Peppers Bar & Grill was a great stop overall. We tried the oxtail and the fried fish entrées, and both were really good--flavorful, well-cooked, and satisfying. The food is definitely the highlight here. The drinks were just okay and didn't really stand out, so it's probably best to stick with wine or beer if you're ordering beverages. That said, the atmosphere makes up for it. The location is very cool and relaxed, and it's an easy walk from Camana Bay, which is a big plus. All in all, a very nice spot with solid food and a convenient, enjoyable location. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

I chose this place expecting a solid take on Caribbean staples. What I received was the opposite. The Rasta pasta was a pale, watery dish with no trace of jerk flavor...none. It lacked the richness, spice, and depth that define it. Instead, it felt diluted and unfinished, as if the key elements never made it into the pan. The "curry goat" was even more disappointing. The sauce was thin to the point of being soupy, with little to no curry presence. The dish had no body, no warmth, no layering of flavor just water where there should have been depth. Even the rice was off, adding nothing to salvage the plate. These are foundational dishes in Caribbean cuisine. To miss the mark on both so completely is not a small oversight it's a fundamental failure in execution. I've included photos for context, because the presentation reflects the experience. read more

See all

The BBQ chicken was absolutely loaded with flavor--smoky, juicy, and perfectly glazed. Every bite hit. The oxtails were next level. The meat was so tender it was literally falling off the bone, swimming in rich, savory gravy that soaked perfectly into the rice and peas. The plantains were sweet, golden, and cooked just right. I tried the Pepper's Punch--it was strong with a nice kick. I just asked for a splash of pineapple juice and the waiter made it perfect. On top of the food, the service was amazing and the vibe was on point with live music that made the whole experience feel like a celebration. If you love real Caribbean flavor, this place is a must. read more

See all

Everything was very good, I just wanted more spice! Their jerk chicken was marketed as very spicy and I had to put a good dousing of their scotch bonnet sauce on top. That sauce was fire though. Their whole snapper with the okra and peppers was phenomenal, and I loved the salt fish fritters. Overall very happy with the meal. This place is hopping, such a fun vibe. They have TVs to watch sports and live music. No reservations so expect to wait for a table if they're busy, which seems like always! read more

The ambiance is great. The food and drinks are superior. The service is wonderful, friendly, professional and exceptional.

Great service! Be sure to try the Peppers punch and conch fritters to start! Whole snapper was delicious along with the BBQ chicken. As for sides - the fries and coleslaw were great! read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Whole snapper, rice and peas - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

Delicious!! Large portions here we definitely over ordered. Expect to wait around 20-30 minutes for a table they get really busy. Fries were just ok not the best. The meat was delicious. read more

See all

Outstanding food very authentic Caribbean food.. be careful of the spice levels if you not used to spicy food , the heat will sneak up on you .. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Pork sausage , jerk ribs(fall off the bone ) with cole slaw and an order of fried sweet plantains . - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

See all

Pulled this up here on Yelp, and given the great reviews and the location, with the suggestion of a local flair, our party of six came to enjoy lunch. The food was absolutely delicious! The drinks were strong. The service impeccable!! Highly recommend. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Mahi Mahi special. - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

This place came highly recommended so we decided to try it after a day on the water. There is an added 15 percent gratuity for dining in restaurant. We were seated right away and orders taken. We had the pasta with jerk chicken and Alfredo sauce and ribs with sweet potato fries. We also had a side of fries. Everything was delicious. My only complaint was the limited meat on the ribs. That was disappointing. No the less, we did enjoy our food and the atmosphere of the joint. There are 2 bar area to sit in. Parking is all around the building in 3 sides and can be tight. Service was decent. read more

See all

Great service, very vibrant and celebratory atmosphere. The food was tasty, but it was not what I would call authentic homestyle cooking. That said, the callaloo rice was delicious and the extensive options on the menu made it possible for just about anyone to find something they might enjoy. I did not enjoy the conch fritters because they were more like a piece of fried bread and I could not taste the conch.. The serving size was definitely large making this a cost-effective option. read more

Peppers is a must do if you're in Grand Cayman! Its large covered outdoor space creates a very open and comfortable vibe. They have several TV's, plenty of tables and bar seating. The service was quick and our server was very attentive. I also find their pricing to be very fair and reasonable. The icing on the cake is the food is amazing. I ordered the oxtail with rice and peas, and a margarita to drink. My husband ordered the curry goat with corn on the cob. Each also included plantains, a small side salad and cole slaw. Everything was great. The oxtail was very tender and seasoned to the bone! My husband raved about the curry goat also. Most importantly, the margarita was great lol. I have no complaints! read more

See all

This place is fantastic! Great food, great drinks, great entertainment, friendly staff. This is a must do when visiting grand cayman. This blows the other restaurants out of the water! read more

A must when you're in the Cayman Islands! Our hotel was thankfully a short walk away, so we went here twice on our trip. I had to of course, try the oxtail. I would say it was just okay. It wasn't the best oxtail I've ever had but it defs wasn't the worst. I appreciate that they gave a fair amount of meat and it wasn't just a bunch of bones. Now my favourite things would have to be the jerk pork and coleslaw. Heck, the rice and peas was amazing too! The jerk pork was perfectly seasoned and juicy and they give you a good amount! The coleslaw was fresh, not overloaded with mayo and everything about it was just right. My jerk pork meal was so big I had enough leftovers to have a full dinner later that night. I highly recommend Peppers and that's not just me, a lot of others will agree! read more

See all

Food was great! We took it to go since have an infant and everything was delicious - we tried jerk chicken, jerk pork and conch fritters. Everything was soo good! Would definitely come back read more

A MUST VISIT when you are in Grand Cayman! Peppers offers local Caribbean cruisine in Grand Cayman Island. While visiting the island, I went twice! It's that good! The first time I ordered curry goat with rice and peas, paired with Pepper's Punch (a rum punch). It was delicious! I'm a fan of curry goat so there is that! It was very flavorful and surprisingly, not super spicy. My mom ordered the braised ox tails and thoroughly enjoyed her meal and commented on the flavor. We visited on Friday and Saturday and they had live entertainment in the form of a small band. They were great both nights. Service was friendly! Because it's a different culture, I don't want to label it slow or fast. When the food came it was hot and good. When on vacation, my motto is to enjoy the vibes and not be in a rush. Housekeeping add, when checking in on Yelp, I noticed it has this restaurant located in Florida. This restaurant is in Grand Cayman Island and *not* Florida, USA. read more

Good service, great value, and really good food. I would say 4.5 overall experience. Nice Island vibe on the decor. We missed the live music, but we hear that is a regular Saturday event. The drinks are pleasantly strong, and full of flavor. The ribs are an absolute must. Sweet, sticky, Smokey, and tender, all at the same time. We will definitely go back. read more

See all

Great server-she explained things in the menu that we didn't recognize, was very patient, and kept our drinks full

Wow! What a great place. Just upset we didn't visit earlier in the week. The best jerk chicken I've ever had. Juicy, flavorful and spicy If you add the bonnet and bbq sauce. Rum drinks were good, happy hour beers were reasonable and great live music. Only negative was I didn't wear bug spray. It's outside so make sure you spray before you eat. So good read more

Great service at the bar as the restaurant was super busy. Bartenders were on pointe, working fast and furiously. Hubby ordered conch fritters, a Mahi dinner, and a beer - loving every bit of it. I ordered the rasta pasta - tasty with a light tomato sauce. Ambiance is island tiki bar like. Suggestion: More plant based dinners, please! read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Pov from bar - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

See all

After a long flight, the hotel told us to head here for refreshments and Peppers did not disappoint! Live music and an airy seaside Caribbean atmosphere put us at ease and when I asked the bartender Tristian if they had the best ribs on the island (per the sign out front) he whole heartedly agreed. True story! These things were succulent, meaty and cooked to perfection. Pair them with a little sauce and fried plantains and you have some downright soul food here in Grand Cayman. On a Friday night the band was rocking, locals and tourists alike were all smiles and I left with a happy heart (it is Valentines Day after all) and a very happy stomach. read more

Oh my goodness, this food was so good! The coconut curry mahi was amazing and the side of tostones were great too. My husband really enjoyed his goat and red beans and rice. Cool lowkey island vibe. Service was great. They were kind enough to put the Bucs game on for us too! read more

See all

There were 5 in our group and all would recommend. We had jerk chicken, ribs, various sides and apps. Frozen margaritas and local beers on draft hit the spot. Service was top notch including the bartender. I'm not a self-proclaimed jerk connoisseur but I've had the pleasure to enjoy in Jamaica a handful of times and Peppers exceeded my expectations. Great atmosphere and vibe. The entire place is very clean including restrooms. Our waitress mentioned the owner is from Jamaica which was not surprising after tasting the first bite. read more

Stopped in for some happy hour drinks and apps, Peppers definitely delivered. Very fun, Caribbean vibes with excellent food and service. Our server, Eli, was so bubbly and friendly, she provided stellar service with a smile. Our drinks were delicious, I especially loved the Mudslide, which is a Grand Cayman original! The margaritas and mojitos were fantastic as well. The calamari was fresh and hot. Fun, tropical spot with great food and drinks. read more

We were just leaving a restaurant down the street that we paid $210usd for a dinner and were not full so we looked up Peppers since we heard so much about it. Since they stopped serving food at 10 we did a togo order. We got to Peppers which had plenty of parking and went in to get out loaded fries and decides to get a drink while we were there. We saw others still eating so it should have been ok. The rude bartender told us we couldn't eat it there and if we did she would have have to re ring us, charge 18% gratuity and then plate it for us to eat there. So we said we will eat in the car and come back for a drink. As I was picking up our food to go eat in the car another male bartender asked what we would like and if we wanted to eat inside....very accommodating BUT as he walked away the lady bartender got upset and said some words so we decided to leave. We wanted to stay for the nice band but her attitude was unwanted and a night killer. I will NOT be back but the fries were ok maybe just a little too cheesy. read more

Excellent food Best local spot Service is amazing Ambiance, casual bar Got mahi coconut Ribs Bbq chicken Eat it! read more

Great food, atmosphere and service. Fish and chips not recommended-too much doughy batter and thin pieces of fish. Good local cuisine. Overpriced as is everything on the island. read more

This restaurant was one of the highlights of our dinners out. So much so, that I did not take a single picture of our food, because we were all so busy eating. The meats really are the star here. We ordered all sorts of ribs, jerk chicken, jerk pork, and side dishes. The highlight was the jerk chicken with the callaloo rice and fried plantains. This was the actually the only restaurant we went to where all five of our kids ate all of their meal completely. In fact, some of the kids were stealing food from the adults plates because it was so good. The service is a little spotty, but that is because the restaurant is enormous and they are clearly always very busy. The live music made for a nice ambience. Definitely order one of the frozen cocktails. read more

See all

Amazing food. Can get busy but among the best food on the island. Jerk chicken is recommended

Very good food, nice friendly service and enjoyed sitting outside. The plantains were excellent. Jerk BBQ and Jerk Pork Sausage were good. The jerk pork on the loaded fries was tasty, the fries themselves were okay. read more

We tried some of almost everything. Only thing I would definitely steer clear of was the sausage. That had the consistency of sawdust. Everything else was great. Excellent servers. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Some of everything! - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

We had a pleasant lunch at this iconic open-air restaurant on a very quiet Sunday in early December before the busy season. Our server was friendly and guided us to some good choices on the Caribbean food menu featuring jerk seasoning and BBQ. I third the 1/4 jerk chicken (yummy) and my wife had the "famous" BBQ ribs (good). You get to choose from a list of about 20 sides-we had fries and coleslaw. The open air setting is nice and since food is roasted and slow cooked, the stuff came out really quickly. It's a really big place so I imagine in season it can get pretty busy and lively. Parking available next to the restaurant. read more

See all

First stop on the grand cayman island. The bartender was friendly. We tried their rum punch. It was very strong. Spilt the jerk chicken platter and the salad with blueberries and cilantro house-made dressing. I didn't care for the dressing. Very overwhelming! The atmosphere was comfortable and laid back. We went back once more at night and the vibe was totally different. They have very bright led lights! It takes away from the islandy feeling. They did have some entertainment. It wasn't very good. I my opinion it's a good place for happy hour drinks and small bites. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Rum punch and a sample of their mudslide - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

The food was soooooo good. I went back to back on my trip to Peppers. Service was nice - our waitress was very sweet and knowledgeable of the menu. The ambiance 10/10. read more

This was my groups first meal coming into cayman and it was delicious for our first but after eating at other eateries on the island it's very mid. We were seated quick, rarely anyone was there, and service was attentive and food came out real fast. FOOD ORDERED Classic Burger: friend said this was okay. Just their house burger but nothing special or extraordinary. Braised Oxtail: this one was DELISH. However we felt that there was a lot of bones and not enough meat so portions were a bit off with the rice and beans that we were recommended as a side. Nonetheless, flavor was ON POINT. So tender, FALL OFF THE BONE. 3 of us got this! Coconut Rundown Mahi Mahi: no complaints on this one either. All plates were finished completely! read more

See all

Visited Peppers our first day on the island bc I was craving Curry goat for a long time. It did not disappoint. The food was good but the service was not up to par compared to the rest of the restaurants that we visited. The prices were much higher than the higher end restaurants. read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - Menu always choose an island special - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

See all

Good local eats. Fun mix of Caymanian and tourist clientele. Went on a Saturday night and enjoyed the live music and dancing. Waited in line, which we've never had to do before! read more

Had a great lunch here! We stopped in Grand Cayman for the day and heard good things about this place from a family friend who lives on the island. The atmosphere of the restaurant was super relaxing, they had tables that were large, and the cool breeze going throughout the restaurant was nice. The service was good. The food was tasty especially the calamari. My only complaint would be that the festival came out cold so I wish it was a bit hotter. The rest of the meal was delicious! read more

Peppers Bar & Grill - curry goat, festival , and jerk pork - Caribbean Near Me - Grand Cayman, Florida

See all

Peppers Bar & Grill is on our good too restaurant for fresh island food! We always begin our vacation each visit. The menu includes a great assortment of local favorites and the cocktails are not watered down. Also, the prices are very $$! read more

Great food, great service and good beer. All four of our dinners were very good. We came back at lunch for a beer and app.