P-King isn't what it use to be for sure. Use to be so damn good, now I am hesitant to Ring the King. Not good like it use to be. Use to be really good. Now it's kind of dry, and onion tasting, not much sauce. Just not good like it use to be. Use to love the sausage. We would come to Bluffton and go up and Ring the king right from the booth. Catch a Covid buzz now walking up in places and touching a phone where others have ringed the king too. Nice little Covid particles in the air I'm sure. Place use to be real good though! Came to Bluffton and ate like a king. Not as much anymore. Food isn't good like it use to be. No Sir read more

Open since 1970, this mom and pop Pizza King should not be confused with the chain of Pizza Kings in Indiana. If you want to check out the website go to: http://www.blufftonpizzaking.com/ I am an out of towner, but my other half grew up in Bluffton and a trip to Pizza King is required dining on every trip home. Today we had a small pepperoni mushroom and a medium Hawaiian. The Hawaiian has an awesome spicy sauce that is bright and flavorful. read more

See all

Love this pizza king. Breadsticks better than any other pizza king- fabulous. We love the bbq sauce pizzas, royal feast, or eve a plain sausage hits the spot. Consistently good. Bit pricey but we don't mind cause it tastes so good! read more

Worst pizza EVER! Looks like they dumped a gallon of tomato sauce on, then burnt it. This was supposed to be half royal feast and half cheese. Since when is a royal feast primarily onion and mushroom? It didn't look like a 50/50 on the topping split either. We paid $36 for this pizza and 6 burnt breadsticks. I would like to say management addressed the issues to our satisfaction when we called to complain, but no. We declined their offer of another of these tasty delights. Not looking for a free meal, just some courteous customer service. Nope! Been going here since 1974. Everything has gone downhill from product to ownership to management. Too bad. read more

See all

Although I no longer live in Bluffton, anytime I can go back I am sure to pick up dinner at this location. I am not quite clear on the differences between this location and the rest of the Pizza Kings throughout the state, one thing I can be sure of is that this is the best! I typically order the Royal Feast, which is a supreme, and their delicious bread sticks. I normally get carryout but the few times I have dined in were great. They offer a buffet during certain hours. The only main drawback is the price. This pizza is EXPENSIVE. 1 large pizza and bread sticks is nearly $40. While there are lots of pizza options in Bluffton that are much more affordable, this is my personal favorite. read more

Went there tonight for a take out order...asked for a bag....was offered a trash bag for carry out...won't do business there again

Born and raised in Muncie, IN. This Bluffton crap is an embarrassment to any other Pizza King I've eaten before. Crappy service, arrogant workers(probably a reflection of the ownership and management). The pizza is nothing at all like any of the others ive had. i would call it hot garbage except on the rare occasion i eat it its always cold(cold garbage). Don't even get me started on the price. Thats the funniest part. Wayyy more expensive than any other Pizza King I've ever eaten before and for a much inferior product. Save ur money and go to tyergers instead. way better and cheaper. or drive to a different town and try their Pizza King or even a better option than pizza from pizza king of Bluffton would be to go to Walmart and buy a frozen pizza. This place is a complete joke. read more

The pizza was good especially the pepperoni chunks. However, the price is outrageous and not worth getting unless someone else is picking up the tab. read more

Ripoff. Says buffet for Friday and Saturday, but it is not. If you ask for a specific pizza, they will not bring it out. Very rude and condesending staff. Save you money, very expensive for what you get, and go elsewhere. Tygers is up the road and the pizza and sanwiches are much better. Nicer people as well. You have been warned about Pizza King, which is not related to the Pizza King franchise. Disgusting people. read more

Never will I go here again. They should not be in a customer service business. On Friday and Saturday evenings they have a pizza buffet. They want you to tell them what kind of pizza you would like so they can put it on the buffet for you. The first time I went, I asked for plain cheese pizza (the only kind of pizza I eat), and they would bring out a pizza that is 1/2 plain cheese. Because they have other customers there, it would disappear quickly and I only got a couple of slices. So I would ask for more plain cheese. I waited and waited and no more plain cheese came out so ended up leaving still hungry. I thought I would try again and this time not leave until I got at least enough pizza to leave and not be hungry. Same thing happened, 1/2 cheese pizza came out, I asked for more, and waited and waited. The resonse was "we already brought out some cheese for you." Nevermind that most of it was eaten by other patrons. I overheard the waitress complaining to other staff that I had been there too long. I am a somewhat shy young man and did not know how to handle the situation so again I left. My family told me not to go back here anymore, but there is not alot of pizza choices in Bluffton so I wanted to try again. Before they seated me, I asked if I could get plain cheese pizza. She told me that last time I was there I was rude! and they did not want my business. I was shocked! I have never been rude. I speak in a more direct manner having moved here from Chicago and I'm shy, but I am certainly not rude. I always use my please and thank you's and am a kind hearted person. If anything, I should have been more insistent on my previous visit that I get enough pizza to leave and not be hungry. After all, you are paying for an all you can eat buffet. But they don't really want you to eat all you can eat, not even close. THIS PLACE NEEDS TO CLOSE! I have never said that about any business before. read more

The pizza is incredibly delicious, but extremely overpriced. Totally recommend the pepperoni pizza and bread sticks.

I like Tyger's pizza much better and their prices are far more reasonable. My husband occasionally will get a hankering for Pizza King (once a year, maybe?) and we will order it. It's far too expensive to eat too often. I gave it 2 stars only because my husband occasionally wants it. If it were up to me, we wouldn't eat here. read more

Our son and daughter in law were home visiting this weekend; everyone decided they were really hungry for Pizza King....so we ordered, picked up our order and came home anticipating a delicious pizza! Well, the royal feast was as delicious as always, but I was mortified when I opened the cheese pizza to serve.....what a shock and disappointment! The cheese pizza....looked as if there were no cheese on it, looked like it had been prepared the day before and tasted even more disappointing.....needless to say, a very sad meal for those who were so very excited about having Pizza King. According to the prices on the menus, one would expect superb food. read more

Ok let me begin by stating the pizza and breadsticks are very good. The pizza is definitely on the expensive side which I was ok with because I knew the prices before ordering or at least I thought I did. The reason for my negative rating is cause upon receiving my bill they proceeded to nickel and dime me for all sorts of stuff above and beyond their already $$$$ prices. One example: I ordered pepperoni and sausage on one half and just ham on the other. Grade school math states that's 1.5 toppings. They charged me for 3 toppings even after discussing/arguing in length with the manager and getting some run around about some fuzzy math they use to determine topping amounts. I was perfectly fine with them charging me for 2 but 3????? Come on!!!!?????? The pizza price only had ballooned to over $30 for a 16 inch 1.5 topping pie. Never again. You have been warned!!!!!! read more