Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Puerto Rico Magic Tarpon

    4.4 (25 reviews)
    Open 7:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Puerto Rico Magic Tarpon Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Puerto Rico Magic Tarpon

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    My wife and I booked a fly-fishing trip a year ago and had a great time. So, this year when we were back in PR, we booked two days. Capt. Carlos and Capt. Luke took good care of us. Both captains are knowledgeable and represent this well-run company. Good knot skills and fish handling. Tibor fly reels and TFO Mangrove rods perform flawlessly. Capt. Armando operates a well-run business. Excellent communication from start to finish. If you are in PR and want to fish, call or book online now!!! We will be back!! PS We are from Tennessee, not California!!! Not sure why that comes up.

    Aleks T.

    Had the absolute best time with Capt Francisco! Really successful trip with lots of bites, catches, and activity. He knew all the spots and we had so much fun scooting around. Will definitely be chartering with Magic Tarpon again when the opportunity arises and highly recommend to anyone else looking to do a fishing trip!

    The one that got away

    Capt Luke put my wife and I on the silver kings right away! The nicest guy and an extremely gracious and knowledgeable captain. He taught my wife how to cast better than I can and we fought 3-4 Tarpon that we lost (I blame the angler!!) and had a few other bites where they cleaned the bait off the hook, super smart fish! My Lizzy wrangled in her first catch ever - a snook. And I was able to land my first tarpon. Luke, Magic Tarpon as a whole, and their other captains are the Tarpon charters you must take in PR. If you want experience knowledgeable, patient, and reliable captains - I promise you have them at Magic. When the bite stopped Luke tried his secret lucky spot where we got another bite right away but the hook was cleaned off again! He then took us for an amazing ride around the lagoons and mangroves to end the perfect morning. Highly recommended. Thanks for the best day I could've asked for.

    Great Fishing Trip!!

    Wonderful trip with Capt Randy! very knowledgable about fishing and lots of great local tips! We Caught 2 Tarpon on our trip. Fish were 100pds and 90pds! We will be back loved our trip!

    Captan Carlos was great! The fishing was a little slow due to the weather but he put us on the fish as much as possible!

    big and beautiful tarpon
    Whitney B.

    Do yourself a favor and book a tour with these guys. My husband and I met a man in El Yunque National Forrest who recommended these guys. We called later that day and booked a morning tour for the very next day (a Friday) to fish for Tarpin. I know it's called fishing and not catching, and I would have been happy with even just one fish but we caught SEVERAL! I caught a couple monstrous fish I didn't even know how to hold (biggest fish I've ever caught at 30 or so pounds). Carlos was patient and knew the habits of the Tarpin and we were able to catch several even after their morning feeding time died down. We had a blast. Very pleasant day, absolutely no complaints, Carlos catered to us and made sure we had everything we needed and patiently reminded me when I needed to correct my rod in order to pull the fish in.

    Tarpon fish
    Eric C.

    It was awesome!!! Caught some good sized Tarpon. This fish was on my bucket list to catch. Captain Carlos was very friendly & took great care of us. Kudos Carlos!

    Tarpon

    Captain Carlos went the extra mile to ensure we had the best time and successful trip. I would highly recommend this charter service.

    Cap Randy pulled this monstrous terp out when it got close

    This was my first fishing trip but the best experience ever. Captain Randy was so nice and answered all of our questions with no problem. We caught the biggest fish I've ever seen in real life and we were even heading out to do more. I ended up getting seasick in the ocean which really sucks cuz I wanted to stay out there and see what else we could catch. if your looking for an exceptionally awesome experience, book with these guys, you won't b disappointed.

    Amber N.

    On vacation from Chicago and had a great afternoon trip with Randy today. Had a shuttle pick us up from the hotel and drop us back off. Caught live bait and had a good time getting multiple hits, seeing the tarpon jump and even reeling 1 in. Randy was very friendly and informative. Thanks for a great experience!

    Great fishing with Magic Tarpon!
    Jon C.

    Fished with Captain Randy and was not disappointed. The Tarpon were very selective in their feeding, but, was able to land a nice one. Another one got to the boat and threw the hook as soon as Randy reached down to pull it in. I felt very well taken care of and was in good hands.

    See all

    2 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Armando C.

    Armando C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of David Z.
    411
    3
    10

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Whitney B.
    292
    43
    26

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Eric C.
    2
    37
    17

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Leo A.
    0
    12
    0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Amber N.
    10
    41
    76

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of K B.
    0
    104
    11

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Good service. Nice boats. Nice captain. Bad luck in finding fish. Good enough equipment.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Did not like the captain. The boat was to small and the catching fish part not of my liking boring and long!!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Armando C.

    Armando C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Review Highlights - Puerto Rico Magic Tarpon

    Captain Randy was so nice and answered all of our questions with no problem.

    Mentioned in 5 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Caribbean Outfitters - light tackle fishing

    Caribbean Outfitters

    (3 reviews)

    This was THE WORST deep sea fishing trip we have ever had! If I could give them ZERO stars, I would…read morehave! We're still trying to get our money back. Everything we were told was a LIE! We specifically asked about deep sea fishing & catching fish we could keep & cook for dinner. We also asked if the boat had AC & a restroom. Elvia (the wife of Captain Omar) said yes. We would get to catch fish and their boat had a bathroom and AC. They (Captain Omar & Elvia) even convinced us to do the 6 hour fishing trip (more expensive trip) so we could catch more. The total trip for 4 people from 8am-2pm was $885. First, Elvia didn't call us to let us know that their newer boat was having engine problems so we wounl have to go on the older boat. She didn't mention this to us until my husband called her the night before to confirm our charter. We had already paid the deposit of $445 so we didn't dispute the issue with her because we were told this boat still had a bathroom & AC. We arrived at the dock (which was a different location than the original one she told us, this location was further away) & had to call her because no one was there and it was already 8am. We eventually got on the boat & started our trip. The bathroom had no running water so we couldn't wash our hands. The cabin had no AC so we were hot and nauseous. All we did for hours was trolling. We never stopped to actually fish even after my husband told Captain Omar again that we wanted to stop & catch fish, actual fishing. Then when Captain Omar said he would take us to a spot were we could fish the engine over heated & the cabin filled with smoke. He had to stop and slowly head back to port. We all had to evacuate the cabin and stay up top. We were worried it would set the boat on fire. Finally we got back to port & had to get off the boat. No fishing whatsoever. Didn't even get to touch the fishing poles! Then the Captain told us to call his wife to deal with her about the money issue. He apologized & offered another trip late that night but we already had other plans and could not reschedule. We basically just wasted 6 hours just riding on a boat and it was rough waters so that wasn't even relaxing either. When I reached out to Elvia she acted like she did not know who I was or what I was talking about & put her husband on the phone to speak with me. I asked again if they could refund our money, at least 1/2 of it since this experience was not at all what was promised and advertised. He argued with me, got defensive & wanted to speak to my husband and not me. They both basically said that they never told us they had AC & that they told us that trolling was all they do here in Puerto Rico & that the engine breaking down was not their fault. They said they would not refund the $445 deposit but would not charge us the remainder of the balance. I told them that was not acceptable & I would deal with my credit card company to get my money back. Next thing I know, there was an additional charge on our credit card for $250! They lied again! Don't use this fishing charter company! If you do, get everything in writing. Don't take their word for it. They are liars!

    Wake up call comes in but I'm already up anticipating another pre-dawn on the San Jose Lagoon. As…read moreI search for some coffee in the lobby of the Ritz, I remember the attentive the staff is here and simply put in my request for a brew of steaming dark wake me up coffee. I need to be ready for what's ahead. Walking out of the hotel the humidity and warmth of a San Juan morning strikes me and slows my pace up. I think "better than Boston," but the humidity will make me pay later. The coffee arrives at the same time as a cab. There is nothing better than Ritz coffee and there are many cabs a lot better than the cabs in San Juan. I've never been in a good one! 5 minutes to El Cangrejo Yacht Club and my adventure. My captain awaits and his name is Omar. The legend of the San Jose Lagoon, the man who guarantees tarpon catches and the guide who developed the sport of tarpon fishing in this reclaimed body of water that is the result of the airport construction. Off and on this lagoon can be, well let's just say, questionable in water quality but as the years have gone by it get's cleaner and clearer. The journey to the fishing grounds is a combination of catching bait (thread fin herring) and perch (for the big girls.) A ride through the downtown takes you under a bridge that requires a heads up move and out into open water. The anticipation of a frenzy makes the heart beat faster as you round each corner. A frenzy as Omar calls them is a situation where tarpon school together to feed on bait on the service which has an area of a lagoon in a lather with crashing tarpon, snook and diving birds. Today we are on our third day of fishing the early morning bite. A few jumps the first two days leads me to believe that my luck will turn as the fish are here and we change our tactics to work a ledge that the tarpon move along from the lagoon on the other side of the big bridge to the main body of water. It is the trick and the magic that years of fishing and studying tarpon makes Omar the best. While other guides are fishing the shore line to west we stick to the ledge just outside of the bridge. Fish on and I am into my first 60lb tarpon of the day on a nice fresh herring on light tackle braid. No sooner do I cool off with some iced down water (remember reference to the humidity) and we see a boil and I cast to that and ....fish on. 15 minutes later a perfect match to the first one get's released. High fives, water, more water, and another boil. Cast to it .......wait ....wait ....wait reel reel reel and the circle hook hits home. This shinning silver beauty contrasts with the murky Ritz brown coffee color of the lagoon and takes your breath away. Quick picture, release and more high fives! Lines back in, water now in my pocket, my guide shirt and hat soaked in sweat and lines back in. I can not drink the water fast enough as the excitement of the fight, the humidity and now the sun well overhead has me HOT! Just a breather please I think, but can never express to Omar as our friendship has developed into one of constant ribbing and barbs of Puerto Rican humor and Boston comebacks. Oh no.....fish on. Dear God let this stop! I reel and reel and the circle hooks catches and this fish jumps and jumps and she's a beauty of sterling silver. Do you think the fourth in one hour would give me a break and be smaller.......no no no she's pushing 100lbs. So I have Omar pour some water in my mouth over my head and back,,, and this refreshes me enough to dig in. Down and dirty we agree to see if I can pressure her fast to the boat. It works, she cooperates and we finally take a break after releasing yet another. Well, I would like to tell you the morning continued with this level of intensity but it cooled down as my body did too and we jumped 4 more fish landing two all between 40 to 80 lbs. My best tarpon morning ever. Now advice! Fish with Omar and if you can try to book morning trips and do so more than one time as you stay in San Juan. Stay in touch with Omar as the seasons for tarpon are fairly constant but he will call you when the bite is on. The rates are super fair and San Juan is such an easy inexpensive flight for me from Boston. All you need is Omar's cell number which is provided. Call Omar tell him your level of expertise and fly fish when he recommends, but most importantly listen to his advice and stories. He is the legend and my friend.

    Puerto Rico Freedivers Spearfishing Trips - Escalera para doto

    Puerto Rico Freedivers Spearfishing Trips

    (3 reviews)

    What a fun experience! My crazy husband decided he wanted to go iguana hunting so he booked an…read moreexcursion while we were in San Juan. I had NO idea what to expect but had a really fun time doing something that was way out of my comfort zone. Our guide was so friendly and went way over and above to make sure we had a good time and found plenty of iguana. We didn't have a chance to go spear fishing but I'm sure we will next time.

    We had a blast spending the day on the water with Capt. Roberto Reyes. He was very patient with my…read morefiancé and I as it was our first time free diving and spear fishing. We decided to book this trip to push us out of our comfort zone and try something new. Captain Reyes took us on an adventure we will never forget. It was the highlight of our trip with my only regret being that I didn't book another day on the water with him. I am already planning my next spearfishing trip and I will hopefully return one day to show Captain Reyes my progression. If you are planning a trip to Puerto Rico this is as good as it gets! He offers a add on light tackle combo for a small additional fee that is worth every penny. We hooked into a monster tarpon at the end of the trip to finish the day. I am back home and writing this review days after returning from our trip and I am sitting here getting excited thinking back on the events of that day. Not only will you come home with some amazing memories and story's to tell you will have a new addiction! I cannot wait to get back into the water and do some spearing! Thank you Puerto Rico Freedivers

    Borikua Tours - Cave Tours

    Borikua Tours

    (4 reviews)

    Most of the tours I found in Puerto Rico seemed designed for people with no mobility issues. I have…read morenerve damage and use a cane, so I was specifically looking for a tour that could accommodate my needs and also give me a chance to explore other parts of the island--which is why I was excited to find your tour. Initially, you indicated that I would be picked up at my hotel, and later you also provided a secondary pickup location three blocks away. Due to the fact that it had rained every day during my stay--and given my medical condition--I strongly preferred the hotel pickup option to avoid standing in the rain, which is difficult and painful for me. However, if the alternate location was the only option, I was willing to try to manage it. I attempted to confirm the pickup location with your company the day before the tour but never received a response. Then, on the day of the tour, it was canceled without any direct communication or proper explanation--only a vague message saying you didn't want to "ruin my trip," which is exactly what happened. I have taken many tours over the years and have never had an issue with any other company. I am seeking compensation for the cancellation and the disruption it caused, especially since this tour was the main reason for my travel to Puerto Rico.

    My boyfriend and I did the cave tour with Robert and I would absolutely recommend it to anyone that…read morevisits Puerto Rico. We had a blast. Awesome (and challenging) hike up, and then some incredible scenery walking and crawling through the caves. Thanks Robert!

    Aqua Adventure - Pick up location

    Aqua Adventure

    (58 reviews)

    If you're looking for a nice relaxing day on a private island then this may be the trip for you!…read moreThis is a group tour that travels with more than just those you booked with. As long as 15 people are on the tour, they will take you to your Calebra. If less than 15 you stay local! There were well over 15 so we were able to tour Calebra. It was so beautiful! Once you get there, they pick you up on a ferry to take you to the boat . The boat travels for about an hour before getting to a private island and that is where you get the guided snorkeling or diving tour depending on what you selected! My friends and I did the snorkeling. As someone who can't swim (I know I know lol) I had a great time. The tour guides were very informative and helpful for all ages and swim levels. They do provide fruit, cold cut sandwiches and rum punch and when you stop . If you're looking for a "party" boat then this may not be for you. Don't expect lots of liquor and twerking etc it's a family type tour, Some of my friends were a bit disappointed by the price expecting that we'd stop somewhere that had a bar and restaurant but it was just a private island (we're in our high 20s low 30s). So idk I think it depends on your expectations but I was okay with everything and the service was great!

    Never In my life did I think I would give a 1 Star but would not recommend this company. We…read morecontacted them weeks prior to our trip to inquire about getting scuba certified. We were told we had to first buy and complete the course work through PADI and from There they would do the water/ dive sessions and compete the certification. The shop also gets a kick back from Padi as work since it makes u select a dive shop where ur course work is sent to. Once we complete the course work, we each reached out to the dive shop about 2 - 1 1/2 weeks in advance to schedule the dates and times for the water sessions. We did not receive any type of response back from the shop. We attempted to message on whatsup as requested but still did not receive a confirmation or any type of communication. We called down to the shop, where we were told to just text them. We again tried to text the shop but did not receive any response. We flew to San Juan and arrived and immediately went to the shop, we were told to text them and they would get back to us.. we asked directly if they had availability and we were told they would check and get back to us via text.... A day goes by, we attempt to call and no response.. fully we get a text saying they are fully committed...... This was without doubt the worst type of un-reliable customer service and a refusal to communicate.. I would not trust this dive shop or operation. They should never have told us to use to do the course work with their shop and then refuse to complete our certification. Luckily Scuba Dogs next door came to our rescue when we told them about the horrible customer service we received. Just be aware this shop will not be reliable.

    Puerto Rico Magic Tarpon - boatcharters - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...