

Pecan Penny's - Half a ear of corn $4.00 dollars REALLY!! - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Business owner information

Maritt V.

This is not the correct portion size for this price, I’m really sorry…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher B.

5 years ago

Don't get it delivered. That cheap out on your sides. Decent ribs. I'm guessing they boil them before smoking them. Too bad. I was excited about ordering from here. I only got a teaspoon of sauce for my ribs and got two tablespoons of Mac for $6.50. Total bummer. Thanks for the overpriced sort of okay tasting bbq. read more

Pecan Penny's - This is about one teaspoon of sauce for my half rack of ribs. - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - This is about two dollars worth of Mac snd cheese that I paid $6.50 for. - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle N.

8 years ago

Checked out this place a week ago for lunch. Delicious BBQ, their coleslaw was great. My friend got the wings and they were delicious, and I got the brisket. They have about six sauces you can try. Word of advice though... DONT Park in any parking lots near it, you will be towed. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shelly Z.

Elite 21

107

234

8 years ago

We love BBQ and were in the area so we decided to try this place! First of all, customer service is fantastic!! They go above and beyond and we really appreciate that. The food: we got the sampler. The chicken was my favorite. It is deep fried and so, so good. Brisket and pulled pork were good. Collard greens were good like everyone else said, but we actually like another local BBQ place's better, Mac and cheese was alright, and the hush puppies were really good. We also finished our meal with a pecan pie. Personally, I didn't care for it, but my husband and son did. Overall, we enjoyed it and will support any business that has such astounding customer service! read more

Business owner information

Krista S.

Shelly,…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Curt M.

4 years ago

Meats are very good. Sides are okay, but not outstanding. (YELP wants more, but that's all I have to say. )

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Samantha S.

4 years ago

Your new waitress Share, is a whole vibe and took care of me very well. The food is good, especially the cheesy grits, and filled me up quick. Nice selection of drinks too for a hot day sitting in the nice sun on the patio! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher M.

295

8 years ago

What a treat late on a Sunday!!! These collards are legit, ya'll....they took me back home to the Valley! Mac 'n cheese is creamy dreamy....but the wings....so crispy on the outside and soops juicy on the inside....and all the sauces!!!! Mmmmm!!!!! Little surprises too with a pickled melange and a sturdy piece of Texas Toast! Add all that to a kicking atmosphere and chill staff, and it is a must! Great addition to the downtown scene!!!!!.......But really....the collards!!! :) read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Olivia B.

5 years ago

There weren't many places open in the short north today after the doo-dah parade , so we ended up at Pecan Penny's. We had the chicken and waffles, brisket poutine, peach cobbler and pecan pie and a kool-aid pickle. The brisket poutine and pecan pie was the best I ever had. Glad we stopped read more

Pecan Penny's - Chicken and waffle, kool aid pickle - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - Brisket poutine - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pecan Penny's - Pecan Pie , peach cobbler - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Georgi S.

5 years ago

The server didn't know the menu, had a poor attitude and took forever. Bottomless mimosas where you literally pour your own shouldn't take 30 minutes to bring to the table. I ordered the chicken and waffles and I got maybe a quarter of a waffle and the chicken was dry. I understand restaurants are struggling post-COVID BUT your attitude makes all the difference. read more

Pecan Penny's - Sad chicken and waffles - Barbeque Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Claudia C.

8 years ago

My husband & I went for my birthday. Incredible Wings, big, juicy, & full of flavor. No sauce needed! Burnt Brisket Tips, Amazing flavor, saucy, & perfect. Brisket, seriously one of the best! Tender and flavorful! I lived in Texas for 6 years & never liked brisket. This changed! We ordered the cole slaw & mac & cheese. The slaw tasted exactly like my slaw. A+ The mac & cheese was on the dry side but very good. The surprise of the meal was the Pickled Avocado! WOW what a taste bud awakening experience! So GOOD! We had a couple of beers from local breweries. We will be back for the cocktails & more menu items. I highly recommend this very open & airy place. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Regina M.

5 years ago

Food was great! 1st time visiting. Went because of burger week. Burger with egg was very very good. Fries were hot. Pork belly delicious. Drink was tasty. Benjamin very attentive and friendly. Will go back again!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Patch R.

172

6 years ago

The food and ambiance of the patio/live music were great, but I'm a growing boy and need BIGGER PORTIONS. Got the brisket, Mac and cheese and hush puppies and again, all of it was good, but I ended up walking to Mikeys for two slices once we were finished. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeff R.

Elite 26

113

219

682

8 years ago

I've gone twice now. The first time everything I ate (I had a sampler) was great. The 2nd time the brisket was dry, the baked beans were sweet and the cucumber salad had too much vinegar. I also felt the waiter was rude to my friend. She had asked what the beers were because only the breweries are listed on the menu and he responded "that's what I'm trying to tell you!" I basically seemed like he was telling her to shut up. Then after that he brought out 3 wrong beers for people at my table. I won't be going back. read more

Business owner information

Carla D.

It's very unfortunate that you experienced this from one of our staff…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Roberto R.

Elite 21

8 years ago

I'm someone who appreciates good barbecue, and you can definitely find it here. You can taste a personalized difference with their rubs and sauces that is perfect for someone who likes the occasional smoky meat. I got the half a brisket (picture is a few bites in) and it tasted great. The flavoring was there except it was a little dry. However, that left room to sample their unique sauces which were each tailored to different palates and great all around. Pluses: great downtown happy hour place and great atmosphere. Staff was attentive and courteous. Deltas: juicier brisket. Overall, I would go back, especially to dine and hangout on their patio. Highly recommend trying their smoked wings, which were phenomenal. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lamar T.

151

5 years ago

Came in to eat on 9/18/2021 food was subpar at best. Ribs were fatty and no flavor. BBQ sauces was aight. Would not recommend if you're into good bbq spots. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melissa H.

8 years ago

The location is convenient with plenty of street parking. IF it's a nice day, the restaurant is nice and spacious with the garage doors open. The process of ordering / eating is a bit odd. The bar is full service but the rest of the customers have to order up at the front. The food was great. The baby back ribs' meat fell off the bone, were juicy and delicious. The coleslaw and mac n cheese were also great. Half off drafts during Buckeye games. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Renee C.

3 years ago

Foods good, portions definitely leave much to be desired.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Yohanna H.

5 years ago

We we're visiting Columbus for the first time during Covid, and we wanted to find a restaurant with outdoor seating. Pecan Pennys had an outdoor patio with a fire pit with great music playing. The bbq was amazing! My kids even loved the food! Great customer service! Will definitely be our go to, the next time we are in town! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Fiona P.

6 years ago

I had a great experience here! Our server was great, attentive but not overly so. I was with a date so we didn't get to the menu right away but the server didn't seem to mind. We ordered koolaid pickles to try, because... why not?! They were different, and fun. I suggest trying them out. I ended up getting the brisket, and collard greens! Everything tasted awesome, and whatever BBQ sauce and hot sauce I got on the side was really good too. I loved that they had tons of out door seating, so I will definitely be back in warmer months! Great job. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dee C.

8 years ago

This is a solid 3. Not the best, not the worst. Pretty much stole City BBQ concept, except, not as good! Cute enough but nothing to write home about. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Roxy K.

7 years ago

Didn't get to try the food because we were never served. My boyfriend and I waited 10 mins and walked out because our waitress never took our order and was busy taking care of a family who looked wealthier than us. Edit in response to owner's comment: We went during the week, not on a Friday or Saturday. I also find it quite tacky that they used a negative review to advertise their drink specials. read more

Business owner information

Carla D.

Roxy,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daisy V.

5 years ago

I wish I had taken a picture of the delicious food- but it's literally in my belly right now. SO good! I ordered the smoked wings and half rack of ribs, with a side of cornbread, hush puppies, collard greens and a kool aide pickle. The wings were perfectly cooked and seasoned- I love sauces but these wings didn't even need them. The ribs were also great and pulled right off the bone. The collard greens were my favorite side and kool aide pickle was a fun novelty but I wouldn't order again. Overall I highly recommend trying this place. Ps I ordered online and the food was hot and well packaged when it arrived. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Harris W.

8 years ago

They are very new. Had the brisket, it was great. The chicken was good. Really loved the Mac&cheese and the greens. A bit disorganized. Looking forward to next time read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alan G.

6 years ago

Best patio in downtown Columbus and pleasantly attentive servers compared to other restaurants. Delicious food too!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tina A.

139

8 years ago

Fabulous BBQ! The smoked wings were awesome. The sample platter was so good. We loved the food and will be back. So glad we tried it-you should too! The service was great and everyone was very attentive. Our friends had the ribs they were also very good. Kool-Aid pickles sound strange but were pretty tasty. Nice bbq joint in downtown Columbus read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Crissy L.

127

8 years ago

The brisket is Phenomenal!! I mean juicy, flavorful, tender it just shreds apart. It's even good cold!(more on that later) The ribs are good I'll reccomend some sauce though as they're a bit dry. As far as service they are friendly and helpful. My food wasnt warm at all but I didnt want to give it back after I started eating the brisket (it's literally that good) my waitress still offered alternatives to assure I was satisfied and I appreciated it I dont like causing issues in restaurants cause I'm scared of what they'll do to my food. I will say that I'll never be nervous to voice a concern at pecan pennys read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

david d.

8 years ago

Went here with my kids earlier this summer. The food (had the sampler) was good but far from great. I'm certainly not a BBQ expert, but I think there are better options in Columbus. The atmosphere was pleasant and the patio is quite nice. Would come back to hang out and have a drink or two but wouldn't come here just for the food. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristin C.

Elite 17

597

8 years ago

I was a little hesitant to try Pecan Penny's considering my adoration with Legacy's BBQ. I wondered if I would be disappointed. However, Pecan's mostly stepped up to the plate. It is an order and sit sort of place which is in line with the BBQ spirit. Our initial impression was a little unpleasant as the hipster ringing up was having a terrible time with my credit card. He finally said, "Have you been having problems with it?" My husband quickly answered, "No, we have been using it all day." He switched registers and just as my husband started to hand him his credit card, it went through. (I usually don't have problems, although most places have chip readers now). Then, he asked if we wanted to leave the tab open which was kind of weird since we weren't getting any alcoholic drinks. Also, he had this big ordeal about how he wanted our credit card first so it could be under a name, not a number, but then he handed us numbers. My husband just got an irritable feeling from the whole drawn out exchange. Our food came out so fast we were a little flustered. Now, the food, it was very good. The brisket was slightly dry for the moist cut I requested. However, it was very flavorful and not grisly. I still prefer Legacy's brisket, though. The baked beans, baby back ribs, berry cobbler, collard greens, pickled veggies, though, were superb. Homemade sauces were good and varied. Cobbler needs ice cream, not whipped cream, coming from a real Southerner! People often came around asking if we were okay. The feeling overall was super hipster/trendy, not the typical down to earth BBQ. Sides are separate so it adds up. We weren't sure if they had draft but they had some nice local beers listed. So Penny's please just work on the checkout experience and the moisture of the brisket. And get ice cream for the cobbler. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carrie E.

4 years ago

Awesome food! Awesome service! Ordered the Chicken Sandy and cornbread. The pecan butter is amazing. Thanks Jokhi!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Angel L.

Elite 18

8 years ago

My husband and I had lunch here last week and I was disappointed. We ordered the smaller order of ribs and the sampler for 2 so that we could try a variety of foods and really get a good idea about the place. The ribs were cooked fairly well but there wasn't a lot of meat on them. The pulled pork and brisket were cooked nicely but didn't have a ton of seasoning. We tried several of the different sauces but found the labels to be confusing and thought they all tasted the same. They were all very runny and had too much of a vinegar flavor. The mac and cheese was okay but pretty dry. The hush puppies were not great on their own but were pretty good when dipped in the sauce that came with them. The bread was great. I'm glad we already tried a good portion of the menu already because I definitely don't expect to return. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 6 of 10

113 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43215
Downtown
Directions
(614) 826-0750
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.pecanpennys.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Pecan Penny's open?

Pecan Penny's opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Pecan Penny's close?

Pecan Penny's closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Pecan Penny's closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu, Sun 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Pecan Penny's take Bitcoin?

No, Pecan Penny's does not take Bitcoin.

Does Pecan Penny's take credit cards?

Yes, Pecan Penny's takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Pecan Penny's have catering options?

Yes, Pecan Penny's does have catering options.

Does Pecan Penny's have a drive thru?

No, Pecan Penny's does not have a drive thru.

Does Pecan Penny's have a happy hour?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has a happy hour.

Does Pecan Penny's serve alcohol?

Yes, Pecan Penny's serves alcohol. Full Bar

Services

Is Pecan Penny's by appointment only?

No, Pecan Penny's is not by appointment only.

Indoor Amenities

Does Pecan Penny's allow dogs?

No, Pecan Penny's does not allow dogs.

Does Pecan Penny's have TVs?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Pecan Penny's have bike parking?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has bike parking.

Does Pecan Penny's have outdoor seating?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has outdoor seating options.

Does Pecan Penny's have parking?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Pecan Penny's wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Pecan Penny's is wheelchair accessible.

Does Pecan Penny's allow outdoor smoking?

No, Pecan Penny's does not allow outdoor smoking.

Does Pecan Penny's have free WiFi?

Yes, Pecan Penny's has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Central Texas-style smoked BBQ, burgers, specialties, house-made sides & snacks, served with local beers & craft cocktails in vibrant downtown Columbus. Two large patios with fire pits.

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Pecan Penny's

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

The Alibi Bourbon and Cocktail Lounge

I really, really, really love the drink menu of the Alibi. Like, a lot. Their visual chart is a…read moregodsend for cocktail explorers, and all of the drinks came out delicious and exactly as described. It's so creative, and the drinks are really the stellar stand out here. However, the atmosphere of those drinks is what gives me pause when thinking about coming back. The limited table situation, tiny cramped space, and loud music means that it doesn't feel particularly relaxing. People are constantly brushing up against you (even at 5PM), and holding a conversation at a normal distance is nearly impossible. NOTE: This place is covered in dust. No shade to the ownership as it doesn't appear to be anywhere near food prep areas (it's on the decor, on/around shelving, all over the faux plants, etc.), but if you're someone who's sensitive to dust, this is probably not a good fit. PROS: -I loooooooove how they've done their drink menu. As someone who is still exploring the potential of cocktails, their nerdy "chart" that places all of their drinks on a sweet/bitter and alcohol-forward/approachable visual chart is SUCH a help. As such, everything I ordered was absolutely amazing for me. I knew exactly what to expect from a drink because of its position on the chart, and it delivered. -Their drinks are really unique. Aqua faba? Fat washed alcohols? Lollipops or toasted marshmallows as garnishes? Super cool. Don't let some of the weirder descriptions creep you out of trying them. -All of their drinks were delicious. Everything I ordered was exactly as described. I often go places where the taste is barely related to its namesake, but they were entirely on-point here. CONS: -I'm not sure if someone called off that night as other reviewers are in love with the service, but our service was really really slow. No real rapport with the staff; just stating the name of a drink as they rushed past and then they were off to try to clean a table or take someone else's order. The drinks they made were great, but this isn't somewhere we'd go if we were in a hurry. -The pictures do not accurately convey how small this place is. Like, it's small. I'd guess less than 1000 square feet. My apartment is bigger by a lot. This isn't necessarily an issue, but it means people pile up quickly as they wait for seating (there's like 4/5 tables and then bar seating). The human walkways are small enough that the bartenders and other guests will brush against you a lot - even while seated. -I get the vibe they were going for here, but with the smaller space, I think a lot of the potential decor options had to "go" in order to fit more humans. It's giving me hardcore The Hearth Room (in Cincinnati) vibes, and I think it could honestly pull it off if it simply had more space. The "relaxed, sophisticated bourbon bar" doesn't quite come through as well when things are so focused on simply fitting in more bodies. -It's loud AF. Like, really, really loud. Between all the people and the blasting pop music, it required leaning into someone's ear in order to speak at normal volumes. We'd regularly have to pause the conversation if something in the music was building to a drop. This is not a place I'd take someone I wasn't very very comfortable with because it really requires being in someone's space to talk. -There's a single all-gender toilet here for everyone in the establishment. It's basically a revolving door of people in and out of it. The door auto-closes, however, so it's really difficult to figure out if it's open or not. There was usually a queue of people waiting in front of the door.

I never leave Alibi disappointed. They always have such a creative menu with something for…read moreeveryone. It always amazes me how quickly they crank out such creative drinks. I'm sure some of them are batched, but they don't taste like they are. Service was excellent, as always. Endlessly knowledgeable. Small place, but never feels crowded even when full.

Photos

Fresh, handmade seasonal cocktails

Smoked old fashioned (Buffalo Trace)

See all

The Laundry

4.7

(11 reviews)

0.7 mi

Cute little spot to have a cocktail. Bar service was exceptional and my boyfriend said his old…read morefashioned was awesome . I just wish my Cosmo had real lime and not a ton of the fake stuff. It made the entire drink taste like imitation lime. All in all it is an adorable spot in G-Village to have a cocktail

This bar is a hidden gem! It's Small, intimate and very welcoming. The decor is trendy comfortable…read more We had a charcuterie board which was excellent and sampled some of their custom cocktails. The service was first class. They have a smaller wine by the glass selection but you can pick out a bottle from the attached wine shop and take it with you if you don't finish it. And the shop has a huge selection of wines that you don't usually find in stores. The attached wine shop is the largest boutique wine shop in the city! They change their menus every two months. What a great way to keep things fresh and interesting! We will return!

Photos

Bartenders and a bottle of Veuve

House white

See all

Bar

I Like It Like That Bar

4.7

(26 reviews)

3.0 mi

Went to I Like It Like That earlier this week for a magical time! The vibes here are always fun &…read morewelcoming; and you feel like you're at home having a great time with all your friends! Their seasonal menus & themes are so fun, and everyone on the service team is friendly & incredible! This time I went for the @yelpcbus event & caught a phenomenal magic show; I still am wondering how all of the magic happened!! I got to try some of the delicious wood fired pizza; the Casanova & Greenwich Village (not pictured) are delicious! The mocktail is well balanced and refreshing; and all of their other cocktails are a must try as well! Be sure to stop by soon!

Fun! Laid back vibe. Good food and good drinks. The drink menu is so extensive that it can probably…read moreget overwhelming at some point. Very creative drinks. As a vegetarian I did have some options to pick from. The ambience is very cute, servers are very helpful, and and definitely a place you can try once.

Photos

Chocolate Chips and Pig Ghost

See all

Bar area

Law Bird

4.6

(76 reviews)

0.6 mi

Stopped in for drinks with some friends and figured we'd grab some food while we were there. I had…read morepretty low expectations for a hot dog, but this thing was ridiculously good. Good snap, loaded with toppings, and exactly what you want after a couple drinks. The atmosphere was relaxed, the drinks were solid, and the food was way better than I expected. I'm not usually the type of person to write a Yelp review about a glizzy, but credit where it's due. I sat down expecting a hot dog and left after absolutely disrespecting one. I'll definitely be back.

Lawbird is hands-down the best cocktail bar in the city. The themed menus which change at a…read morereasonable pace, great staff, and "good vibes" really make this the go-to destination in Columbus and perhaps the Midwest for a cocktail. Pair a stop either before or after to one of German Village's great restaurants and you're in for a special, albeit pricey night. In addition to fantastic drinks, Lawbird offers cocktail tasting classes from time to time which are a fun way to get sauced early in the day. And you will get sauced. If the owners keep up the good thing they have going - this will become an iconic establishment in the city. I hope they do. I've been more than 20 times so far and never get bored. Cheers!

Photos

Wine AND snacks? What more could you want?

Dole Whip (pineapple)

See all

Astra Rooftop

4.2

(79 reviews)

1.2 mi

My friends and I took advantage of a 60 degree day and went to Astra for happy hour. They had the…read morepatio partially covered, so we were still able to enjoy the rooftop views. Our server was great and guided us through some great drink options, everything from tropical to smoky flavors. We tried the ribs, pepperoni pizza, shrimp, and a salad. The shrimp was my fav, but everything was tasty. Excited to come back once it's warm out!

3.5 star for the service 3 star for the food…read more 5 star for the vibes and interior design This place is more for wow factors and the vibes, if you are a picky foodie, it might not be a perfect spot. Really in love with its vibes, both indoor dining room with different segments of seatings and outdoor patio tables are amazing. The interior design here is truly unique and artistic. Great for big groups, date night, or even just chilling with friends. Not sure if it's the standard here, but there was never anyone filling our water during the entire dining time after they left 2 bottles of water on the table. Our server is patient and friendly but not on point. They messed up our orders, forgot one order and brought one wrong (we ordered smashed burger but received chicken sandwich). Very surprising that the staff didn't do anything or offer to send in the correct order. The chef of table service for Tomahawk is fun and enjoyable to carry conversations but unfortunately our Tomahawk was overcooked. We loved the presentation for sure though. Their smoked ribs is not "smoked" but boiled and soaked in sauce. The "smoked" part refers to its presentation, but their machine was down, and we were not told, so we basically got the ribs, neither smoked in cooking method nor smoked when it was brought to our table. The donut tree is another one great for eyes and cameras. It comes with little fireworks at the table service. Overall we enjoyed the breeze and atmosphere here. Will come back for relaxation if in town.

Photos

Caesar Salad

See all

Steak

Antiques On High

Antiques on High was one of our favorite brewery stops during this trip…read more When I first suggested stopping at Antiques on High, my significant other kept saying he didn't want to go antique shopping. Once he realized it was actually a brewery, he was all in! The brewery has a great atmosphere, and the bartender was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Since we've been visiting several breweries during our getaway, they even gave us a Seventh Son passport, which was a nice surprise and a fun way to continue exploring the local brewery scene. I ordered the Wild & Sour flight and really enjoyed it. It was a great way to sample a variety of unique flavors, and each pour showcased the creativity and quality that Antiques on High is known for. Between the excellent beer selection, friendly service, and welcoming atmosphere, this is definitely a brewery I'd recommend to anyone visiting the area. Looking forward to stopping back again!

This is a really cool bar. I went for a Book Bar event held by Thurber House. We got drink…read moretickets so I got a glass of wine at the bar, then went upstairs to the event space. Really cozy with table seating. The door to the balcony was open to let in fresh air. I would def. come back to have a drink in the downstairs area as well. Nice bartender, good wine. I was also happy to grab a parking spot on the street right out front. Lucky girl.

See all

The Citizens Trust

4.0

(65 reviews)

0.6 mi

Amazing building, beautiful and historic. Really pretty entryway. Checking out the vault door…read moredownstairs by the bathrooms is a must. Varied seating options including couches and areas for large parties. Drinks are $17-20ish. A small amount of elevated bar snacks available as well. Quiet and nice vibe, kind staff.

My Sister & I stopped here for some cocktails during their Christmas pop up. I was appreciative of…read morethe festive atmosphere without the area feeling stuffy or cramped. It was extremely busy but I didn't feel like I was packed on top of other people and the service was actually extremely fast and friendly. The only down side was we weren't super jazzed about the cocktails or shots we had. Still had a fun time though!

Photos

Le Santa drink ~ called Yippee Kayaaa (you know the rest)

See all

Aviation

Stories on High

4.2

(98 reviews)

1.1 mi

The sliders were great. The asparagus was so good we ordered two. The cocktails were delicious…read more Excellent service Beautiful views all around

Great experience at stories on high a few weeks back. Came with a friend from out of town who…read moresuggested it. I didn't even realize it was there! No reservation but we were able to get a table on a Thursday. Nice cocktail selection, prices are a bit high but I think a lot of cocktail places in Columbus are a bit steep. Their menu was themed for the furry convention that was going on which was pretty fun and cute. We got some food, which are all pretty small, more like apps and tapas to share. My friend got the confit wings, and I got the lions mane mushrooms. They were delicious, if not just a bit expensive. So the food and drinks I'd say were 4-stars, but the view, ambiance and service were all excellent. Definitely worth checking out and enjoying a fancy night out.

See all

The Oracle

What a gem. Electric interior and lovely outside patio…read more We grabbed to-go cocktails during covid last year and that was a great experience. Each to-go bottle was equivalent to 2 drinks and came with a bag of chips. Now that's both cute and awesome. Yesterday we came in after moving into the neighborhood and enjoyed the back patio. What a nice place to spend an evening. Spacious yard with plenty of tables and seating. There was a tarot reader last night too so you could sign up to have a reading. We sat with our pup and enjoyed a couple drinks each while decompressing from a busy weekend of unpacking and settling in. Ordered the goodnight sweet prince which was mezcal with chartreuse, lime, Prosecco, pea flower (which I learned is purple ha). I wanted the drink not sweet and the bar must have run out of syrup for me lol. It was perfect without it. More on tart side but that's how I like it. Second drink was a negroni with dry vermouth. Predictable and always a fave for me. I also tasted a barrel aged whiskey just for fun and it's saying a a lot that I could sip it. I normally cannot drink whiskey but this tasted amazing and too easy to drink. Creative and interesting drinks for a good price. They have beer and wine too if you're not into cocktail. And cbd drinks too! They really have it all. I had to ask the bartender if the wine prices were glass or bottle (we are used to $17-$20 glasses in Seattle) and to my very pleasant surprise learned they are bottle prices. I also saw they had $5 negronis during happy hour and that really spoke to me. We will return often.

Well now Pilgrim, ya'll know my name and how damn dumb I can be at times, but ya don't know that I…read morejust don't drink firewater. Nope. Got drunk once and made a fool of myself around Miss Libby when we was courtin - and she don't cotton to fools. So never again. That be what it may, I do like to socialize and be around interestin people. Since the kindly folks of the Cheyenne and Lakota tribes taught me the value of cultural diversity, I now enjoy just about every ones company. I like this waterin hole cuz you can find all kinds of fasinatin and different types of folks there. The grub is nice and fancy too. I like that. So when you got the urge to water your horses, this is a fine place to tie up. Happy trails and don't get in one of them horseless buggies and drive it when youre all liquored up - even just a little. Just ride on the back of someone elses horse.

Photos

Goodnight sweet prince

French Pop

See all

The bar

Chouette

4.0

(105 reviews)

0.6 mi

Braelyn is an amazing server and Greg at the Bar made out first experience amazing. We were…read moreimpressed by the attention to detail and the ability to fix the smallest of details; as well as the overall professionalism of the staff

Decided to bring my mom here before brunch she was in town because we are French and were…read moreintrigued! The inside is so beautiful and the patio gives a classic French cafe feel, so we definitely felt right at home. My mom wanted to try the Gruyère cheese puffs and WOW, I've ever had anything like them. For our main dish, we both got their mussels and fries which is my favorite meal of all time and it did not disappoint. The fries were slightly mushy but I actually loved them! We finished our dinner with a cappuccino which unfortunately was VERY cream heavy. It left a weird mouth feeling and was very odd. However, overall this was an amazing dining experience!

See all

Kitchen Social

Best place we went while visiting Ohio! Absolutely loved the vibes, decor - modern /upscale, but…read morestill casual, phenomenal service by Preston, even while busy, and the food was AMAZING! We had the mule of the week (cherry limeade) and blackberry drink, chicken schezuan, street corn nachos, cheddar biscuits, and pimento cheese burger. Y'all I wish I would've taken more photos because this place was the best! If we come back to Ohio, we are coming back to kitchen social! If you're thinking of going, make a reservation, and go!!! - A foodie from HTX

Yeahhhh ngl, this was extremely fire. The flavors were melting on my tongue…read more I definitely asked for the sauce on the side but I'm glad my server forgot / didn't listen to me bc this was tewwww good. The steak could've been more on the rare side but tbh i still ate the entire thing... & the veggies in this dish were divine. I could kill a whole tub of the carrots and cauliflower. 10/10 The place itself is so insanely busy so def make a reservation ahead of time & try to avoid Sunday brunch / lunch or you'll hit the church crowd. Service was great as well. Parking can be a bit annoying and tight but nothing too bad that will make u want to choose another restaurant.

Photos

Bathroom

Veggie bowl

See all

CRÈME BRULEE FRENCH TOAST Brioche, Vermont syrup, almond brittle, seasonal berries, mascarpone cream.

Valters at the Maennerchor

Great place! We've been here a few times - both for breakfast and for dinner - and both are great!…read more Reuben was classic and solid. French onion soup had an amazing flavor. The Kasespatle was Mac and cheese for adults! This restaurant has a great vibe since it has the unique look of being an old house. Great outdoor patio and great service!

I think people sleep on Valters because it is tucked away and has been there forever…read more The food is delicious and well prepared. Kira our server was outstanding. She managed to deal with our crazy group of 8 quite well and kept the food and drinks coming. The restaurant is cozy and friendly and an overall great experience.

Photos

See all

Red sangria

Cento

4.5

(175 reviews)

0.4 mi

Firstly, this was mine and my new fiancé's first time ever coming here, and I can say that the…read moreoverall experience was nothing but incredible. Our server, Alex, was incredibly kind and helpful, but was also so incredibly down to earth. That alone made us feel so much more comfortable, and I truly appreciate that. Moving to the food, the peach burrata was exceptional! And the carbonara and bolognese were beyond tasty. Overall, this was one of the best meal experiences that u have ever had and I am so incredibly happy that we were able to celebrate our anniversary here (I proposed to her after dinner!) Thank you for the amazing experience, and I cannot wait for the next time we come back! We'll ask for Alex again lol

We had a wonderful experience! Our server, Allie, was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about…read morethe menu. Her recommendations were spot on, and everything we ordered was delicious. We were celebrating a birthday, and she even offered to take pictures for us, which was such a thoughtful touch and made the occasion feel extra special. Ethan, our server assistant, was equally fantastic. He made sure our drinks were always full and kept the table cleared promptly, helping everything run smoothly throughout our meal. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was great, and the outstanding service from both Allie and Ethan truly made our visit memorable. We can't wait to come back!

Photos

The Garden Terrazzo, heated in winter

Lemon Tart with whipped cream and raspberries

See all

Burrata with roasted tomatoes, pesto and extra virgin olive oil

Press Grill

8/10: The Hand-Cut Cottage Fries were abundant in toppings! I wish there would have been more…read morepotatoes slices to even out the ratio of toppings to potatoes, but the presentation was beautiful and came out in a timely manner. 8.7/10: "The Works" pizza was ordered by my partner: Really liked everything about the pizza, especially the crust because it was crisp, buttery, 'a naturally good pizza'! 9/10: The Pesto Chicken Sandwhich with Mac n Cheese is what I ordered! The bacon and bread of the sandwhich were both crispy perfect. The Mac n Cheese is extremely cheesy~ The server was really kind and always came up to check in on us! It had a nice vibe, the music was more club music-y than I expected but it was a pleasant surprise. The high tables were right behind the bar, giving it a cozy feel. Overall score: 9/10!!

I've been coming to Press Grill for at least 10 years, if not longer, and it's always been…read moreconsistent. It's my go-to whenever I'm in the Short North for work. I usually order the pizza, which never disappoints, but this time I just wanted something to snack on. The loaded cottage fries definitely hit the spot. The wings were fried perfectly, and the sauce was warm without being overwhelming. Nothing flashy, just solid food every time. That kind of consistency keeps me coming back.

Photos

Press Grill

Press Burger (single) and wedge fries

See all

The Avenue Steak Tavern

Always a perfect experience here!…read more Came in last week for a more casual Wednesday night dinner. Had the White Cheddar Cheese Burger with french fries which was so freaking good. My burger was cooked very well, and the french fries were a pretty generous serving, so you definitely have more than enough food. I also had the Brooklyn to drink, which I really liked. I typically like a sweeter old-fashioned, but they use a rye whiskey in theirs, so the Brooklyn was a nice alternative. Our server, Danny was super friendly and very attentive to our needs. It was actually our anniversary that day, so the restaurant gave us a complementary slice of chocolate cake which was to die for. That is the best chocolate cake I've ever eaten. Always a great time here, we will certainly be back!

REVIEW BY: Avila.Eats on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube…read more Service: waiter was friendly, talkative, and gave great recommendations. Thor made for a great experience for our first time dining and will gladly return to be served by him. Ambiance/Atmosphere: inside is open but smaller than expected. Well spaced tables and comfortable booths. The bar is nice and old fashioned. Well lit tavern style decor. Food: 1. Roll is hot and fresh. Crunchy outside and so fluffy inside. Already buttery and the extra butter adds more flavor. 7 2. Chicken sandwich Super crispy and well seasoned chicken. Bun is pillowy soft yet firm the sauce adds a sweetness and there's a slight spice from the hot honey but not much honey flavor. Pickles add a nice crunch and pop of flavor. 6.5. As you made it towards the middle, the honey flavor became more prominent. 7 3. Creamed spinach is really good. Soft and well seasoned. A tang that adds a bright pop. It's made with bakery cream and it keeps it rich and smooth. 8 4. Burger is juicy, perfectly seasoned. The bun is amazing and compliments so well. The sweet pickle mayo is creamy and rich with a nice sweetness. The ingredients are fresh. White cheddar pairs excellently. 8.25 5. Hash brown soft inside with a crispy exterior. No real flavor. The center has caramelized onion that help. 5. Adding their steak dust is a game changer. 7 6. Banana bread pudding is absurd. Strong banana flavor. Soft and warm. The chocolate on top is rich and decadent. The vanilla ice cream pairs beautifully for a warm and cold pairing. This is as perfect as I'd imagined. 10.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Dustin M.

Elite 26

246

3 years ago

Location: Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio, Pecan Penny's exudes a cool, hipster vibe with its industrial aesthetics and inviting decor. The eye-catching BAR-B-Q mural adorning the walls beckons patrons in, promising a unique dining experience. Cleanliness: In a culinary landscape where cleanliness can be elusive, Pecan Penny's stands out. The overall cleanliness left a lasting impression, underscoring their commitment to a hygienic dining environment. Service: While the ambiance set high expectations, the initial interaction fell short. A brief wait at the entrance and a somewhat indifferent response from the server conveyed a sense of inconvenience. However, with a more attentive and engaging approach, the service experience could elevate the overall dining journey. Culinary Delights: Embarking on a gastronomic adventure, I opted for two hotdogs and a side of Mac-N-Cheese. The visual appeal of "The Whitaker" hotdog was matched only by its delightful taste - the brisket chili, shredded cheddar, diced onion, jalapenos, and sour cream created a symphony of flavors. The "Chi-Town Dog" was equally enticing, marred only by an excess of mustard. The Mac-N-Cheese, though lacking in presentation, surprised with its decent taste. A golden, crispy cheese layer could elevate it to excellence. Final Verdict: Pecan Penny's earns a respectable 7/10. The establishment boasts a visually appealing and modern setting, coupled with a commendable focus on cleanliness. While the service teetered on average to slightly below, the culinary offerings, particularly the hotdogs, proved to be a palate-pleasing highlight. With a touch of enhanced presentation and a motivated service team, Pecan Penny's has the potential to become a must-visit culinary gem in Columbus, Ohio. read more

Emily M.

6 years ago

I would def recommend going to sit out on the patio and enjoy the summer breeze while eating some super delicious bbq! Went here and had great service and even better food! Ordered some local beers and split the sampler with my girlfriend. It was a perfect date! The sampler was amazing- I loved the pork and was super blown away with the chicken! The chicken was the hidden gem for me- so juicy!! The sauces were great to slather on the trio of goodness that was included in the sampler- pork, brisket, and chicken. We got mac and cheese and waffles fries as the sides- two come with the sampler. All around great experience- will be back again! read more

Christina H.

493

204

5 years ago

They offer great, open outdoor seating with lots of delicious choices. We've been here a couple times before and you can always rely on friendly service, great drinks, and great food. I'd recommend the bowls to try a little more of everything. The poutine is also great for sharing! Tip: try out all the sauces with some fries to make sure you pick the best for your meat. They have 6 options at the table so you can mix it up. read more

Sara D.

7 years ago

Great food, drinks and atmosphere. The ribs are my favorite!! Their signature sauces are good but the ribs don't even need them!! The new drink specials every night are awesome and such a good deal. Definitely a place for quick food or to hang out for hours. read more

Carla D.

8 years ago

The best bbq in the city. That brisket is all I can think about! I definitely recommend it and their wings too! 50 cent wings all day on Mondays! read more