I rented from this company 2017-2020 I had absolutely no issues whatsoever. It was a flawless…read morepartnership. I only moved away due to a death in the immediate family. Now here I am in 2026 and after moving back to the area 1.5yrs ago to help a friend who's undergone a major life change; I'm looking for a place of my own. I reached out to them and have two viewings set up. And from what I can tell; nothing's changed. The initial call was friendly and efficient. They could see my history and were kind and professional. I'm going back to them because I NEVER had one issue when doing business with them in the past and it appears I won't this go around.

I wanted to come here to give Preston at America's Rental Managers a review. In looking for a home…read moreto relocate, I called the wrong agency, which turned out to be the right agency because Preston gave me all of the pertinent information to make an informed decision. Thank you Preston, for putting me at ease concerning my relocation. Cherlisa M.

TM Company founder and CEO Tanner Morgan is an exceptional property manager. I hold him and the…read morecompany in very high regard because of his professionalism, knowledge, amiable personality and general "know-how" when it comes to anything related to renting and managing properties. He has also demonstrated considerable skill in mediating issues with tenants. Hiring this company was one of the best decisions we made to protect our investment. We have no problem rating him and his company with the highest marks and gladly recommend him.

Tanner is the best! We live in California, so very dependant on his expertise! We just recently…read moremet him on a trip to Alabama and had a delightful first meeting. He is "the real deal"!

My husband and I had a terrible situation happen in Alabama that made us wary of becoming residents…read morein 2020. Rudy and his family not only assisted us in becoming tenants in a beautiful home but checked on us, invited us out to become acclimated to Alabama and we're very down to earth and warm. We had issues with our rental that they addressed and when we moved we were charged for cleaning though it was done and carpets too( we lost the receipt in the move) we were given majority of our deposit back. We were let out of our lease graciously. They're real people with stuff like everyone but it makes me want to rent front them again if we were to ever move back to Alabama. We love the Rudolph family and appreciate them.

I have had a great experience with Rudulph Real Estate! I have been with them since 2010 and they…read moreare prompt on maintenance issues being resolved and they are always helpful if I have an issue and I call. They are very knowledgeable and very professional. I recommend Rudulph Real Estate to everyone looking in this area. And, if you want to purchase a home --- they can help you with that, too!

Very prompt and helpful providing photos of a property while we are in another state. Thank you!read more

Tamara by far is the BEST!!!! She always exceeds expectations and is always punctual, reliable, and…read moreknowledgeable. I work with many real estate agents, and she by far is the best one yet. She also has saved the company money by finding us the best tenants.

Excellent service and very responsive. Drew was on top of everything from start to finish!read more

Trista was fine until the very end and then started ignoring my emails for weeks at a time…read morerequiring multiple follow-ups. Also paid for professional carpet cleaning and still they kept hundreds from our security deposit. Pretty crappy way to end a lease.

After speaking with the representative that commented on my review, I'm bumping them up a star. She…read morereviewed my account and discovered that the account manager that was responsible for my neighborhood didn't follow company procedure and the person that responded to the e-mail I wrote last week failed to do their due diligence in researching my complaint. She apologized for the difficulty and corrected the fees that I owed and I was able to log in to my account and pay them without further incident. It was clear from the conversation that they have been working on the internal issues, and if those issues continue to improve, I'll be back to amend my review. I'm sorry that I had to post a negative review for my concerns to be taken seriously, but I was quite pleased at how quickly they were able to get things resolved! I'm cautiously optimistic about future dealings with McKay!

Sorriest so-called "management" company you could ever encounter. They deny, delay, defer and even…read moreif they promise to fix your problem, you get to find out how adept they are at lying. This happened repeatedly and nearly all issues I had to pay for/resolve/repair myself since it was less trouble than dealing with them. Absolute nightmare.

If I could give zero stars, I would…read more My experience with this rental company was deeply frustrating and unacceptable. Throughout my tenancy, I submitted multiple maintenance requests for issues including mold on the walls--an issue that was never properly addressed. One request was even denied outright by a property manager. I was consistently ignored or given vague, non-committal responses with no real action taken. Upon moving out, I was shocked to receive notice that not only was my entire security deposit being withheld, but I was being charged an additional $1,550 for repainting due to "dark spots" on the wall--spots that were clearly mold I had reported numerous times. Despite my repeated attempts to get clear answers, I was met with silence or vague explanations for over a month. I eventually did recover my full deposit, but only after persistent follow-up and pressure. No tenant should have to fight this hard for what is legally theirs. Beware of this company. If you rent from them, document everything, insist on written responses, and stay vigilant--especially when it comes to unresolved maintenance issues. Their lack of accountability and failure to uphold basic standards of habitability raise serious concerns.

This property management company is the absolutely worst and the president Jennifer the same. Watch…read moreout if you are a landlord and have them managing one of your properties. They will secretly charge your tenants an extra $100 once their lease ends and they go month to month. I didn't realize they were doing this until I reviewed the tenant statements. There is nothing in the landlord agreement about them charging this amount or keeping it. If anything that is the property owners money. I reached out to the owner Jennifer about it and she was unfriendly and refused to do anything about it. Stay far away from this company!

Watts Realty Company is an excellent choice for property management in Birmingham. I have a…read moreresidential property in Trussville that was rented in 3 weeks from proper pricing for the area. I have been very pleased with my tenants and communication regarding repairs, lease renewals and payments.

I have been a loyal renter of Watts for years now. Great properties! They are very willing to…read morelisten to advice on how to better improve their services, which means they are consistently striving for greatness.