Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rentomatic Property Management

    2.4 (16 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 2 months ago

    Get a quote

    You can now request a consultation from this business directly from Yelp

    Services - Rentomatic Property Management

    Listing agent

    Rentomatic Property Management Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Rentomatic Property Management

    Portfolio From The Business

    Sponsored

    Recommended Reviews - Rentomatic Property Management

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    22 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 2

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    RentOMatic has been great to work with. Service request have been done in a timely manner and the condo was beautiful and well priced.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Rentomatic Property Management

    You might also consider

    Pyramid Property Management

    Pyramid Property Management

    (10 reviews)

    I've been working with them for years. They are great! Love the rental. Thank you very much!read more

    1-Star Review: Pyramid Properties LLC Absolute worst…read moreproperty management company I have ever dealt with. My experience with Pyramid Properties LLC at their West Valley townhome location was a complete nightmare from start to finish. 26 Days Without A/C in 100°+ Heat: We moved in on June 14, 2026, and the A/C went out immediately. Despite countless phone calls, emails, and texts to Rebeca, Zach, and Eddie, we were met with nothing but false hopes and lies. It wasn't until July 9--26 days later--that a new unit was finally installed. Even after that, the system never worked right and only cooled half the house, which management deemed "satisfactory." Empty Promises & Missing Amenities: Upon move-in, we were promised pool and fitness center keys that never materialized. We sent Eddie (the director) a detailed list of other necessary repairs on July 7, along with another request for the pool keys. He responded that they would "get right on it." None of the maintenance items were ever fixed or attempted, and you guessed it--we never got the pool keys. Outrageous & Illegal Charges: We finally moved out on July 31, but the nightmare didn't end there. They slapped an illegal balance due of over $23,000 on my account. The entire place is run like a joke by a bunch of amateurs. Save yourself the stress and look elsewhere. If you are looking for a reliable, professional property management team that actually follows through on what they say, PMI is the way to go. Dusty Lambert

    M&M Properties - More cockroaches

    M&M Properties

    (17 reviews)

    Do not trust these people. The lack of communication and help from these guys is a shame. They are…read moreflat out crooks. You, Marie should be ashamed of yourself. TERRIBLE past year and a half with these bozos. If there was a zero star I'd click that x100000.

    Wish I could put negative stars. I still have nightmares from this. I rented from M & M properties…read more M & M properties did not abide by the law and scammed my family and I. I especially caught Marie and Cindy in illegal acts! Marie is a "partner" of M & M properties and acted very uneducated and unprofessional. I only include Cindy because I physically gave her a notice of deficient conditions and she is working for very poor management. M & M properties acted very ILLEGAL. They lied, stole, acted uneducated, scammed me and was a very uncaring property management to us. To be brutally honest, this business should be be shut down. Especially if Marie is gonna try to run it and scam others! I would not believe a WORD they are saying. And I have pics to prove it. They moved my family and I into a cockroach and black widow infested townhome at 52 W Merrimac Ave Salt Lake City Utah! Which also has black mold in the unit. This unit also DOES NOT have Co2 detectors with gas appliances and no smoke alarms! How could I have not realized they were putting my family and I in such an unsafe and unsanitary unit!? I even called the health department on them. We put in multiple maintenance requests. Still having issues and then we served them a notice of deficient conditions for multiple reasons and no action was taken. Not a shocker.. so we moved out ASAP! Which they did not refund my full security deposit immediately after move out which is stated in the Utah Fit Premises Act after serving a notice of deficient conditions. We lived there 1 MONTH and they took $250 out of my $1450 deposit for "cleaning fee" when it was in the same condition then we moved in. THE FIRST NIGHT WE STAYED WE FOUND COCKROACHES COMING UP FROM INSIDE THE VENTS FROM UNDER THE UNIT!! I told them the second I found them. And guess what Marie said? "Those are Beatles" They even tried to act like they didn't know. Which I caught them in that lie. The neighbor also verified he has had cockroaches and sprays every other week for them. Ofcourse they are nocturnal pests. So Ofcourse we didn't see them when viewing the townhome but sure did see them every single night/morning after. Also got pest control to verify they are cockroaches. I have a 3 year old daughter and a dog. I can't live with a large infestation of cockroaches and black widows. M & M properties acted illegal, stole, acted uneducated, scammed and is a very uncaring property management. I will be taking them to small claims court. My family and I couldn't eat, sleep, or shower for a full month but still gave them all my income. Took such a toll on my mental and physical health. I also thought it was weird when the lease said $3,000 lease buy out fee. I can't believe I was so blind. If you want to get messed over then go ahead and try to do business with them. Definitely not worth $1450 deposit and $1600 for rent a month. What a joke. Wish I read other reviews first. I would also check out yelp. Hope this spreads some truth and awareness so nobody else has to deal with it.

    Nestwell Property Management - The remodel room was pitch black with the installed lighting at night, It was used as storage. Still very clean when we left

    Nestwell Property Management

    (203 reviews)

    Roger has been amazing to work with! he has been so thorough and kind to work with! his…read morecommunication was impressive as well! thank you so much!

    I was disappointed with my move-out experience with Nestwell. I felt several charges were assigned…read moreto us without adequately considering whether the issues predated our tenancy or were simply normal wear and tear. Nestwell ultimately charged us $585 for tenant responsibility, including: Removing an porch bench (there when we move in) - $15 Replacing a "broken" (not broken?) doorbell and removing hooks - $85 Swapping an incorrect privacy lock - $65 Removing carpet remnants (this carpet was apart of the unit?) and tacks from the stairs - $50 Replacing broken bedroom blinds (Also not broken??) $105 Repairing a damaged window screen - $60 Removing adhesive hooks and tape - $30 Disposing of trash/debris (there was no trash??) $40 Blowing debris from the garage (?... we swept when we left) - $40 Vacuuming HVAC duct (Also cleaned when we left) - $60 Replacing burned-out light bulbs - $35 My disappointment is with the move-out inspection process itself. It felt like our disputes were dismissed without supporting photos or documentation explaining why certain items were determined to be tenant responsibility. A more transparent process, with detailed move-in and move-out photos and evidence supporting disputed charges would go a long way toward building trust with tenants. I hope Nestwell continues to improve the transparency and fairness of its move-out inspections.

    Progress Residential

    Progress Residential

    (5 reviews)

    Absolute worst rental agency I have dealt with in over 20 years of renting…read more Tenants should never be held financially responsible for replacing or repairing an A/C unit, especially when they did everything they could to maintain and preserve an already failing system. If there were any legitimate charges, they should have been addressed through the security deposit--not added to the rent without any prior notice or communication. Even more unacceptable was having to wait two months for a functioning A/C unit, despite air conditioning being included as part of the lease agreement. No tenant should have to endure those conditions while continuing to pay full rent. The lack of communication, professionalism, and accountability throughout this experience was unacceptable. Shameful. Unprofessional. Completely unacceptable. I would not recommend renting through this agency.

    UTAH!!! DO NOT RENT FROM PROGRESS RENTAL!!!!!!! Absolute crooks who take advantage of people who…read morehave no other option but to rent a home in a state with ZERO rental regulations. It cost me $350 just to apply for a rental * after paying to just tour the house* without informing any customer beforehand of the fees and what to expect with apparently variations to each person * is it two months rent? Two months plus a deposit? Two months plus deposit plus lease acceptance fee?* * and now we are out the $250 "holding fee"because we see too many red flags to continue with them. Being a small business owner this is absolutely devastating!!! SHAME ON THEM!!!!!

    Equity Property Management - Another angle of the damage done to the door when someone tried to break in.

    Equity Property Management

    (14 reviews)

    Really great property management company! I was a tenant for one year. Lisa, the Property Manager…read moreis amazing. She has a heart of gold. The other office girls I never met in person were always very kind via emails. Jessica-the local girl who helped tenants or fixed minor problems is very nice, helpful and kind. The maintenance guys are the best. They know what they're doing. All in all and through thick and thin they all are wonderful. But once again Lisa B. - there's only one and she's amazing! Thank you all. Judy

    Genuinely the worst experience you could ever imagine from a rental company! Their office was in…read morethe same building as my apartment and it was astonishing how things are run when you see it up close. You want to call them during their OPEN hours? Not a chance. You're lucky if someone's in the office either! If there is, it comes with children running around SCREAMING and drawing on walls. The office is a complete mess, and no one ever knows what's going on. They are beyond distracted, a conversation in that office is extremely overstimulating. We tried to move into a different place with them on 3 different occasions, all of which we heard nothing back, or the place was leaking water and absolutely disgusting. When moving out, you are required to schedule a time for the inspection. I showed up, no one knew anything, and we basically did a fake walk though that meant nothing for my deposit. A week later, I came back to drop off my keys and ask about my deposit, once again, no one knew a thing. They even said that! Wrote my number down, and never got back to me until I called threatening with an attorney 2 weeks later. Before we moved in, we came up all the way from Boise to tour this specific place. We showed up 30 minutes early and no one ever showed up! We drove all the way home with nothing accomplished. That was the beginning of our struggles with Equity Real Estate. Once we FINALLY got ahold of them and set things straight, we were able to sign the lease and get our move-in date. When we arrived, we had never seen the inside because no one showed up for our tour, so we had no idea how dirty the apartment was. There was sugar and a porno shot glass in the cabinet, the microwave and stove were completely filthy, the fridge smelled, I had to do an entire cleaning prior to moving in. Not to mention, how dirty the actual building and hallway are leading up to the apartments. When it comes to the place itself, things are cheap. The cabinets are loose, the bathtub moves and leaks, the floor creaks horribly, the door handles BARELY work, etc. Overall, I saw more children in Equity's office than agent, non of which know what's going on. I highly recommend NOT renting through this company. They are the most distracted, rude, uncaring people in Pocatello. ALSO- the price of these apartments is RIDICULOUS for how tiny and cheap they are. We are now paying the same amount for 3x the size, and a company that actually cares about us.

    Rentomatic Property Management - propertymgmt - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...