Our go to for family pizza night! The food is fresh, the service is great. The meatball sub is my favorite!

The Pizza is Fantastic! Nick Melon has a dough recipe for his pizza that you will never be able to forget once you 've had a slice!(Sorry Tourists) read more

Pizza was really good and love that you can order by the slice. Everyone was really nice. Garlic knots where kinda dry but that's kinda of the nature of the beast since they are not made to Order. You have a lot of options. The place can use a little TLC but overall I would go back. read more

Met friends here. Had pizza 2 salads and a meatball sub. It's basically serve yourself on drinks out of cooler. And they make you tasty food. Ambiance could use some work outside, inside nice. All of our food was delicious. read more

Loved this for a quick bite to eat before a movie. Never been here before but impressed with salad and pizza. I had a piece of square and a piece of this crust. My preference was the thicker square pizza which was very good. My wife had a great salad which was extremely good and large for $10. One suggestion though as we dined in, the 2 large AC unit filters hanging in the rafters looked like haven't been changed in over a year. Simple easy fix to do this every couple months. It really made me start wondering about the air quality and cleanliness of other issues in the restaurant. read more

Il Panificio is still the best thin pizza around. Crispy crust with alittle char and a perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Looking forward to a new and improved place once they pick it out downtown read more

Il Panificio USA - So good...still best around - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Worst pizza ever. It arrived cold, soggy, colorless, and flavorless. AVOID. Cannot believe this place is still in business!

First time really eating here. It was definitely hot inside and not very enticing to stay. They had many pizza options out that you could order from to get a slice or two. I opted for the buffalo chicken and a cheese Sicilian slice. Overall the buffalo had no flavor. I asked them to keep it in the oven a bit longer to get crispy, so the crisp level was great but just no taste. The Sicilian was delish, all lacked flavor but the texture was perfect! read more

See all

Take out was inedible. Burnt eggplant, rancid oil salad dressing. I took a few bites- I hope I don't get sick. read more

Il Panificio USA - Eggplant parm - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

*I came here because Dave Portnoy was here. He scored this place a 7.4/10* Food: pretty damn good pizza. It has a good chew but is not too chewy, and there is some crunch in it as well. I definitely would recommend checking it out. Service: I received great service from the staff. Friendly and patient. Ambiance: Typical pizza shop ambiance. They have outdoor seating as well as indoor seating. There is also parking nearby (pay to park). read more

Il Panificio USA - Slices - Cheese Pizza Pie, Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

When in downtown running errands, this is a good place to pick up a pizza or a few slices of pizza. I have only ordered pizza to go and it heats up well for a flavorful snack. Last time, I ordered half a margarita pizza without cheese and half with cheese. They quickly recovered from their shock ( guess they have not enjoyed pizza rossa in Italy yet) and created a very tasty treat! Quite a few high tops tables if you want to eat there- a few parking spots directly out front or on the street. Lots of pre-made pizzas for you to choose which slices look best to you. Don't forget about these restaurants at this end of Main Street. read more

Il Panificio USA - Variety of pizza by the slice options - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

The restaurant is amazing. Best pizza in Sarasota. Irish Italians. Best pizza in the city.

Thin and crispy New York Jersey style pizza. Good flavor. Fair price for Sarasota as well.

Realllly good Jerzy style slices. Good vibes for Florida pizza w northern feel. Meatball sub was also on point. Recommended for people that enjoy real authentic pizza read more

Bad service, messed up my pizza and didn't want to make it right even after i brought it up to them.

perfect place for a work lunch! have not been here in quite some time and it still is just as delicious! the focaccia bread is sooooo good! i love that they offer wine and beer as well - hey it's 5:00 somewhere! cute crowd. pleasant staff. read more

See all

The crust is toothsome and chewy with a charred edge and enough bubbles. The sauce tastes like rich tomato and not a sugar bomb. The cheese is mozzarella. It melts exactly like it's supposed to. No weird cheese mixes that coagulate and come off in strange shreds. The sausage doesn't look like rat pellets and tastes like real Italian sausage. I always get mushroom and sausage or pepperoni but I did try their margherita. It was not authentic as it didn't have fior de latte mozzarella but it did have fresh basil and tasted yummy nonetheless. Warning: they do have a pineapple and ham "pizza". Closest to New Haven style I've gotten down here in 13 years. IYKYK. read more

Fresh pizza dough, rolled in plain sight, using quality flours you can taste... these folks are fabulous. Easily best pizza in Sarasota. If you have better message me. Sometimes their service is mid, sometimes their AC is down, sometimes the homeless could visit, but they are consistent with what matters most, pizza! Fat crust or thin, lots of variety, local. read more

Il Panificio USA - Thin crust & deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

One of the only pizza places in Sarasota that I enjoy. Their subs are also outstanding. I will definitely continue eating here

Down in Sarasota for a little day trip. Looking for someplace that has sandwiches to take down to the park. While riding down Main Street we passed I'll Panificio. Glad we did! Given the Wuhan virus situation it was not crowded so we ordered. We go the Italian sandwich to share. Plenty big for 2. It was very fresh. The bread was really good along with the cold cuts, especially the pepper crusted ham. You may say an Italian sandwich is pretty much the same but that would be wrong. Just compare and Jimmy Johns to a Jersey mikes. Well the one from here is awesome! Can't wait to try it hot! read more

See all

Best pizza in Sarasota hands down. The crust is chewy and crispy. Delish my personal favorite! read more

Il Panificio USA - Sausage onion green pepper - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Exceptionally wonderful food and beautiful restaurant! The service was just as great! No complaints and a fantastic dinner!

The salads & pizza is delicious! We treat our team and every time they are over the moon!! The service is great and always accommodating!! read more

Great tasting thin pizza delivered to us in Siesta Key. Great salad also. If it's good enough for Portney, it's good enough for me

would not recommend the chicken parm sub. very dry and barely any marinara Bravo Pizza, 1 mile east down the road has much better service/pricing/taste read more

Best pizza in southwest Florida - hands down. This is how you should enjoy your pizza! Thin crust, cheese only, crispy and delicious! Don't bother getting any of the specialties - just ask for the cheese and you'll love it! Coming back from New York I was in search of this type of pizza - best! read more

Il Panificio USA - Cheese Pizza Pie and Pepperoni Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Fantastic thin crust pizza by the slice!!!! Will be back many times for sure!! Served fast and very hot!! read more

Il Panificio USA - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Great place for a quick lunch or a more sit down with friends. Lots of seats inside and out along with its own parking lot which is tough to find in downtown SRQ. Looking forward to coming back and trying more options on the big menu read more

Il Panificio USA - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Been coming here for years and years. Love the pizza. But in recent years, the store has been turned over to kids. Service has gone from considerate to AWFUL. Today, I called and ordered a regular cheese pie. Guy says ok 15/20. I give him my name. He says ok. So I show up in 20 give my same and ask for my piazza. And he looks at me like I'm a spaceman. He looks around. No pizzas waiting for pickup. You didn't order, you'll have to wait 15/20 minutes. I start explaining - I even pull out my phone to show the call and its length so I'm not playing him. He says yes, looks like you ordered, He shrugs his shoulders and says you'll just have to wait for a new pie. Meanwhile he opens the oven and there are at least half a dozen pies, most of which are cheese. So I say, why not give me one of those. Well, he says, they are for people who ordered pizza. He says this after he acknowledges I ordered. Which started to get me angry. He had acknowledged that I had ordered but simply said "I don't have one for you, you must wait". Well I ordered before THOSE people. Why not give me the pizza you have there? First come first served, right?. You take orders as they come in right? At which point I got steamed and said I want my pizza NOW and I don't want to wait. And those were "the magic words". He was free to calmly babble nonsense at me and I'm supposed to stay calm and polite while is intentionally provoking me with circular reasoning and foolish (il)logic? Now he turns the conversation into one about MY BEHAVIOR. I looked him right in the eye, I said you got what you asked for. You either provoked me with nonsense or you aren't capable of understanding your job. You acknowledged that I had ordered the pizza but then said "I don't have it". No where in there did you say "sorry, I made a mistake and I will fix it". Such as by taking one of the pies just about done since my order obviously preceded them. But you raised your voice! I said, because you WANTED ME TO. You are one of the great army of Americans who really don't give a crap about doing their job right. Never once did you offer to fix the problem other than telling me too bad, I had to eat the consequences of HIS mistake. All this guy could mumble about was that I simply refused to accept his passive aggressive BS And reacted like most people frustrated by such talk would react. He doesn't care about his work. The service is awful, they need real adults running the place -$20 for a simple pizza with thin crust and thus fewer ingredients. And they hire kids and fools to work the store without a sign of even a single adult behind the counter I look forward to the wrecking ball that is coming soon to get rid of this genius and the owners who think it's okay to hire children to run his business. read more

Delicious! Affordable, quick, friendly service. A great slice that makes awesome leftovers. Love the toothsome crust and cheese:sauce ratio. read more

Il Panificio USA - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

This place is soOoo awesome! Never been to Italy but my cousin has and I showed her pictures of us there. She's like it's the real deal holy field! You can try different slices of pizza, desert is on deck. Oh they have alcohol too!!! Beer and pizza! read more

Il Panificio USA - This is the margarita pizza that topped off with Prosciutto, vegetarian pizza, and last but not least the Supreme. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Great service friendly workers and delicious pizza! Came in right before they closed and still treated me the same as the first customer that came through their door. read more

Pizza and beer for four last night. Ambiance is very good, seating is tight - had to get out of my chair a few times and let people by. Order at the counter and they bring your food out. Selection of pizza slices was grim - they looked like they had been there all day :-(. We ordered an Everthing pizza and had a couple of beers. The pizza came in a reasonable period of time, but instead of bringing it to our table the dude just flung it on the counter for us to pick up. Flavor and toppings were excellent, but the center was pretty soggy. The crust was tasty but very dense and crisp. Everyone complained after dinner that it tore up til he roof of our mouths. No "thanks for stopping by" as we walked out the door - they need to work on their customer service. Summary: ok pizza if you like really stiff crust. Service = Needs Improvement. read more

Il Panificio USA - Panorama of the place. About a dozen tables. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

We were Jonesin' for pizza so we searched for something close to the Hyatt. This was in the top 5 of a local magazine poll and close so I gave it a shot. I would. All it pretty decent and the current 3.5 stars is about right. We had pepperoni and extra cheese. I liked them thin crust but overall it was a little tough and chewy. It is not gourmet and not from a wood burning oven, but it was what we were looking for to go with a cold beer after a long day. The are in the main part of downtown and had a couple of parking spots and then street parking. The have outdoor eating and standing room. They sell whole pizza and by the slice, though by the slice look a little old at 5 pm. The have a drink cooler with water, soda, beer and small bottles of wine. Would I do it again? I might try another spot next time but if someone was ordering pizza for me, I would not turn it down. read more

Il Panificio USA - Outdoor seating and standing area - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We picked up three pizzas from Il Panificio for dinner the other night and we have been going here for years, honestly I think the pizza keeps getting better! Our pizzas were perfectly cooked and the amount of toppings were on point. We ordered a margherita, a pepperoni and jalapeno and a white sauce sausage with half black olives. The crust was absolutely delicious and I couldn't get enough of the pizza. They have a great menu with tons of delicious options and the inside of the store is adorable. It is really authentic pizza and I wish I had one in Virginia where I live because I feel like I can't get pizza as good as this near me! read more

See all

I should have tried the pizza I stopped in for lunch and made a rookie mistake, ordering a sandwich instead of pizza. Not sure I ever visited this restaurant before but I have visited the one in Gulf Gate, and they make great pizzas. This restaurant was a little confusing when I walked in but I made my way to the order here sign. Glancing quickly at a menu on the wall I spotted their Italian sub and went with that. The sandwich was on tough Italian bread and to me seemed a bit dry. You would think that would not be possible with an Italian sub. This was not a loaded sandwich, the amount of filling was about the least you would expect on an Italian sub. There may have been a bread vs filling ratio issue and I'm not sure it had any mayo at all. It still tasted good so I'm a fan, but below average. While I ate my lunch, I did see they had about a dozen pizzas on display for pizza by the slice choices. I'm sure I would have been happier had I looked to my right and grabbed a couple of slices. read more

Il Panificio USA - Italian sub - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Greatest pizza in town w friendly staff!! Original location downtown Main Street. Sarasota wouldn't be the same without this pizzeria.

The pizza is amazing! Mostly because of the crust, which is super thin, light, and crispy around the edges. I have lived in NYC 3 times and this pizza is comparable if not better because the crust does no overpower the toppings. No one just wants mostly bread. The cheese is high quality and very flavorful, as well as the toppings. Located on Main St. in downtown Sarasota in what appears to be an old gas station, the place is mostly all counter. There are a few high top tables and some outdoor seating. The employees can be quite rude, especially when they are busy. We usually call a pizza order in and pick it up, and sometimes they tell us that they are too busy to make a pizza for us and to go elsewhere. Interesting considering they are a pizza place. But, the food is worth it, if they will make it for you. read more

See all

Absolutely the greatest pizza i have EVER tasted! A blonde girl with nose piercings provided the most excellent service. She helped me choose toppings to my preferred liking and gave me many, clearly memorized, options. The thin crust, the spinach, and bacon combined made me fall in love. This is by far the greatest pizza I have ever tasted since I moved to Sarasota a few years ago. I WILL BE BACK! read more

Il Panificio USA - white cheese, spinach and bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

One of the best pizzas in Sarasota. Thin crust, great crispy flavor and delicious sausage that is hard to come by in FL. Lunch slices are dope but a whole fresh pie is a real treat. Great service too. read more