Awhile back, I left a pretty bad review for this place. Since then, they've changed owners, and…read moremade some much needed cosmetic changes to the storefront as well (not that it matters that much, but who wants to buy food from a place that looks like a dump?) Anyway.... I was hesitant to give em another shot, but after hearing about new ownership, fair is fair. And I didn't think my previous review would be "fair" to them. So I made my obligatory "3 visit" rule (I try out a place 3x times before writing a bad review; after all, everyone is entitled to have a bad day, right?). So.... I'm happy to report NOW that the place was clean, the staff were pleasant and friendly, and the pizza was GREAT. Lots of choices (I'm a by the slice kinda guy), all tasted fresh, and frankly, it's pretty damn good. With that: 5 stars, and a hearty recommendation! Enjoy!

This place has really gone downhill. The food was not as good as Pappa Nicks but was livable. Then…read morethey switched to an answering service that takes your orders. A nightmare!!!! He kept telling me I am out of range for delivery. I live 5 minutes down the road and always got delivery before. Sorry Uncle Joe's but we are done. I doubt we are the inly ones. ​

I got a pizza from this place on Sunday and it was some of the best pizza I've ever tasted, the…read moreemployees were very nice, there was a nice kid named Anderson and he helped me pick out what I wanted, I was unsure and he helped me, it was amazing, the place was also very nice like the furniture and lights felt like I was in a high end restaurant, nice spot and nice people as well, 10/10 would recommend.

5-8-25. I had to run an errand and was in the area…read more...... and had a hunkering for some pizza, so I stopped in here for a late lunch. Pretty good selection of specialty slices. It's located inside a Home Depot parking lot and it's not far from Sunrise Hwy. but a little off the beaten path. The pizza was good. I ordered a Greek salad slice and a regular slice. The salad slice was piled high with lettuce, tomato, onions, feta cheese and a few black olives. The sesame crust was a nice touch. Regular slice was decent as well. Plenty of seating inside and the place was kept clean. Staff was friendly and courteous.

My mom and I, stopped in tonight, for an unexpected dinner. Not only was the food outstanding but…read morethe service was amazing! Our server, Venus, was friendly, courteous and knowledgeable about the menu! I would highly recommend this restaurant!

I'll keep it simple. Tried the regular slice…read more The ingredients didn't seem fresh. This was definitely not "good" pizza. I believe that they offer coupons on each pizza box, so when you get 10 coupons you get a free pie. This could be what keeps people coming back which pays their bills. If you can't make good pizza, is there really a point in trying anything else?

MOST NYC-LIKE PIZZA IN PORT WASHINGTON!!!…read more I'm a NYC foodie and have tasted the best slices in NYC, so I can say this is the BEST slice in Port Washington. The slices are delicious, not soggy, not over-sauced. And the crust.....THE CRUST!!! I can't praise it enough! It's so buttery, crunchy, bubbly and SOOO DAMN GOOD! Gino's and Carlo's are overrated. This place is the real deal! Management, please adversise your pizza more!!!

Attempted to get some pizza here today (6-21-25). Sign on the door states it's permanently closed…read moreafter 15 years in business. Definitely a shame when the Mom and Pop small business' shut their doors for good.

Pizzas are made fresh to order and was so delicious. Pizzas cook quick inside the huge oven! Nice,…read morethin pies, and they are made as a personal size pizza (14"). The crust still had the perfect ratio of dough making it fluffy, thin, and not crunchy. The white pie with the truffled ricotta and roasted mushrooms is a must try if you love anything truffle. It was loaded with flavors of garlic, mushrooms and the perfect amount of truffle. I'm so glad I ordered this pie! This will definitely be a spot we will visit again in the summer time. Inside is small, but they have additional seating outside.

I stopped by with my mom for lunch when I was in town visiting and absolutely loved everything…read moreabout the food here! The service was great, seating was easy and wasn't too busy for a Saturday. We split the burrata and the red pie with mozzarella, ricotta, red onion, and meatballs and it was delectable. You really can't beat the pizza here!

Amazing catering experiences…read more For most or our lives my wife and I have hosted very large parties while doing all the cooking ourselves. As an Italian heritage family this has been a source of pride. However over the past couple of years we have taken to trusting the team at Carmelina's to provide food for a number of events. Yesterday was the largest as we catered an engagement party for over 130 people at the Masury in Center Moriches. The food was top notch (chicken parm, eggplant rollatini, chicken franchese, meatballs and garlic knots to go with homemade lasagna and sausage). Delivery was prompt and efficient and the price was more than fair. Thank you again.

Wow!! Seriously - all around fun stop for creative slices that are super fresh, colorful and as…read moretasty as they look. Outside- They look like just another pizza shop in a strip center - but you can see once inside they have a really good pizza maker. One who seems to have the edge over all the others out here. Just one look and my best friend had to have the cherry pepper chicken slice - glazed - colorful- and done to perfection- That may be their best of a few super slices. A few others - notable in looks/ taste - chicken parm - white - grandma vodka - etc. They stay open late but not too late - and will give you a good deal before closing. Very quick and helpful. Saw a small sit down area - no time to try dinner yet - but pizza - now a go to for a box of 6 or 7 fun variety of slices. Thats the way to go.

This hidden gem is worth it. Food always fresh. Great italian meals and shareable portions.read more

Super nice people and garlic knots are pretty good too. Definitely preferred over the other…read moreBellport pizza spot

Hidden gem! Food is great, (& picky eaters) beautiful decor and our waitress, Jackie was wonderful.read more

Staff are always super friendly whether it is takeout or dining in…read more The food is always great. The portion sizes are generous. My favorites are the eggplant rollatini and the spinach white slice. The garlic knots are always great as well. The setup of the place is very cute.

There's only so far cute branding can get you. We stopped…read morein for dinner and the food was so mid and the service was even worse. One server to like ten tables. And you could tell. Disappointing.

The options are endless! So many delicious choices from pasta, to pizza, to plentiful salads. The…read moreemployees are always so friendly and quick to meet everyone's needs. The ambiance is perfect! We love having lunch or dinner there every time we are nearby. The prices are also reasonable and the portions are great. We will be back again!