This place is usually hit or miss on whether you will get a good pizza or not and $26 for three topping small pizza is way too much for subpar half bad pizza read more

Okay soooo apparently don't order from inside is what I am gathering from the other reviews?? My only experience is delivery through DoorDash. To be completely transparent, I've done a ton of traveling and if the food tastes good to me, I'll pay whatever price within reason so the prices don't bother me. Inflation is here to stay and if it's THAT much of an issue for you, Little Caesars is right down the street for much cheaper, but you'll sacrifice taste and quality. I am usually a coal oven or wood fire pizza only Neapolitan or NY style pizza only kind of gal. However, for being neither of those things Godfather's Pizza is quite good. It does not "taste" chain to me, and I can indulge and not feel like complete trash after eating it. Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, and Dominoes are all within a couple of miles of Godfather's and having had all of them several times----Godfather's is the clear winner for me. There are a multitude of specialty pizzas in a generous number of sizes including mini which you don't find very often. Even the mini pizza had generous toppings, was made with care, and it was less than 10 dollars. The several times we have ordered, the cheese is plentiful, the toppings are evenly distributed, and our order has been 100% correct each time. Also, they actually cut CLEANLY through their pizzas! I don't know why but for whatever reason all the other chains in this area really struggle to cut their pizzas cleanly, so I am always having to run a knife through them anyway or the slices are tearing weird. I won't lie, looking at pictures of the pizza, they don't really look all that visually appealing but the taste is very solid. I also could wager that they don't travel all that well. Being heavy on the toppings and thicker slices I can imagine any travel time beyond like 10-15 minutes the pizzas probably become soggy pretty quickly. But overall, have I had better? Yes. Have I had worse? By far. But when you're looking for quick, convenient and most importantly tasty pizza---really I don't have any major criticisms and will continue to give them my business. read more

Very disappointed as of 1-20-2026. The pizza ingredients are not equal to several months ago, and also the flavor is not good. I think they are freezing the ingredients, which decreases the flavor. They obviously are not fresh as they were in the past. I think the previous employees quit there positions and these new hired employees dont accept their responsibilities. There was no employee at the counter for several minutes, and she was negligible. The current employees need to be replaced by responsible employees or this place will close. I ordered from Godfathers about every 2 weeks, previously, but I will not place another order ever again. It's a long drive for a pizza that is not nearly as favorable as it used to be. Soooo disappointed. read more

Good pizza but NOT a good place to go as they can't handle the pressure of being busy.

Chicken bacon ranch garlic pizza was alright. Service was good and atmosphere was decent. Expensive for such a low grade pizza.

We had not had Godfather's in a long time but we were in the vicinity and had to stop in. We shared a garden salad, Humble Pie pizza and cinnamon monkey bread, all were delicious and just as we remembered. We had plenty of pizza and dessert for lunch the next day. We would highly recommend eating here read more

Worse service ever don't ever go to this place they don't do cash delivery's and they wasted my time

Have not had a Godfather's pizza in decades as it was not available in Texas. Upon return to Kansas, it needed a visit. The location in a shopping area is small but clean. I had wanted to try the advertised buffet, but it was not available. There was a lunch special of two mini pizzas with one topping, so spouse and I tried that. I didn't care for the sauce, but then that is a checkpoint for me with every pizza. The cheese was a little too browned but still "cheesy." Service was "meh." The counter help looked bored with her job and I didn't feel like my business was welcomed. More pickup and carry out customers than dine-in, but it's a good location for that. read more

For a chain establishment I can't say their pizza isn't good. It's very cheesy and loaded with toppings when you want it to be. Decent variety of specialty pizzas. While I don't dine in, when ordering online/phone it's always out quick! read more

This is a shitty place to visit! They are rude and the place is ridiculous dirty. When asked if I could clean the tables they refused and came to clean them half ass. Wow no wonder there was no one eating in the restaurant. read more

Food was great as always. Manger? was rude as could be. Don't think I have been talked to like I was a kid ever by a manager. I really hope she is not the manager as man that is horrible. Made a mistake of looking at what I thought was the food we ordered. And she came unglued cause I opened a box. We were the only people in the store. So when she brought out two mini pizzas. I assumed they were ours. I was wrong and was told that in the rudest way ever. I even offered to pay for new ones for the customer that was somewhere waiting for pizza. But that was not good enough. This person should never be in a place of authority over any team. On top of that she was yelling at her workers in the back and cussing like no other. Never have I seen anything like this at a restaurant. read more

When I go on roads trips on jobs outside of Tulsa I have to find Godfathers at the Loves Gas Stations and they fantastic. Imagine the pure joy that flooded my fatty heart when I learned that an ACTUAL Godfather RESTAURANT existed there. I was amazed how many did not realize ONE was left. The AC went out in the car. Sun beating down as I sweated with anticipation for 11 am to come. Then they opened. The store was clean. The order taker was awesome. The pizza...Classic Combo. Small yield of six pieces. Absolutely everything I hoped it would. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Classic Combo - Pizza Near Me - Wichita, Kansas

See all

Lady at cash register rip me off. Paid more for a medium pizza than a large because you did tell me about the special. First time I'd been there in awhile, took granddaughters won't be back. read more

Ordered the medium combo special with pizza and breadstick. Marinara had a great taste compared to other places. More than enough for 1 person. Delivery was earlier than expected and was as hot as if it came right out of the oven. Two thumbs up for great taste and fast delivery. read more

Extremely disappointed in my trip today. Being an ex manager at two locations in Wichita I am terribly saddened by the fall of this stores business skills and customer service. It seems we just throw the pizza together to get it out of the way. I ordered two half and half pizza extra sauce. Neither were actually half and half and had no sauce. I called and they offered a credit of one pizza. This is rediculous all the way around. I think a credit to just one pizza is not enough especially when I had to drive 30 mins there and 30 mins back. read more

See all

So drove all the way across town to try Godfathers. Last one in town and all of that. Enjoyed the heck out of them when there were a lot of them in town. Wow. What a letdown. 2 medium pizzas and 2 drinks WITH a 4$ off coupon, right at $40!!!! Ok, I splurged. Then sat down to see what $40 worth of pizza tasted like. Friends and I started talking. Watched others get their food. Waited....watched....waited. Finally 45 minutes later GF went up to find out where our food was. Um, er, ah...let me check. Yup, you guessed it. Had not even started it! What!?! There's 2 tables here and we don't have any food!! Hello!!! At least they voided my ticket. Said they would have those right out to us to take with us. They finally got them out to us. I guess I might try it a again, but I'll order it a day ahead of time. read more

I'd go here once a week if I didn't have to drive all the way over here every time because it is always worth the drive! I never tire of the buffet. I enjoy all of the pizza, the salad, the sides, the ease of getting a drink refill. Did I mention the abundant pizza? You know it! Plate after plate of delicious pizza, with the perfect crust you just don't lay to the side! We will be back soon! read more

Godfather's Pizza - More than just pizza here! - Pizza Near Me - Wichita, Kansas

See all

Why I don't order at least over the phone Godfathers Pizza. About a year ago I got double charged for Pizza, I called about it and was told that I would receive the money, $53, back into my account. I called several times to no avail so a bill that should have been for about $53-54 cost me over $100. So much for their promise to reimburse me. read more

Awesome pizza,Godfather's never disappoints. I can't believe I have lived in this area for 22 years and this was my first experience with their lunch buffet. Best mac and cheese anywhere--no lie! Panera has the best "white" mac and cheese,but these guys have the best "yellow" mac and cheese hands down.Excellent salad bar with top notch dressings and all the fixins! Warning: LOL. It WILL render you quite useless after lunch however because it's so easy to over indulge. Good thing I was on vacation this day so I could just go home and rest.Absolutely worth the $9.49! 11am-2pm. daily. You better bring your appetite though! read more

Godfather's Pizza - Their pizza never disappoints but this is hands down the best restaurant mac and cheese I have EVER had! Wow! - Pizza Near Me - Wichita, Kansas

Seriously over priced! $3.99 for a side salad from the salad bar that only had lettuce, croutons, and onions. $2.50 just to add Black Olives on the pizza. The pizza is good but for what they are charging it needs to be EPIC! It also takes forever to get your food but time flies listening to the employees friends holler at them from the from the front counter loud enough for even the customers in the back can hear. read more

Godfather's Pizza - Taco Pie and Key Lime Streusel. - Pizza Near Me - Wichita, Kansas

It has been many many years since I ate at God Father's pizza because it closed in my area. I found another location recently and the pizza that I had ordered tasted very good. I went back 2 to 3 more times. Best pizza read more

Visited Godfathers for the first time in years. Had a personal pizza with beef, sausage, pepperoni and black olives. Was as good as I remember it. Wish I had one close to me. read more

See all

Ate at the only Godfather's left in Wichita. Used to always eat there as a teen and young adult. It was a Monday evening so they weren't busy. The food was pretty much as I remember it. We ordered a medium combo special with a side of monkey bread. The pizza was thick with generous toppings. Very hot and not at all soggy like some places we have gone. It is not super spicy which for us is good. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient. There interior is up to date, clean, not fancy. Looking v forward to going back again. Wish there were more in Wichita and closer to home. read more

We were driving through on 35 and called in our pizza order, and when we told them about when we'd arrive they timed the baking so that we picked it up nice and hot right out of the oven--delicious! We got a large "hot stuff" and got a sweet deal on it. Aside from the online deals they have local in-store offerings, so be sure to call and ask. read more

Still the best pizza in Wichita. The lone restaurant still open here is corporate owned, as the local franchise folded long ago, so the food might be a little cold by the time I get it all the way back home since carry out is now our only option since Covid came along. I'd go five stars if the kids working there would start wearing their masks correctly, and not like chin diapers. read more

I love Godfather's Pizza. This location always gets my order correct. Staff are friendly.

Visited Godfather's Pizza last night. It has been a tradition from about 15 to 20 years ago to take our kids to Godfathers. Now that my wife and I have moved to Atlanta Georgia, and the kids have grown up, we thought it would be fun to go there again. We had over 25 of us between the adults and their kids,and none of us left hungry. The manager was very accommodating for our large group. It brought back a lot of good memories with the breadsticks, taco pizza and streusel dessert pizza. A great time was had by one and all and the food was really good. read more

They have always been my favorite pizza. However, they are getting way too overpriced. Our pizza last night wasn't very good, and the help inside the store really does not give a shit. Getting to the point where, just not worth the effort to go there anymore. If I am going to pay $30 for a pizza, going to go to Old Chicago! read more

Love Godfather's Pizza. It is a unique style of pizza. This location was not particularly great but it still serves good pizza.

We met with family from 4 different towns - some from 3 hours away - for a fun gathering. We ordered 2 large pizzas, a medium pizza, a dessert pizza and beverages. The pizza was absolutely tasteless, over baked, a complete and total disappointment. The dessert pizza was good. Our evening meal out with family was not at all what we had hoped for. Won't be back. read more

It's okay. Not sure if it's better than Pizza Hut's buffet. But it's nice and cheap when you're craving pizza for lunch.

Godfathers is actually the best pizza in Wichita Kansas. This is hands down the best pizza in the city bar none. The sauce, toppings, cheese, and crust, everything is the best. 2nd best is Picasso's but they don't sell a normal size pizza, only by the slice, forget it! Godfather's pizza is so well balanced and delicious. I remember when Pizza Hut used to be the best but now it is a 0. No other pizza business in Wichita Kansas equals God fathers by even 10%. I have tried every pizza business in this city and nothing is really close. I have had better pizza in other States but not in this city of Wichita KS. Order your favorite Pizza at Godfathers and I know you will experience the same. Be sure to order your Pizza with the specific toppings and crust that you enjoy and it will exceed your expectations for Pizza in Wichita Kansas. read more

Haven't had Godfather's Pizza in forever. It's the best pizza ever. A buddy brought some into work! OMG! It was so GOOD!

Ok, an update in the form of a comparison between Godfather's and Little Caesar's....This Godfather's charged me $34.00 for 2 each 8" sized pizzas - a very small supreme, and a very small pepperoni and beef. Wow, after my fiancee and I ate, we were a tiny bit full...their menu says that a small pizza will feed 2-3 people...really? Maybe if the 2-3 people are toddlers, or 2 foot tall pygmies that have already eaten in their Amazon jungle habitat....lol Now with the Little Caesar's that I just got at the South Seneca location (a regular spot for me).... I paid less than $20 for a large 5 meat pizza (new add), and an Extra Most Pepperoni pizza, and an order of crazy bread with sauce.....the quality of the Little Caesar's easily matched the Godfather's in taste, and for less than $3 more than ONE of the skimpy small pizzas from Godfather's, I've got easily 4 to 5 times as much great food as BOTH of the Godfather's whimpy pizzas...our tummies, and bank accounts are much more satisfied with Little Caesar's over this mafia-like dump....I still have a lot of food left over for after work tonight after both of us have eaten completely, spending less than $20....Godfather's, you suck for air! read more

Placed order for $24.99 deal, added one extra topping and paid approx. $32.00. Called two days later for exact same deal and order and was told the total was $42.00 and the woman refused to explain how she got the total. Called for delivery tonight and was told they were not delivering because the delivery driver's car was broke down. Love their pizza, but they're way over priced, charge what they want when they want depending on who you talk to, inconsistent customer service and sometimes totally rude. How they stay in business is a mystery. Great pizza, if you can get it at the correct price and get lucky enough to get a nice person that day. read more