Of course, we needed to grab some pizza while in Buffalo and opted to stop by Bella Pizza on a hopping Saturday night for some slices to go. We had called in an order for some cheese slices, some pepperoni slices and a salad. When we got the food out, however, it turns out we got all cheese slices. The salad was loaded with black olives, tomatoes, onion, cucumber, and cheese. The dressing was well packaged in a small cup wrapped in plastic, perfect for transit. The food was all quite tasty and was much enjoyed. Staff was courteous and efficient. There is a small parking lot available out front and it was hopping! We saw someone come out with a giant pizza that must have been the party size - very impressive and no doubt great for a crowd! read more

See all

Stopped at Bella's and got a Ham Sub that was pretty heavy was perfectly made and a toasted roll! And some mild wings that was crispy and meaty delicious! When was there saw the pizza in the case and just had to get some love there pizza with plenty of spicy pepperoni and cheese and great sauce. Me and my daughter had a great dinner enjoyed everything. It was a busy afternoon and the ordering and pickup was great service the counter girl did a great job and was very pleasant despite the crowd coming and going read more

Bella Pizza - Ham sub with oil and mayo - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Food: everything here is 5/5. The pizza is always consistent and I've been ordering here since the early 2000s. You can't go wrong with cheese and pep and they have specials for a large pizza on Mon and Wed. Also, you should always order the breadsticks. You get a single order of 5 with a cup of sauce and they are a nice little appetizer. Service: also 5/5. The staff are quick and efficient because there is usually a line, but they are always so nice. Ambiance: it's a pizza shop so I don't know what you would expect. They have a large counter with slices and breadsticks ready to go for lunch, and a dessert case. They also have cold pop to pair with your meal. The dining room is closed but always looked clean. read more

Bella Pizza - Large Cheese Plus One Item - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The delivery person delivered my food to the wrong house next door . Thank goodness my neighbors are nice and brought the food over to us. Do better delivery person! read more

I ordered a assorted wrap to be delivered... I asked for it to be cut in half, double onion, mayo, oil, light tomatoes and lettuce. I was told that it is automatically cut in half.... The wrap was delivered and it was not cut in half, there was NO lettuce or tomato , and NO oil and mayo. It was wrapped so loose that as soon as I wrapped it and picked it up and tried to wat my 1st bite, the whole thing fell apart and fell on the floor. I immediately called Bella to let them know. They offered to replace it, I told them that I wasn't going to be her, would be leaving very soon and wouldn't be around to wait for it. The manager offered to give me credit for only half of it, oh and I was also told that the person who took my order lied about them automatically cut in half and they sometimes so write down the specific instructions. When i asked why she only wanted to reimburse me for only half, her actual response was: " How do I know that you are not lying? Really how rude and unprofessional. I easily would have returned the item back to them if they wanted. I was so offended by being called a liar, that said never mind and just hung up. I have been ordering from them for over 10 years. And, this is how you treat a regular customer?? I am totally disgusted with this service. Shame on you read more

Best pizza! Bella is always my first stop when visiting family back home, I won't go anywhere else!

Used to order from them all the time and now there refusing my order. I called and told the person that I was going to do a delivery with a credit card. After she gave attitude towards me before giving the credit card so I hung up. So a delivery guy shows up and I had to refuse the delivery. I educated the drive of what happened on the phone and that I only had credit card. Bella used to be great but went downhill quick. I will do business elsewhere read more

This is the best pizza and wings hands down! We order from here a couple times a month and I stop in for a slice when I'm working. Today we ordered for the Bills game online and went to go pick it up and the car wouldn't start . I called back to let them know and they offered to deliver instead which I completely embraced! They originally thought it was a street closer to them but we ended up being out of their delivery zone and delivered it to us anyway! Thank you guys so much for providing amazing food and hospitality and excellent service to your customers! We can't thank you enough and we tell everyone that the very best pizza and wings are at Bella's! read more

Love the pizza here. Giant slice with pepperoni crisped, cupped edges... delicious. The stuffed banana pepper pizza is my favorite. Def a must try if you never had it before. They used to have the dining area open which make the place feel as if it always about to close. Not much to the inside as you walk in through two doors to give your name/order to get your food. Gets quite cramped inside on busy days. People sometimes can block the door as you're trying to exit with food. All in all, a good place for pizza. Expensive, but good. If you're in the southtowns try this place out as they have locations in Lackawanna, Boston, and Lakeview. read more

Chicken wings were old the bones were black that's a sign that they have been around for a while.

My husband's favorite; pretty sure it's because he grew up with it. Their pizza is consistently good - thick "Buffalo-style" crust, plenty of cheese, and the classic cup n' char pepperoni. I also love their crinkle cut fries and chicken fingers (they're big and have a crunchy coating). Some how the fries manage to stay hot and crispy despite a 35 minute drive. It might have something to do with the way they package them, tightly enclosed in a couple sub bags. Try the pizza for yourself! It's a Buffalo classic done right. read more

Bella Pizza - My husband favorite pizza of all time - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Wings were very good. Ordered cheese pizza and got pepperoni:/ I don't eat pork so that was a waste unfortunately. Otherwise it's good food.

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 29 BELLA PIZZA SOUTH PARK AVE. LACKAWANNA, NY SCORE 8.8 "We Take Pizza Seriously" quoted on the custom box. Bella is one of the most suggested to me and it most definitely lived up to the hype! Located in south Lackawanna just near the edge of Blasdell, this is one of three locations. Decent size building with full parking and a dining room which was unfortunately closed. Staff was friendly and the pizza was fantastic! The sauce was phenomenal and it had just the right amount of cheese. My only complaint is the bottom was a bit soft. Also, I highly recommend you add a side of breadsticks! Comment where I should review next! read more

Bella Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

If you are looking for a new carry out spot, then I have the spot for you! We have been ordering here for almost a year and love this place. 100 % accuracy. Always pick up per our preference .Clean and nice decor in the business. Great owner! The ranch is to die for! The food is always fresh and tasty. Amazing salads and Mac and cheese bites, as well as chicken tenders and pizza to name a few favorites. I can't say enough nice things about this place! Please check them out for your next Lions game read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The pizza and wings are delicious and a great value I get the medium cheese and all flats wings

I give this place 2 thumbs down , ordered from here about 2 weeks ago, we were down the street at a meat raffle and our group didn't have food ‍ anyway! We had wings and pizza it took us almost a H.R. to get. When some of us probably coulda walked to get it. every thing was with the wings and most of us thought the pizza was ok to...... UNTIL I found a long piece of HAIR in my slice ‍‍‍‍ the only reason I saw it was because I'm a hand eater so I breaking mine into squares and there it was a long piece of somebody's hair between the sauce and cheese YUCK!!!! This is an hour go to pizza spot and if we were not there for that raffle we would never have ordered from there anyway , Needless to say we won't order from there again to sell at your own risk. read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Great staff. Hearty pizza and they deliver !!!!!!!!! That's a plus!!!!!!! I'll be ordering again if I come to buffslo read more

I've been a long time customer of Bella and love the pizza and fingers, but I was extremely disappointed in a sausage sub that had no tomatoes, very little lettuce and the roll wasn't toasted, was just awful for the high price. read more

We do not order out often but I was just tired. Ordered two pasta dinners. One baked ziti, one veal parm, lots of sauce, I specifically asked for extra sauce!! Took over one hour to be delivered. The baked ziti was spaghetti parm? Veal parm was dry, no sauce on veal or spaghetti??? And it was cold read more

This is a family favorite. We love the pizza and wings I am enjoying a pepperoni with black olives pizza And the wings are so good. Hot wings bone in. The prices have gone up every year read more

I have been hearing positive things about Bella Pizza for years and tried it today. I am usually disappointed when I take peoples advice on good pizza as I LOVE pizza more than most. Bella was absolutely delicious for a traditional Buffalo Pizza! The staff was super nice too. I would highly recommend. read more

Have always loved their garlic parm wings here! all their wings are delicious-fresh and nice white meat. BUT can't take the inconsistency anymore. The money I spend on wings here to get them different every time is very annoying. Sometimes dry. Sometimes wet. Sometimes crisp. Sometimes not. Sometimes big. Sometimes small. And they never listen to my order!! I'd say extra sauce on the wings then they are dry or the wrong flavor of wings will have extra. They don't listen. I will not be ordering from there anymore. Too annoying to look past. Shame read more

Our first time at this pizza place and it was great! The pepperoni pizza was amazing and the garlic bread was crazy garlicky! We even ordered the curly fries that was nice and crunchy. I loved the chocolate chip cream cheese cookie that was amazing. The service was also great! I'll be going back! read more

Bella Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

This pizza is decent for Buffalo style pizza, if you are a fan of this style of pizza. There is too much sauce, and the cheese and toppings werent evenly distributed. The wings were pretty good. Nothing to write home about, but this place is decent. read more

See all

if you're using tap pay do not go to this business. They are taking your full amount of money off your card and then telling you that you owe additional money. I just paid $80 for $50 pizza and then had to pay an additional couple bucks that's ridiculous and the manager Jay is awful. She has a shitty attitude and she doesn't know how to have a good customer service zero out of 10. read more

Our usual pizzeria was closed on Father's day so we opted for our second favorite which is a bit of drive for is but well worth it. Our cheese and pepperoni pizza was ready exactly on time and it was extremely quick service picking it up. It was a great pie as always with the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. read more

Never ever again !!!!! You just cannot get what you order from this place EVER. I come here because I live up the road BUT NEVER AGAIN. So sick and tired of not getting my order right. I ordered a turkey club. Got home and had turkey on plain dry roll. Now I come back for what I ordered and they give me a turkey club AND a assorted sub I didnt even order. Omg who runs this place. In the past I have ordered wings that came with no sauce. Mozzarella sticks that came with no sauce and fried mushrooms that came short of the order WITH no sauce. I'm dine here... Oh and when I went back for the marinara sauce for the Mozzarella sticks we has a spaghetti noodle in it. read more

Bella Pizza - Marinara sauce for mozzarella sticks with a spaghetti noodle in it - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

My wife loved her chicken fajita pizza. I liked the cheese and pepperoni however it was very greasy. We loved their Greek salad. We ate in and the place is not the cleanest. They are so busy they could use and extra person to make sure tables are bused and the floor is kept clean. Also the beverage machine was out of coke and was never changed during our visit. read more

Ordered the special pizza of the month which was chicken white and as always the pizza was really good. Also ordered a single order of wings and not a single drumstick. All "flats". Dissapointing but tasty. Seems Bella is still decent for pizza and wings but thats all I will order from here anymore. As this place began to chain out in the area and open new locations, the quality on everything else has fallen dramatically, which is ironic because I hear the quality of subs etc at other Bella locations is supposedly great. Prices steadily rise up and up. 3 stars at best here. read more

Bella Pizza - Not a single drumstick. All flats! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

There I was, thinking Bella was just an emotionless basic, turned into a vampire by Robert "how did the Twilight books even get published" Pattinson. That changed as I put this in my mouth. No, not *this*. I'm talking about *that* (points to the Pizza pic). I still love Imperial, Mattina's, Mineo's, Franco's on Eggert, Good Guys, Pizza Oven and Ventry's in NF and more, but Bella soared to the top of my pizza list with the sexiest, gooiest, lusciousest, amazingest slices that ever caused me to use words that don't even exist. Hence it's my 2,500th review (this is becoming déja vu), so I'm going to rap about it. Yo. Yo my name is Fox and I'm a strange Fella, I eat pretty much anything but Salmonella, F. Scott Fitzgerald's cool but I prefer Ella, And Burning Man's nice but I'd rather do Coachella. I went to the bank and there was a cute Teller, I sweet-talked him into coming to my Cellar, We role-played, I was Yoda, he was Helen Keller, He showed me how to Windmill, I taught him to Propeller. I said my diamond's so hard I make that Tiffany Jeller, He said I make sausage disappear faster than Penn & Teller, I said you make The Jam better than Paul Weller, But is it really meant to be the colour of Nutella? So then he was hungry, I was hungry as Wella, (Please no comments on my skill as a Speller), I said, there's this place where the pizza is Hella, Good, so I took him and we went to eat at Bella! Best Buffalo-style Pizza I've ever had. I loved Zip's (hit or miss), Imperial (still do), but Bella is juicier, tastier, wetter, better. But I've heard that wetter *is* better. Synonyms aside, if you don't like Buffalo-style Pizza, try Bella's huge, hot, melty, slippery, saucy, sexy slice, and put your pizza palate to the ultimate test in WNY terms. It really is that good, that if you don't like it, I will admit you just don't like Buffy Pizza and will stop trying. But don't be afraid of how wet, slippery, piping hot (always make sure it's piping hot), cheesy, bready, and pepperoni-y it is. Some don't like sweet pizza, but I don't find this sweet. There are hints of sugar in almost everything made in America (lol) but this is rich and perfect like David Beckham. Not dark/heavy/salty, but certainly not syrupy. For sweet, head up to Lockport's Pizza Oven - so sweet, but not my thing. Now if you *do* like Buffalo Pizza, then holy moly, or molé if you go to nearby Vallé of Méxicoé (trying to use as many accéntéd és as possiblé bécausé I héard from a friénd of a formér lovér that accénts gét guys laid. You can névér say I didn't try, amirité?) But yes if you *do*, then try Bella. You may find your new fave. Big, wet, melty-cheesy, greasy-pepperoni, shiny-shimmery, sexy-slippery, one of the best slices I've ever put in my mouth (and I've put plenty in my mouth, so to speak), it inches (I love the word inches) ahead of others for many reasons including consistency. I've yet to be given a cold, dry or congealed slice, or one which didn't equal previous standards. No other WNY Pizzeria has achieved that unrivaled consistency in my experience, nor do most taste anywhere near this good. The biggest testament to excellence: I drive 45 mins from my house to get here (well, 35, but if any cops are reading, it was a typo, I meant 45), passing 238 pizzerias on the way. Nearby Imperial (top 5, I often get both) is dry, doughier, still unequivocally delicious. The wings here are good, but I prefer Imperial & Wise Guys (Hertel). Come down to South Buffalo, try Mineo's, Imperial, Bella. Don't judge WNY Pizza until then. Bella gave me my groove back just like Stella, The crust is so good it can be eaten Acapella, The cheese is like Chris Martin (all Yella), With crispy Pepperoni swimming in the Mozarella. If it was in Brazil it would rule the Favela, If my tummy is a cell then this pizza's the Flagella, If Pizza Hut's a one-liner, this is a Novella, This slice is "Taylor Lautner", not Edward or Bella. I ran so fast to get here, I ruptured my Patella, When I slipped in the rain and almost caught Rubella, Until Rihanna let me stand under her Umbrella. Ella Ella. Eh Eh Eh. We went to the Pub and we shared a pint of Stella, We Netflix & Chilled while we watched Barbarella, We made out and listened to Michael Jackson's Thrella, She showed me her Hopeless Place, I showed her my Goodfella. I had her like Cabaret had Liza Minella, I got repelled like Citronella when I ate her Paella, But I chose not to tell her, that she smelled of Mortadella, Cuz she looked like Cinderella and I ruled her like Mandela. She said "I went to Harvard" so I showed her my Cornella, Then I asked Ri Ri if she'd be my Abuela, She said "that means Granny!" and tried to cap me like Old Yeller, I ran away, but after days, I could still smell her... So I wrote a tell-all book and it became a bestseller. (But the straight-to-TV movie was less-than-stellar). (And since you asked, I'm a grower *and* a shower *and* a sweller). read more

See all

I stop by Bella's for a slice just about every time I go visit my parents since it's along the way. Their slices are huge. Matter of fact, their slices are so big that they do not fit in the typical pizza slice boxes so they use large styrofoam take out containers. A big thing for me to make a good pizza is the sauce and Bella's sauce is flavorful and plentiful, I've also gotten a ham sub from there and that was good too. The dining area is huge so you can always find a place to sit and eat and the staff has always been friendly and pleasant. Highly recommend! read more

Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This place is one of the best pizza places in the area. That's why I wanted to support them during the pandemic by getting takeout. This is my seventh time here. This pizzeria suggests ordering online and then paying online with a credit card to reduce unnecessary contact during the pandemic. I ordered and paid that way. I ordered mild chicken fingers which came with blue cheese and fries. I asked for a larger blue cheese while ordering. I also ordered a small cheeseburger bacon pizza. The base was cheddar cheese and it was absolutely fantastic. A coworker told me (months ago) that their chicken fingers are the best in the area and that's SO true!!! There is a barrier that hangs low between the customer and the cashier, with enough room to slip your food to you. There was a minimal wait. The last time I ordered from here was three months ago. I ordered a sheet pizza and wings. The cheese and pepperoni pizza was really good. The wings were great. I will continue to support this awesome business. read more

See all

Miracle Whip on a chicken finger sub?!? Not a fan of this place, Very overpriced for bad food

The food was good. I especially love their breadsticks. The pizza had a lot of sauce though. The service is good. Idk about the ambiance. read more

My family has been avid Bella customers since they opened in Lackawanna. Tonight I placed a large order, including 2 whole subs, a large julienne salad, a double order of stuffed mushrooms, and a slice. When I got home from picking it up, my husband 2 bites of his chicken parmesan sub to find that the fingers were burnt to a crisp. We called and after a few tries we got through. We were connected with a manager named Luciano. He offered to make a new sub and send it out, but based on how busy they are, the time it takes to make a new sub, and deliver it to my house, it would have taken well over 30 minutes. The alternative was to place a credit on my acct for 1/2 a sub. I can't see compensating the cost of 1/2 a sub when the entire sub is not edible. Luciano stated that those are the only to options he could offer. I would have no problem bringing the burnt sub back to the restaurant tomorrow, but as I have company tonight that it would more rude for me to leave than how Luciano stated is able to "fix" the situation! I am flabbergasted that this how such a good company instructs its managers to handle mistakes made in their business; on their "calling card read more

Bella Pizza - Burnt chicken parmesan sub - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

I prefer thin crust NY style pizza. I know that's an unpopular opinion in Buffalo and I was convinced into trying their pizza. I'm still not the biggest fan of plain cheese or pepperoni, but everyone needs to try their cowboy steak pizza. It sounds like it's a lot going on, but it's a perfect meal. BBQ sauce base, with steak, melted cheese, and topped with crispy thick-cut onion rings. Every pizza you get is huge, so you'll have plenty of food, even with a small pie. Their breadsticks are also great. Perfectly seasoned with lots of Parmesan cheese sprinkled on, served with a red sauce. The thing I'm not the biggest fan of is the wings. Yes, they're super big, but usually that makes them a little fattier than I like. I also prefer my wings to be a little crispier on the outside and I feel that their wings usually don't hit that mark. read more

Cheese and pepperoni pizza was delicious today. The garlic Parmesan wings were great as always. The price was outrageous but that's because the cost of wings are crazy since COVID. The reason I'm writing this review is because of the cashier. She was a young attentive lady that was courteous and seemed to want to work. You don't get manners nowadays with the youth working at restaurants and she was happy to be there. It says a lot because so many businesses can't function properly because people don't want to work ... which is why the dining area is closed. Very pleased with everything! read more

Another fantastic visit. I will say, however, that this is not cheap pizza. A large cheese and pepperoni with 20 wings cost us $30 for their special. I did want to make a note that this restaurant needs to pay more attention to the cleanliness of their bathrooms. The women's room was out of paper towels when we were there. How is this possible? Your employees are using this bathroom and I assume they're washing their hands before they go back to touching food, RIGHT?? Aren't they more than well aware that you're out of paper towels? Also, mopping is good for daily cleaning, but occasionally you do have to get on your hands and knees and scrub into the corners of the bathroom. Built up dirt and filth was in all the corners of the women's restroom. Gross. And the men's restroom reeked like urine ( we had to go in to get some paper towels.) Once you pay a little more attention to increasing the cleanliness of the bathrooms, this would go up to another 5 star review again read more

See all

I have grown up with Bella's. I remember when they were in a small store front next to dairy queen. So for almost 50 years this place has been spectacular. so I now live in Cleveland and will always stop in for pizza and wings when I'm in Lackawanna. The assorted subs with oil and onions is another favorite. Wings are outstanding. My mouth waters when I think of Bella's. The pizza has pepperoni that curls up and the edges burn to give a perfect pool of grease and char. Go here!!!!! read more

My co workers and I have been looking for a new pizza place that offers something that we all enjoy. One of them lives around the corner from Bella's and suggested we try it because she enjoys their food. This was a good call from her, I was completely satisfied with my pizza. It was made exactly the way I asked for it and the sauce on the pizza was sooooooo good!! The customer service was good and the food was still hot and tasty by the time I got back to work. I wasn't able to finish my entire personal pizza so I refrigerated what I had left and I enjoyed the cold pizza just as much as the hot pizza.. We also had some fries, CRINKLE CUT, those were AMAZING! There are not many places who sell crinkle cut fries so this was a major plus for me.. This is a must try for pizza.. I will be visiting more often to try out other things.. read more

Bella Pizza - Personal Pizza with Pep, Mushrooms and Extra Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all