What a great dinner; we had a delicious fish fry dinner. Service was amazing and we will be backread more

When we visit the Fireside Theater it has become our tradition to visit Tavern on Rock before the…read moreshow. It has a cozy atmosphere and the staff has always been friendly. There is ample free parking in the lot next to the establishment. Plenty of seating at the bar and more seating in the dining area. Music playing at a level that still allows for conversation. We always enjoy a well made, hand muddled old fashioned (or two). There are many appetizers to choose from and they have come well prepared and in nice portions. There always seems to be a fair number of regulars, which should be a good sign for anyone visiting. When we visit Fort Atkinson, we will surely return.

I just love this pub and will go to it many times because it's really great food who doesn't love…read moretheir patty melt. It's just delicious. I'm hesitant to write this review because I don't want it to be so crowded lol Their Irish beef stew is amazing

Anything I've ever eaten at Paddy's has been terrific. The servers work their tails off trying to…read moremake sure you're happy. The atmosphere is first rate. It feels alive, pleasant and comfortable. We probably show up every 10 days on average.

Love the place, almost everything is fantastic. But... The quality of the meat is just not there…read more Please stop serving expired food to customers. We expect fresh, great food, and you have that in your bread, drinks, slaw, etc. The funky smelly weird cuts like breakfast steaks labeled "ribeye" and flat "filet" that have been sitting in the basement too long are symptoms of an owner that has given up. Clean out your walk in cooler, etc. Date everything. Double your steak prices and change suppliers if you have to. Please find the pride again. Wayside is a gem. Do better. We really love your staff, they're amazing.

Went for the Friday fishfry and found it to be just ok. I decided on the fried perch and it was…read morequite tasty but found several bones. Not too big of deal, it's fish and you're bound to find one now and again. My wife had the bluegill and it was very good. The water glasses were just bigger than a shot glass at 4 oz. Everything was pretty good but I was mostly disappointed to see imitation buttery spread on the table. I believe most of us prefer real butter, I mean we are in the dairy state haha.

Honestly this is probably the best fish fry I've ever had. It was flakey and the batter was…read morefreaking phenomenal! Now the only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 - well hubby's sandwich isn't extravagant but when you ask for extra crispy bacon and it comes out floppy - ugh - but also we don't like to send food back so he ate what he could. The staff was great and the outdoor seating and the live music was awesome! We'll definitely be back.

The island bar is definitely one of our regular stops. The food is awesome. The atmosphere is great…read moreand they have done a lot to improve this area to include a concrete patio pad and sunshades. The owners are super nice and very hospitable. Live music every weekend and the pretzels and cheese curds are amazing!

I've been going here for years. It was Mr Brews, but has been bought and turned into "two-twenty"…read moreor something like that. The atmosphere is all wrong. Feels like a big loud sports bar, but they're trying to make it intimate dining. It doesn't work. Service was ok. The waiter was attentive. However, my wife asked for salmon. They were out. She asked for chicken. They were out. So she got the same salad she used to get when it was the branded chain (still on the menu). I had a "power bowl." Our seats were conveniently positioned to watch the kitchen staff cut open a bag of quinoa and black beans and microwave it. Yep. That was my plate. $20 for a microwaved meal. To their credit, it did taste good, but watching that made me realize we were definitely not coming back. Used to be a great place for a beer and a burger. Now, I'll look elsewhere. It's not bad, but the high-end pricing doesn't match the atmosphere or quality. The power bowl and salad were in the cheap end of the menu.

Pretty horrible .... Walked in walked out . Okay for a shot and beer but not to eat . Dirty and…read moreonly one waitress for the 4 tables . She apparently didn't want to be there .

It was horrible, had to ask another patron if they even had menus…read more We ordered simple food thinking it was going to be good, it took about 25 minutes to cook a pancake, when we walked in - they had huge bags of potatoes on the floor so we were like "Oh this will be good" ... Not - my husband received frozen hash browns rather than fresh. His food was burnt and then the waitress gave us the wrong bill, I didn't notice until after we left - I always take a picture of my bill. Also, by the time we arrived home both of us were sick. I do not recommend this place, and all we wanted to do was to support our local businesses - but were treated like we didn't belong. Sad - Oh and the health inspector should pay a visit.

The very definition of a hole-in-the-wall greasy-spoon diner…read more 1. Limited counter seating? Check. 2. Locals-only regulars? Check. 3. Outdated décor? Check. 4. Sassy server? Check. 5. Huge portions? Check. 6. Great food cooked expertly? Check. 7. Absurdly low prices? Check. Setting foot in Scottie's is like stepping back in time...in the best way possible. Finding a seat is pure luck; show up early or be prepared to wait, but know that you will be waiting outside, because there isn't an inch of spare room inside. If you do find a coveted spot, grab it because it won't be there long - and be prepared to rub shoulders and knees with the person next to you. Don't worry; that's all part of the experience. You might not know them when you first arrive, but you'll be best friends by the time you leave. Pro tip: the cook is not Scottie. There is no Scottie anymore. Presumably there was a Scottie once, but his whereabouts are unknown. At least to me. Jackie is amazing. If you've seen "Alice," she is the embodiment of Flo. I'm kinda shocked I haven't heard her tell someone to "Kiss my grits!" yet. She delivers good-natured sass just as frequently as plates of steaming hot food. Again, all part of the experience. Your food is cooked to order in front of you, so you know it's fresh. Even if the place is packed it won't take long, because there are only a handful of seats. And about that food: it's damn good. You can't go wrong with any of the skillets. The biscuits and gravy are wonderful. The toast, slathered with melted butter? Heavenly. The pancakes are enormous and awesome. The coffee, hot and delicious. Best of all, when you're handed your check, you will invariably mutter out loud, "That's it?!" The prices are insanely low. They're what you might have paid for breakfast in the 1980s. Two people can easily walk out of there stuffed and only $15 poorer. Tip Jackie well. She deserves it. It may be hot in there. It will definitely be cramped in there. You might see a fly or two. You'll leave smelling like grease. But you will be happy and satisfied and already planning your next visit. Besides, like I said... All part of the experience.

Loved the location. Their homemade ranch dressing is very good. Food was plentiful and good.read more

I have been to this place 3 times. The food is always just fine. However, all 3 times service has…read morebeen horrible. We showed up yesterday around 1120 ahead of the lunch rush. We sat as a family of 4 for 35min and were not acknowledged. My other 2 experiences weren't quite this bad. But certainly excessive waiting for what I expected every time.

The worst prime rib I have ever had no flavor and the onions and mushrooms tasted like dog food…read more How can these people serve humans this crap!!

Was tooling around on the Harley, and came across this place on a Sunday. Well, what a pleasant…read moresurprise! Wife and I both ordered a Bloody Mary. They had Shiner Bock on tap (that was my chaser) and the Bloody's were delish! Pickle, mushrooms, beef stick and all the rest hit the spot. Looked at the menu and decided on a mushroom swiss burger. We didn't order a split, but the server was nice enough to bring us both a plate, and it was all divided up already! The burger was hot and fresh and the swiss cheese pull was on point. Fries were sour cream and onion wedges, split on our two plates as well. It's a neat little place with good/friendly service. Check it out on a road trip! Bonus- There are some nice deer heads in this place as well. As a hunter and WIsconsinite, I appreciate that. :)

We had such a nice server! The Blackjack chicken sandwich was probably our favorite. The homemade…read morepub chips were great! The restaurant is casual with really nice natural light. They also have a nice outdoor seating section.

Pretty darn good fish fry ! Get the smothered bake potato. The drinks were well made and the…read moreservice was pretty good too. I would definitely go back as it's perfect to take a date ? Take your parents ? Take your friends who are looking for a place not too far away . Great view of the river to help calm the nerves

Incredible experience from the old fashioned flight, to the appetizer fried cheese, the sides wild…read morerice duck soup, Caesar salad, and the entrees of pork chop with Bleu cheese, and broiled walleye fillets. Some of the best supper club food we've ever had. 10/10, you have to go!

It's a small place but such a gem!…read more There were so many things they do well here. The dirty martini was actually dirty! The service was top tier. Everyone was super friendly and we received our orders in a timely manner. The only reason I gave it a 4 instead of a 5 is because of the prices. $20 for one piece fish dinner and a side seems like a lot to me! The wedge salad was HUGE and cost $10 to upgrade. It tasted great but could've used more dressing. The bread is a MUST order. For $5 you can't go wrong. If you add shrimp to your meal be warned they are GINORMOUS haha but tasty also. Overall, the vibes of the place were so great. I would definitely eat here again, and I would DEFINITELY get another dirty martini!! Also, stop by next door if you have time before or after your reservation. Awesome bar with welcoming people.