I was super excited to find out that there is a Pizza My Heart in Tracy! I have only been to the Santa Cruz location so it's nice to have one closer. We went for lunch on a Saturday shortly after they opened so it wasn't crowed. It is set up much like the Santa Cruz shop-counter service and seat yourself. The shop is very clean and well kept with a good amount of seating. We each had ordered a slice and I grabbed a pre-made salad which was very fresh. I like how they have extra grab your own cups of dressings available. We also ordered the cookie which was warm, freshly baked chocolate chip and it was divine. I will definitely be returning to try one of their specialty pizzas which are not available to try by the slice. read more

See all

Mixed experience -- one great slice, a lot of frustration. I ordered 5 slices online with a 30-minute pickup window. Instead of being ready, the timer kept pushing back minute by minute until it hit a full hour. When I called, the young lady told me those slices were in high demand and they were slammed, so the wait kept growing. Here's my issue: I ordered and paid an hour ahead. That should put me ahead of walk-ins, not behind them. If a paid online order doesn't reserve your food, what's the point of ordering early? It felt like first-come-first-serve -- except I did come first. The Big Surf was genuinely good. But the cheese slice was dry and sad -- barely any sauce, just a couple squirt lines on top of the cheese instead of sauce spread underneath across the whole slice. It tasted thrown together, which honestly tracks with how rushed everything felt. They also forgot the ranch I paid extra for. For the prices they charge per slice, I expected better. If I come back, it'll only be for the Big Surf -- and only if I'm desperate. read more

If you're in Tracy and craving amazing pizza, this spot hits every time. The pizza was fresh, loaded with flavor, and honestly just what my heart needed after a long day. But what really stood out was the customer service--Jagger went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. You can tell he genuinely cares, and that kind of service makes all the difference. Great pizza, great people, and a place that leaves your heart full. Tracy definitely has a gem here. read more

I love pizza my heart in San Jose. Here it's not the same. The dressings are the same but the pizza taste a bit different. I had the pesto cheese which should be hella good but it's was plain here, bland and no flavor. Like it wasn't even salty. It's 1pm Thursday. There's a bunch of workers standing around who should be bussing tables and cleaning up the soda machine. The container had no forks and there were a handful of knives. read more

Pizza My Heart - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

See all

This was our first time ever at a Pizza My Heart so keep that in mind as you read this. PIZZA: Hubby and I ordered their largest size, an 18" whole pie, doing half Big Sur and half Cowell's Combo. If you're into a classic combo, Cowell's is the way to go. Both sides were delicious, but I especially loved the seasoned crust on the Big Sur. And can we talk about the complimentary ranch?! I don't know many pizza spots that offer free ranch. They also had bleu cheese, Italian dressing, and a Pesto Ranch, all self-serve. The ranch was thick and so good, and I definitely took advantage because I love ranch with my pizza. WAIT: They're still fairly new, so the line inside was SO long when we arrived. Within about five minutes, a staff member (maybe the owner?) came to the back of the line and asked if we were there for the slices. We said no, we were there for a whole pie, and were able to cut to the register to order, which was awesome and didn't need to wait in the super long line. The girl taking our order was friendly and answered our questions. After ordering, we were quoted 1 hour and 15 minutes lol. We were shocked but decided to wait it out. It ended up being closer to an hour. When we finally opened the box, it was piping hot, I got a full facial from the steam lol. While waiting, I noticed another family get in line but they weren't approached like we were. The staff member was busy at that point, and I overheard them say the line was too long before leaving. Not sure if they were ordering slices or a whole pie, but I do think the business could benefit from posting a sign directing whole-pie orders to the register. It would definitely help with flow and avoid confusion. Pro tip: * If you're there for slices, get in line. I heard someone say it took them just 30 minutes to get through the line. * If you're there for a whole pie, head to the register. Prepare to wait about 1 hour. I recommend going in to order, and then do some shopping nearby. AMBIANCE: Super cute Santa Cruz surf-themed decor. They even had an original ride car from the boardwalk that you could sit in for photos. I overheard a staff member say they bought it off Facebook Marketplace and revamped it, such a fun touch that really adds to the vibe. Overall, a solid pizza spot. We'll definitely be back, I need to try their pepperoni next. Maybe just a slice this time! Oh, and they were running a promo where you got a Pizza My Heart t-shirt for $8 if you ordered (I believe) a slice. It was something like that, (b/c i asked someone how they got the shirt, and she wasn't so sure lol). Sounded like such a fun idea! I wish that applied to whole pie orders too because after waiting an hour for our 18" pizza, (again their largest size) I feel like we definitely earned a t-shirt too!! lol read more

See all

Pizza My Heart has incredible tasting pizza and has always been my go to for pizza in Tracy. I definitely recommend this place!

We tried my heart pizza for the 1st time and was really good. So happy to finally have a place nearby that sells pizza by the slice. read more

See all

The pizza here was honestly mid. I'm so disappointed I even came here, service was great definitely not coming back $17 for 2 slices and a soda is what I paid & btw the pizza doesn't hold itself it's like it just melted back onto the tray when I lifted read more

If you know me, I don't give 5 stars unless I'm like really wowed. But Pizza My Heart in tracy, amazing. I've had them in Santa Cruz, and was amazed and surprised they came to the valley. My son and I went to try it out, I had a slice of the pepperoni and he had cheese. They were super busy, but because they sell by the slice, it went by super fast. Customer service was great, place was a little dirty but I give it to the fact they were busy. We'll be back...hopefully they get their 5 star from me:) read more

See all

First time trying this place! I got the hook and even though its vegetarian I was pleasantly surprised with the taste! It is on the thinner side which I prefer and the crust is very chewy and crunchy as-well. The pesto ranch also paired perfectly with the pizza, it was getting a bit salty near the end but nothing unbearable. Plenty of seating and would recommend! read more

See all

Our pizza was super soggy, we could barely even pick up a slice without all the toppings sliding off. The middle was basically raw with wet toppings, uncooked pepperoni, and too much sauce with barely any cheese. We didn't even finish a slice before throwing the whole box away. Also, all 3 ranch cups we ordered that were $0.50 each weren't even filled 1/4 of the way of the sauce container. 3 of them combined didn't even fill up a whole one. Waste of money. read more

This is our new favorite pizza spot! I've been to other locations and loved the pizza so I was excited when I heard they were coming to Tracy. The inside is so cute and plenty of tables to sit and eat. The vibes remind me when I'm at the beach and want a slice of pizza. I went and ordered a pie the first week they opened and I have to say it was very well organized considering the lines of people. I did have to wait 60 min but that was okay since I was able to run home and come back. When I picked up the pizza it was very hot and fresh and was perfection. The staff working were very nice and helpful and best of all the pizza was delicious. Can't wait to go back! read more

Pizza My Heart - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

See all

A pizza my heart just in my backyard! A 30 minute drive instead of over an hour. The slice and a shirt $8 can't beat that deal. I miss the days of seasoning on the counter to enhance my pizza flavor. My cheese was good but I prefer the pepperoni. I asked for the slices to be cooked well. So there was a nice crisp to my pizza. Good under carriage on both slices and a great flavor on the pepperoni. Great sauce flavor and just right amount of cheese. My only complaint is the pepperoni is pretty greasy. Service was great. It was busy and some pizzas there was a wait for them. Will be back! Love that they serve Coca Cola products! read more

See all

Very good pesto pizza. The flavor was on point. They had the glass bottle sodas at check out, loved that. Customer service was friendly, the restaurant was clean. I would definitely recommend you check them out. read more

I grew up going to the OG location in Capitola during beach trips. This pizza place means something. So I was skeptical! Came in today(5/19/26) as soon as they opened. I am very glad to say I had a great experience. The two young men who opened the restaurant this morning were friendly, and even more important, cooked some pizza worthy of my childhood memories. The service was awesome, the place was immaculately clean, the vibes were great. Best pizza I've had in years. I'm not a heavy sauce guy, so I was worried at first, but the sauce was not at all overpowering. Not too acidic, not too sweet, not too salty. Whoever opened this franchise location really did the OG justice. Tracy can never match beach vibes of the OG, but the food product was spot on read more

Pizza My Heart - Pesto and pepperoni and sausage - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

Excellent customer service! The staff is incredibly friendly, and even though they are clearly very busy, they answer the phone right away with such a welcoming and positive attitude. I ordered online and picked up my order yesterday since it was easier for me. When I arrived, they actually showed me the pizza before handing it over, which I really appreciated--it showed they take pride in what they make and care about their customers' experience. The 18" hook and cheese pizza was absolutely delicious! My family and I really enjoyed it, and we will definitely be coming back again. The only downside is that parking is very limited. I ended up parking over by the Chipotle lot and walking over. On the bright side, I guess I got my workout in for the day--haha! read more

At $30 for a 14" cheese pizza, I feel ripped off. This pizza looked and tasted like a Chef Boyardee pizza kit. I could have bought the prepared dough, sauce and some cheese from WINCO or Trader Joe's and had a superior pizza at a quarter of the cost! read more

Pizza My Heart - Cheese Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

I am completly dossapointed with this Tracy location. My wife and I have been to Pizza of the Heart in the bay area mytiple times and love it. We were excited that they opened one closer to us so we came to try it. I ordered three slices that they had ready and they just needed to warm them up. 30 minutes later after seeing people who came after me eating already and others leaving I had to ask the manager where my order was they couldnt find it. It took them another 10 minutes to figure it out. when i finally got my 3 slices 2 of them were burnt and they were cold never warmed up. I usually dont like to complain but we drove 30 minutes just for this bad experience. read more

Pizza My Heart - 3 cold slices and 2 of them were burnt. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

This was my first time here, and it will definitely be my last. When it came time to pay, I selected "no tip." The cashier deleted my entry twice and had me re-enter the tip option, which made it feel like I was being pressured to leave a tip. If I want to tip, I will do so on my own. Customers shouldn't be made to feel uncomfortable or pushed into leaving a tip, especially when there is no table service involved. To make matters worse, when we finally received our pizza, it was barely warm. This place isn't cheap, so having the food come out cold is definitely not okay -- especially for the price we paid. I really do like supporting local businesses, which makes this experience even more disappointing. Between the uncomfortable tipping situation and the food quality, I won't be returning to this location. read more

Was super excited when I heard Pizza my heart was coming to town. We ordered a half/half Cowells combo and the chicken bacon specialty. Our pizza was soggy AF. I even questioned if it was cooked all the way through. And I usually love leftover pizza but when I went to pik up the pizza just fell apart:( It certainly did not measure up to previous experience with Pizza my heart at other locations. Fell short. Flaccid. read more

Came in with my wife and 3 daughters, we had an amazing experience. Pizza was excellent and felt like we were back in Santa Cruz. Line moved quickly and the entire staff was very tentative to making sure we had everything we needed. Tables were clean and felt very comfortable. Super excited to have Pizza My Heart out in the valley. Can't wait to bring the family back for our once a week pizza my heart dinners. read more

Pizza My Heart - Big Sur - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

Half mushroom, half ham with pineapple was absolutely delicious. Just the right amount of sauce and the crust was amazing. We got the pesto ranch dipping sauce. OMG it was amazing We will be back for sure. So happy they have come to Tracy. Janice and Glenn read more

Great pizza and customer service. Nice place with a bunch of space. I got to see the employees show great patience and mediation skills with an unhinged customer having a tantrum. The employees did really well with the situation. read more

Lilly was great she was extremely patient even though I took forever to order. She made sure my food came out fresh and in a timely manner. I would come back again. read more

I was really excited to try this place. It's a very cute vibe and a fun atmosphere. The staff was friendly and the service was good. My issue was....the pizza. I think the pizza styles are good and flavor options are fun but the pizza itself for me was lack luster. We ordered a few slices to try at the table. Pizza is different for everyone . For me though, I love a good crust, crispy bottom and good sauce to cheese ratio. The pepperoni was so dry. Barely any sauce and cheese. The veggie one was super soggy but to be honest, all pizza slices were far from crispy. The pesto pizza seemed the best still not in love. As for Tracy, Hella Pie will still be my go to! I was hoping for this to be my new spot but I won't be buying pizza there anytime soon. On the up side... the Pesto Ranch was on point! read more

Great place to eat food is awesome and the place is clean Bir Sur Pizza off the hook look like Santa Cruz inside very beach like

Pizza was tasty enough but the crust was so soggy that my slice wilted as soon as I picked it up, especially the ones with veggies. Not even close to the crispy New York style crusts that I expected since their crust is so thin. read more

Stopped by on my way home from work to get a slice since it's been quite a while since I've been to any of their locations. Used to live in Aptos/ Capitola area years ago so would go there quite often. Got the Manressa since thats always been a fave and let me tell you it did not disappoint! Took it home and put it in my oven for 5 minutes to heat it up and get the ricotta all melty and it was fire!! I actually wished I would have gotten 2! Oh well I might just be back tomorrow! I also wanted to mention the customer service was great too! read more

I heard about this place opening in Tracy and decided to stop in for my favorite pizza. I had the privilege to meet Chuck the owner. You can't miss him... based on the "good hair" he obviously came from his other restaurant based out of Santa Cruz. He was super excited to be expanding "over the hill" and into the valley. Super cool dude and glad I stopped in for an order to go. Keep up the "cool hair" Chuck and it was a pleasure to meet you. read more

My daughter and I visited this long awaited establishment today! The wait time for our order was a bit long but that's because it was a busy Friday. Once our pizza was ready, it was nothing less than perfection! Loved the friendly vibe and overall welcoming atmosphere. We also had the pleasure of conversing with the awesome owner. Love, love, love, love that Tracy has FINALLY gotten another food establishment worth dining at! Pizza My heart has ALWAYS been a favorite place to dine at but now my family and I have definitely found our favorite pizza spot in our home town! read more

Pizza My Heart - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

I'm originally from Santa Cruz and have been eating Pizza My Heart for years, so seeing them open in Tracy absolutely blew me away. Ordered through DoorDash and the pizza was excellent -- same flavor, same quality, same PMH I grew up with. Never thought I'd get a real slice of Santa Cruz out here. This made my night. read more

I usually don't leave a bad review but I went in and the pizza I wanted they didn't have at the moment. They said they could make one and it would be about 12 minutes and I said sure no problem. I drove 50 minutes to get here and was willing to wait for what I wanted. I waited 20 minutes before asking if it was ready and they hadn't even put it in yet. I was so frustrated and just settled for something else. There were no other customers eating in the lobby and the workers were just sitting around and talking. Bad experience and I will just drive farther to another location next time. read more

I was super pumped to get a couple of pies when I heard Tracy had opened up. So I did tonight. They are a super-friendly staff. They accommodated me 5 minutes after closing to pick up 1 large pesto and 1 mushroom pizza . Talked with, I think, the manager about expanding into the valley. Unfortunately, this message goes to Chuck, the owner. The quality is very different. Not in a good way. A 2 out of 10. And that is being generous. Sad to say, I won't be back. I lived in Santa Cruz back in the 80's when Capitol was the only location. I would get a slice daily. I have been in the Culinary field for over 40 years now, half of those years mostly around pizza, and I know what is and what isn't. I'm also sorry to say it's not even close to what I remember and know it to be. read more

So happy that Pizza My Heart has finally opened closer to where we live! We've been longtime fans so truly excited to have one close by. We stopped in for the first time today during the lunch rush, and even though it was busy, the line moved quickly and efficiently. The food was amazing... exactly the quality we've come to expect. Everything tasted fresh and consistent, just like always. We tried 3 different slices and 2 salads. Salads were fresh and crisp, and each pizza was spot on. The restaurant was very clean, and the entire team was friendly and welcoming. What really stood out was seeing the founder there in person. You could tell how invested he is, wiping down tables, keeping things spotless, and overseeing everything to make sure it runs perfectly. That level of pride and hands-on leadership says a lot. This is definitely going to be a long-established favorite in Tracy. We're so happy it's here and hope it continues to thrive for many years to come! read more

So great!!! They were absolutely packed but their staff made up for it! Very generous and can appreciate the hustle! Pizza was obviously so so good and they even have a vegan option for cheese (not for me but my nursing baby that has a lactose intolerance). The manager was also very chill and made sure that everything was taken care of considering the crowd. read more

Today was pizza my heart 3rd night open, the line went pretty fast. My family was able to get slices and find a table to enjoy it. It was all a great experience and we are so excited to finally have them in Tracy. The owner was very friendly, helpful, and hands on. My family will definitely be coming back often. The workers were on top of it tonight! read more

Pizza My Heart - Big Sur! My favorite by the slice! - Chicken Wings Near Me - Tracy, California

Visited this location today and the pizza was amazing! All the staff were friendly. It's also beautiful on the inside. Will for sure be back ! This is for sure a big plus to Tracy . read more

Went here twice. The first time they were able to give me premade slices as ordered. The second time my husband ordered online a whole pie and waited 25 minutes. When he got there, they said that his order was canceled not by him, but by the computer. They were unable to help him, be compensated or offered any other thing except to make him another pie, which would make him wait another 25 minutes. The manager was there, but did not know how to handle the situation. Very disappointing. read more

Love the pizza all the way to the crust mmmm. The cloves of roasted garlic are the bomb. I use to go to hella pie now I just come here for better quality pizza. So happy this place is in Tracy. Best pizza place and friendly environment. Reminds me, I want to pick up a pizza my heat t-shirt from this place. Please never leave Tracy!!!! We needed this place. Only ask, get beef pepperoni please! read more

Excited to have Pizza My Heart in Tracy! Stopped in Saturday 2/21 for lunch. Line was almost out the door, but it moved quick. Ordered slices of the Big Sur and Super Veggie to go. Both very delicious! Staff is friendly. Plenty of seating. My go-to pizza place now. Will return to try the other kinds of pizza slices. read more