Very good food especially subs and chicken fingers, service is nice and fast usually. During the summer the outdoor seating is nice.

Great local business!! We ordered fried chicken, salads, & sides for 2 separate family events. Everything had been delicious, fresh, plentiful, & packaged well. The orders were ready on our time schedule. The staff is so helpful, pleasant & accommodating. The menu at Eden Seafood is extensive. A business gem in the Southtowns! read more

The last 3 parties we had, this was our place to go even tho it was a 25 min drive each way. (warmed it up in the oven for a few minutes ) We always get the chicken, but the last time we got the antipasto also. Both were excellent. The antipasto was twice as big for the same price as what I had gotten previous from a well known big take out Italian restaurant in W. Seneca. Will be ordering again in Sept. read more

I was so excited to see a mini (personal) pizza offered on their menu! That's not a common find for other local pizzerias. I decided to get the mini mushroom pizza to go and was pleasantly surprised they used portebello mushrooms which gave it lots of mushroom flavor! I also got suckered into ordering their "garlic crust" because I'm a garlic lover so why not give it a try? I have to say, it sounded and looked better than it ended up tasting. They really layered on the sauce and cheese which I LOVE, but the sauce was sweeter than I normally like and the pizza seemed a bit undercooked. I'm also not convinced that I got the garlic crust I ordered as it didn't seem to have any additional garlic flavoring on it. I do like the feel of this pizza shop though. The guy at the front counter was warm and welcoming. They have a plethora of home-made desserts in the front cabinet and their menu is nicely displayed on a big board when you walk in. I am very interested to try some of their other options! read more

Eden Seafood & Pizzeria - Dessert cabinet! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Eden, New York

See all

Always great food and even better customer service!! Great neighborhood staple that is reliable and quick.

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 5 EDEN'S SEAFOOD & PIZZERIA EDEN, NY Score 6.8 Recommended by Ray Z. Holy cheese! This pizza is guaranteed to fill you. A bit too much cheese for my liking but the taste is pretty decent. Dining room closed due to covid and they do not deliver. It was fishy that this place is half seafood/half pizzeria but the pie in general was not half bad. read more

Eden Seafood & Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza - Seafood Markets Near Me - Eden, New York

Darn it, well another one bite's the dust. Something is/has happened to this place. Why? Because we won't drive over 20 miles to get pizza, antipasto, sandwiches and or fried chicken from just any old place. Yet now we're done. Anyone can stub their toe in the restaurant business, for any number of reasons and we're very understanding about it. However 3 strikes and your out is our basic philosophy. It started with the antipasto which was a wonderfully generous and consistent. Then we got it and the proteins were diced up into tiny little pieces. Which just doesn't work. The next time was back to normal size but the ingredients seemed less. The last time and it wasn't the same at all. No banana peppers less then half the usual proteins, cheese and other toppings. Then came the fried chicken. It was ALWAYS great. I mean as good as any I've ever had and I'm a fried chicken fan so driving for the good stuff is no problem. Then it was different. Couldn't tell you what it was we just looked at each other and said huh, that's disappointing. A few weeks later it was worse my SWAG was maybe fry oil wasn't hot enough or a bit past it's prime or someone made a mistake with the recipe because it was mediocre at best but we ate it. This last time it was officially terrible and frankly inedible. Goodness for fried chicken to be inedible for me, well you get the idea. I don't remember ever throwing away fried chicken and I'm an old guy so this was a first for me. My guess is what I suspected last time. That it was cooked in old blown out fry oil. If you ever had fried chicken, ff, etc cooked with old oil you'd know. It tastes very greasy with a back flavor of burned oil. Last was the pizza. Always a winner, flavorful crust, quality ingredients... then I didn't even recognize it. The ingredients were much less than the numerous other visits and the dough was now flat. Not as in shape but in freshness and flavor. It tasted like it was old as well. Old dough looses its flavor, texture and height etc and this had those characteristics. That happened twice. There can be any number of reasons for the changes we experienced. We are loyal customers who understand that stuff happens BUT we also know when it's time to move on. read more

See all

Kept hearing good things about their fried chicken so we had to try it ordered a 12 piece and sweet potato fries the chicken was worthy of 5 stars best we had in a long time only reason I gave a 4 star rating was fries were very overcooked and dry but this will not stop me from trying more items from here read more

Great subs and friendly staff. Also excellent desserts! I'm still working my way through the menu. read more

Disappointing. We were regular customers.... but I think they changed their sauce and it is not as good.... Their pizza is usually good..... but it's just MEH now... and we got a cookie sandwich that was stale.... only saving grace was the order of Laney's chips. Not sure we'll be going back read more

Great food, great service and never disappointed. Very clean and friendly service. The prices aren't bad. Highly recommend the wings.

The pizza here is excellent I got a slice of cheese and pepperoni. The sauce was delicious. The cheese was good and the crust was excellent. I love the tables of wood with shellac on them big screen TV. Lots to choose from service was good and prompt. My pizza was heated very quickly. read more

They offer a great variety of sauces for your wings or fingers. The salads are huge and can easily be a dinner for 2; we usually go with chicken souvlaki. The fried chicken is always on point and is highly recommended! Delish. read more

One of the best places on the area for fried chicken. Nice variety of other items on the menu. Friendly staff. Convenient location.

You are another one trying to pass your chicken planks as chicken fingers . No they are awful plus mine were burnt . When I lived in Eden I got the fingers once a week . Went through about a month ago and stop and got some . Never again . Don't cheat your customers with subpar product . I know for a fact that you used to have one of the best . I buy my own from now one from schwans and they are the best 24 for 3 ibs that 58.00in a restaurant . Code number is 505 . read more

Amazing food and the best family owned business around! Such a great staff, highly recommend!

Amazing fried chicken! I am typically not a fan of fried chicken but I had it from Eden Seafood and am obsessed! It's amazing and I can't get enough! read more

Grew up eating Eden seafood. Every time we swing through we must get the chicken finger taco and fish sub and a slice. Walk away painfully overstuffed but its "oh so good" :-) read more

See all

I recently ordered a whole ham sub and a salami sub and I come to find a hair in each of them. I find this not only disgusting but also disturbing. I have completely lost my appetite. This was uncalled for and ruined my dinner with my family. 1 star more like 0. This was nasty. Thank gosh the chiefs won because if they didn't I would've cried in my room because this was so disgusting read more

Great subs and pizza! Awesome and friendly service. :)

I am not the biggest fan of their pizza, but their subs and wings are to die for! Reasonably priced and the employees are always very nice.

Eden Seafood has some serious staffing issues that need to be addressed by the owner. Watching the antics behind the counter which was borderline elementary school is bad enough, but forgetting that two waiting customers are in your dining area in full view, while the food that is already paid for ,sits done for 20 minutes is just not acceptable ! Then the antics about how no one can "call" the owner with a complaint. Seriously ? Mistakes happen, how the mistake is handled with the customer is the important part. We where told by the employee "oh just go grab yourself a "free" drink. I just paid Mr. Ventry $3 or so for a 2 liter ! Not everything can be made better with something for free. If I wanted something free I would have asked for free food when I walked through your door. How about just providing a decent product with decent service ? This is far from the first time that I have received poor service or food from Eden Seafood. This one was the last time. Close up or sell the place... read more

When we go out for pizza this place is at the top of the list, but their chicken tops it. They have the best fried chicken in the area. If you're nearby give it a try. read more