Smelled so good and I loved how the place looked. The guy at the front was kind and helped me with my order.

This is the BEST pizza I can remember, and I am from CT - the crust in perfection- even incredible cold the next day ... the toppings are fresh , and many to choose from - the owner takes pride in each pie - look no more if you are a pizza connoisseur- if you have ever been to Pepe's in New Haven - then look no more - come here when living in the sunshine state - lucky to have them on my work plaza read more

I ordered cheesy bread and pasta with red sauce and meatballs on 2/6/26. There was NO cheese on the bread, only garlic butter, oil and Italian seasonings. It was burnt on the bottom, too. I've had this bread in the past and it was fantastic! The pasta dish was pretty disappointing. It appeared and tasted to have been previously frozen and re-heated. Not 'homemade'. The meatballs were small and didn't have much flavor. But the kicker is: there was no red sauce on the pasta. It was dry. I've never had a pasta dish prepared like that before. I didn't think to check the order before I left. I was hungry so I just ate the dinner. The food was great back in 2023 . My order cost $24 with tip. Too high for the quality of the dinner. Don't think I'll be back in the future. read more

Delicious pizza, fast delivery. We had mushroom & onion. Good crust. It will be our spot for pizza while we are in Sarasota.

Solid pizza, day in day out. Always get the sausage and mushrooms. Big toppings and never too much sauce. They have been there for nearly 17 years. Just good and steady! read more

This pizza restaurant is very good. I've never eaten inside as they only have a place for about 8 to 10 people during the evening, but I've taken out about a dozen times so far the Hawaiian pizzas are awesome. The prices are very good but beware prices it depends on where and how you order their pizza prices were from a 0 to 5 dollar difference in the price based on which menu or service you order from if you go to their website it's pretty standard but they tend to use Uber to order even if you pick up and that adds about 4 to 5 dollars on top of the price where is if you use their website directly it's a flat cost no extra price. The Hawaiian pizza was 2430 one time I ordered it and then it was $31.40 the next time so be careful the pricing, but the food is excellent. It's always hot and fresh and always has a great taste. Whatever pizza you order read more

This pizza is excellent. While we have other favorites, we still enjoyed it even when it was delivered cold by GrubHub (not the restaurant's fault). That speaks to its quality. read more

Simply excellent, the twist on Bruschetta was fantastic, we had the Margarita Pizza another excellent choice and the fresh meatballs. Priced right and fast service. Give this place a visit as we have found our new go to spot. read more

Pizzeria Della Nonna - Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

The best pizza in Sarasota. Hands down. We have been searching to find a place that isn't too doughy or too "coal fired" this is it! The sauce makes it. Get the Hawaiian. Carry-out only but stays piping hot until you are home. read more

Terrible pizza, don't waste the time or money on it. Tastes undercooked and bland. I've had better frozen pizzas. Yuck! Anybody who thinks this pizza is enjoyable clearly has never had a good pizza... read more

In town for a week and decided to go with this pizza based on their menu and reviews. Wonderful choice! Pizza was delicious and loaded with toppings. We had 2 traditional and a gluten free traditional, all wonderful! Also had an anti pasta salad, small, that fed 4 people. Definitely a top pizza place. read more

Pizzeria Della Nonna - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

A good substantial sandwich I checked out their menu before I arrived for lunch and felt like a sandwich as well as a slice of pizza. Unfortunately, they do not offer pizza by the slice. So many of the Yelp reviews talked about the pizza but with the small at 12", that would be too much for me today. I settled for just a sandwich, the Italian, very good with a variety of meats. It turned out to be a good value and large enough to satisfy my hunger. There were no other customers and my food was ready in less than 10 minutes. I ordered and picked up at the register and headed outside to sit at one of their two outdoor tables. They also have a row of tables inside. Looks like a nice small restaurant. Parking is convenient, the person who filled my order seemed like a nice guy, and I enjoyed my lunch, relaxing outside on a comfortable day. read more

Pizzeria Della Nonna - Italian - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Unmemorable. The crust is reminiscent of frozen pizza. There are better pizza places around.

I haven't been to many local pizza spots - so I can't really say how this matches up to the competition. But I can say that this is pretty subpar pizza. I got two takeout pizzas. I tried them both - a regular pepperoni pizza, and a margherita. Neither had much in the way of flavor or texture. The service was just fine - nice people and prompt. The restaurant is small - just a few tables. I might just be spoiled by NYC and New Haven style pizza. But I think Florida can do better! read more

Pizzeria Della Nonna - Pep pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Delicious food! Their pizza is very good and so are their meals and salads. One of the best pizza places around.

We ordered a small pizza to be delivered and it was a very disappointing experience. Our pizza had a soggy undercooked dough and undercooked meats. The crust was practically raw and could not support the toppings. The ingredients tasted canned and definitely not fresh and there was so much sauce it was like having soup instead of sauce. This little pizza was over $30 with delivery and it was a sadly not worth eatin. read more

This is by far the best pizza I've had in the Sarasota area. Nothing fancy, nothing overpriced, just real good pizza. Great sauce, perfect amount of cheese, and not too much dough. We just love it - can't say enough! read more

Delicious every time. They only do carry-out, which kind of stinks because the restaurant is nice inside.

Stopped in around 6:30 on Saturday night and ordered for carryout. Asked a fellow who was waiting for his food what he recommends. He said the Hawaiian pizza. My wife and I ordered a 12" and an order of capellini with meatballs. Both were made to order and absolutely delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Best gluten free pizza I've ever had! The ingredients tasted very fresh and the pizza had lots of toppings. Will definitely order from here again! read more

Delicious.. just good pizza! Loved the sauce and as a non crust person the crust was also very tasty read more

We found this place by accident while looking for an affordable alternative to Sarasota seafood restaurants. OMG. GREAT Italian food and pizza. Had the Hawaiian pizza at the recommendation of another patron, and the meatballs and capatellli. Huge portions, so flavorful, pizza totally yum. read more

Pizza crust was like cardboard. Very disappointed after reading other reviews. The saving grace were the salads. The Greek and the Greek antipasto were excellent. Service was also great. read more

This place seems to want to cease business. The hours posted on Yelp were incorrect and they no longer offer dine in.

First night in area with friends and didn't want to go out so we decided on pizza carry out. Was wonderful pizza and they also have a 12" gluten free crust. The pizza was loaded with toppings and very good. We also had a small anti-pasta salad that fed 4 people and some left over. Loved,it! Would definitely order again. read more

Pretty mundane pizza. Plenty of other options out there imho. Perhaps the classic Italian Pizza may be like this but I'm a thick pizza with stuff kind of guy, not flat, sauce and a sprinkle ... read more

New to the area we were looking for a pizza to eat during football watching. Saw their ad and called. It was yummy! All of the items piled on and cooked perfectly. Very reasonable in pricing as well. Short review but trust me it was a great experience. Will be back. read more

Very much a hidden gem, but worth it. Nice people and food food. Some of my family is gluten free and they say it's the best gf pizza they've ever had. The Greek salad is also a favorite. And when we order take out, the pizza is always hot and ready on time. read more

Delicious! I am vegan and order here all the time for the plant based options (of which there are not many in the area)! My husband thought the plant-based sub was real meat. Also the house salad is delicious. read more

Ingredients were fresh but slim. Dough is super thin and soggy. They need to do some work!

great little gem, don't judge this place on location or size..... Peter makes amazing food in this Greek/Italian fusion Pizzeria

We ordered pizza and salads. Everything was delicious. Pizza was on thinner size which made me then eat 2...3 pieces :) highly recommend this place. read more

Best pizza and antipasto in Sarasota - heck, all of Florida! BAM. This is our go-to place for great, fresh Italian food. We always get the antipasto that is loaded with fresh lettuce, delicious olives and meats wrapped in cheese and served with the chefs homemade Italian dressing that is incredible! The pizza is thin crust, hot, cheesy and melts in your mouth. read more

Pizzeria Della Nonna - Suzanne with her note to Peter! He liked is so much he framed it. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Best pizza in Sarasota pizza is very good right amount of sauce and topping.. very friendly and quick service. A must when living or visiting Sarasota read more

I'm very disappointed in the other Yelp reviews for this place. The pizza crust was frozen/pre-made. It was like buttery cardboard. The sauce was also probably not made there. It was flavorless, as was the poor quality cheese. This was one of the worst pizzas I've ever had from an actual restaurant. I should have just bought a frozen from the grocery store. read more

This was my first visit. I ordered take out pizza with sausage and garlic. I'm a New Yorker. The taste of NY pizza is high bar to meet. The food was ready on time. I was very satisfied with dinner tonight. I will be enjoying more items on their menu in the future. Support local businesses, especially during the pandemic. read more

Tried this place twice very disappointing! Last time was Margarita pizza totally tasteless read more

Best pizza in Sarasota. Generous with the toppings and staff is always very friendly. Out of town guests always love it, too. Pretty much the only place we go for pizza. read more

Excellent pie's...ton's of toppings and great crust! Meatball sub was excellent and the timing for take out was exactly what was quoted. We will be back! read more

Impossible Burger was the best ever. Vegan cheese pizza and regular cheese pizza were very good. Crust on pizza was very good. Higher quality ingredients. Convenient location. Owner seems dedicated to quality. read more