Incredible experience from the old fashioned flight, to the appetizer fried cheese, the sides wild…read morerice duck soup, Caesar salad, and the entrees of pork chop with Bleu cheese, and broiled walleye fillets. Some of the best supper club food we've ever had. 10/10, you have to go!

It's a small place but such a gem!…read more There were so many things they do well here. The dirty martini was actually dirty! The service was top tier. Everyone was super friendly and we received our orders in a timely manner. The only reason I gave it a 4 instead of a 5 is because of the prices. $20 for one piece fish dinner and a side seems like a lot to me! The wedge salad was HUGE and cost $10 to upgrade. It tasted great but could've used more dressing. The bread is a MUST order. For $5 you can't go wrong. If you add shrimp to your meal be warned they are GINORMOUS haha but tasty also. Overall, the vibes of the place were so great. I would definitely eat here again, and I would DEFINITELY get another dirty martini!! Also, stop by next door if you have time before or after your reservation. Awesome bar with welcoming people.

Service was a little iffy, but the food was great. We had a ribeye and chicken florentine.read more

Great food and usual quiet surroundings! We've always enjoyed their seasonal offeringsread more

Love the place, almost everything is fantastic. But... The quality of the meat is just not there…read more Please stop serving expired food to customers. We expect fresh, great food, and you have that in your bread, drinks, slaw, etc. The funky smelly weird cuts like breakfast steaks labeled "ribeye" and flat "filet" that have been sitting in the basement too long are symptoms of an owner that has given up. Clean out your walk in cooler, etc. Date everything. Double your steak prices and change suppliers if you have to. Please find the pride again. Wayside is a gem. Do better. We really love your staff, they're amazing.

Went for the Friday fishfry and found it to be just ok. I decided on the fried perch and it was…read morequite tasty but found several bones. Not too big of deal, it's fish and you're bound to find one now and again. My wife had the bluegill and it was very good. The water glasses were just bigger than a shot glass at 4 oz. Everything was pretty good but I was mostly disappointed to see imitation buttery spread on the table. I believe most of us prefer real butter, I mean we are in the dairy state haha.

What an awesome Italian restaurant this place is! The vibe is very quaint inside. You MUST make a…read morereservation. It's a chef and a server. The flow of dinner was very nice. To start we ordered 2 appetizers. They came out timely. They were very delicious! Highly recommend the meatballs and spinach artichoke dip! All of our pastas were cooked to perfection as well. Served hot. Anything you pick will be amazing. We were served bread with dinner as well. Portion sizes were plentiful. Cannot wait to come back and try other pasta dishes!!

I was in the mood for an Italian pasta meal and found Mangiami Italiano online. It said they were…read moreopen until 8pm on Saturday, so since it was only 6:30, I decided to take a ride over. From the outside, the place looked inviting.., even had a big free-standing sign on the sidewalk that said OPEN. When I walked in, though, the setting felt dark and dingy. There were about 20 tables total, and only 5 of them were occupied. I asked for a table for one, and the host asked if I had a reservation. When I said no, I was told they were "reservations only." I even asked if they were expecting a big rush, given the number of empty tables and more than an hour left before closing, but the answer was still no. So instead of serving a paying customer, they turned me away. Honestly, what a poor way to run a business, especially when the place was 75% empty. Extremely disappointing experience. I won't be back

I've been here numerous times even for a Friday night fish fry. The food is always amazing and you…read morecan do some shopping and see a show if you want to as well but you don't have to see a show to enjoy a wonderful fish fry

Took our granddaughter to see Frozen for her birthday so this was special. The dining area was so…read morecute and sea oriented. The staff was nice and attentive. The whole dinner was delightful. Mac n cheese bites were delicious, the dressing on the fruit salad was scrumptious, the lasagna was a tad dry really but nice flavor and the dessert was melt in your mouth good. It was a wonderful night for all of us!

We had such a nice server! The Blackjack chicken sandwich was probably our favorite. The homemade…read morepub chips were great! The restaurant is casual with really nice natural light. They also have a nice outdoor seating section.

Pretty darn good fish fry ! Get the smothered bake potato. The drinks were well made and the…read moreservice was pretty good too. I would definitely go back as it's perfect to take a date ? Take your parents ? Take your friends who are looking for a place not too far away . Great view of the river to help calm the nerves

Had breakfast this morning. Wife had eggs and toast. I had full order of B & G plus 2 scrambled…read moreeggs and hash browns. Everything was to our liking. She likes their coffee with flavored creamers. We will return.

The food was fine. The service was horrible. Our waitress acted like someone peed in her coffee…read morethis morning. I promise it wasn't us, no need to be a b****!!!!! Instead of asking us if we were ready to order like a normal person she just came up to us and said, "Yes?" We were literally appalled not to mention when her and the guy hostess were whispering to each other while making eye contact with us. Thanks a lot for the service! Never coming back here again.

The amazing Mexican food does not disappoint. Love the queso and authentic Mexican. We keep…read moregetting fajitas for some reason we love them.

Very good Mexican Restaurant. We ordered the el patron fajitas. A small steak ( you could have made…read moreall of the fajitas from this. Some chicken, chorizo (very good) and shrimp. The beans seemed homemade, as the flour tortillas. My wife had the corn and she said they were better than any store bought. So probably homemade also. This was the single platter and I had about 4 fajitas the next day. The Carne asada was equally delicious. We did not try any drinks. Definitely worth entering this place. Our usuals were full with no room. Good choice.

Food is consistently fantastic. The people are so nice, and the prices are right. Love this place.read more

Great friendly service and food. If you haven't tried the garlic shrimp with 3.00 extra chicken you…read moreare missing one of their best dinners.

What a great dinner; we had a delicious fish fry dinner. Service was amazing and we will be backread more

When we visit the Fireside Theater it has become our tradition to visit Tavern on Rock before the…read moreshow. It has a cozy atmosphere and the staff has always been friendly. There is ample free parking in the lot next to the establishment. Plenty of seating at the bar and more seating in the dining area. Music playing at a level that still allows for conversation. We always enjoy a well made, hand muddled old fashioned (or two). There are many appetizers to choose from and they have come well prepared and in nice portions. There always seems to be a fair number of regulars, which should be a good sign for anyone visiting. When we visit Fort Atkinson, we will surely return.