Pricey for what it is - we got a slice of pizza, two icees, and a coke zero and it was $24. The staff was kind and heated up the pizza which was just ok (at best). The arcade is fairly dismal. Expensive and a large amount of machines are broken. Kind of has the vibe of being in a finished basement that isn't super well kept up. Air hockey for $1.50 was the best thing going. I enjoyed walking through the historic cave to enter the area. read more

Food, fun for the kiddos (and a couple arcade-loving adults) -- Pluto's was just what my family needed after exploring French Lick for a bit. My husband, kiddos, mom, siblings, nieces and nephews and I stumbled on Pluto's when we were searching for a lunch spot. My kids immediately gravitated to the arcade games. Most were between 50 cents to $1, so $10 in quarters kept them busy for a bit. These were a mix of prize and video games. And while the kids played, the adults ordered pizza and beer. The pizza we got was decent -- hitting the spot in terms of food. Pluto's also has a few bowling lanes that a work group had rented out. That could be fun to do on a return trip. Especially if you have kids while staying at French Lick, don't miss this spot. read more

See all

The food is good, service is impeccable as its part of the resort. The ambiance reminds me of a old New Jersey or Chicago pizza joint only with just kitchen. Its cool. It in the Arcade/Bowling alley. read more

Pluto's Pizzeria - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

Thought the food was gonna be good since French lick is huge, I thought wrong, they have the food sitting out all day and put it in the oven when you order, did not even taste good, I only ate the mushrooms out of my calzone, wouldn't eat anything else, service was ok. read more

Pluto's Pizzeria - Food is still raw, it was all soggy and just not pleasant - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

I would not return to this restaurant. It was $5 for a slice of pizza that must have been sitting there all day or longer to then be put in a pizza oven for two minutes to reheat. It tasted like burnt crust and basic cheese. There was nothing to it! The drinks were also $5 with one refill included. Frozen pizza would have been a five-star experience compared to what we ate. Ordering a full pizza made to order may have been different although I'd rather go into town to a pizza restaurant to have a better experience. read more

Pluto's pizza is attached to the Pluto's Blowing Alley inside The French Lick Resort. I will say that it's kind of difficult to get someone's attention when you walk into this place. I stood at the register for about 5 minutes before the guy rolling dough even turned around or acknowledged me. I did not order pizza but instead an order of breadsticks, Cesar salad and a drink which ran well over $20. I get that the pizzeria is inside a resort so I'm sure some of the price mark up was because of that. Breadsticks...super doughy! Like maybe they needed to cook longer. And the marinara was super chunky so pretty much unable to be used as a dipping sauce. Salad was decent! Nice size to go container with the basic shaved parmesan, romaine, crotons, and dressing cup. read more

See all

We didn't eat here but had a blast at the bowling alley. My husband had to do the score card because I don't know how to keep score without a board doing it for me. We got here when they opened at 11am and they weren't busy. We went to the pizzeria to pay for 2 games and I got a beer. The bowling shoes felt a little big but they were clean. We had a lot of fun here. If you like bowling this is a must do at the resort. It is located on the lower level and the walk there is interesting. read more

See all

We got The Pluto, which is supposedly vegan friendly. The woman who took our order wasn't very nice and had no idea what vegan actually means. She confidently told us The Pluto was vegan when it isn't. We requested no onions, the pizza was loaded with onions, they gave us a GIANT box and for some reason put the pizza in a tin foil dish which made the crust all soggy. The sauce was good but it wasn't enough to make that soggy mess palatable. Especially for the ridiculous price of 27$. For an 8" pizza... Do yourself a favor and don't waste your time and money on this place. read more

Very very very bad experience TWO nights in a row. The food is good and reasonably priced but the staff (three different folks over two nights) are downright rude and incompetent. Rude to your face AND messed up orders both nights (eg ordered a SLICE of deep dish and they charged me a whole pizza. There is a systemic cultural problem Robles here, not just one bad actor. ALSO you have to go they them to pay for and get set up with bowling and it is a MESS. More incompetence. PLUS it's not safe. Despite a 'mask mandate' we bowled about 4 feet away from family of five (all adults) who refused to wear masks. We were put at risk and no staff member cared even in midst of FLAGRANT violation of posted rules. Unless you have kids or are aching to bowl- STAY AWAY. Plenty of other great things to do and staff on premises. This place needs rigorous overhaul read more

$10.90 for a small cup of ice with a pinch of soda and a false advertisement of NY style pizza. Small not so tasty slice. The bowling alley is a joke. $40 for 1 hr which only allowed for 1 game. Best part of the horrible experience is that there is no score board. They give you a paper and pencil. I could not make this horrible expensive experience up. read more

Ordered a Sausage Cheese calzone, outside was nice, inside was raw dough. Advised staff, they just said "thank you", no money off or refund offered. Terrible, would not recommend to ever eat there. read more

I was looking for a place to get my granddaughter gluten free pizza while we were visiting the area and picked his place out before our trip. I wish I had read more reviews, but live and learn! We ordered one pizza for two adults and two children, a small gluten free pizza and five small soda's. The total bill was $75.00!!! Oh my goodness, we thought it was wrong but, no, it was correct. The gluten free pizza was eatable at most, and the other pizza was just ok. Frozen pizza from the grocery store would have been better. So disappointing to plan a pizza night and get a poor pizza and pay a small fortune. Some photos show cute tables with red stools, there was nothing in there. We had to sit in another room close to the bowling alley. My advice, don't bother. read more

If I could have a review just state "I've had better" that would sum up this place. Slow service, not the best food, but hey what else can you ask for from a restaurant like this read more

Dramatically overpriced and incredibly underwhelming. I ordered a sausage pizza and a stromboli to go. The stromboli came first, then came the wrong pizza. So, I stood there while they remade the pizza and the stromboli got cold. After 30 minutes, the pizza was done and I took the food back to the room for my hungry family. The stromboli was half plain bread and part scant sausage and occasional bites of pepperoni 12 uncooked slices thick. The sausage looked and tasted like Tony's frozen pizza sausage. They neglected to actually cut the pizza and never delivered an apology for the time sink screw up. Never again. read more

Better than any hotel pizza joint deserves to be. Real pizza ovens. Handmade dough (gluten free, I was told). Decent pizza by the slice and calzones. Friendly staff. read more

The place is a nice quaint atmosphere and a great place to go after drinking or gambling. It is also nice for kids because of the close proximity of bowling and an arcade. The pizza was OK. Nothing great, but it was not bad either. I had a slice of pepperoni and a Deep Dish Chicago Style slice. The Pepperoni Pizza was tasty, but the cheese was a little bland. The crust was flavorful and the pizza sauce had some character. The Chicago Deep Dish slice left me a little disappointed. While it looked really good, it was void of flavor for the most part. While it did have a great base sauce, the cheese was just not all that good. The sausage had no spice at all, and I believed it to be a little undercooked. It was pretty doughy but edible. The price for a slice is pretty steep, but since its in the resort, it's par for the course. I REALLY wish they would have a better selection of beer there. Just Bud products....sad. If you are selling gourmet pizza, you need to have some great beer to go with it. May I suggest Upland Brewing or New Albanian Brewing to showcase some Indiana beers in French Lick. I will say I will order from them again. Just better have crushed red pepper in hand to add some bite to their pizza pie! read more

Pluto's Pizzeria is a small pizza shop on the lower level of the French Lick Resort. the puzza, calzones, stromboli, breadsticks and pretzels are all made fresh daily by Anthony, a native of Brooklyn, New York, home to the best pizza in the world. Pluto's Pizzeria is delicious and you'll think you're in Brooklyn - it's seriously that authentic. You will be glad you tried it. read more

Pluto's Pizzeria - Chef Anthony - Pizza Near Me - French Lick, Indiana

Terrible pizza! $32 dollars for two people! $4 for a 20oz drink!!!!! Absolutely nasty pizza... I would get better pizza from the mall!

Pleasantly surprised with the slices of pizza available at Pluto's (which is located in the basement of the hotel, right next to the bowling alley). Everyone really liked their pizza, and it's a good deal for a quick bite to eat. Would be great for anyone with kids, or people like us (in our twenties and hungover!) read more

This place is in the arcade at French Lick hotel. It's ok for a late night craving or if you have kids, but if you're seeking good pizza look elsewhere. read more

This is without a doubt the worst thing I've ever put in my body. Anything who has ever eaten food would know this is the most pitiful attempt at pizza on the planet. read more

One star because you are open. Worst service ever! The girl at counter was rude.Had a slice of pepperoni pizza because they didn't have anything else. A salad and two bottles of water. It's was almost $20! read more

So the lady getting our drinks got them wrong told her what we ordered and she kinda argued with me. Rolled her eyes and shook her head the rest of time getting our drinks. Talked to the guy who brought our food he said he would tell his manager. But manager hasn't spoke to me. Got a salad and lettuce was brown and some of the cucumbers were dry. Pizza was not what I excepted. Very little sauce and way to much cheese I am not impressed. Four dollars for a drink and I can't get refills!. I spent almost 100.00 to feed 5 ppl. You would think that could at least buy a smile from the wait staff read more

Good pizza and Stromboli, right off the bowling alley and arcade at the French Lick Resort.

As has been previously shared on other reviews, this place is pricey. The pizza is good for sure. But it's not worth what they charge. And drinks.... $4 for a soft drink. Insane. This is right next to the bowling alley in the resort so seating is limited. I'm glad i went to check it out. But will probably be the one and only time i eat from this pizzeria. read more

One of the few places open Wednesday night following the Wizard of Oz train. Kind of hidden but worth the find. The deep dish by the slice was awesome. read more

One of my favorite pizza places. My husband and I like to come to west baden just for this pizza from time to time. Great quality and a great price. Friendly service every time :) read more

This place handles large personal or business events just as well as walk-ins. The pizzeria is part of Pluto's bar, bowling alley and arcade. Tony the Sous Chef or Manager is all class and gives this place a a lot of its character. read more