Pizza King looks like they sell a ton of slices to locals and tourists. They have a window that is convenient to grab a slice or two, eat and then go to the amusement park across the street. They are also conveniently by our Vrbo so we headed there tonight for an easy dinner. Walking up, we saw quite a few pies at the window. They also had pinwheels as well. So many options to pick from. Everything looked OK. The pizzas looked like they were made a while ago. You can tell when a pizza is hot, the grease is glistening still. Non of these pizzas were doing that. My husband and I snagged 2 slices of cheese. Both of the slices were two different sizes, very big difference between the two. I gave my husband the bigger slice. I honestly thought they would have heated up the pizza a little more. They were still cold. The cheese was not even melted or warm. You shouldn't have bothered heating them up cause it didn't do anything for them. The pizza sauce had good flavor to it. There wasn't a lot of it. The cheese itself was there but missing on some parts of the slice. The crust was hard and very chewy since it wasn't warm. I was really hoping for a melty, cheesey, hot slice of pizza. Unfortunately, I didn't get that. I had high hopes for this joint since they always seem so busy. Maybe it was at the hour we came but the pizza just didn't hit. I'm happy we got to try it out anyways. Still looking for that slice is pie is New York that's going to blow my socks off. read more

See all

Good food, reasonable prices, good place for a quick bite decent menu should be open later tho. 8 pm is kinda early for me.

Me and my family have gone here multiple times and the food has been great each time! Food usually comes out fairly quick and is always hot! Great little spot to sit outside and enjoy the sun! read more

The pizza is awful couldn't eat more than a few bites. I would avoid this place. I have nothing more to say but needed more words.

We are giving this a 5 and honestly if they had table service in the bar, this would have been a 5 all day long-so a true 4.8! To be fair, after I ordered at the window, they did bring our food to our table inside the bar. You do have to go to the bar to grab your drinks. Fun selection of beers, mozzarella sticks were AMAZING. Obviously homemade-not frozen. Wings were crispy and sauce was excellent. So Good!!!! Pizza was good as well. Owner was there working and was friendly. He changed a keg, took out the trash and was pulling in tables at closing time. Definitely not a slacker. read more

See all

Fantastic pizza. The owner Dan is a great guy. He really cares about his employees and customers.

Very good pizza with a great sauce and awesome crust. They have an outside window and picnic tables to eat at. Service is very good. read more

Pizza King and Grill - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Sylvan Beach, New York

See all

Everything here is good and they have a good selection of beers. Their wings and pizza are excellent

5 orders of Chicken Fingers to go & only received 3. No napkins or the Ranch i asked for. Then yesterday My Daughters walked there and ordered 4 garlic knots. They received only 2. My daughters walked back and asked for the rest of the orders. The rude woman said it "is what it is" and then slammed the sliding window and walked away. Months ago we all walked there and got slices of pizza. Everything was fine until i asked for napkins. The same girl gave me an attitude. She grabbed the napkins aggressively. Slammed them on the outside counter and shut the window in my face. Not sure how the owner is ok with this hints this continues to happen!!!!! read more

Sylvan Beach is really lucky to have such a solid pizza spot, and although I'm not a drinker myself, the bar has a great beachy vibe and i love hanging out there! read more

Overall pizza and food was excellent. Prices were a bit steep but order was prepared quick and good so really can't complain. Would recommend! read more

I order. Cheese to edges I made it clear I would pay ! I get there and for 25.00 I got mostly crust worst ever ' I will not be back will not recommend! If you can't do what a customer wants tell them don't lie and say sorry that's the way it comes' read more

Pizza King and Grill - Crust - Pizza Near Me - Sylvan Beach, New York

Two words: garlic knots. These are easily some of the best garlic knots I've ever had. They're huge, perfectly baked (crispy on the outside and soft on the inside), and completely smothered in garlic butter. The pizza was on the same level--real-deal New York pizza with a perfect crust. This place blew my expectations out of the water and definitely lived up to the name "Pizza King." read more

Pizza King and Grill - slice of plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sylvan Beach, New York

See all

Great food, awesome pizza, great service. Love the outdoor bar, super convenient. Be back soon!

Never a dull moment here! Great crowd! Lots of great beers to choose from. Awesome staff.

You can't go wrong here, folks. I am a pizza lover and very picky. Crust was exactly the way it should be Foldable but crispy too. Sauce cheese and pepperoni was correct mixture. Not at all what I expected for a pizza shop in Sylvan Beach, NY! Owner was awesome. He brought out water for some pups on a hot evening. Who does that? This place is a gem! read more

Excellent place for friends and family to enjoy pizza and a beer. Service is amazing, food is even better.

Good pizza- char grilled wings are delicious!! Truly recommend. YUM. The owner is a friendly person who makes the effort to greet and get to know his customers. read more

Greatly enjoy the teriyaki boneless wings here, they also have great New York style pizza. Always have slices on hand, take out, dine in or delivery. My mouth is watering thinking of those bonelsss wings!!! Did I mention I loved the wings? Good choices in sauces but my go to...teriyaki! read more

Don and the Pizza King staff were top notch when it came to delivering one hundred wings and french fries for our nephew's 21st birthday party!!! Wings are his favorite and Pizza King's were a hit with him and the rest of the gang! A big thank you goes out to Don and his wife for taking on our large order and going the extra mile. Terrific customer service!!! read more

Solid pizza, thin, crisp, not too greasy. Easy in and out for pickup. Great spot in sylvan.

Best garlic knots I've had hands down. Spicy garlic wings are great. Staff are friendly and helpful. Food is fresh. A weekly staple for me.

Really expected this place to be mediocre at best.. we were very surprised and this is THE best pizza I've ever had! And I've had a lot of pizza. I'm not sure about the other food, but the pizza is on the money. You won't be disappointed. read more

Ordered delivery, came quickly on weekend evening. No mistakes. Garlic knots fantastic, portions good. Salad fresh.

Utica Greens Steak and Cheese with Pepperjack Cheese is amazing!! The owner was really cool too, don't leave Sylvan Beach without stopping in, the pizza is also amazing! read more

The staff were extremely rude and the food was terrible. I have a mixed race family and I have never had an experience before that we were being treated differently until we went here. Firstly, they were rude and seemed annoyed when we were ordering our food. Next, when our order was done they placed it on the counter and yelled out to us. There were two other families there and they had their food brought to them and were treated very nicely. I will NEVER EAT HERE AGAIN!!! read more

I ordered pizza and wings from Pizza King on a busy Sunday night in the Beach. Called ahead to order a small pizza and was told "we don' t have small, just medium and large" so I got the medium with two toppings. I also got an order of char-broiled wings. I was a little surprised when I picked up my order to find my total was just short of $20! Took everything home only to discover that there was no blue cheese and no celery for the wings. Not sure if this was an oversight or if these are extras but for the cost, I would have thought at least one blue cheese would be included. The wings were great but quite salty but I'd definitely get them again but next time with the blue cheese! Pizza was just ok, not bad but nothing special either. read more

I'm pizza-picky. So while vacationing with the in laws up in Sylvan Beach my wife and I got hungry for some lunch and ditched the beach for Pizza King. Good call. The pizza was good and I found the prices to be pretty good. We had a pepperoni slice and a buffalo chicken slice. Don't be put off by the appearance of the buffalo chicken slice. It LOOKS like chewed up chicken slapped on the pizza. But it tasted awesome (and it was NOT chewed up chicken :P No worries). Had I had the time I would like to've gone back to try the stromboli and a canolli. Both looked very, very tasty. It's also worth noting that Pizza King delivers. I don't know how far away they deliver, but that's a plus if you're renting a place and don't want to drive or try to park down there (which can be a challenge if it's packed, if it's bike night, etc). read more

Visiting friends and we ordered pizza and wings for pick up. Pleasantly surprised how good it was for a beach town pizza joint. Plain cheese (for the kids) and BBQ chicken pizzas were both good. Wings were above average for the area. I'll eat here again without question. read more

We have tried to order pizza numerous times. The pizza has always been burnt and never flavorful. For what you have to pay for a pizza in the beach I guess I can't be too surprised. read more

Our go to Pizza shop, employee's are always friendly. Prices are good, best wings in the beach!!

Terrible. I ordered two orders of chicken tenders, chicken Parm and cheesesteak. The chicken Parm is their frozen tenders with sauce and cheese. Like I needed more tenders. The hoagies were about 8 inches. Very salty. Wasn't worth it. read more

First time in Sylvan Beach and ordered a large regular crust, which was thin & crispy. Pizza was delicious! Toppings were a little sparse. Next time we'll order double pepperoni. We'd also like to try the garlic crust and/or garlic knots. They were out, so they must be rather popular! Price was average for a touristy area. Service was quick for a Saturday night, only 20 minutes! read more

We decided to try this place because in the winter, renting here doesn't really give much options as everything is closed. So we ordered a XL pepperoni pizza and 20 honey BBQ charbroiled wings. The pizza was good, not like Sami's pizza in Bridgeport, NY but not little Cesar's either. BUT the wings were killer awesome! The sauce was not thick, nice sweet thinner sauce. And so we will be ordering again, but mainly to get the wings. read more

The pizza here is so good, and the wings are pretty tasty too...we ordered from them several times and delivery was fast and our order was perfect every time. Thanks for making me put on 5lbs this week Pizza King ! read more

The best Pizza Ive found in the Syracuse area. The place is clean and well maintaned. While I was there is was great to see the detail the workers took in cleaning the place. My only complant is no A/C. It was wayyyyyy to hot in there. read more

Staff was really nice! Lots of options, and the prices were decent, especially considering the location. I will be happy to go again next time I'm in Sylvan Beach! read more

Bland almost flavorless pizza when trying cheese slices - the true test of a pizzeria. "Heated" up the slices, and they were barely warm. $6.53 for 2 plain cheese slices - seriously - in Sylvan Beach N.Y.... Employee even took the shakers of cheese and red pepper flakes off the counter while customers were standing there so they could not be used, and barely acknowledged patrons. First and last visit, spend your money where it is actually appreciated. read more

Pizza was pretty darn good. I love pizza and typically try local pizzas in most cities I visit. Restaurant itself was not as clean as I would have liked, but it was 10 pm on a Saturday at the beach so I'm sure they had been very busy. We ordered a "supreme" and it was loaded. They use some of the best Italian sausage I've ever had. read more

A friend and I biked to Sylvan Beach and had a slice of heaven at Pizza King! Excellent crust, excellent sauce! Proprietors very friendly. And while we were there they turned on what looked like an AC above the door, worked really well. read more