New owners recently re-opened this location after it had been closed for awhile…read more Chocolate is hand made, delicious and Expensive. I wanted to get the Dubai truffle but one domed truffle piece before tax was $5.99. This is not a typo. Staff was friendly and made some suggestions when we couldn't make up our minds. They also have ice cream which is very popular. Great place for an occasional treat.

Such a cute spot! I love that they make the chocolate on site & it was so delicious! I got the…read morechocolate covered krispie treat & it was massive and So yummy They even have ice cream! The staff was so nice and helpful when I couldn't decide what to get. Will definitely be stopping by again !

Best ice cream , and soft serve we ever had. Wish that you were close by in Nassau county . Worth…read morethe wait.

Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice…read morecream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla soft serve and a second option like strawberry or pistachio. These are so creamy and delicious. They have occasionally have dole whip as well. They have vegan chocolate covered bananas. They can also make those mini sundaes or chocolate saucers dairy-free/vegan ahead of time for birthday parties. They have a variety of vegan toppings like sprinkles, nuts, chocolate/strawberry dip, etc. please support this spot if you're ever in the area.

Theres not one single time that Ive come in here where I don't regret it…read more The service is atrocious. I've never seen a slower group of employees in my life. If you walk in and there's more than person ahead of you, just leave. The kids cannot handle it. Go to Carvel or Baskin.

Beware! Check your bill! They are ripping off customers…read more Every year for the last ten years, I order a birthday cake from Hershey's in West Islip. Went in on Friday. Ordered the cake. Was told it was $20.99 for the small. Today is Tuesday and I just returned from picking up the cake. After ringing it up, it came up $21.83. I told the cashier who kept repeating, "I just work here. I just work here," that the price was wrong. I was told the price was $20.99. The TICKET says $20.99. She called her manager and told me the prices went up. The price didn't go up. They are just ripping off customers, hoping they won't notice. I was given a price of $20.99. after calculating the tax, I left the actual cost of the cake, not the ripped off fake amount scam they tried to pull off on me. What an utter disgrace. NEVER AGAIN! After response from owner: Christine, I paid with cash. I always pay with cash. Your cashier saw the cash. So when she was on the phone with the "manager," the manager should've asked her was the customer paying cash or credit card. And your "manager" stated the prices had gone up. So your "manager" lied. So yes. You are ripping customers off if you don't explain cash vs credit or train your employees to select the button that states the customer is paying cash. And if you had read the above review carefully, you would see that I paid in cash.

Amazing place! $5 bubble tea is the right size and worth every penny. Waffles are crunchy and…read moredelicious. This is a great place to have dessert (weather you go healthy or not!) Don't walk run here and enjoy. They are also open late!;

Ive been coming to this place for years now. I really like their variety of items in the menu. My…read morefamily and I love ordering boba tea drinks from here because they dont overfill them with ice and they have a lot of flavors to choose from. Their waffles menu are also very good! The people working here are always nice and the service is fast. You dont wait around for too long.

My son and his friend wanted to go for ice cream and we usually go to Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shop…read moreon Straight Path. But they don't have indoor seating and I just got a new car 2 days ago. No way was I letting 3 teens in my car with ice cream. His friend recommended Coyle's off Sunrise Highway. I can't believe we've never stopped here before! It was all decorated for Christmas and had friendly old ice cream shop / diner vibes with plenty of booths and counter seats. It was empty because it was 5 pm on one of the coldest days of the year. They have a wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors, plus soft serve, waffle cones, waffle bowls, their own sundae creations, and ice cream cakes and other treats to take home. I got a cannoli and Irish cream cup, my son got pistachio, and his friend got mint chip and Nutella. My daughter got a hot chocolate that she also enjoyed. I'd say it's easily comparable to OFICS, but the seating and atmosphere takes it to the next level. We will definitely be back -- ideally when the weather warms up!

Where has this place been all my life! Now it is the most economical but it is delicious! & they…read moredon't skimp on the scoops! They have sooo many options! I tried a few and ultimately went with the cookies and crème with crunchies! My daughter went basic as well with chocolate and sprinkles. They do allow you to taste flavors so if you are feeling adventurous , I saw go for it! You likely will not be disappointed. I typically go to carvel for ice cream cakes, but this might by new go to! Oo and they have two different types of ice creams. Hard ice cream and soft ice cream. I asked what the difference is and they said soft ice cream is soft serve the artificial stuff that you get from the ice cream truck. The hard Ice cream is the ice cream made in house . Aka the good stuff. You're gonna wanna go for the hard ice cream!

been going here almost 30 years to this location. all I can say is. Thank You. Great People. Great…read moreFamily. Great Location. miss you Paul. Truely a great guy whom loved his customers. Ill be back to order the same sundae Ive been ordering since the beginning. ;)

Twice I visited the Carvel at Bay Shore and twice I had a problem…read morebecause of buy one get one free Wednesday. I asked for a buy one get one sundae and i was told it didn't apply to sundaes. The next time I ordered a small cone with a small cup. I was told I couldn't get a cone and get anything free. I walked out and went a few miles on Bay Shore Rd and got 2 Sundaes for one price. They even say it on the door. Do yourself a favor and go straight to the one on Bay Shore Rd especially on Wednesday.

Ice cream is awesome. It will turn your frown upside down. It's so tasty and delicious and fresh…read morereal ice cream I love the apple ice cream really fresh fruit. I recommend this as amazing experience

I usually love Cold Stone, but my visit to the Babylon location today was incredibly disappointing…read more First of all, the prices here have gotten completely out of hand. I ended up paying $20 for literally just a kiddie-sized Birthday Cake Remix cup and one of their new ice cream tacos. $20!! I know inflation is a thing, but charging that much for a tiny kid's cup and a taco is just straight-up highway robbery. But honestly, the price wasn't even the worst part. What really grossed me out was watching the employee scoop and mix the ice cream without wearing any gloves. Especially at a place where they are constantly handling food, mixing things on the stone, and touching different utensils, not wearing gloves is absolutely disgusting and a massive hygiene issue. Between getting ripped off and watching basic food safety get ignored, I won't be coming back to this location. Save your money and go somewhere that actually cares about cleanliness.

I will absolutely be returning to Coyles! Delicious ice cream with so many flavor options, and the…read moretwo employees working behind the counter were very nice and very quick with service even on a Fourth of July night. Awesome place!

Coyle's Homemade ice cream has a wide selection of cold, rich and creamy flavors that you can get…read moreon a cone, cups, cake and sundae style. I have personally tried a few flavors on there own in previous visits which usually hits the spot. This last time I opted to upgrade to one of their suggested menu sundaes: "Salty Munchie Sundae" and oh goodness was it super sweet and very filling. I literally had to pause and freeze half for the next day. Nonetheless, if you have a sweet tooth and a big empty tummy feel free to give it a whirl. My Mr had the brownie sundae and was able to finish with ease. Service is super friendly and pretty quick, so if in the neighborhood looking for a treat outside of a bakery item, pop in here. :)