Food: 1/5 So forgettable. It was just not good. Neither the pizza nor the spaghetti were memorable…read moreat all. Now they weren't that bad, but I have no idea how this place is still in operation. Service: 2/5 The lady behind the counter wasn't rude but she wasn't that nice either. It just felt like the staff were waiting for us to leave (it was the middle of the day). I won't be going back and I wonder how much longer this place will hold on. Then again, who knows... Ambiance: 3/5 It had pizza place from the 90's vibes, which was nice, but it also wasn't all that clean and the salad bar had seen better days. Overall, I would not recommend it, nor would I go back.

Good thin crust. Lots of toppings. Reasonably priced. I wish they were closer to where we liveread more

Delicious! Lasagne, garlic toast, salad for lunch. A small order of lasagne is more like the…read moreregular size at other places. Everything tasted fresh. I highly recommend!

My wife and I were traveling through the area and stayed at a local area hotel…read more We decided to give this pizza restaurant a try. Glad we did, the pizza was delicious, garlic cheese bread as well was great. The young lady who waited on us was very polite and attentive. Great overall experience.

Went to The Shop for the first time last night . We went to see a band (The Benders) that we had…read morenot seen for many years. We had a great time! People were friendly and so was the staff. The band was great! We will probably go back even if the band is not there. Very small, dive bar feel, but we were very comfortable and had fun.

Really great place to get your drink on! Never have an empty glass and always have friendly…read moreservice. They have sports nights,music nights, and more. Also pool tables and shuffle board! My friends and I have a blast here!

I don't know if corporate or the local store did something unexpected, they refunded the full…read moreamount of the order that 4 out of 5 items that had mistakes. To be fair, my last review was done before any refund was made, nor did anyone contact me, so I will be giving them another chance to earn my business as I have enjoyed this Domino's for years and didn't want to find another pizza store. So give them a chance to earn your business, but stand up if its not what you've ordered, but also give them the praise when they do it right.

Staff here is always so friendly and their service and food is always on point. New management…read morereally turned this place around. Definitely recommend

We had a family dinner celebrating a birthday for our grandson turning 10 years old. The menu…read moreoffers plenty of choices so that everyone could find something they loved. The food was delicious and served in a timely matter. The portions and prices were reasonable. We had great service and we were able to bring our own birthday cake. The server offered us plates and forks when time came to eat it. We had plenty of elbow room at our table of 7 with not only help from our waiter but others would also go by and offer assistance. When it came time to pay our bill we were given split checks without any issues which was most appreciated. The dining area is large with lots of TVs for those that want to watch sports. Great place for all.

For some reason they've switched their menu to being a bar menu pretty early on a weekend . I've…read morewent in twice to get food just looking for some life and they try to give me a fried food menu . I live in Derby thought I would try then but they're not converting me over. Sad. Not the way to win new customers. I member when the same thing happened to Player's years ago. It might save money in short-term but it can be the start of a death spiral.

I've had friends rave about this restaurant for years so I finally tried it out. I wish I had a…read moremore positive experience. Portions were very small. We only got two very small pieces of bread and when we asked for more we were told it would be $4 additional. My wife got a vegetarian bow tie pasta but there were very few vegetables - it was virtually all pasta and lacked flavor. The sausage ravioli was decent but I left hungry. The bright spots were the ambience and the server - nice dining room and a rooftop patio. The server was very sweet.

Food was well cooked and with very good flavors. The quality of the charcuterie products was…read moreamazing.

Ordered to be ready at a specific time and they made it an hour and half early. So we are now…read moreeating a cold pizza!

Service is SOOO SLOW. If you insist on ordering pizza from here, give it at least an hour, even if…read morethey say 20 minutes. They are are understaffed and the staff they do have has no sense of urgency when the orders come in.

Very disappointed as of 1-20-2026. The pizza ingredients are not equal to several months ago, and…read morealso the flavor is not good. I think they are freezing the ingredients, which decreases the flavor. They obviously are not fresh as they were in the past. I think the previous employees quit there positions and these new hired employees dont accept their responsibilities. There was no employee at the counter for several minutes, and she was negligible. The current employees need to be replaced by responsible employees or this place will close. I ordered from Godfathers about every 2 weeks, previously, but I will not place another order ever again. It's a long drive for a pizza that is not nearly as favorable as it used to be. Soooo disappointed.

Okay soooo apparently don't order from inside is what I am gathering from the other reviews?? My…read moreonly experience is delivery through DoorDash. To be completely transparent, I've done a ton of traveling and if the food tastes good to me, I'll pay whatever price within reason so the prices don't bother me. Inflation is here to stay and if it's THAT much of an issue for you, Little Caesars is right down the street for much cheaper, but you'll sacrifice taste and quality. I am usually a coal oven or wood fire pizza only Neapolitan or NY style pizza only kind of gal. However, for being neither of those things Godfather's Pizza is quite good. It does not "taste" chain to me, and I can indulge and not feel like complete trash after eating it. Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, and Dominoes are all within a couple of miles of Godfather's and having had all of them several times----Godfather's is the clear winner for me. There are a multitude of specialty pizzas in a generous number of sizes including mini which you don't find very often. Even the mini pizza had generous toppings, was made with care, and it was less than 10 dollars. The several times we have ordered, the cheese is plentiful, the toppings are evenly distributed, and our order has been 100% correct each time. Also, they actually cut CLEANLY through their pizzas! I don't know why but for whatever reason all the other chains in this area really struggle to cut their pizzas cleanly, so I am always having to run a knife through them anyway or the slices are tearing weird. I won't lie, looking at pictures of the pizza, they don't really look all that visually appealing but the taste is very solid. I also could wager that they don't travel all that well. Being heavy on the toppings and thicker slices I can imagine any travel time beyond like 10-15 minutes the pizzas probably become soggy pretty quickly. But overall, have I had better? Yes. Have I had worse? By far. But when you're looking for quick, convenient and most importantly tasty pizza---really I don't have any major criticisms and will continue to give them my business.

It's located just off a main road, but you can't miss the sign. If you need a quick drink or snack,…read moreget in and get it. The place is new, clean, spacious, had fast filling gas pumps and PIZZA! Pizza seems to be one of the big draws for a Casey's. They make their own from scratch daily. Fresh when you order.

I would have never thought a gas station would have awesome pizza . It's a little to greasy but…read moreit's so good!