We were craving authentic NY style pizza, but live in Cleveland so we researched places a few hours…read moreaway and landed in Brooklyns Finest. A 3 hour drive and so worth it! I think we tried almost every flavor, but the standouts were the Buffalo Chicken - which I would never order but it was so incredibly good and the crust is perfection. The White Pizza with the ricotta was amazing, the Pepperoni was small and crisp and so tasty and the Margarita pizza had crushed tomatoes on it which was a first but so good. I think we got 10 slices, and ended up getting 2 more slices of the Buffalo Chicken to take home - yes we ate pizza for 3 days and so worth it lol. It heated up perfectly in the oven for 10 minutes and tasted just as good as it did at the restaurant. So worth 6 hours of driving.

Traditional NY Pizza, in all ways! In an assuming plaza, it has the nostalgic pizza place feel -…read morewith a Buffalo Bills twist. When you first enter, there is a phenomenal selection of specialty pies, and all are included in their two slice & soda special for $9. They offer both fountain sodas and a generous selection of refrigerated drink options also. Once you order, there is a back dining room with several different size tables, but all with Bills chairs, which is a neat trend we loved seeing in this area, despite being from Florida. The man who greeted us was kind helpful and I was impressed with the pizza options. We ordered: - Buffalo Chicken: had a really good flavor & was my favorite! - BBQ Chicken: my son loved it - Margerhita: also had a good flavor - Pickle: the best we've had by far - Beef Pattie: looks like a Jamaican one but isn't spicy and had a very strange almost veal or lamb taste. Overall the flavors of the pizzas were really very good, but unfortunately every slice was so overcooked and burnt that it quickly overtook the great flavor of each bite. Now, the thing is, everyone likes different kinds of pizza, and apparently Brooklyn style isn't necessarily our jam, but for something we really don't like (black crust), it was still very good and we would highly recommend it to people who like more cooked pizza.

Was moving and I still haven't been here yet heard good things! So I ordered a sheet pizza and a…read morelarge one and a ham sub! Pizza was great plenty of cheese and pepperoni everyone asking where did I get it ! My daughter loved her sub plenty of ham and vegetables. We had to stop again couple days later to get another sub it was that good . And it didn't break the bank when I'm in the area i'll be back for the pizza again and sub and I'll have to try wings too

A go to place for food. Pizza, wings, subs, you can't go wrong. The any 3 subs & large c&p pizza…read moredeal is the best !

Ferris has the most amazing varieties of pizza calzones. Toppings vary. The staff is so friendlyread more

Heard this place had the best NY Style pizza in Buffalo. My sister and I both got slices of cheese…read morepizza and we both agreed that there was just too much cheese. Also, the place just feels dirty overall. Sorry to say we won't be back.

Amazing Buffalo style pizza, one of the best in Western NY…read more My first time here and we ordered a (single $18.20) chicken fingers and a slice of cheese pizza ($4.25). Fantastic food but definitely pricey. While I was waiting, I met a few customers and they all raved about the cheese pizza. They all said it's the bomb and they were right! Restaurant has a dine-in area which looked clean and comfortable.

After traveling the country try I finally got back home to have the best pizza!…read more Just ordered takeout but they were cutting the pizza as I arrived so the timing was perfect. I got in and out quick with my order. The drive home was torture bec the pizza smelled so good. Place was busy and had a line of people waiting on their orders. Still plenty of parking in the lot. People were dining in the seated area which I wasn't aware was open again.

Not like I needed a reminder, but One Pie Pizza Co. serves up an excellent, truly authentic…read moreBuffalo-style pizza. This time I ordered their take on a WNY specialty pizza: the chicken finger pizza. In short, it was fantastic! Since I'm a member of their rewards program, I received a "$5 off your next order" code and figured it'd been a couple months since my last visit. The coupon couldn't have come at a better time. I placed my order online on a Saturday around 4:15pm for a 5:05pm pick-up. I know, you lose a bit of the personability when you don't call the restaurant to place an order, but online ordering is so easy and quick, and I love being able to pick my pick-up time and know my order will be ready, and paid for, when I arrive. As of 07/2026, the inside of One Pie Pizza Co. underwent a remodel. It's not as spacious, but I think it opens up their kitchen more, which I'm 100% on-board with since that means more pizza and other goodies. The staff are just as friendly and courteous as ever, I'm glad that hasn't changed. So, for dinner, I ordered a QTR Sheet (six slice) from their "SUPER Specialty Pizza" menu - The BFLO Chicken Finger (blue cheese base) cooked "LIGHT WELL DONE", which is a choice between their homemade red sauce or blue cheese base that is topped with diced chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and Frank's (medium) sauce. The "LIGHT WELL DONE" option is for cooking the dough underneath a bit more, firming it up, making it crispier. I like a little extra cook on my pizza as, sometimes, the Buffalo-style dough is a bit too limp, almost soggy/wet, which makes holding a slice... challenging. haha Now, I've had a few chicken finger pizzas throughout the years and while I love them, they don't always love me back. They're typically very dense pizzas thanks to all the cheese (blue cheese base AND cheese blends on top) but I was impressed with how well One Pie Pizza Co.'s sat. Don't get me wrong, this pizza is absolutely loaded. When I opened the box, I was worried how I was going to pick it up as it looked messy, but as they say, appearances can be deceiving! I was impressed and didn't finish my meal wearing it all over my hands and face. Every slice was generously topped, the flavor was spot-on. Now, I love a cheesy pizza, but I really appreciate the constraint One Pie Pizza Co. showed with not going overboard with a "blend" of cheeses on top of a blue cheese base - The layer of mozzarella was plenty, a great flavor on its own. As with all of their pizza, this left me happy and full. With that $5 off coupon, this brought the price to under $20, an incredible price, especially in 2026! One Pie Pizza Co. remains one of my favorite pizzas in Buffalo. I'm glad I finally tried their chicken finger pizza, this was excellent. With how well it agreed with me, I'm pretty confident in saying One Pie Pizza Co. will be where I order chicken finger pizzas from exclusively going forward!

Excellent crispy crust. Go for bolder toppings. I had pepp with hit honey. I also had mush onion…read moreand that didn't hold up as well. Anthony Bourdain tip...I had to use restroom which is really only for staff. However it was super clean and nice and AB says if they keep it that nice you can imagine the kitchen. Well done One Pie!

Second time trying this new pizzeria by my house. First time was outstanding. We got a breakfast…read morepizza and chicken fingers with some really interesting sauces. Yesterday I ordered a meatball bomber and paid extra for pepperoni. When I received my sandwich, it had literally three pieces of pepperoni on it. Definitely unacceptable I'm hoping this is just growing pains because I think the food is going to be pretty good and the location is something this area desperately needs. But I think it'll be a while before I order another sub from them

Stopped in to try this new pizza spot and the wings honestly stole the show -- especially with the…read moresweet chili sauce. Perfect balance of sweet and heat, and the wings were well crispy but also held the sauce really well. Definitely a must-order. We also grabbed a Buffalo chicken pizza that was on special -- great price and really good. Plenty of flavor and a solid slice all around. Overall, a spot that keeps things simple and does them right. I'll be back for those wings. Food was ready on time staff was extremely nice.

Very attentive and pleasant staff. Pretty good pizza to. Ordered a small cheese, sausage, and…read moremushroom and it was a perfect size for me and my dining companion. We even had a slice left over to take with us

First time, last time! Really bad service! The owner is really offensive and not polite at all!!!…read moreBad place!!!

I waited 15-20 minutes for wings and I would definitely wait again. The wings where perfect and I…read moredidn't ask for ranch or extra sauce but they added it anyway with no extra coast witch as a customer I appreciated very much the sauce all thought simple was very tasty. And atmosphere is not modern but that's what made Guzzo's spot stand out to me almost like how you expect a pizza place to look keep up the amazing work. To all employees and employers there I will be back this is my new favorite wing place can't wait to try more on the menu:)

Pizza , wings , pizza rolls everything was delicious, So much we went back the next day we where…read morein town. Both cashiers we had the 2 times we went wheee very helpful to us especially because we where in town from AZ